The Unclosed Circle of Pythagorean Tuning, Zhu Zaiyu's Root Approximation of Equal Temperament and the Beat Roughness of Just-Intonation Overtones: chapter answers
A chain of pure fifths generated by adding and cutting a third does not return to huangzhong after twelve steps; it is the oldest problem in tuning theory. This book writes it, and several popular claims around it, as runnable arithmetic: how large the remainder is and why it can never be zero; why Jing Fang's sixty pipes and Qian Lezhi's three hundred and sixty sometimes helped and sometimes did not; whether Zhu Zaiyu's twenty-five-digit close ratio was right and whether it was needed; whether the major thirds of three tunings become beats or roughness in the ear; and what moving standard pi…
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-159 · 中文版
- Chapter 1 · Twelve Steps of Adding and Cutting a Third: the Exact Arithmetic of the Pythagorean Comma
Chapter 1 computes in exact fractions the ratio of huangzhong to the returning pipe, 3^12/219 or 23.46 cents, and shows that the Guanzi's start of eighty-one is the smallest that keeps whole numbers, twelve pipes needin… - Chapter 2 · Jing Fang's Sixty Pipes and Qian Lezhi's Three Hundred and Sixty: Why Continued Fractions Favour 12, 41 and 53
Chapter 2 uses continued fractions to show that records of closure fall only at 5, 12, 41, 53 and 306 steps, that Jing Fang's seyu misses by only 3.6150 cents, and that by the three-gap theorem a tuning only ever has tw… - Chapter 3 · Zhu Zaiyu's Close Ratio: Digit-by-Digit Roots, a Twenty-Five-Digit Recomputation and the Marginal Value of Precision
Chapter 3 replays Zhu Zaiyu's three root extractions digit by digit and confirms that all twenty-five digits of the close ratio usually quoted, 1.059463094359295264561825, are correct, while an octave error below one ce… - Chapter 4 · Three Ledgers for the Major Third: Just 5/4, Pythagorean 81/64 and Equal Temperament
Chapter 4 compares the three tunings: the equal-tempered major third is 13.686 cents wider than just, and the schisma third eight steps down the chain of fifths is only 1.954 cents off. - Chapter 5 · The Roughness Curve: the Plomp and Levelt Data and the Sethares Dissonance Model
Chapter 5 computes dissonance with the Plomp-Levelt curve and the Sethares model, finds the equal-tempered major third on middle C 1.151 times as rough as the just one, and cites experiments showing that preference for… - Chapter 6 · Beats and High-Register Roughness: the Same Mistuning Beats Low and Grates High
Chapter 6 shows that the same mistuning is a slow beat in the low register and roughness in the high, and that 432 Hz merely lowers everything by 31.77 cents, with modelled dissonance rising slightly rather than falling… - Chapter 7 · The Sources Examined: the Diyuan Chapter of the Guanzi, Zhu Zaiyu's Lvlv jingyi and the Blacksmith Legend in Boethius
Chapter 7 examines the Diyuan chapter of the Guanzi, Zhu Zaiyu's Lvlv jingyi and the blacksmith legend in Boethius, showing that by the law of strings hammer weights of twelve to six give only 600.00 cents. - Chapter 8 · Practice and Falsification: Fitting Marketing Copy with a Detector for Pseudo-Precise Tuning Claims
Chapter 8 gives a checklist, copy-checking rules and a pre-registered test with a sample of 169. Marked boxes separate published evidence, runnable Python calculations (22 programs), classical sources and the author's h…
Illustrative model calculation, not a live quote