What does Etymology, Parataxis and the Two-Track Transfer conclude, in numbers, about “The Hypotactic Tree and the Paratactic Network: the Gap Ratio and the Graph of Juxtaposition”?
Answer: Chapters 3 to 6 draw sentences as graphs, define the gap ratio and the ambiguity entropy of each juxtaposition edge (8.273 bits for the Analects passage), and search all English plans under a traceability of at least 0.90: Wen Tingyun's couplet keeps at most 0.314 of its gap and the Analects passage 0.371, and under perturbation the optimum holds the line with probability only 0.598. Anachronistic reading yields an illustrative 1.307 expected misreadings per thousand graphs, and with only three faulty sentences a checker must read 0.632 of a manuscript.
Scope of the numbers: Anachronistic reading yields an illustrative 1.307 expected misreadings per thousand graphs, and with only three faulty sentences a checker must read 0.632 of a manuscript. Parameters are illustrative and all calculations come from the book's 23 programs.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python only
| PDTB 2.0 relation tokens | 40,600 |
| Explicit | 18,459 0.4547 |
| Implicit | 16,053 0.3954 |
| AltLex | 624 0.0154 |
| EntRel | 5,210 0.1283 |
| NoRel | 254 0.0063 |
| not explicit | 22,141 = 0.5453 (+/- 0.0048 at 95%) |
| implicit among explicit+implicit | 0.4651 |
| CTB rough count 0.82 vs PDTB 0.5453: odds ratio 3.80 | |
| text edges marked gap ratio | |
| Lunyu 1.1 | 7 2 0.714 |
| Wen couplet | 7 0 1.000 |
| Tianjingsha | 10 0 1.000 |
| Wen, hypotactic English | 5 4 0.200 |
Show the full program
# Chapter 3. p31: how much of discourse is left unmarked?
# Part A, published counts: Penn Discourse TreeBank 2.0 relation tokens
# from the LDC2008T05 readme (Prasad et al. 2008); the Chinese figure
# 0.82 is Zhou and Xue's (2012) rough count over 20 Chinese TreeBank
# files of modern newswire, compared there with 54.5 per cent for PDTB.
# Part B, the book's own "gap ratio" (unmarked relation edges / all
# relation edges) for three public-domain texts, hand-annotated.
import math
PDTB = [("Explicit", 18459), ("Implicit", 16053), ("AltLex", 624),
("EntRel", 5210), ("NoRel", 254)]
tot = 0
for _, k in PDTB:
tot += k
print("PDTB 2.0 relation tokens: {:,}".format(tot))
for name, k in PDTB:
print(" {:<9}{:>7,} {:.4f}".format(name, k, k / tot))
expl = PDTB[0][1]
non = tot - expl
p_en = non / tot
se = math.sqrt(p_en * (1 - p_en) / tot)
print("not explicit: {:,} = {:.4f} (+/- {:.4f} at 95%)".format(
non, p_en, 1.96 * se))
imp_only = PDTB[1][1] / (PDTB[0][1] + PDTB[1][1])
print("implicit among explicit+implicit: {:.4f}".format(imp_only))
p_zh = 0.82
odds = (p_zh / (1 - p_zh)) / (p_en / (1 - p_en))
print("CTB rough count 0.82 vs PDTB {:.4f}: odds ratio {:.2f}".format(
p_en, odds))
print()
GRAPHS = [("Lunyu 1.1", 7, 2), ("Wen couplet", 7, 0),
("Tianjingsha", 10, 0), ("Wen, hypotactic English", 5, 4)]
print("text edges marked gap ratio")
for name, e, m in GRAPHS:
print("{:<25} {:>5} {:>7} {:>10.3f}".format(name, e, m, (e - m) / e))Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). Classical Chinese Etymological Philology, Paratactic Imagery Topology and East-West Aesthetic Asymmetry in High-Authority Writing (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 3: The Hypotactic Tree and the Paratactic Network: the Gap Ratio and the Graph of Juxtaposition. 5D Library. DOI pending
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-382 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026382,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Classical Chinese Etymological Philology, Paratactic Imagery Topology and East-West Aesthetic Asymmetry in High-Authority Writing},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {1.0.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 1 · Graphs Are Not Pictures: the Shuowen's Six Categories, Phonetic Loans and a Morphosyllabic Script
- Chapter 2 · Classical Chinese Has a Grammar: Word Order, Function Words and the Hard Constraint of Parallelism
- Chapter 4 · Ambiguity Entropy: the Distribution of Readings on Each Juxtaposition Edge and the Burden on Readers
- Chapter 5 · The Two-Track Transfer: the Largest Gap That Survives an English Traceability Constraint
- Chapter 6 · Reading the Past with Today's Senses: a List of Misreadable Words, the Cost of Sampling and the Form of Inscriptions
- Chapter 7 · Classical Sources: the Great Commentary and Wang Bi on Words, Images and Intent; Humboldt and Aristotle on Grammar and Signs
- Chapter 8 · Closing the Loop: a Two-Track Ledger for Carrying Mood across Languages, Field Tools and Checker Specifications