What does PPP Distortions and Multi-Currency Price Endings conclude, in numbers, about “Arbitrage Bands: How Wide a Price Gap Can Hold, and What Holds It”?
Answer: The arbitrage band is the full cost of moving a good from the cheap market to the dear one: freight, the currency spread, the reseller's cut, time and risk, and tax above the de minimis line. There are two leak routes: buyers purchasing for themselves are limited by single-item freight and are most dangerous between neighbouring markets; resellers are limited by their own cut, and their band hardly falls below about forty per cent. Under this book's sample parameters the deck's mean band is 37.4% and the box's only 32.0%: the higher the unit price, the less price-level gap the band can hold. All the leaks come from the ringgit market: a price rise alone would take the deck to 139.90, while order caps, local-only shipping and a price rise together take it only to 109.90. Digital goods have no freight, and their tiers stand or fall with a regional check applied equally to every customer. In a general framework, pricing by market is third-degree price discrimination, and what keeps it honest is transparency: a named currency, a total with no hidden fees, one price per market at one time, genuine "was" prices and published order caps. The leak share is watched against a weekly alarm line, and the effect of the levers is tested with a pre-registered comparison.
Scope of the numbers: Exchange rates and price levels in the book are stated sample assumptions, not live data; taxes, display rules and the law on price discrimination are described only in general terms, not as legal or tax advice. Marked boxes separate published evidence, runnable calculations, sources and the author's hypotheses, each stating what would refute it.
Data table
The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 32.0, 37.4
| deck: band_ij in % of shop price P_j (row = buyer market i, column = shop market j) | |
| USD SGD MYR TWD JPY P_i USD | |
| USD - | 38.9%r 43.3%r 39.5%r 38.5%r 43.99 |
| SGD | 37.9%r - 33.6%c 39.3%r 38.4%r 37.52 |
| MYR | 37.9%r 23.1%c - 39.3%r 38.4%r 22.60 |
| TWD | 37.9%r 36.4%c 42.9%r - 29.9%c 34.18 |
| JPY | 37.9%r 38.7%r 43.0%r 33.4%c - 39.46 |
| route: c = consumer, r = reseller at its best parcel size | |
| LEAK USD buyers from MYR shop: spread 94.6% > band 43.3% (route r, n | 200) |
| LEAK SGD buyers from MYR shop: spread 66.0% > band 33.6% (route c, n | 1) |
| LEAK TWD buyers from MYR shop: spread 51.2% > band 42.9% (route r, n | 200) |
| LEAK JPY buyers from MYR shop: spread 74.6% > band 43.0% (route r, n | 200) |
| mean band over 20 ordered pairs | 37.4% |
| box: band_ij in % of shop price P_j (row = buyer market i, column = shop market j) | |
