What does Pythagorean Comma, Zhu Zaiyu and Beat Roughness conclude, in numbers, about “The Roughness Curve: the Plomp and Levelt Data and the Sethares Dissonance Model”?

Answer: Chapter 5 computes dissonance with the Plomp-Levelt curve and the Sethares model, finds the equal-tempered major third on middle C 1.151 times as rough as the just one, and cites experiments showing that preference for consonance follows harmonicity more than roughness.

Scope of the numbers: Its listeners, samples and copy are illustrative, and all calculations are generated by its programs; the book is not medical advice, claims no effect of any frequency, scale or instrument on body or mind, and is not purchasing advice. Marked boxes separate published evidence, runnable Python calculations (22 programs), classical sources and the author's hypotheses.

中文版

Data table

The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 1.151

C4 rootjustequalPyth.equal/just
minor third0.37230.43400.44891.166
major third0.34580.39810.41581.151
fifth0.12030.14020.12031.165
major sixth0.18270.23870.25201.307
major third by register (root, Hz, just, equal, equal/just)
C265.411.49921.51821.013
C3130.810.70000.73581.051
C4261.630.34580.39811.151
C5523.250.19560.26181.338
C61046.500.14070.21461.525
Show the full program
# Chapter 5. p53: the same model on the three tunings and five
# registers. Same tone and pair rule as p52 (6 harmonics, amplitudes
# 0.88^k, Sethares' fit to Plomp-Levelt). Part 1: four intervals on
# C4 = 261.63 Hz in just, equal and Pythagorean tuning. Part 2: the
# major third, just and equal, with roots from C2 to C6 (A4 = 440).
import math

B1, B2 = 3.5, 5.75
AMPS = [0.88 ** k for k in range(6)]


def pair(f1, a1, f2, a2):
    lo, gap = min(f1, f2), abs(f2 - f1)
    s = 0.24 / (0.0207 * lo + 18.96)
    return min(a1, a2) * (math.exp(-B1 * s * gap) - math.exp(-B2 * s * gap))


def diss(ratio, f0):
    parts = [((k + 1) * f0, a) for k, a in enumerate(AMPS)]
    parts += [((k + 1) * f0 * ratio, a) for k, a in enumerate(AMPS)]
    terms = []
    for i in range(len(parts)):
        for j in range(i + 1, len(parts)):
            terms.append(pair(*parts[i], *parts[j]))
    return math.fsum(terms)


IV = [("minor third", 6 / 5, 3, 32 / 27), ("major third", 5 / 4, 4, 81 / 64),
      ("fifth", 3 / 2, 7, 3 / 2), ("major sixth", 5 / 3, 9, 27 / 16)]


def main():
    f0 = 261.63
    print("C4 root        just    equal   Pyth.   equal/just")
    for name, j, k, p in IV:
        dj, de, dp = (diss(j, f0), diss(2 ** (k / 12), f0), diss(p, f0))
        print("{:<12} {:>7.4f} {:>8.4f} {:>7.4f} {:>9.3f}".format(
            name, dj, de, dp, de / dj))
    print("major third by register (root, Hz, just, equal, equal/just)")
    for name, k in (("C2", -33), ("C3", -21), ("C4", -9), ("C5", 3),
                    ("C6", 15)):
        f = 440 * 2 ** (k / 12)
        dj, de = diss(5 / 4, f), diss(2 ** (4 / 12), f)
        print("{:<3} {:>8.2f} {:>8.4f} {:>8.4f} {:>8.3f}".format(
            name, f, dj, de, de / dj))


main()

Single source and citation

Fan, Y. (2026). The Unclosed Circle of Pythagorean Tuning, Zhu Zaiyu's Root Approximation of Equal Temperament and the Beat Roughness of Just-Intonation Overtones (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 5: The Roughness Curve: the Plomp and Levelt Data and the Sethares Dissonance Model. 5D Library. DOI pending

DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-159 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

BibTeX
@book{fan2026159,
  author    = {Fan, Yafu},
  title     = {The Unclosed Circle of Pythagorean Tuning, Zhu Zaiyu's Root Approximation of Equal Temperament and the Beat Roughness of Just-Intonation Overtones},
  year      = {2026},
  publisher = {5D Library},
  edition   = {1.0.0},
  note      = {DOI pending}
}

Other chapter answers in this book