What does Mission Communities: Seats and Volunteers conclude, in numbers, about “The Dual-Track Funnel: Free Contributors, Paid Seats and Fairness Between the Tracks”?
Answer: The free track is not a lobby for the paid track. Lakhani and von Hippel show that free contribution rests on a low marginal cost and on contributors' own benefits. Program p51 shows that a hard push sells more seats in the first year, is overtaken by gentle invitation from month 35, and after five years has 446 fewer holders and only a little more than half as many active contributors; program p52 shows that 1 invitation a year is best, and that raising it to 6 loses 0.323 of contribution hours; program p53 shows that a merged points ledger fills 0.960 of the honour roll with payers. Never merging the two ledgers is the floor of fairness between the tracks.
Scope of the numbers: All parameters are illustrative, all calculations come from its programs, and revenue figures are illustrative arithmetic, not forecasts or guarantees. It is general guidance, not legal, tax or investment advice.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 35
| month policy | occasional | active | seats | hours/month | net seat RM | |
| 12 | soft | 6,214 | 2,028 | 92 | 22,992 | 27,526 |
| 12 | hard | 5,897 | 1,487 | 119 | 18,508 | 36,528 |
| 24 | soft | 7,838 | 4,436 | 485 | 46,234 | 310,397 |
| 24 | hard | 7,110 | 2,898 | 541 | 33,540 | 367,898 |
| 36 | soft | 8,557 | 6,007 | 1,065 | 63,006 | 1,100,172 |
| 36 | hard | 7,505 | 3,637 | 1,049 | 42,897 | 1,184,196 |
| 48 | soft | 8,960 | 6,993 | 1,709 | 75,156 | 2,512,513 |
| 48 | hard | 7,678 | 4,042 | 1,514 | 49,097 | 2,490,856 |
| 60 | soft | 9,208 | 7,632 | 2,348 | 84,355 | 4,570,021 |
| 60 | hard | 7,772 | 4,291 | 1,902 | 53,512 | 4,221,799 |
| soft policy holds more seats from month 35 | ||||||
| soft policy has more cumulative net revenue from month 47 |
Show the full program
# Chapter 5. p51: a dual-track funnel under a soft and a hard invitation policy.
# Monthly cohort model over 60 months (all rates illustrative). 1,000 new
# free contributors arrive each month. States: F occasional contributor,
# A active contributor, S seat holder (who keeps contributing).
# F->A A->F F->gone A->gone A->S refund S->A
# soft invite 0.060 0.040 0.080 0.020 0.012 0.05 0.015
# hard push 0.050 0.040 0.100 0.040 0.025 0.20 0.030
# "refund" is the share of new seats returned in the cooling-off window;
# S->A is the monthly share of holders who let the seat lapse but stay.
# Hours a month: F 1, A 8, S 6. A seat costs RM 1,000 a year, accrued as
# RM 1,000 / 12 per holder-month after the cooling-off window; revenue is
# illustrative arithmetic only.
import math
POLICIES = {"soft": (0.060, 0.040, 0.080, 0.020, 0.012, 0.05, 0.015),
"hard": (0.050, 0.040, 0.100, 0.040, 0.025, 0.20, 0.030)}
INFLOW, MONTHS, PRICE = 1000.0, 60, 1000.0
def run(p):
fa, af, fg, ag, as_, refund, sa = p
f = a = s = 0.0
rev, rows = [], {}
for m in range(1, MONTHS + 1):
new_s = a * as_
kept = new_s * (1 - refund)
f2 = f + INFLOW - f * (fa + fg) + a * af
a2 = a + f * fa - a * (af + ag + as_) + s * sa + new_s * refund
s2 = s + kept - s * sa
f, a, s = f2, a2, s2
rev.append(s * PRICE / 12)
hours = math.fsum([f * 1, a * 8, s * 6])
rows[m] = (f, a, s, hours, math.fsum(rev))
return rows
res = {k: run(v) for k, v in POLICIES.items()}
print("month policy occasional active seats hours/month net seat RM")
for m in (12, 24, 36, 48, 60):
for k in ("soft", "hard"):
f, a, s, h, r = res[k][m]
print("%4d %-6s %10s %7s %6s %12s %12s" % (
m, k, "{:,.0f}".format(f), "{:,.0f}".format(a), "{:,.0f}".format(s),
"{:,.0f}".format(h), "{:,.0f}".format(r)))
seat_x = min(m for m in range(1, MONTHS + 1)
if res["soft"][m][2] > res["hard"][m][2])
rev_x = min(m for m in range(1, MONTHS + 1)
if res["soft"][m][4] > res["hard"][m][4])
print("soft policy holds more seats from month %d" % seat_x)
print("soft policy has more cumulative net revenue from month %d" % rev_x)Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). Mission-Driven Co-Creation Networks, Paid-Seat Identity Commitment and Voluntary Contribution Flywheels (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 5: The Dual-Track Funnel: Free Contributors, Paid Seats and Fairness Between the Tracks. 5D Library. DOI pending
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-360 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026360,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Mission-Driven Co-Creation Networks, Paid-Seat Identity Commitment and Voluntary Contribution Flywheels},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {1.0.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 1 · A Seat Is Not Sold on Perks: How Much of Willingness to Pay Is Identity, Recognition and Mission
- Chapter 2 · The IKEA Effect and the Ratchet of Sunk Investment: Effort Raises Value, and Also Breeds Regret
- Chapter 3 · Honours That Cost No Money: Honour Ladders, Public Plaques and the Saturation of Honours
- Chapter 4 · Does Money Crowd Out Enthusiasm? The Boundaries of Crowding Out
- Chapter 6 · The Community Governance Contract: Design Principles, Protection Against Capture by Payers, Refund Reserves and Single-Tier Referral
- Chapter 7 · East-West Classical Sources: The Record of Rites on the Great Unity, the Platform Sutra, Mauss's Essay on the Gift and Franklin's Subscription Library
- Chapter 8 · System Architecture and the Operating Loop: Registries, Ledgers, the Honour Engine, the Seat Lifecycle and Pre-Registered Tests