5D Library › Rhythmic Acoustic Stimulation, Auditory Steady-State Responses and Modulation Signal Engineering · 中文

Chapter 1. Where Is the Envelope? Binaural Beats and Isochronic Tones

Three kinds of beat

Two pure tones close in frequency can produce three quite different things in hearing. A monaural beat: the two tones add in one ear (or in the air), and the amplitude of the sum rises and falls at their frequency difference; this envelope exists physically. A binaural beat: the left ear hears only f0f_0 and the right ear only f0+Δff_0 + \Delta f; each ear receives a tone of constant amplitude, yet the listener hears a beat at Δf\Delta f, which arises in the brainstem from a comparison of the phases at the two ears (Oster 1973). An isochronic tone: a carrier is switched or amplitude-modulated directly, and the rhythm is written into the waveform itself.

One quantity separates the three: the modulation depth of the envelope of the signal reaching each ear. The envelope is the magnitude of the analytic signal, the Hilbert envelope; modulation depth is (maximum minus minimum) over (maximum plus minimum) of the envelope.

Calculation

# Chapter 1. p01: What envelope reaches each ear? Binaural vs isochronic.
# One second of sound sampled at 8,192 Hz. The envelope of a signal is
# the magnitude of its analytic signal, obtained by a discrete Fourier
# transform with the negative frequencies removed (a Hilbert envelope).
# Modulation depth = (max - min) / (max + min) of the envelope, edges
# trimmed. Cases (carrier f0 = 400 Hz, beat or rate df = 10 Hz):
#   L ear of a binaural pair: cos(2 pi f0 t) alone;
#   R ear of a binaural pair: cos(2 pi (f0 + df) t) alone;
#   both tones mixed in the air (loudspeakers) or by bone conduction;
#   L ear through headphones with 40 dB interaural leakage;
#   isochronic tone [1 + m cos(2 pi df t)] cos(2 pi f0 t), m = 1, 0.5;
#   a static 432 Hz tone with no modulation at all.
import cmath
import math

FS = N = 8192

def fft(x):
    n = len(x)
    if n == 1:
        return [x[0]]
    ev, od = fft(x[0::2]), fft(x[1::2])
    out = [0j] * n
    for k in range(n // 2):
        w = cmath.exp(-2j * math.pi * k / n) * od[k]
        out[k], out[k + n // 2] = ev[k] + w, ev[k] - w
    return out

def ifft(x):
    n = len(x)
    y = fft([v.conjugate() for v in x])
    return [v.conjugate() / n for v in y]

def envelope(x):
    X = fft([complex(v) for v in x])
    h = [0.0] * N
    h[0] = h[N // 2] = 1.0
    for k in range(1, N // 2):
        h[k] = 2.0
    return [abs(v) for v in ifft([a * b for a, b in zip(X, h)])]

def depth(x):
    e = envelope(x)[N // 8: -N // 8]
    return (max(e) - min(e)) / (max(e) + min(e))

def tone(f, a=1.0):
    return [a * math.cos(2 * math.pi * f * i / FS) for i in range(N)]

