What does Multi-Oracle Conflict Resolution conclude, in numbers, about “Pairwise Conflicts, Part Two: the Decade, the Single Question, the Board of the Moment and the Outer Projection”?
Answer: This chapter covered five pairs, Zi Wei against Liu Yao, Zi Wei against the western bundle, Qimen against Liu Yao, Qimen against the western bundle and Liu Yao against the western bundle, each in six directions, thirty keys in all. p50 gives each pair's handover point and the four tied cells. p51 shows that no pair on its own goes beyond probe or trim, the largest |L| being 1.00, and that the twenty keys with one side holding are only four solo voices. p52 shows that the in-group discount ignores whether voices agree, and that the birth group is capped at 2.000 witnesses and the moment group at 3.333. p53 puts the thirty keys into 29160 full verdicts, where the pair's own direction survives in only 0.537 of them and neither end of the ladder ever appears. p54 walks five fictional owners through the whole procedure. p55 gives the way to test the ledger, which needs well over two hundred resolved records before it can say anything. The five decision rules come down to three sentences: write the time scale before choosing a side; when one source disagrees with itself, check the birth time first; when two pictures of one moment disagree, split the action into a reversible half and an irreversible half.
Scope of the numbers: All figures come from the book's programs; it is not investment, legal, medical or psychological advice.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 1.00, 2.000, 3.333
| birth group, rho 0.5: effective witnesses n | 1: 1.000, n=2: 1.333, n=3: 1.500; limit 1/rho = 2.000 |
| moment group, rho 0.3: effective witnesses n | 1: 1.000, n=2: 1.538; limit 1/rho = 3.333 |
| ziwei-west at decade (divisor 1.5 when both speak) | |
| money A 1.00 B 0.25 | agree 1.25 | 0.83 probe | split +0.75 -> +0.50 probe |
| contract A 0.80 B 0.30 | agree 1.10 | 0.73 probe | split +0.50 -> +0.33 hedge |
| partner A 1.00 B 0.35 | agree 1.35 | 0.90 probe | split +0.65 -> +0.43 hedge |
| love A 1.00 B 0.45 | agree 1.45 | 0.97 probe | split +0.55 -> +0.37 hedge |
| launch A 0.80 B 0.30 | agree 1.10 | 0.73 probe | split +0.50 -> +0.33 hedge |
| relocate A 0.90 B 0.25 | agree 1.15 | 0.77 probe | split +0.65 -> +0.43 hedge |
| cells (of 36) where the discount changes the rung: agree 19, split 11 | |
| qimen-liuyao at moment (divisor 1.3 when both speak) | |
| money A 0.80 B 0.70 | agree 1.50 | 1.15 probe | split +0.10 -> +0.08 hedge |
| contract A 1.00 B 0.90 | agree 1.90 | 1.46 staged_attack | split +0.10 -> +0.08 hedge |
| partner A 0.70 B 0.80 | agree 1.50 | 1.15 probe | split -0.10 -> -0.08 hedge |
| love A 0.50 B 0.80 | agree 1.30 | 1.00 probe | split -0.30 -> -0.23 hedge |
| launch A 1.00 B 0.70 | agree 1.70 | 1.31 staged_attack | split +0.30 -> +0.23 hedge |
| relocate A 0.90 B 0.60 | agree 1.50 | 1.15 probe | split +0.30 -> +0.23 hedge |
