What does Biphasic Light Dose and Thermal Limits conclude, in numbers, about “The Biphasic Dose Window: the Mathematical Form of the Arndt–Schulz Curve”?

Answer: Chapter 1 writes a product-form biphasic dose function with a closed-form peak. On illustrative readings built to follow the qualitative order reported in a published review, the monotone model's residual sum of squares is 4.3 times the biphasic model's, the peak lies at 0.537 J/cm², and at 30 times the peak time the modelled excess over control falls to 15.6 %.

Scope of the numbers: It writes only physical quantities (irradiance, fluence, temperature rise, duty cycle) and dose ranges reported in published studies; all devices and parameters are illustrative and all calculations are generated by its programs. It is not medical advice and claims no effect of any kind; anyone planning a self-experiment must first consult a licensed physician.

中文版

Data table

The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 0.537, 4.3

biphasic : A 2.107 Ka 0.1905 Ki 1.514 SSE 0.0681 R2 0.900
peak D* 0.537 J/cm^2, peak R 2.148
half-max window 0.0764 to 3.78 J/cm^2 (ratio 49)
monotone : A 0.684 K 0.0347 n 4.0 SSE 0.2922 R2 0.570
SSE ratio monotone / biphasic4.3
dose read biphasic monotone
0.0031.02 1.033 1.000
0.0301.25 1.281 1.246
0.3002.10 2.075 1.684
3.0001.60 1.664 1.684
30.0001.35 1.101 1.684

Key formula

\[R(D) = 1 + A\,g(D),\qquad g(D) = \frac{D\,K_i}{(D+K_a)(D+K_i)}\]
Show the full program
# Chapter 1. p12: biphasic versus monotone fits to five dose levels.
# Dose levels 0.003, 0.03, 0.3, 3 and 30 J/cm^2 are those of the 810 nm
# fibroblast reporter experiment summarised by Huang et al. (2009).
# The readings below are ILLUSTRATIVE numbers built only to follow the
# qualitative order the review reports (no rise, small rise, maximum,
# lower, still above the 0.03 level); they are not the paper's values.
# Models, fitted by least squares on a log grid (A in closed form):
#   biphasic  R = 1 + A * D*Ki / ((D + Ka) * (D + Ki))     (as in p11)
#   monotone  R = 1 + A * D**n / (K**n + D**n)             (saturating)
import math

DOSE = [0.003, 0.03, 0.3, 3.0, 30.0]
READ = [1.02, 1.25, 2.10, 1.60, 1.35]
Y = [r - 1.0 for r in READ]


def fit_shape(shape):
    # for a fixed shape f(D), least squares gives A = <f,y> / <f,f>
    f = [shape(d) for d in DOSE]
    a = math.fsum(fi * yi for fi, yi in zip(f, Y)) / \
        math.fsum(fi * fi for fi in f)
    sse = math.fsum((yi - a * fi) ** 2 for fi, yi in zip(f, Y))
    return sse, a


best_b = None
for i in range(-250, 51):
    ka = 10.0 ** (i / 50.0)
    for j in range(-150, 151):
        ki = 10.0 ** (j / 50.0)
        if ki <= ka:
            continue
        sse, a = fit_shape(lambda d: d * ki / ((d + ka) * (d + ki)))
        if best_b is None or sse < best_b[0]:
            best_b = (sse, a, ka, ki)

best_m = None
for i in range(-250, 151):
    k = 10.0 ** (i / 50.0)
    for n10 in range(2, 41):
        n = n10 / 10.0
        sse, a = fit_shape(lambda d: d ** n / (k ** n + d ** n))
        if best_m is None or sse < best_m[0]:
            best_m = (sse, a, k, n)

sse, a, ka, ki = best_b
dstar = math.sqrt(ka * ki)
gmax = ki / (math.sqrt(ka) + math.sqrt(ki)) ** 2
c = gmax / 2.0
b = c * (ka + ki) - ki
r = math.sqrt(b * b - 4.0 * c * c * ka * ki)
lo, hi = (-b - r) / (2.0 * c), (-b + r) / (2.0 * c)
sst = math.fsum((y - math.fsum(Y) / len(Y)) ** 2 for y in Y)
print("biphasic : A %.3f  Ka %.4f  Ki %.3f  SSE %.4f  R2 %.3f"
      % (a, ka, ki, sse, 1.0 - sse / sst))
print("           peak D* %.3f J/cm^2, peak R %.3f"
      % (dstar, 1.0 + a * gmax))
print("           half-max window %.4f to %.2f J/cm^2 (ratio %.0f)"
      % (lo, hi, hi / lo))
sse_m, a_m, k_m, n_m = best_m
print("monotone : A %.3f  K %.4f  n %.1f  SSE %.4f  R2 %.3f"
      % (a_m, k_m, n_m, sse_m, 1.0 - sse_m / sst))
print("SSE ratio monotone / biphasic: %.1f" % (sse_m / sse))
print("dose     read   biphasic  monotone")
for d, rd in zip(DOSE, READ):
    fb = 1.0 + a * d * ki / ((d + ka) * (d + ki))
    fm = 1.0 + a_m * d ** n_m / (k_m ** n_m + d ** n_m)
    print("%7.3f  %5.2f  %8.3f  %8.3f" % (d, rd, fb, fm))

Single source and citation

Fan, Y. (2026). The Biphasic Dose Window of Photobiomodulation: Arrhenius Thermal Limits and Exposure Times under Pulsed Modulation (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 1: The Biphasic Dose Window: the Mathematical Form of the Arndt–Schulz Curve. 5D Library. DOI pending

DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-287 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

BibTeX
@book{fan2026287,
  author    = {Fan, Yafu},
  title     = {The Biphasic Dose Window of Photobiomodulation: Arrhenius Thermal Limits and Exposure Times under Pulsed Modulation},
  year      = {2026},
  publisher = {5D Library},
  edition   = {1.0.0},
  note      = {DOI pending}
}

Other chapter answers in this book