What does Limited-Edition Scarcity Pricing conclude, in numbers, about “Method: Three Sources of a Scarcity Premium, Four Indicators, Evidence Grades and "Buying the Casket, Returning the Pearl"”?

Answer: Chapter 1 is the method. In the sample of 500 numbered card sets from an invented brand, Moontide, gross margin is RM 120,874 with no cap on quantity and falls to RM 103,556 when the quantity is fixed at 500; for the limit to pay, a believed limit must raise collectors' willingness to pay by more than about eleven percent (break-even 0.1174). When buyers put the chance of a reprint at one half, the clearing price drops to RM 282.76, below the base price; and showing by a test that one allocation rule halves the complaint rate needs 1272 orders per rule, about 2.54 sales.

Scope of the numbers: Legal rules on such claims are described only in general terms, not as legal advice. Marked boxes separate evidence, calculations, sources and hypotheses, each hypothesis stating what would refute it; the classical source is the Han Feizi parable of buying the casket and returning the pearl, read as a lesson on packaging premiums.

中文版

Data table

The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 0.1174, 103556, 120874, 282.76, 500

no limit, no signal: best price RM 236, sets 857.7, gross margin RM 120874
limit 500 believed fully, no signal: clearing RM 304.24, gross margin RM 103556
limit 500 believed fully, signal s0.12: clearing RM 340.75, gross margin RM 121263
premium over the no-limit price: scarcity RM 68.24 + signal RM 36.51 = RM 104.75
reprint belief q clearing buyers@289 sold@289 revenue@289 margin@289
0.00340.75 730.9 500.0 144500 96165
0.10327.91 688.0 500.0 144500 96165
0.25309.81 614.2 500.0 144500 96165
0.50282.76 456.7 456.7 131999 87846
0.75259.58 239.6 239.6 69242 46081
commitment loss at q0.50: clearing falls RM 57.99, i.e. 0.170 of the credible clearing
signal uplift needed before a credible limit of 500 beats no limit: s0.1174
Show the full program
# Chapter 1. p11: Three sources of a scarcity premium on the Moontide sample: scarcity, commitment, signal.
# Collectors' WTP is lognormal (median RM 260, sigma 0.40), as fixed in p10. Two parameters are ASSUMPTIONS,
# not measurements: q = buyers' believed chance of a later reprint at RM 229 (discount factor 0.85 for the
# wait), and s = 0.12, the WTP uplift that a believed limit adds as a social signal, scaled by (1 - q).
# A buyer facing price p buys now when v - p >= q * delta * max(v - 229, 0).
import math

N, EDITION, BASE, COST, FEE = 1440, 500, 289, 88, 0.03
MEDIAN, SIGMA = 260.0, 0.40
REPRINT, DELTA, S_UP = 229.0, 0.85, 0.12


def surv(v):
    z = (math.log(v) - math.log(MEDIAN)) / SIGMA
    return 0.5 * math.erfc(z / math.sqrt(2))


def margin(p):
    return p * (1 - FEE) - COST


def threshold(p, q, s):
    """Lowest raw WTP v that buys now at price p (WTP after uplift is v*(1+s*(1-q)))."""
    k, u = q * DELTA, 1 + s * (1 - q)
    if p <= REPRINT:
        return p / u
    return (p - k * REPRINT) / (1 - k) / u


def buyers(p, q, s):
    return N * surv(threshold(p, q, s))


def clearing(q, s):
    lo, hi = 100.0, 800.0
    for _ in range(80):
        mid = (lo + hi) / 2
        if buyers(mid, q, s) > EDITION:
            lo = mid
        else:
            hi = mid
    return lo


best = max(range(120, 501), key=lambda p: margin(p) * buyers(p, 0, 0))
qb = buyers(best, 0, 0)
print("no limit, no signal: best price RM {}, sets {:.1f}, gross margin RM {:.0f}".format(
    best, qb, margin(best) * qb))
c0 = clearing(0, 0)
print("limit {} believed fully, no signal: clearing RM {:.2f}, gross margin RM {:.0f}".format(
    EDITION, c0, EDITION * margin(c0)))
c1 = clearing(0, S_UP)
print("limit {} believed fully, signal s={:.2f}: clearing RM {:.2f}, gross margin RM {:.0f}".format(
    EDITION, S_UP, c1, EDITION * margin(c1)))
print("premium over the no-limit price: scarcity RM {:.2f} + signal RM {:.2f} = RM {:.2f}".format(
    c0 - best, c1 - c0, c1 - best))
print()
print("reprint belief q   clearing  buyers@289  sold@289  revenue@289  margin@289")
for q in (0.0, 0.1, 0.25, 0.5, 0.75):
    c = clearing(q, S_UP)
    b = buyers(BASE, q, S_UP)
    sold = min(EDITION, b)
    print("      {:4.2f}         {:7.2f}  {:10.1f}  {:8.1f}  {:11.0f}  {:10.0f}".format(
        q, c, b, sold, sold * BASE, sold * margin(BASE)))
c50 = clearing(0.5, S_UP)
print("commitment loss at q=0.50: clearing falls RM {:.2f}, i.e. {:.3f} of the credible clearing".format(
    c1 - c50, (c1 - c50) / c1))
target = margin(best) * qb
lo, hi = 0.0, 1.0
for _ in range(60):
    mid = (lo + hi) / 2
    if EDITION * margin(clearing(0, mid)) < target:
        lo = mid
    else:
        hi = mid
print("signal uplift needed before a credible limit of {} beats no limit: s = {:.4f}".format(EDITION, hi))

Single source and citation

Fan, Y. (2026). Luxury Scarcity Allocation Auctions, Early-Bird Price-Ladder Dynamics and Limited-Edition Physical Premiums (Version 0.1.0), Chapter 1: Method: Three Sources of a Scarcity Premium, Four Indicators, Evidence Grades and "Buying the Casket, Returning the Pearl". 5D Library. DOI pending

DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-136 · v0.1.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

BibTeX
@book{fan2026136,
  author    = {Fan, Yafu},
  title     = {Luxury Scarcity Allocation Auctions, Early-Bird Price-Ladder Dynamics and Limited-Edition Physical Premiums},
  year      = {2026},
  publisher = {5D Library},
  edition   = {0.1.0},
  note      = {DOI pending}
}

Other chapter answers in this book