What does Heavyweight Cotton, Print Durability and Micro-Batch Economics conclude, in numbers, about “Does a Thicker Film Wash Better? Two Failure Modes and an Interior Optimum in Film Thickness”?

Answer: Chapter 5 finds an interior optimum in film thickness: doubling the film leaves only 0.257 of the optimal B10 life, and near the optimum the care condition matters more than thickness.

Scope of the numbers: Marked boxes separate published evidence, runnable calculations (20 programs), sources and the author's hypotheses, each stating what would refute it.

中文版

Data table

The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 0.257, 10

added rigidity at 80 um: 240 GSM 0.1431, 300 GSM 0.1103
h (um)eta wearedge(240)B10 240B10 300
3020.7993.08.48.4
5044.5324.518.018.1
7073.7150.628.129.4
90107.483.028.537.1
110145.150.720.032.2
130186.433.113.423.2
150231.122.89.316.5
170278.816.36.612.0
190329.411.94.98.9
best on 10 um grid, 240 GSM: h = 80 um, B10 = 30.3 cycles
best on 10 um grid, 300 GSM: h = 90 um, B10 = 37.1 cycles
B10 at 160 um vs best, 240 GSM: 0.257
Show the full program
# Chapter 5. p51: an interior optimum in heat-transfer film thickness.
# Two failure modes compete (Weibull shape 2.5 for both, illustrative):
# wear and crack-through of the film, life ~ (h / 80)^1.5 x 90 cycles;
# edge lift, driven by the stiffness the patch adds to the cloth,
# life ~ (D80 / D)^2 x 110 cycles, D = (film rigidity about the cloth's
# mid-plane) / (cloth rigidity). Film: modulus 30 MPa (illustrative
# polyurethane order). Cloth: Peirce G from p11 (240 GSM, n = 3 route to
# 300 GSM) and thickness 0.80 mm growing with weight on that route.
# System scale: (eta_w^-b + eta_p^-b)^(-1/b); B10 = scale x 0.4065.
import math

BETA, EF = 2.5, 30e6
CLOTH = {240: (331.8 * 9.81e-6, 0.80e-3), 300: (648.0 * 9.81e-6, 1.00e-3)}


def added(h_um, gsm):
    g, t = CLOTH[gsm]
    h = h_um * 1e-6
    d = EF * h ** 3 / 12 + EF * h * (t / 2 + h / 2) ** 2
    return d / g


def scale(h_um, gsm, d80):
    eta_w = 90.0 * (h_um / 80.0) ** 1.5
    eta_p = 110.0 * (d80 / added(h_um, gsm)) ** 2
    s = (eta_w ** -BETA + eta_p ** -BETA) ** (-1 / BETA)
    return eta_w, eta_p, s


D80 = added(80, 240)
k = (-math.log(0.9)) ** (1 / BETA)
print("added rigidity at 80 um: 240 GSM %.4f, 300 GSM %.4f" % (
    D80, added(80, 300)))
print("h (um)  eta wear  edge(240)  B10 240   B10 300")
best = {}
for h in range(30, 210, 10):
    w, p, s = scale(h, 240, D80)
    s3 = scale(h, 300, D80)[2]
    for gsm, v in ((240, s), (300, s3)):
        if v > best.get(gsm, (0, 0))[1]:
            best[gsm] = (h, v)
    if h % 20 == 10:
        print("%5d   %7.1f   %7.1f   %7.1f   %7.1f" % (
            h, w, p, s * k, s3 * k))
for gsm in (240, 300):
    h, v = best[gsm]
    print("best on 10 um grid, %d GSM: h = %d um, B10 = %.1f cycles" % (
        gsm, h, v * k))
print("B10 at 160 um vs best, 240 GSM: %.3f" % (
    scale(160, 240, D80)[2] / best[240][1]))

Single source and citation

Fan, Y. (2026). Heavyweight Cotton Areal-Density Mechanics, Heat-Transfer Coating Wash-Cycle Durability and Micro-Batch Custom Apparel Economics (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 5: Does a Thicker Film Wash Better? Two Failure Modes and an Interior Optimum in Film Thickness. 5D Library. DOI pending

DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-337 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

BibTeX
@book{fan2026337,
  author    = {Fan, Yafu},
  title     = {Heavyweight Cotton Areal-Density Mechanics, Heat-Transfer Coating Wash-Cycle Durability and Micro-Batch Custom Apparel Economics},
  year      = {2026},
  publisher = {5D Library},
  edition   = {1.0.0},
  note      = {DOI pending}
}

Other chapter answers in this book