关于「复合模型、不可识别性与个案证据」,《内感受解离与自主神经修复》给出的定量结论是什么?
结论:把链条接成三状态模型后,模型内部「降低高阶精度降低防御驱动、收回传导度」成立,但这是算术——\(\pi\) 乘在唯一抬高 \(S\) 的项上——不是关于身体的发现。该模型有三处已知缺陷,其中最要紧的是它无法表示第一章的情形;承认这一点的变体给出一个可检验的边界条件:常驻警觉先验超过约 0.3 时,降低 \(\pi\) 由有益转为有害。结构可识别性给出本章的主要结果:四组参数把同一条心脏观测曲线重现到浮点误差量级,而蕴含的平均内脏传导度从 0.506 到 0.884、最低值从 0.000 到 0.426,所以「心率变异度上升故内脏灌注恢复」是把假设写成了测量;心脏通道能识别的只是反应的时点。最后,在完全无效应的生成器下,AB 个案设计由于进入时点的选择与自相关,平均给出 +0.294 个标准差的「改善」,朴素检验在 28.5% 的个案中宣称获益,而真实 0.5 个标准差效应下为 61.6%,似然比约 2.2。
数据口径:把注意力放到身体内部而不去解释它,能不能解除交感防御、让内脏与盆腔的微循环自行恢复?本书是教学与研究用的数学模型与方法学讨论,不是医疗建议。 第五,RMSSD 与高频功率随呼吸方式大幅改变:在平均心搏间期完全不变的合成记录中,RMSSD 从 18.4 变到 31.4 毫秒,而 6 次/分时高频指标反而塌陷,因为呼吸峰已移出频带。
对照数据表
下表数字由本章 Python 程序原样打印,可重新运行复现。 程序只用 Python 标准库与结论吻合的打印值: 0.294, 0.5, 2.2, 28.5, 61.6
NO treatment effect in the generator; AR(1) phi = 0.6; entry above +1.2 SD. phase-A mean minus phase-B mean, average over 4000 cases: +0.294 SD cases showing ANY improvement: 69.4% cases 'significant' by the naive t test: 28.5% (nominal 2.5%) The apparent improvement is +0.294 SD on average with no effect present, and the naive test declares a benefit in 28% of cases. Two causes, both structural: entry at a high point guarantees the baseline is above the person's own mean, and autocorrelation means the 14 baseline points are worth only about 3.5 independent observations (and the 28 practice points about 7.0), so the naive standard error is far too small. What the same design finds when there IS an effect of 0.5 SD: 'significant' in 61.6% of cases, against 28.5% with no effect at all. So a 'significant' single case is about 2.2 times more likely when a 0.5 SD effect is present than when nothing is: a likelihood ratio of about 2.2, which on any reading is weak evidence. The design does not separate a real half-SD effect from the structural artefacts above. What a single case CAN establish, and what the Chapter 8 checklist asks for instead: a randomised multiple-baseline or ABAB design with the phase change times decided in advance by someone else, a pre-specified outcome, and a randomisation test that respects the autocorrelation. The program below runs that randomisation test on one series with no effect. observed A-minus-B difference: +0.913; randomisation p = 0.704 over 27 admissible change points. A p value near 1/27 is the floor this test can reach, which is itself a limit on what one case can show.
核心公式
查看完整验算程序
# Chapter 6. The desensitisation case analysis, and why a single case cannot
# carry it. A synthetic AB design: 14 daily baseline ratings, then 28 ratings
# "on practice". There is NO treatment effect anywhere in the generator. What
# there is: (a) an autocorrelated series (AR(1), phi = 0.6), (b) entry at a
# high point, because people start practising when things are bad -- the
# selection that produces regression to the mean, and (c) a slow spontaneous
# drift toward the population mean. The program reports how often the naive
# comparison of phase means "finds" an improvement, and what the correct tests
# do. Synthetic data; fixed seed; standard library only.
import math
import random
from statistics import NormalDist
N_A, N_B, PHI, SD = 14, 28, 0.6, 1.0
# population mean rating; entry when the level exceeds +1.2 SD
MU, ENTRY = 5.0, 1.2
def one_case(rng, drift_per_day=0.0, true_effect=0.0):
# burn in until the series is above the entry threshold, then start the
# baseline
x = rng.gauss(0, SD)
for _ in range(200):
x = PHI * x + rng.gauss(0, SD * math.sqrt(1 - PHI ** 2))
tries = 0
while x < ENTRY * SD and tries < 10000:
x = PHI * x + rng.gauss(0, SD * math.sqrt(1 - PHI ** 2))
tries += 1
a, b = [], []
for i in range(N_A):
a.append(MU + x)
x = PHI * x + rng.gauss(0, SD * math.sqrt(1 - PHI ** 2))
for i in range(N_B):
b.append(MU + x - true_effect + drift_per_day * i)
x = PHI * x + rng.gauss(0, SD * math.sqrt(1 - PHI ** 2))
return a, b
def mean(v):
return math.fsum(v) / len(v)
def naive_t(a, b):
"""Independent-samples t, the comparison a case report usually makes."""
