What does Multi-Oracle Conflict Resolution conclude, in numbers, about “Method: Log-Odds, the Correlation Discount, the Nine-Step Ladder and Scoring Afterwards”?

Answer: Chapter 1: a weight of 1.0 claims a hit rate of 0.7311 and needs 27 judged calls to confirm, the worst-fitted cell 6872. At correlation 0.5 three witnesses sharing a source are worth 1.5, and an undiscounted synthesis is right only 0.8534 of the time when it claims over nine in ten. Across 8,748 verdicts five votes top out at 1.9415, so all-in and retreat open only through an evidence gate: the log-odds of a hard fact (a signed order, cash received, a judgment or regulatory decision in force, a default that has happened), registered in advance, zero by default. A useless synthesis scores 0.2782 on Brier, worse than fifty-fifty, yet over 20 calls looks useful with probability 0.2352.

Scope of the numbers: All figures come from the book's programs; it is not investment, legal, medical or psychological advice.

中文版

Data table

The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 0.5, 0.7311, 1.0, 27, 6872

  weight w   LR e^w   implied hit rate   logged votes needed to beat a coin
     0.5    1.6487          0.6225                    101
     0.6    1.8221          0.6457                     71
     0.7    2.0138          0.6682                     53
     0.8    2.2255          0.6900                     41
     0.9    2.4596          0.7109                     33
     1.0    2.7183          0.7311                     27
effective weights w x fit: 180 cells, smallest 0.06 (relocate liuyao natal)
                             -> hit rate 0.5150, needs 6872 votes
                             largest 1.00 -> hit rate 0.7311
share of cells whose implied hit rate is below 0.55: 0.178
for comparison: a hit rate of 0.55 needs 617 votes, 0.60 needs 153 votes
1 independent agreeing votes of weight 1.0: odds x 2.7183, p 0.7311
2 independent agreeing votes of weight 1.0: odds x 7.3891, p 0.8808
3 independent agreeing votes of weight 1.0: odds x 20.0855, p 0.9526
Show the full program
# Chapter 1. p11: Every weight is a claim about accuracy, and every claim has a price in logged decisions.
# A vote of weight w multiplies the odds of "attack is right" by the likelihood ratio LR = e^w. If a system is
# symmetric (right with probability a whether the right call is attack or defend), its LR is a / (1 - a), so
# the weight implies a hit rate a = 1 / (1 + e^-w). The effective weight at a time scale is w x fit.
# Sample size to show a hit rate a beats a coin (one-sided alpha 0.05, power 0.80, normal approximation):
#   n = ((z_alpha * 0.5 + z_beta * sqrt(a (1 - a))) / (a - 0.5))^2,  z_alpha 1.6449, z_beta 0.8416.
import math

WEIGHT = {
    "money":    {"bazi": 0.9, "ziwei": 1.0, "qimen": 0.8, "liuyao": 0.7, "west": 0.5},
    "contract": {"bazi": 0.6, "ziwei": 0.8, "qimen": 1.0, "liuyao": 0.9, "west": 0.6},
    "partner":  {"bazi": 0.8, "ziwei": 1.0, "qimen": 0.7, "liuyao": 0.8, "west": 0.7},
    "love":     {"bazi": 0.7, "ziwei": 1.0, "qimen": 0.5, "liuyao": 0.8, "west": 0.9},
    "launch":   {"bazi": 0.7, "ziwei": 0.8, "qimen": 1.0, "liuyao": 0.7, "west": 0.6},
    "relocate": {"bazi": 0.8, "ziwei": 0.9, "qimen": 0.9, "liuyao": 0.6, "west": 0.5},
}
FIT = {
    "bazi":   {"natal": 1.0, "decade": 0.9, "year": 0.7, "month": 0.5, "day": 0.3, "moment": 0.2},
    "ziwei":  {"natal": 1.0, "decade": 1.0, "year": 0.9, "month": 0.6, "day": 0.3, "moment": 0.2},
    "qimen":  {"natal": 0.2, "decade": 0.3, "year": 0.5, "month": 0.8, "day": 1.0, "moment": 1.0},
    "liuyao": {"natal": 0.1, "decade": 0.2, "year": 0.4, "month": 0.7, "day": 0.9, "moment": 1.0},
    "west":   {"natal": 0.6, "decade": 0.5, "year": 0.6, "month": 0.7, "day": 0.7, "moment": 0.8},
}
ZA, ZB = 1.6449, 0.8416


def hit(w):
    return 1 / (1 + math.exp(-w))


def n_needed(a):
    return math.ceil(((ZA * 0.5 + ZB * math.sqrt(a * (1 - a))) / (a - 0.5)) ** 2)


if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("  weight w   LR e^w   implied hit rate   logged votes needed to beat a coin")
    for w in (0.5, 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, 1.0):
        print("   {:5.1f} {:9.4f} {:15.4f} {:22d}".format(w, math.exp(w), hit(w), n_needed(hit(w))))
    eff = sorted((WEIGHT[q][s] * FIT[s][t], q, s, t) for q in WEIGHT for s in FIT for t in FIT[s])
    lo, hi = eff[0], eff[-1]
    print("effective weights w x fit: {} cells, smallest {:.2f} ({} {} {})".format(
        len(eff), lo[0], lo[1], lo[2], lo[3]))
    print("                             -> hit rate {:.4f}, needs {} votes".format(
        hit(lo[0]), n_needed(hit(lo[0]))))
    print("                             largest {:.2f} -> hit rate {:.4f}".format(hi[0], hit(hi[0])))
    share = sum(1 for e in eff if hit(e[0]) < 0.55) / len(eff)
    print("share of cells whose implied hit rate is below 0.55: {:.3f}".format(share))
    print("for comparison: a hit rate of 0.55 needs {} votes, 0.60 needs {} votes".format(
        n_needed(0.55), n_needed(0.60)))
    for k in (1, 2, 3):
        print("{} independent agreeing votes of weight 1.0: odds x {:.4f}, p {:.4f}".format(
            k, math.exp(k), hit(k)))

Single source and citation

Fan, Y. (2026). The Multi-Oracle Conflict-Resolution and Chief-of-Staff Action Codex (Version 0.1.0), Chapter 1: Method: Log-Odds, the Correlation Discount, the Nine-Step Ladder and Scoring Afterwards. 5D Library. DOI pending

DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-132 · v0.1.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

BibTeX
@book{fan2026132,
  author    = {Fan, Yafu},
  title     = {The Multi-Oracle Conflict-Resolution and Chief-of-Staff Action Codex},
  year      = {2026},
  publisher = {5D Library},
  edition   = {0.1.0},
  note      = {DOI pending}
}

Other chapter answers in this book