5D Library › Cart-Abandonment Recovery Kinetics, Sunk-Data Retention Ratchets and High-Ticket B2B Qualification Mechanisms · 中文

Chapter 7. The Sunzi on the Nine Grounds, the Guiguzi on Probing, and the Mozi on Paying by Merit

Why read these sources here

Each of the book’s three questions has an ancient passage that is often quoted: the urgency after abandonment is likened to “placing them on deadly ground so that they live”, an advisor’s questioning to the Guiguzi’s “chuai” and “mo”, and paying by results to the Mozi’s “measuring merit to distribute pay”. This chapter checks the texts, to see which readings can be computed and which point elsewhere.

The Nine Grounds: deadly ground for oneself, not for the buyer

Source text

Sunzi, “The Nine Grounds” (Jiu di)

投之亡地然後存,陷之死地然後生。

“Throw them into ground where they would perish, and they will survive; plunge them into deadly ground, and they will live.” (杨丙安 1999)

Sunzi is speaking of a general who throws his own army into ground with no retreat so that the soldiers fight to the death. It is a commitment by oneself, not a threat to an enemy or a third party. Turning it on buyers, manufacturing false urgency with “last chance” or “only a few places left”, is exactly the misleading dark pattern of Chapter 6. The corresponding practice is for the seller to bind itself: a real start date for a cohort, a stated date for a price change, a promise of an unconditional refund.

Chuai and mo: ask the most informative question first

Source text

Guiguzi, “Chuai” and “Mo” chapters

古之善用天下者,必量天下之權,而揣諸侯之情。

“Those of old who were good at managing the realm always weighed the power of the realm and gauged the dispositions of the feudal lords.”

摩者,揣之術也。內符者,揣之主也。

“Mo (probing) is the technique of chuai (gauging); the inner signs are what gauging seeks.” (许富宏 2008)

“Chuai” is gauging the other side’s real situation; “mo” is probing so that the inner situation shows outwardly. The date and authorship of the Guiguzi are disputed; this chapter uses only the sense of the text. Written as information theory, “gauging the dispositions” says that the value of a screening question is the mutual information between a client’s fit and the answer.

Calculation

# Chapter 7. p13: "Weigh the power, probe the feelings" - which question
# first? Five yes/no qualification questions, each with P(yes | high
# fit) and P(yes | low fit); prior high-fit share 0.20. The value of a
# question is the mutual information between fit and the answer (bits).
# With answers independent given fit, compare the expected uncertainty
# left after the best three questions and after the worst three.
from itertools import combinations, product
from math import log2

PRIOR = 0.20
QS = {"budget approved": (0.80, 0.25), "team over 10": (0.70, 0.40),
      "deadline in 90 days": (0.60, 0.30), "decision maker": (0.75, 0.50),
      "used a consultant": (0.50, 0.35)}

def h(p):
    return 0.0 if p in (0.0, 1.0) else -p * log2(p) - (1 - p) * log2(1 - p)

def left(names):
    # expected entropy of fit after answering the questions in names
    total = 0.0
    for ans in product((0, 1), repeat=len(names)):
        ph, pl = PRIOR, 1 - PRIOR
        for q, a in zip(names, ans):
            yh, yl = QS[q]
            ph *= yh if a else 1 - yh
            pl *= yl if a else 1 - yl
        total += (ph + pl) * h(ph / (ph + pl))
    return total

if __name__ == "__main__":
    h0 = h(PRIOR)
    print("   uncertainty before any question: {:.3f} bits".format(h0))
    for q in sorted(QS, key=lambda q: left((q,))):
        print("   {:20s} information {:.3f} bits".format(q, h0 - left((q,))))
    sets = sorted(combinations(QS, 3), key=left)
    print("   best three leave {:.3f} bits; worst three {:.3f} bits".format(
        left(sets[0]), left(sets[-1])))
#    uncertainty before any question: 0.722 bits
#    budget approved      information 0.149 bits
#    deadline in 90 days  information 0.043 bits
#    team over 10         information 0.042 bits
#    decision maker       information 0.031 bits
#    used a consultant    information 0.011 bits
#    best three leave 0.507 bits; worst three 0.641 bits

Among the five illustrative questions, the uncertainty about a client’s fit before any answer is 0.722 bits. “Budget approved” gives 0.149 bits, far more than “deadline within 90 days” (0.043), “team over 10” (0.042), “decision maker” (0.031) and “used a consultant” (0.011). Asking only three, the best three leave 0.507 bits and the worst three 0.641 bits. This agrees with Chapter 5: a good question is one whose answers differ most between the two kinds of client.

Measuring merit to distribute pay: pay for increments

Source text

Mozi, “Exalting the Worthy I” (Shang xian shang)

以德就列,以官服事,以勞殿賞,量功而分祿。

“Rank by virtue, assign duties by office, reward by labour, measure merit and distribute pay accordingly.” (孙诒让 2001)

The usual quotation “measure merit, distribute pay” reads in the original “measure merit and then distribute pay”. Applied to advisors and sales teams, the question is how merit is measured. Chapters 2 and 8 show that attributed figures include sales that would have happened anyway; paying by attribution distributes pay for others’ merit. Mozi’s principle asks for merit counted as increments, with refunds deducted.

Hypothesis · not established

The author’s reading (not yet tested): paying advisors by “incremental sales minus refunds” rather than by number of sales yields higher net revenue and a lower refund rate after a year. What would show the reading wrong: in a trial randomising pay schemes by team, the former’s net revenue is no higher than the latter’s, or its refund rate no lower.

Summary

The Sunzi’s “Nine Grounds” is about commitment by oneself and cannot vouch for false urgency aimed at buyers. The Guiguzi’s “gauging the dispositions” can be written as the information in a question, and “budget approved” is the most informative in the illustrative model (0.149 bits). The Mozi’s “measure merit and then distribute pay” asks for merit counted as increments, not by attribution.

References

孙诒让. 2001. 墨子间诂. 中华书局.
杨丙安. 1999. 十一家注孙子校理. 中华书局.
许富宏. 2008. 鬼谷子集校集注. 中华书局.

Fan, Y. (2026). Cart-Abandonment Recovery Kinetics, Sunk-Data Retention Ratchets and High-Ticket B2B Qualification Mechanisms: Multi-Pulse Follow-Up Timing, Switching-Cost Accumulation and Screening Equilibria [弃单挽回动力学、沉没数据续费棘轮与高客单顾问筛选机制] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090209 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).