| cells (of 36) where the discount changes the rung: agree 11, split 0 |
Show the full program
# Chapter 5. p52: The shared-data discount inside a group, for the two same-group pairs of this chapter.
# Design effect: n correlated voices with correlation rho count as n / (1 + (n - 1) rho) independent ones.
# The rule divides a group's signed sum by 1 + (n - 1) rho, n = non-hold voices in the group, whether the
# voices agree or not. Here "undiscounted" is the same sum without the division (a counterfactual only).
from collections import Counter
SYSTEMS = ["bazi", "ziwei", "qimen", "liuyao", "west"]
SCALES = ["natal", "decade", "year", "month", "day", "moment"]
QTYPES = ["money", "contract", "partner", "love", "launch", "relocate"]
VALUE = {"attack": 1, "defend": -1, "hold": 0}
WEIGHT = {
"money": {"bazi": 0.9, "ziwei": 1.0, "qimen": 0.8, "liuyao": 0.7, "west": 0.5},
"contract": {"bazi": 0.6, "ziwei": 0.8, "qimen": 1.0, "liuyao": 0.9, "west": 0.6},
"partner": {"bazi": 0.8, "ziwei": 1.0, "qimen": 0.7, "liuyao": 0.8, "west": 0.7},
"love": {"bazi": 0.7, "ziwei": 1.0, "qimen": 0.5, "liuyao": 0.8, "west": 0.9},
"launch": {"bazi": 0.7, "ziwei": 0.8, "qimen": 1.0, "liuyao": 0.7, "west": 0.6},
"relocate": {"bazi": 0.8, "ziwei": 0.9, "qimen": 0.9, "liuyao": 0.6, "west": 0.5},
}
FIT = {
"bazi": {"natal": 1.0, "decade": 0.9, "year": 0.7, "month": 0.5, "day": 0.3, "moment": 0.2},
"ziwei": {"natal": 1.0, "decade": 1.0, "year": 0.9, "month": 0.6, "day": 0.3, "moment": 0.2},
"qimen": {"natal": 0.2, "decade": 0.3, "year": 0.5, "month": 0.8, "day": 1.0, "moment": 1.0},
"liuyao": {"natal": 0.1, "decade": 0.2, "year": 0.4, "month": 0.7, "day": 0.9, "moment": 1.0},
"west": {"natal": 0.6, "decade": 0.5, "year": 0.6, "month": 0.7, "day": 0.7, "moment": 0.8},
}
GROUPS = {"birth": (["bazi", "ziwei", "west"], 0.5), "moment": (["qimen", "liuyao"], 0.3)}
THRESH = (2.0, 1.2, 0.5)
PAIRS = [("ziwei", "liuyao"), ("ziwei", "west"), ("qimen", "liuyao"), ("qimen", "west"), ("liuyao", "west")]
DIRS = [("attack", "defend"), ("attack", "hold"), ("defend", "attack"), ("defend", "hold"),
("hold", "attack"), ("hold", "defend")]
def posterior(sig, q, t):
total, parts = 0.0, {}
for g, (members, rho) in GROUPS.items():
raw = sum(WEIGHT[q][s] * FIT[s][t] * VALUE[sig[s]] for s in members)
n = sum(1 for s in members if sig[s] != "hold")
part = raw / (1 + (n - 1) * rho) if n > 1 else raw
parts[g] = round(part, 4)
total += part
L = round(total, 4)
v = [sig[s] for s in SYSTEMS]
big, mid, small = THRESH
if L >= big:
act = "all_in"
elif L >= mid:
act = "staged_attack"
elif L >= small:
act = "probe"
elif L > -small:
if "attack" in v and "defend" in v:
act = "hedge"
elif v.count("hold") >= 3:
act = "hold"
else:
act = "trigger_wait"
elif L > -mid:
act = "trim"
elif L > -big:
act = "fortify"
else:
act = "retreat"
return L, parts, act
def lone(a, b, sa, sb):
sig = {s: "hold" for s in SYSTEMS}
sig[a], sig[b] = sa, sb
return sig
def ladder(L, sig):
probe = {s: "hold" for s in SYSTEMS}
probe.update(sig)
big, mid, small = THRESH
v = [probe[s] for s in SYSTEMS]
if L >= big:
return "all_in"
if L >= mid:
return "staged_attack"
if L >= small:
return "probe"
if L > -small:
if "attack" in v and "defend" in v:
return "hedge"
return "hold" if v.count("hold") >= 3 else "trigger_wait"
if L > -mid:
return "trim"
return "fortify" if L > -big else "retreat"
if __name__ == "__main__":
for g, (members, rho) in GROUPS.items():
eff = ["n={}: {:.3f}".format(n, n / (1 + (n - 1) * rho)) for n in range(1, len(members) + 1)]
print(" {} group, rho {}: effective witnesses {}; limit 1/rho = {:.3f}".format(
g, rho, ", ".join(eff), 1 / rho))
for (a, b), home in ((("ziwei", "west"), "decade"), (("qimen", "liuyao"), "moment")):
rho = 0.5 if a == "ziwei" else 0.3
print("{}-{} at {} (divisor {:.1f} when both speak)".format(a, b, home, 1 + rho))
for q in QTYPES:
va, vb = WEIGHT[q][a] * FIT[a][home], WEIGHT[q][b] * FIT[b][home]
ag = posterior(lone(a, b, "attack", "attack"), q, home)
dis = posterior(lone(a, b, "attack", "defend"), q, home)
fmt = " {:<8} A {:.2f} B {:.2f} | agree {:.2f} -> {:.2f} {:<13} | split {:+.2f} -> {:+.2f} {}"
print(fmt.format(q, va, vb, va + vb, ag[0], ag[2], va - vb, dis[0], dis[2]))
changed = Counter()
for sa, sb in (("attack", "attack"), ("attack", "defend")):
for q in QTYPES:
for t in SCALES:
sig = {a: sa, b: sb}
raw = WEIGHT[q][a] * FIT[a][t] * VALUE[sa] + WEIGHT[q][b] * FIT[b][t] * VALUE[sb]
if ladder(round(raw, 4), sig) != posterior(lone(a, b, sa, sb), q, t)[2]:
changed[sa + "/" + sb] += 1
print(" cells (of 36) where the discount changes the rung: agree {}, split {}".format(
changed["attack/attack"], changed["attack/defend"]))Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). The Multi-Oracle Conflict-Resolution and Chief-of-Staff Action Codex (Version 0.1.0), Chapter 5: Pairwise Conflicts, Part Two: the Decade, the Single Question, the Board of the Moment and the Outer Projection. 5D Library. DOI pending
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-132 · v0.1.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026132,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {The Multi-Oracle Conflict-Resolution and Chief-of-Staff Action Codex},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {0.1.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 1 · Method: Log-Odds, the Correlation Discount, the Nine-Step Ladder and Scoring Afterwards
- Chapter 2 · Six Question Types and Their Weights: Which Voice Speaks for What
- Chapter 3 · Six Time Scales and Twenty-One Consensus Tallies: Who Overrides Whom, and When a Vote Counts
- Chapter 4 · Pairwise Conflicts I: Bazi Against Four Systems, and Ziwei Against Qimen
- Chapter 6 · The Nine-Rung Action Ladder: Turning One Number into One Move
- Chapter 7 · Synthesis Scripts: Saying the Verdict to the Client
- Chapter 8 · Practice: A Three-Year Exclusive Supply Contract and Five Voices at Odds