What does Multi-Oracle Conflict Resolution conclude, in numbers, about “Practice: A Three-Year Exclusive Supply Contract and Five Voices at Odds”?
Answer: Chapter 8: an invented manufacturer weighs a three-year exclusive supply deal; three votes attack, two defend, the month-scale value is exactly -0.5000, trim; a pre-registered buyer default, if confirmed, adds -1.0 and makes it fortify. With the weights in doubt, hedge and trim split almost evenly, so the deal becomes a one-year non-exclusive contract with a bank guarantee: RM 41,200 less if all goes well, RM 406,200 less lost if orders stop. A blind ledger needs 240 judged calls for 0.8795 power against a coin.
Scope of the numbers: All figures come from the book's programs; it is not investment, legal, medical or psychological advice.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: -0.5000, -1.0
| votes: bazi attack, ziwei attack, qimen defend, liuyao defend, west attack | |
| head count | 3 attack, 2 defend -> a plain majority would say attack |
| scale birth raw/n/part moment raw/n/part L p verdict | |
| natal +1.76/3/+0.8800 | -0.29/2/-0.2231 +0.6569 0.6586 probe |
| decade +1.64/3/+0.8200 | -0.48/2/-0.3692 +0.4508 0.6108 hedge |
| year +1.50/3/+0.7500 | -0.86/2/-0.6615 +0.0885 0.5221 hedge |
| month +1.20/3/+0.6000 | -1.43/2/-1.1000 -0.5000 0.3775 trim <- pre-registered |
| day +0.84/3/+0.4200 | -1.81/2/-1.3923 -0.9723 0.2744 trim |
| moment +0.76/3/+0.3800 | -1.90/2/-1.4615 -1.0815 0.2532 trim |
| month, unrounded float sum | -0.5000000000000001; rounded to 4 places: -0.5000; line -0.5 -> trim |
| tie rule of the ladder: L = +0.5 opens probe, L | -0.5 opens trim (no tie lands in the middle) |
| evidence gate at the month scale (votes alone L -0.5000, trim): | |
| probe needs evidence >= +1.0000 (check: probe) | |
| staged_attack needs evidence >= +1.7000 (check: staged_attack) | |
| all_in needs evidence >= +2.5000 (check: all_in) | |
| fortify needs evidence < | -0.7000 (check: fortify) |
| retreat needs evidence < | -1.5000 (check: retreat) |
| pre-registered fact: buyer already 60+ days overdue to any supplier, evidence -1.0 | |
| -> L -1.5000, fortify (the boss's own 0.70 is a hunch, not evidence: it stays 0) |