if __name__ == "__main__":
    f0, df = 400.0, 10.0
    L, R = tone(f0), tone(f0 + df)
    leak = 10 ** (-40 / 20)
    cases = [
        ("binaural, left ear alone", L),
        ("binaural, right ear alone", R),
        ("both tones mixed in air", [a + b for a, b in zip(L, R)]),
        ("left ear, 40 dB leakage", [a + leak * b for a, b in zip(L, R)]),
    ]
    for m in (1.0, 0.5):
        cases.append(("isochronic, m = {}".format(m), [
            (1 + m * math.cos(2 * math.pi * df * i / FS)) * c
            for i, c in enumerate(L)]))
    cases.append(("static 432 Hz tone", tone(432.0)))
    print("   signal                         envelope modulation depth")
    for name, x in cases:
        print("   {:30s} {:12.4f}".format(name, depth(x)))
    print("\nReading: each ear of a binaural pair receives a steady")
    print("tone with no envelope at all; the beat exists only after the")
    print("two ears are compared in the brainstem. Played through the")
    print("air, the two tones mix and the beat becomes an ordinary")
    print("monaural one of full depth. An isochronic tone carries its")
    print("rhythm in the waveform itself; a static tone carries none.")
#    signal                         envelope modulation depth
#    binaural, left ear alone             0.0000
#    binaural, right ear alone            0.0000
#    both tones mixed in air              1.0000
#    left ear, 40 dB leakage              0.0100
#    isochronic, m = 1.0                  1.0000
#    isochronic, m = 0.5                  0.5000
#    static 432 Hz tone                   0.0000
#
# Reading: each ear of a binaural pair receives a steady
# tone with no envelope at all; the beat exists only after the
# two ears are compared in the brainstem. Played through the
# air, the two tones mix and the beat becomes an ordinary
# monaural one of full depth. An isochronic tone carries its
# rhythm in the waveform itself; a static tone carries none.

The result is stark. Taken alone, the left and the right ear of a binaural pair each have modulation depth 0.0000: the cochlea receives a steady tone with no rhythm. The same two tones mixed in the air give depth 1.0000, a monaural beat at full depth. With 40 dB of interaural leakage, the left ear still gets an envelope of only 0.0100. The depth of an isochronic tone is its modulation index, 1.0000 or 0.5000. A static 432 Hz tone has depth 0.

Waveforms (thin) and Hilbert envelopes (thick) of two kinds of beat and an isochronic tone. One ear of a binaural pair has no envelope.

Binaural beats depend on phase locking

Since the rhythm of a binaural beat is not in the sound wave, it can only come from the auditory nerve locking to the fine structure of each carrier: both nerves must follow their carrier for the brainstem to have phases to compare. Phase locking weakens quickly as frequency rises and is usually measured by the vector strength (Johnson 1980). Classical psychoacoustic studies of binaural beats likewise find them only on fairly low carriers (Licklider et al. 1950; Perrott and Nelson 1969).

Evidence

Published evidence. Licklider, Webster and Hedlun, and Perrott and Nelson, measured the carrier frequencies and beat rates up to which binaural beats can be detected (Licklider et al. 1950; Perrott and Nelson 1969); Johnson measured systematically how the synchrony (phase locking) of cat auditory-nerve fibres to single tones changes with frequency (Johnson 1980). Exact limits vary with listeners and methods; this book uses only the direction: the higher the carrier, the weaker the locking.

The program represents the decline of locking with an illustrative vector-strength curve VS(f)=0.85e−(f/1000)2VS(f) = 0.85\,e^{-(f/1000)^2}, sets the effective drive of a binaural beat to b=0.25VS2b = 0.25\,VS^2 (both sides must lock; 0.25 makes the binaural response weaker than full-depth modulation), sets the drive of an isochronic tone to its modulation depth mm, and compares the two drives in power.

Calculation

# Chapter 1. p02: Why binaural beats fade with carrier frequency.
# A binaural beat exists only if both auditory nerves follow the fine
# structure of their tone, so that the brainstem can compare phases.
# Phase locking is measured by the vector strength VS(f) (1 = perfect,
# 0 = none); the curve used here is an illustrative shape, 0.85 below a
# few hundred Hz and falling steeply above 1 kHz:
#     VS(f) = 0.85 exp(-(f / 1000)^2).
# The effective central drive of a binaural beat is taken as
# b(f) = 0.25 VS(f)^2 (both ears must lock; 0.25 scales the weaker
# binaural response relative to a fully modulated tone). An isochronic
# tone of depth m drives with m. If the steady-state response grows in
# proportion to the drive, its power ratio is (m / b)^2, in dB.
import math

