5D Library › Cart-Abandonment Recovery Kinetics, Sunk-Data Retention Ratchets and High-Ticket B2B Qualification Mechanisms · 中文
Chapter 6. Allocating Advisor Time, and Deposits as Signals
Twenty call slots, sixty applications
Calculation
# Chapter 6. p11: Twenty advisory calls a week, sixty applications.
# Each application has a fit score; the true chance of closing is
# logistic(score), and a closed deal is worth RM 9,800 or RM 29,800
# (30% choose plus). A call costs RM 350 of advisor time. Compare
# first-come-first-served with calling the 20 highest scores, when the
# score is informative (noise 0.5) and when it is mostly noise (2.0).
import random
from math import exp
SLOTS, APPS, WEEKS, CALL = 20, 60, 2000, 350.0
DEAL = 0.3 * 29800 + 0.7 * 9800
def week(rng, noise, ranked):
apps = []
for _ in range(APPS):
z = rng.gauss(-2.2, 1.0)
p = 1 / (1 + exp(-z))
apps.append((z + rng.gauss(0, noise), p))
if ranked:
apps.sort(key=lambda a: -a[0])
called = apps[:SLOTS]
return sum(p for _, p in called) * DEAL - SLOTS * CALL
if __name__ == "__main__":
print(" deal value RM {:,.0f}; call cost RM {:.0f}".format(DEAL, CALL))
for noise in (0.5, 2.0):
res = []
for ranked in (False, True):
rng = random.Random(79)
res.append(sum(week(rng, noise, ranked)
for _ in range(WEEKS)) / WEEKS)
print(" score noise {:.1f}: first come RM {:,.0f} a week".format(
noise, res[0]))
print(" top scores RM {:,.0f} a week ({:+.0%})".format(
res[1], res[1] / res[0] - 1))
# deal value RM 15,800; call cost RM 350
# score noise 0.5: first come RM 34,912 a week
# top scores RM 69,833 a week (+100%)
# score noise 2.0: first come RM 34,912 a week
# top scores RM 51,628 a week (+48%)In the illustrative model an advisor has 20 call slots a week and receives 60 applications; a closed deal is worth RM 15,800 on average (three in ten choose licence plus), and each call costs RM 350 of advisor time. Calling applicants in order of arrival nets RM 34,912 a week. If each application carries a score related to the true chance of closing (noise 0.5), calling only the 20 highest scores nets RM 69,833 a week (+100%); even with a very noisy score (2.0), RM 51,628 (+48%). The score need not be accurate, only better than chance.
When a deposit is a signal
A refundable deposit (credited on purchase, returned if there is no deal) is often treated as a screening tool. In signalling theory a signal separates two kinds of people only if it costs them differently (Spence 1973). A refundable deposit costs an applicant only the bother of paying and the brief tie-up of money, which need not differ between the two kinds of client.
Calculation
# Chapter 6. p12: A refundable booking deposit as a signal. Applicants
# are high fit (share 0.20, close with 0.40 after a call) or low fit
# (close with 0.05). A deposit of RM 500, credited to the licence and
# refunded if no deal, costs an applicant only effort and liquidity:
# k_high and k_low in RM. Applicant i books if her expected gain from
# the call exceeds that cost, with gains spread uniformly up to G_high
# and G_low. The deposit screens only if it costs low-fit applicants
# relatively more, or their gains are smaller.
PRIOR, CLOSE_H, CLOSE_L = 0.20, 0.40, 0.05
def book_rate(cost, gain_max):
return max(0.0, 1 - cost / gain_max)
def after(k_h, k_l, g_h, g_l, n=1000):
h = n * PRIOR * book_rate(k_h, g_h)
l = n * (1 - PRIOR) * book_rate(k_l, g_l)
closes = h * CLOSE_H + l * CLOSE_L
return h, l, closes / (h + l)
if __name__ == "__main__":
cases = (("no deposit", 0, 0, 1000, 1000),
("same cost, same gains", 150, 150, 1000, 1000),
("same cost, low gains smaller", 150, 150, 1000, 300),
("cost higher for low fit", 100, 250, 1000, 1000))
for name, kh, kl, gh, gl in cases:
h, l, rate = after(kh, kl, gh, gl)
print(" {:28s}: {:5.1f} high, {:5.1f} low;"
" close per call {:.3f}".format(name, h, l, rate))
# no deposit : 200.0 high, 800.0 low; close per call 0.120
# same cost, same gains : 170.0 high, 680.0 low; close per call 0.120
# same cost, low gains smaller: 170.0 high, 400.0 low; close per call 0.154
# cost higher for low fit : 180.0 high, 600.0 low; close per call 0.131Without a deposit, all 200 high-fit and 800 low-fit applicants book, and each call closes at 0.120. If the deposit costs both kinds the same, and a call is worth the same to both, both drop out in the same proportion (170 and 680 remain) and each call still closes at 0.120: the deposit only reduces bookings. Only when low-fit clients expect less from a call (400 remain), or find the deposit more burdensome (600 remain), does the close rate per call rise, to 0.154 or 0.131.
Note
Ethical limits. A non-refundable “application fee” or “good-faith payment” will in many cases be treated as an unfair term; creating urgency with fake slots or countdowns is a misleading dark pattern (Mathur et al. 2019; Laws of Malaysia 1999). Refundable, creditable and clearly stated terms are the floor for any deposit.
Hypothesis · not established
The author’s hypothesis (not yet tested): in the author’s advisory services, scheduling calls by application score rather than by arrival raises sales per call slot by at least 30%. What would show it wrong: in an experiment randomising weeks, the two schedules differ in sales per slot by less than 30%.
Summary
Giving limited advisor time to the highest-scoring applicants does far better than first come, first served, even with a noisy score. A refundable deposit is a signal only if it costs different clients differently or they expect different gains; otherwise it only reduces bookings.
References
Fan, Y. (2026). Cart-Abandonment Recovery Kinetics, Sunk-Data Retention Ratchets and High-Ticket B2B Qualification Mechanisms: Multi-Pulse Follow-Up Timing, Switching-Cost Accumulation and Screening Equilibria [弃单挽回动力学、沉没数据续费棘轮与高客单顾问筛选机制] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090209 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).