Show the full program
# Chapter 8. p80: The case. An invented contract manufacturer is asked to sign a three-year exclusive deal.
# Signals (stipulated for the case, each from the reading rules of an earlier volume): bazi attack,
# ziwei attack, qimen defend, liuyao defend, west attack. Question type: contract. The question as
# pre-registered on 2026-11-16 reads "sign by 30 November or not", so its time scale is month. The program
# prints the verdict at all six scales to show what a scale chosen after the fact would buy, the unrounded
# sum at the chosen scale, and what a plain head count of the votes would have said. Rule restated from
# reference/synthesis_rules.py, including its evidence gate: posterior(..., evidence=0.0) adds the log-odds
# of a hard business fact (signed order, cash received, judgment or regulatory decision in force, default
# that has happened) to the votes. The case pre-registers one such fact and its value before any reading.
import math
SYSTEMS = ["bazi", "ziwei", "qimen", "liuyao", "west"]
SCALES = ["natal", "decade", "year", "month", "day", "moment"]
VALUE = {"attack": 1, "defend": -1, "hold": 0}
WEIGHT = {"bazi": 0.6, "ziwei": 0.8, "qimen": 1.0, "liuyao": 0.9, "west": 0.6} # the contract row
FIT = {
"bazi": {"natal": 1.0, "decade": 0.9, "year": 0.7, "month": 0.5, "day": 0.3, "moment": 0.2},
"ziwei": {"natal": 1.0, "decade": 1.0, "year": 0.9, "month": 0.6, "day": 0.3, "moment": 0.2},
"qimen": {"natal": 0.2, "decade": 0.3, "year": 0.5, "month": 0.8, "day": 1.0, "moment": 1.0},
"liuyao": {"natal": 0.1, "decade": 0.2, "year": 0.4, "month": 0.7, "day": 0.9, "moment": 1.0},
"west": {"natal": 0.6, "decade": 0.5, "year": 0.6, "month": 0.7, "day": 0.7, "moment": 0.8},
}
GROUPS = {"birth": (["bazi", "ziwei", "west"], 0.5), "moment": (["qimen", "liuyao"], 0.3)}
CASE = {"bazi": "attack", "ziwei": "attack", "qimen": "defend", "liuyao": "defend", "west": "attack"}
def posterior(signals, scale, evidence=0.0):
total, parts = float(evidence), {}
for g, (members, rho) in GROUPS.items():
raw = sum(WEIGHT[s] * FIT[s][scale] * VALUE[signals[s]] for s in members)
n = sum(1 for s in members if signals[s] != "hold")
part = raw / (1 + (n - 1) * rho) if n > 1 else raw
parts[g] = (raw, n, part)
total += part
L = round(total, 4)
v = list(signals.values())
if L >= 2.0:
act = "all_in"
elif L >= 1.2:
act = "staged_attack"
elif L >= 0.5:
act = "probe"
elif L > -0.5:
if "attack" in v and "defend" in v:
act = "hedge"
else:
act = "hold" if v.count("hold") >= 3 else "trigger_wait"
elif L > -1.2:
act = "trim"
elif L > -2.0:
act = "fortify"
else:
act = "retreat"
return total, L, parts, act
if __name__ == "__main__":
v = list(CASE.values())
print("votes: " + ", ".join("{} {}".format(s, CASE[s]) for s in SYSTEMS))
print("head count: {} attack, {} defend -> a plain majority would say attack".format(
v.count("attack"), v.count("defend")))
print(" scale birth raw/n/part moment raw/n/part L p verdict")
for t in SCALES:
total, L, parts, act = posterior(CASE, t)
b, m = parts["birth"], parts["moment"]
print(" {:<7} {:+.2f}/{}/{:+.4f} {:+.2f}/{}/{:+.4f} {:+.4f} {:.4f} {}{}".format(
t, b[0], b[1], b[2], m[0], m[1], m[2], L, 1 / (1 + math.exp(-L)), act,
" <- pre-registered" if t == "month" else ""))
total, L, parts, act = posterior(CASE, "month")
print("month, unrounded float sum: {!r}; rounded to 4 places: {:+.4f}; line -0.5 -> {}".format(
total, L, act))
print("tie rule of the ladder: L = +0.5 opens probe, L = -0.5 opens trim (no tie lands in the middle)")
print("evidence gate at the month scale (votes alone L {:+.4f}, {}):".format(L, act))
for rung, line in (("probe", 0.5), ("staged_attack", 1.2), ("all_in", 2.0)):
e = round(line - L, 4)
check = posterior(CASE, "month", e)[3]
print(" {:<14} needs evidence >= {:+.4f} (check: {})".format(rung, e, check))
for rung, line in (("fortify", -1.2), ("retreat", -2.0)):
e = round(line - L, 4)
check = posterior(CASE, "month", e)[3]
print(" {:<14} needs evidence <= {:+.4f} (check: {})".format(rung, e, check))
e = -1.0
total, L2, parts, act2 = posterior(CASE, "month", e)
print("pre-registered fact: buyer already 60+ days overdue to any supplier, evidence {:+.1f}".format(e))
print(" -> L {:+.4f}, {} (the boss's own 0.70 is a hunch, not evidence: it stays 0)".format(L2, act2))Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). The Multi-Oracle Conflict-Resolution and Chief-of-Staff Action Codex (Version 0.1.0), Chapter 8: Practice: A Three-Year Exclusive Supply Contract and Five Voices at Odds. 5D Library. DOI pending
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-132 · v0.1.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026132,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {The Multi-Oracle Conflict-Resolution and Chief-of-Staff Action Codex},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {0.1.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 1 · Method: Log-Odds, the Correlation Discount, the Nine-Step Ladder and Scoring Afterwards
- Chapter 2 · Six Question Types and Their Weights: Which Voice Speaks for What
- Chapter 3 · Six Time Scales and Twenty-One Consensus Tallies: Who Overrides Whom, and When a Vote Counts
- Chapter 4 · Pairwise Conflicts I: Bazi Against Four Systems, and Ziwei Against Qimen
- Chapter 5 · Pairwise Conflicts, Part Two: the Decade, the Single Question, the Board of the Moment and the Outer Projection
- Chapter 6 · The Nine-Rung Action Ladder: Turning One Number into One Move
- Chapter 7 · Synthesis Scripts: Saying the Verdict to the Client