na, nb = len(a), len(b)
ma, mb = mean(a), mean(b)
va = math.fsum((x - ma) ** 2 for x in a) / (na - 1)
vb = math.fsum((x - mb) ** 2 for x in b) / (nb - 1)
sp = ((na - 1) * va + (nb - 1) * vb) / (na + nb - 2)
se = math.sqrt(sp * (1 / na + 1 / nb))
return (ma - mb) / se if se > 0 else 0.0
def eff_n(n, phi):
"""Effective sample size of an AR(1) mean; the naive t ignores this."""
return n * (1 - phi) / (1 + phi)
if __name__ == "__main__":
rng = random.Random(1979)
REPS = 4000
T_CRIT = 2.021 # t, 40 df, two-sided 0.05
hits = drops = 0
diffs = []
for _ in range(REPS):
a, b = one_case(rng)
d = mean(a) - mean(b)
diffs.append(d)
t = naive_t(a, b)
hits += t > T_CRIT
drops += d > 0
print(
"NO treatment effect in the generator; AR(1) phi = {:.1f}; entry"
" above +{:.1f} SD.".format(PHI, ENTRY)
)
print(
" phase-A mean minus phase-B mean, average over {} cases:"
" {:+.3f} SD".format(REPS, mean(diffs))
)
print(
" cases showing ANY improvement: {:.1%}".format(
drops / REPS
)
)
print(
" cases 'significant' by the naive t test: {:.1%} (nominal 2.5%)"
.format(hits / REPS)
)
print(
"\nThe apparent improvement is {:+.3f} SD on average with no effect"
" present,".format(mean(diffs))
)
print(
"and the naive test declares a benefit in {:.0%} of cases. Two"
" causes, both".format(hits / REPS)
)
print(
"structural: entry at a high point guarantees the baseline is"
" above the"
)
print(
"person's own mean, and autocorrelation means the {} baseline"
" points are".format(N_A)
)
print(
"worth only about {:.1f} independent observations (and the {}"
" practice points".format(eff_n(N_A, PHI), N_B)
)
print("about {:.1f}), so the naive standard error is far too small."
.format(eff_n(N_B, PHI)))
print("\nWhat the same design finds when there IS an effect of 0.5 SD:")
rng2 = random.Random(1980)
hits2 = sum(naive_t(*one_case(rng2, true_effect=0.5)) > T_CRIT
for _ in range(REPS))
tpr, fpr = hits2 / REPS, hits / REPS
print(
" 'significant' in {:.1%} of cases, against {:.1%} with no effect"
" at all.".format(tpr, fpr)
)
print(
" So a 'significant' single case is about {:.1f} times more likely"
" when a".format(tpr / fpr)
)
print(
" 0.5 SD effect is present than when nothing is: a likelihood"
" ratio of"
)
print(
" about {:.1f}, which on any reading is weak evidence. The design"
" does not".format(tpr / fpr)
)
print(
" separate a real half-SD effect from the structural artefacts"
" above."
)
print(
"\nWhat a single case CAN establish, and what the Chapter 8 checklist"
" asks"
)
print(
"for instead: a randomised multiple-baseline or ABAB design with the"
" phase"
)
print(
"change times decided in advance by someone else, a pre-specified"
" outcome,"
)
print(
"and a randomisation test that respects the autocorrelation. The"
" program"
)
print("below runs that randomisation test on one series with no effect.")
rng3 = random.Random(1981)
a, b = one_case(rng3)
series = a + b
obs = mean(a) - mean(b)
# randomisation test over admissible change points, 8 .. 34
stats = []
for cp in range(8, len(series) - 7):
stats.append(mean(series[:cp]) - mean(series[cp:]))
p = sum(1 for s in stats if s >= obs) / len(stats)
print(
" observed A-minus-B difference: {:+.3f}; randomisation p = {:.3f}"
.format(obs, p)
)
print(
" over {} admissible change points. A p value near 1/{} is the"
" floor this".format(len(stats), len(stats))
)
print(
" test can reach, which is itself a limit on what one case can"
" show."
)唯一数据源与引用
范雅福(Fan, Y.). (2026). 《内感受解离、突显网络切换与内脏自主神经修复》第 6 章「复合模型、不可识别性与个案证据」(版本 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24020418
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24020418 · 阅读本章所在专著 · 5DL-B-053 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026053,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Interoceptive Decoupling, Salience-Network Switching and Autonomic Visceral Restoration},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {1.0.0},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.24020418},
url = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24020418}
}