| USD SGD MYR TWD JPY P_i USD | |
| USD - | 34.4%r 34.9%r 34.6%r 34.4%r 280.00 |
| SGD | 34.2%r - 25.9%c 31.4%c 32.4%c 255.64 |
| MYR | 34.2%r 24.1%c - 31.4%c 32.4%c 203.62 |
| TWD | 34.2%r 30.0%c 33.3%c - 27.7%c 231.01 |
| JPY | 34.2%r 32.4%c 34.8%r 28.8%c - 255.03 |
| route: c = consumer, r = reseller at its best parcel size | |
| LEAK USD buyers from MYR shop: spread 37.5% > band 34.9% (route r, n | 200) |
| mean band over 20 ordered pairs | 32.0% |
Show the full program
# Chapter 5. p51: Maximum sustainable price spread for every ordered market pair, deck and box.
# SAMPLE parameters as in p50 (assumed, not live). For a buyer market i and a shop market j, with shop
# price P_j in USD at the p45 sample fx, the spread ceiling is the cheaper of two leak routes:
# consumer one unit, card fee + risk + waiting + parcel shipping + tax over de minimis
# reseller best parcel size n in 1..200: unit cost / (1 - fee - margin)
# band_ij = min(route cost) / P_j - 1. A price P_i above P_j * (1 + band_ij) invites a leak.
import math
from fractions import Fraction as F
FX = {"USD": F(1), "SGD": F("1.33"), "MYR": F("4.42"), "TWD": F("31.6"), "JPY": F("149.0")}
LOCAL = {"deck": {"USD": F("43.99"), "SGD": F("49.90"), "MYR": F("99.90"), "TWD": F(1080), "JPY": F(5880)},
"box": {"USD": F(280), "SGD": F(340), "MYR": F(900), "TWD": F(7300), "JPY": F(38000)}}
SHIP = {frozenset(("MYR", "SGD")): F(6), frozenset(("MYR", "TWD")): F(11), frozenset(("SGD", "TWD")): F(11),
frozenset(("MYR", "JPY")): F(13), frozenset(("SGD", "JPY")): F(13), frozenset(("TWD", "JPY")): F(9)}
P = {"card": F("0.03"), "risk": F("0.02"), "wait": F("0.003"), "extra": F("1.20"), "handling": F("0.80"),
"spread": F("0.01"), "fee": F("0.06"), "margin": F("0.10"), "tax": F("0.10"), "deminimis": F(100)}
WEIGHT = {"deck": F(1), "box": F(3)} # extra-unit shipping multiple; the box is heavier (sample)
def ship(i, j):
return F(24) if "USD" in (i, j) else SHIP[frozenset((i, j))]
def consumer(i, j, pj, prod):
days = 12 if "USD" in (i, j) else 7
tax = P["tax"] * pj if pj > P["deminimis"] else F(0)
return pj * (1 + P["card"] + P["risk"] + days * P["wait"]) + ship(i, j) * WEIGHT[prod] + tax
def reseller(i, j, pj, prod):
best = None
for n in range(1, 201):
tax = P["tax"] * n * pj if n * pj > P["deminimis"] else F(0)
unit = (pj * (1 + P["spread"]) + (ship(i, j) * WEIGHT[prod] + P["extra"] * WEIGHT[prod] * (n - 1)) / n
+ P["handling"] + tax / n)
s = unit / (1 - P["fee"] - P["margin"])
if best is None or s < best[0]:
best = (s, n)
return best
if __name__ == "__main__":
mk = list(FX)
for prod in ("deck", "box"):
usd = {c: LOCAL[prod][c] / FX[c] for c in mk}
print("{}: band_ij in % of shop price P_j (row = buyer market i, column = shop market j)".format(
prod))
print(" " + "".join("{:>9}".format(c) for c in mk) + " P_i USD")
leaks = []
for i in mk:
cells = []
for j in mk:
if i == j:
cells.append("{:>9}".format("-"))
continue
pj = usd[j]
cons = consumer(i, j, pj, prod)
res, n = reseller(i, j, pj, prod)
route = "c" if cons <= res else "r"
band = min(cons, res) / pj - 1
cells.append("{:>8.1%}{}".format(float(band), route))
gap = usd[i] / pj - 1
if gap > band:
leaks.append((i, j, float(gap), float(band), route, n))
print("{:<5} {} {:>8.2f}".format(i, "".join(cells), float(usd[i])))
print(" route: c = consumer, r = reseller at its best parcel size")
for i, j, gap, band, route, n in leaks:
print(" LEAK {} buyers from {} shop: spread {:.1%} > band {:.1%} (route {}, n={})".format(
i, j, gap, band, route, n if route == "r" else 1))
if not leaks:
print(" no leaks")
print(" mean band over 20 ordered pairs: {:.1%}".format(math.fsum(
float(min(consumer(i, j, usd[j], prod), reseller(i, j, usd[j], prod)[0]) / usd[j] - 1)
for i in mk for j in mk if i != j) / 20))Single source and citation
Fan, Y. (2026). Purchasing-Power-Parity Distortions, Multi-Currency Psychological Price Endings and the Southeast Asia–Taiwan–Japan Pricing Matrix (Version 0.1.0), Chapter 5: Arbitrage Bands: How Wide a Price Gap Can Hold, and What Holds It. 5D Library. DOI pending
DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-134 · v0.1.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026134,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Purchasing-Power-Parity Distortions, Multi-Currency Psychological Price Endings and the Southeast Asia–Taiwan–Japan Pricing Matrix},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {0.1.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}Other chapter answers in this book
- Chapter 1 · Method: The Hard-Conversion Trap, Purchasing-Power Parity and Psychological Endings
- Chapter 2 · Anchors of Six Currencies: Denominations, Small Change, Endings and Tax-Inclusive Labels
- Chapter 3 · Purchasing-Power-Parity Distortions: Why Hard Conversion Is a Price Rise in Low-Price-Level Markets
- Chapter 4 · Ending Lattices: Landing a Tier Price on a Number Local Buyers Recognise
- Chapter 6 · Tax-Inclusive Display, Fees and Exchange-Rate Drift: How Endings Wear Down Before and After Checkout
- Chapter 7 · Rolling Out the Southeast Asia–Taiwan–Japan Pricing Matrix: Four Product Classes, Update Rhythm and the Calculator Specification
- Chapter 8 · Practice: Mistharbor Cards Launches in Five Markets, from One Dollar Price through the Four Steps