What does Room Modes and Bass Dead Spots conclude, in numbers, about “Binaural Rhythms: the Physics of Headphones versus Loudspeakers, and the Published Evidence”?

Answer: Chapter 6 shows that a binaural beat exists only in the comparison of the two ears, that over loudspeakers the monaural beat depth at the ears varies with the seat from 0.114 to 0.819, and reports faithfully the inconsistent conclusions of an EEG review (5 of 14 studies supportive, 8 contradictory) and a meta-analysis (pooled effect size 0.45).

Scope of the numbers: Its rooms, absorption coefficients, reverberation times, positions and listening habits are illustrative parameters; all calculations are generated by its programs. It is not medical advice, claims no effect, judges no one's hearing, and asks readers to consult a licensed physician before any self-experiment.

中文版

Data table

The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 0.114, 0.819

head centre (x, y) mL-ear depthR-ear depthILD@200 dB
(2.6, 1.7)0.2610.2163.0
(2.6, 1.4)0.2010.1141.8
(2.6, 2.0)0.2680.641-4.1
(2.2, 1.7)0.6730.7311.5
(3.0, 1.7)0.8190.8514.0
(3.4, 1.2)0.3510.2010.8
smallest monaural depth over these seats: 0.114; largest: 0.819
range 0.705; the field test of Chapter 6 asks for a range >= 0.40
Show the full program
# Chapter 6. p62: a "binaural" pair played over loudspeakers in the study.
# Left speaker plays 200 Hz, right speaker 206 Hz (illustrative), both at
# the same drive, at (0.5, 0.8, 1.1) and (0.5, 2.6, 1.1) m. Ears sit 0.09
# m either side of the head centre (along y), 1.1 m high. Pressures use
# the modal sum of p41 (modes up to 500 Hz, T = 0.51 s). At each ear the
# two tones add, so each ear hears a monaural beat of depth min/max of
# the two tone amplitudes (p61). The study is below its Schroeder
# frequency (p32), so the depth changes from seat to seat.
import itertools
import math

C = 343.0
ROOM = (4.2, 3.4, 2.7)
T60 = 0.51
B = 3.0 * math.log(10.0) / (math.pi * T60)
LEFT, RIGHT = (0.5, 0.8, 1.1), (0.5, 2.6, 1.1)
F1, F2 = 200.0, 206.0


def modes(room, fmax, c=C):
    top = [int(2.0 * fmax * d / c) + 1 for d in room]
    out = []
    for n in itertools.product(*[range(t + 1) for t in top]):
        f = 0.5 * c * math.hypot(*[k / d for k, d in zip(n, room)])
        if f <= fmax:
            out.append((f, n))
    return sorted(out)


def psi(n, r):
    return math.prod(math.cos(k * math.pi * x / d)
                     for k, x, d in zip(n, r, ROOM))


MODES = modes(ROOM, 500.0)


def amp(src, ear, f):
    terms = [psi(n, src) * psi(n, ear) / 0.5 ** len([k for k in n if k])
             / complex(fn * fn - f * f, f * B) for fn, n in MODES]
    return f * math.hypot(math.fsum(z.real for z in terms),
                          math.fsum(z.imag for z in terms))


def depth(a, b):
    return min(a, b) / max(a, b)


print("  head centre (x, y) m   L-ear depth  R-ear depth  ILD@200 dB")
rows = []
for x, y in ((2.6, 1.7), (2.6, 1.4), (2.6, 2.0), (2.2, 1.7),
             (3.0, 1.7), (3.4, 1.2)):
    le, re_ = (x, y - 0.09, 1.1), (x, y + 0.09, 1.1)
    l1, l2 = amp(LEFT, le, F1), amp(RIGHT, le, F2)
    r1, r2 = amp(LEFT, re_, F1), amp(RIGHT, re_, F2)
    dl, dr = depth(l1, l2), depth(r1, r2)
    rows.append(min(dl, dr))
    print("  (%.1f, %.1f)            %11.3f %12.3f %11.1f"
          % (x, y, dl, dr, 20.0 * math.log10(l1 / r1)))
print("smallest monaural depth over these seats: %.3f; largest: %.3f"
      % (min(rows), max(rows)))
print("range %.3f; the field test of Chapter 6 asks for a range >= %.2f"
      % (max(rows) - min(rows), 0.40))

Single source and citation

Fan, Y. (2026). Room-Acoustic Standing-Wave Modes, Low-Frequency Dead Spots, Listening Dose and the Physics of Binaural Beats (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 6: Binaural Rhythms: the Physics of Headphones versus Loudspeakers, and the Published Evidence. 5D Library. DOI pending

DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-288 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

BibTeX
@book{fan2026288,
  author    = {Fan, Yafu},
  title     = {Room-Acoustic Standing-Wave Modes, Low-Frequency Dead Spots, Listening Dose and the Physics of Binaural Beats},
  year      = {2026},
  publisher = {5D Library},
  edition   = {1.0.0},
  note      = {DOI pending}
}

Other chapter answers in this book