What does Error Bars in Dating conclude, in numbers, about “A Date Is a Distribution: Highest-Density Ranges, Consistency Tests and Prior Windows”?
Answer: A distribution with several peaks cannot be summarised by one number. The 68.3 % and 95.4 % levels can give different numbers of segments, and on a plateau the mean, median and mode can lie a century apart. Before several measurements are pooled they must pass a consistency test, or one outlier slips into the result wearing a smaller error. What genuinely narrows a range is an independent prior unrelated to the claim under test, and a stylistic judgement cannot play that role. Here the story of radiocarbon pauses. The next chapter turns to the clock that porcelain and pottery actually rely on, which measures not carbon but the radiation dose that mineral grains have accumulated since they were last heated.
Scope of the numbers: Objects, prices and parameters are illustrative, the calibration curve is a hand-set illustrative line rather than IntCal data, and all calculations are generated by the book's programs. Chapter 6 writes testing as a problem of expected loss; under illustrative parameters a buyer should not buy untested below a prior of 0.655, and a test is worth most at middling priors.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 68.3, 95.4
| 68.3% HPD: 5 range(s) | ||
| 794 to | 744 BC | mass 0.128 |
| 720 to | 690 BC | mass 0.077 |
| 661 to | 607 BC | mass 0.137 |
| 595 to | 560 BC | mass 0.090 |
| 509 to | 410 BC | mass 0.252 |
| 95.4% HPD: 2 range(s) | ||
| 803 to | 541 BC | mass 0.627 |
| 538 to | 403 BC | mass 0.328 |
| summary | year BC | density / peak |
| mean | 603 | 0.896 |
| median | 605 | 0.908 |
| mode | 705 | 1.000 |
| sd of curve BP over 780 to 410 BC: 10.4 |
Show the full program
# Chapter 3. p31: a calibrated date is a distribution, not a year.
# Same SCHEMATIC curve as p21 (not IntCal). For 2450 +/- 25 BP the
# 68.3% and 95.4% highest-density ranges are listed with their mass,
# and three one-number summaries (mean, median, mode) are compared
# with the density at each of them, relative to the peak density.
import math
import statistics
KNOTS = ((1000, 2830), (820, 2500), (780, 2440), (730, 2470),
(680, 2430), (600, 2465), (540, 2425), (470, 2455),
(410, 2440), (360, 2340), (200, 2160))
CURVE_SD = 15.0
def curve(bc):
for (x0, y0), (x1, y1) in zip(KNOTS, KNOTS[1:]):
if x1 <= bc <= x0:
return y0 + (y1 - y0) * (x0 - bc) / (x0 - x1)
raise ValueError(bc)
def posterior(m, s, csd=CURVE_SD):
years = list(range(1000, 199, -1))
v = s * s + csd * csd
w = [math.exp(-(m - curve(y)) ** 2 / (2.0 * v)) for y in years]
tot = math.fsum(w)
return years, [x / tot for x in w]
def hpd(years, p, level):
order = sorted(range(len(p)), key=lambda i: (-p[i], i))
keep, acc = set(), []
for i in order:
keep.add(i)
acc.append(p[i])
if math.fsum(acc) >= level:
break
segs, start = [], None
for i in range(len(p) + 1):
inside = i < len(p) and i in keep
if inside and start is None:
start = i
if not inside and start is not None:
mass = math.fsum(p[start:i])
segs.append((years[start], years[i - 1], mass))
start = None
return segs
def quantile(years, p, q):
acc = []
for y, x in zip(years, p):
acc.append(x)
if math.fsum(acc) >= q:
return y
return years[-1]
if __name__ == "__main__":
ys, p = posterior(2450, 25)
for lev in (0.683, 0.954):
segs = hpd(ys, p, lev)
print("{:.1%} HPD: {} range(s)".format(lev, len(segs)))
for a, b, mass in segs:
print(" {:>4} to {:>4} BC mass {:.3f}".format(a, b, mass))
mean = math.fsum([y * x for y, x in zip(ys, p)])
med = quantile(ys, p, 0.5)
top = max(p)
mode = ys[p.index(top)]
print("summary year BC density / peak")
for name, y in (("mean", round(mean)), ("median", med),
("mode", mode)):
d = p[ys.index(y)] / top
print(" {:<6} {:>7} {:.3f}".format(name, y, d))
spread = statistics.pstdev([curve(y) for y in range(780, 409, -1)])
print("sd of curve BP over 780 to 410 BC: {:.1f}".format(spread))Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). Error Bars in Thermoluminescence and Radiometric Dating: Multiple Solutions on Calibration Plateaus and When to Send Antiques for Testing (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 3: A Date Is a Distribution: Highest-Density Ranges, Consistency Tests and Prior Windows. 5D Library. DOI pending
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-331 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026331,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Error Bars in Thermoluminescence and Radiometric Dating: Multiple Solutions on Calibration Plateaus and When to Send Antiques for Testing},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {1.0.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 1 · Exponential Decay and Error Propagation: from Counts to the Error Bar on an Age
- Chapter 2 · Calibration Plateaus: Why One Measurement Maps onto Several Historical Ranges
- Chapter 4 · The Thermoluminescence Age: Accumulated Dose over Annual Dose, and Its Error Budget
- Chapter 5 · Why Porcelain Carries No Carbon Clock: Materials, Sampling and the Limits of Method
- Chapter 6 · The Expected Loss of Testing: When to Test and What a Test Can Answer
- Chapter 7 · Classical Sources East and West: Zhao Xigu's Dongtian Qinglu and Libby, Anderson and Arnold 1949
- Chapter 8 · Closing the Loop: a Decision Table for Testing Antiques, the Distilled Tool and a Pre-Registered Plan