def vs(f):
    return 0.85 * math.exp(-(f / 1000) ** 2)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   carrier Hz   VS(f)   binaural drive   isochronic m=1")
    print("                                         advantage (dB)")
    for f in (250, 400, 700, 1000, 1500, 2000):
        b = 0.25 * vs(f) ** 2
        print("   {:10,d} {:7.3f} {:16.5f} {:16.1f}".format(
            f, vs(f), b, 20 * math.log10(1.0 / b)))
    m = 0.5
    b = 0.25 * vs(400) ** 2
    print("   isochronic m = 0.5 at 400 Hz still ahead by {:.1f} dB".format(
        20 * math.log10(m / b)))
    print("\nReading: below about 1 kHz the isochronic tone leads by")
    print("one to two orders of magnitude in power; above 1.5 kHz the")
    print("nerves no longer follow the carrier and the binaural drive")
    print("all but vanishes, so the lead grows by further orders of")
    print("magnitude. The exact figures rest on the assumed curve, the")
    print("direction does not.")
#    carrier Hz   VS(f)   binaural drive   isochronic m=1
#                                          advantage (dB)
#           250   0.799          0.15940             16.0
#           400   0.724          0.13116             17.6
#           700   0.521          0.06779             23.4
#         1,000   0.313          0.02444             32.2
#         1,500   0.090          0.00201             54.0
#         2,000   0.016          0.00006             84.4
#    isochronic m = 0.5 at 400 Hz still ahead by 11.6 dB
#
# Reading: below about 1 kHz the isochronic tone leads by
# one to two orders of magnitude in power; above 1.5 kHz the
# nerves no longer follow the carrier and the binaural drive
# all but vanishes, so the lead grows by further orders of
# magnitude. The exact figures rest on the assumed curve, the
# direction does not.

On a 400 Hz carrier the vector strength is 0.724, the binaural drive is 0.13116, and a full-depth isochronic tone drives 17.6 dB more power; even at half depth it leads by 11.6 dB. At a 1,000 Hz carrier the gap is 32.2 dB; above 1.5 kHz the nerves hardly follow the carrier, and at 2,000 Hz the gap reaches 84.4 dB. The numbers rest on the assumed curve, the direction does not: a binaural beat is a weak and fragile stimulus, and its carrier must be low.

Hypothesis · not established

Testable consequence. If binaural beats act through phase comparison in the brainstem, raising the carrier from 400 Hz to 1,500 Hz in the same listener should markedly weaken the steady-state response at the beat rate, while an isochronic tone at the same rate is unaffected. What would show this wrong: if the response to a high-carrier binaural beat equals that to a low-carrier one, the response does not come from interaural phase comparison and another mechanism (such as a monaural beat formed by leakage) must be sought.

Summary

The rhythm of a binaural beat is in neither ear’s sound wave, only in the brainstem; it depends on phase locking, so it needs a low carrier, and its drive is far weaker than an isochronic tone’s. A “binaural beat” played through the air has already become a monaural beat. A static pure tone has no envelope, and at this level there is no rhythm for the brain to follow.

References

Johnson, Don H. 1980. “The Relationship between Spike Rate and Synchrony in Responses of Auditory-Nerve Fibers to Single Tones.” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 68 (4): 1115–22.
Licklider, J. C. R., J. C. Webster, and J. M. Hedlun. 1950. “On the Frequency Limits of Binaural Beats.” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 22 (4): 468–73.
Oster, Gerald. 1973. “Auditory Beats in the Brain.” Scientific American 229 (4): 94–102.
Perrott, David R., and Michael A. Nelson. 1969. “Limits for the Detection of Binaural Beats.” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 46 (6B): 1477–81.

Fan, Y. (2026). Rhythmic Acoustic Stimulation, Auditory Steady-State Responses and Modulation Signal Engineering: Binaural versus Isochronic Envelope Depth, 40-Hz Phase-Locking Bounds and Pink-Noise Spectral Masking [节律声刺激、听觉稳态反应与双耳等时调制工程] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090211 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).