What does Hard Water, Chelation and Lather conclude, in numbers, about “Critical Micelle Concentration, Solubility Products and the Loss Curves of Five Surfactant Classes”?
Answer: The first table reads as follows. Each cell is the total calcium concentration, in millimoles per litre, at which precipitation starts for the stated surfactant level. The fatty-acid soap stays below 0.001 in all four cells: any hard water makes it precipitate. The alkyl sulfate tolerates 10.050 mmol/L of calcium in a dense lather of 100 mmol/L; diluted to 20 mmol/L it tolerates 2.050, and diluted to 5 mmol/L only 0.550. Diluted further to 1 mmol/L, its tolerance climbs back to 1.000. The acyl glutamate gives 12.967, 2.896, 1.007 and 1.259: the same shape, somewhat higher overall. The ether sulfate is the most tolerant of all; even its lowest cell is 50.399.
Scope of the numbers: Chapter 1 covers units of hardness, six illustrative waters and the activity of calcium. Parameters are illustrative and all calculations are generated by the book's programs.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. printed values that match the answer: 0.001, 0.550, 1.000, 1.007, 1.259, 10.050
Ca tolerance, total mmol/L, at surfactant level S (mol/L) class S=0.100 S=0.020 S=0.005 S=0.001 fatty acid soap <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 alkyl sulfate 10.050 2.050 0.550 1.000 acyl glutamate 12.967 2.896 1.007 1.259 ether sulfate 539.564 144.279 70.163 50.399 betaine / nonionic no calcium salt precipitates W4 water has 1.875 mmol/L Ca; ppt = tolerance below that fatty acid soap ppt ppt ppt ppt alkyl sulfate ok ok ppt ppt acyl glutamate ok ok ppt ppt ether sulfate ok ok ok ok W4 band of S (mmol/L) where precipitation is predicted fatty acid soap 0.100 to 100.000 alkyl sulfate 0.741 to 18.197 acyl glutamate 0.676 to 11.749 ether sulfate none
Show the full program
# Chapter 2. p22: calcium tolerance of five surfactant classes vs dilution.
# Model: a calcium salt CaX_n precipitates when [Ca_free][X]^n > Ksp.
# Above the CMC the free monomer X is pinned near the CMC m, and micelles
# bind part of the calcium, free Ca = total Ca / (1 + Kb * (S - m)).
# Below the CMC there are no micelles and X = S. Tolerance = the total
# Ca at which precipitation starts. Every Ksp, m and Kb below is an
# illustrative order of magnitude chosen to show the shape of the
# argument; none is a measured constant, and activity corrections
# (Chapter 1, p12) are left out because they move all classes alike.
CLASSES = (
# name, n, log10 Ksp, monomer m (mol/L), Kb (L/mol)
("fatty acid soap", 2, -15.0, 1.0e-3, 100.0),
("alkyl sulfate", 2, -9.0, 2.0e-3, 400.0),
("acyl glutamate", 1, -5.9, 2.0e-3, 200.0),
("ether sulfate", 2, -7.5, 0.8e-3, 100.0),
)
def tolerance(n, logk, m, kb, s):
ksp = 10 ** logk
if s <= m:
return ksp / s ** n
return ksp / m ** n * (1.0 + kb * (s - m))
def fmt(x):
if x >= 1000.0:
return " >999"
if x < 0.001:
return " <0.001"
return "{:>7.3f}".format(x)
if __name__ == "__main__":
levels = (0.1, 0.02, 0.005, 0.001)
print("Ca tolerance, total mmol/L, at surfactant level S (mol/L)")
print(" class S=0.100 S=0.020 S=0.005 S=0.001")
for name, n, logk, m, kb in CLASSES:
cells = [fmt(tolerance(n, logk, m, kb, s) * 1000) for s in levels]
print(" {:<18} ".format(name) + " ".join(cells))
print(" betaine / nonionic no calcium salt precipitates")
print("W4 water has 1.875 mmol/L Ca; ppt = tolerance below that")
for name, n, logk, m, kb in CLASSES:
flags = []
for s in levels:
t = tolerance(n, logk, m, kb, s) * 1000
flags.append("ppt" if t < 1.875 else "ok ")
print(" {:<18} ".format(name) + " ".join(flags))
print("W4 band of S (mmol/L) where precipitation is predicted")
for name, n, logk, m, kb in CLASSES:
band = []
for k in range(0, 301):
s = 10 ** (-4.0 + k / 100.0)
if tolerance(n, logk, m, kb, s) * 1000 < 1.875:
band.append(s * 1000)
if not band:
print(" {:<18} none".format(name))
elif band[-1] > 999:
print(" {:<18} every level tested".format(name))
else:
print(" {:<18} {:.3f} to {:.3f}".format(
name, band[0], band[-1]))Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). Water-Hardness Chemistry in Personal-Care Formulations, Calcium-Magnesium Chelation and Surfactant Foam-Deposition Enhancement (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 2: Critical Micelle Concentration, Solubility Products and the Loss Curves of Five Surfactant Classes. 5D Library. DOI pending
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-389 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026389,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Water-Hardness Chemistry in Personal-Care Formulations, Calcium-Magnesium Chelation and Surfactant Foam-Deposition Enhancement},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {1.0.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 1 · Four Units of Hardness and Six Illustrative Waters: the Effective Concentration of Calcium in Shower Water
- Chapter 3 · From Lost Shares to Foam Height: Precipitated Particles and Foam Half-Life
- Chapter 4 · The Stoichiometry of Chelation and the Ceiling on Coverage: How Much Water Can a Formula's Chelant Soften?
- Chapter 5 · Conditional Stability Constants, the Contest between Calcium and Magnesium, and Dilution by Rinsing: Why a Chelant Neither Grips Hard nor Keeps Up
- Chapter 6 · The Deposition of Cationic Polymers: Charge Screening, Competition for Sites and the Coacervation Window
- Chapter 7 · Classical Sources: Lu Yu on Waters, the Guanzi on Water, Hippocrates on Hard Water and Clark's Soap Test
- Chapter 8 · The Empirical Loop: a Weekly Water-Fit Ledger, Field Tools and Checker Specifications, and Pre-Registered Tests