What does Hosted Retainers and Value-Anchored Shares conclude, in numbers, about “Revenue Sharing and Tiered Excess Shares: Floors, Caps, and the Arithmetic of Aligned and Misaligned Incentives”?

Answer: A share must first say what it is a share of. A per-order base is easiest to reconcile, a measured-value base best rewards the supplier's real improvements, and a base of the client's revenue or profit turns the client's own pricing and cost changes into disputes. When both sides must put in effort, the best share depends on whose effort matters more; in p42's sample the client's effort matters more and the share is below thirty percent, while the split of the pie is left to the fixed fee rather than patched with the share. A pure share runs into the client's alternative cost once the client grows; a pure retainer makes the supplier lose money once the client grows. A hybrid's cap belongs below the client's alternative cost and far from the supplier's loss point, its tiers belong in incremental form, and its floor belongs at the level of the client's slowest month. The next chapter connects these monthly bills to the client's whole life, and shows how retention, discounting and acquisition cost decide what a contract is finally worth.

Scope of the numbers: Marked boxes separate published evidence, runnable calculations, sources and the author's hypotheses, each stating what would refute it.

中文版

Data table

The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 42

                      | retainer       | share 8%              | hybrid B
month  orders  value |   margin  take |    bill  take  p/back |    bill  take  p/back
    0   1,500  5,569 |      920 0.341 |   1,920 0.345     - |   1,900 0.341     -
    6   1,898  7,046 |      832 0.270 |   2,429 0.345     - |   2,282 0.324     -
   12   2,402  8,916 |      722 0.213 |   3,074 0.345     - |   2,765 0.310     -
   18   3,039 11,281 |      581 0.168 |   3,890 0.345     - |   3,365 0.298     -
   24   3,845 14,274 |      404 0.133 |   4,922 0.345     - |   3,881 0.272     -
   30   4,865 18,062 |      180 0.105 |   6,227 0.345   2.9 |   4,534 0.251     -
   36   6,156 22,854 |     -104 0.083 |   7,880 0.345   1.1 |   4,800 0.210     -
   42   7,789 28,917 |     -464 0.066 |   9,970 0.345   0.6 |   4,800 0.166     -
   48   9,856 36,590 |     -918 0.052 |  12,615 0.345   0.4 |   4,800 0.131     -
retainer margin below zero: month 34, 5,691 orders
share: a switch pays back within 6 months: month 28, 4,498 orders
hybrid: a switch pays back within 6 months: not within 48 months
marginal RM per extra order at month 48: Lanyu gains 3.7125
   Bridgecalc nets: retainer -0.22, share 1.06, hybrid -0.22
49-month billings if nobody leaves (RM): retainer 93,100, share 8% 280,001, hybrid B 182,251
pure share billed until month 28 only: RM 95,938; hybrid over the same months: RM 82,759
Show the full program
# Chapter 4. p41: Month by month, when Lanyu's growth turns each contract into a reason to leave or to coast.
# Fictional path: 1,500 orders a month growing 4% a month for 48 months. Contracts from p12: retainer
# RM 1,900; pure share 8% of service revenue (RM 1.28 an order); hybrid B (RM 1,900 covers 1,500 orders,
# RM 0.96 an order to 3,000, RM 0.64 above, cap RM 4,800). Lanyu's outside option from p12: an in-house
# system at RM 5,200 a month after a one-off switch cost of RM 3,000 (p11). Value RM 3.7125 an order (p10).
import math

V, FIX, VAR = 3.7125, 650.0, 0.22
INHOUSE, SWITCH = 5200.0, 3000.0


def hybrid(n):
    b = 1900.0 + max(0.0, min(n, 3000) - 1500) * 0.96 + max(0.0, n - 3000) * 0.64
    return min(b, 4800.0)


PLANS = {"retainer": lambda n: 1900.0, "share 8%": lambda n: 1.28 * n, "hybrid B": hybrid}


def payback(bill):
    gap = bill - INHOUSE
    return SWITCH / gap if gap > 0 else None


print("                      | retainer       | share 8%              | hybrid B")
print("month  orders  value |   margin  take |    bill  take  p/back |    bill  take  p/back")
flags = {}
for m in range(49):
    n = 1500 * 1.04 ** m
    val = n * V
    r, s, h = (f(n) for f in PLANS.values())
    gm_r = r - FIX - VAR * n
    ps, ph = payback(s), payback(h)
    if gm_r < 0:
        flags.setdefault("retainer margin below zero", (m, n))
    if ps is not None and ps <= 6:
        flags.setdefault("share: a switch pays back within 6 months", (m, n))
    if ph is not None and ph <= 6:
        flags.setdefault("hybrid: a switch pays back within 6 months", (m, n))
    if m % 6 == 0:
        fmt = "{:5d} {:7,.0f} {:6,.0f} | {:8,.0f} {:.3f} | {:7,.0f} {:.3f} {:>5} | {:7,.0f} {:.3f} {:>5}"
        print(fmt.format(
            m, n, val, gm_r, r / val, s, s / val, "{:.1f}".format(ps) if ps else "-",
            h, h / val, "{:.1f}".format(ph) if ph else "-"))
for k in ("retainer margin below zero", "share: a switch pays back within 6 months",
          "hybrid: a switch pays back within 6 months"):
    where = "month {}, {:,.0f} orders".format(*flags[k]) if k in flags else "not within 48 months"
    print("{}: {}".format(k, where))
n48 = 1500 * 1.04 ** 48
print("marginal RM per extra order at month 48: Lanyu gains {:.4f}".format(V))
print("   Bridgecalc nets: retainer {:.2f}, share {:.2f}, hybrid {:.2f}".format(
    -VAR, 1.28 - VAR, (0.0 if hybrid(n48) >= 4800 else 0.64) - VAR))
tot = {k: math.fsum(f(1500 * 1.04 ** m) for m in range(49)) for k, f in PLANS.items()}
cut = flags["share: a switch pays back within 6 months"][0]
early = math.fsum(1.28 * 1500 * 1.04 ** m for m in range(cut))
print("49-month billings if nobody leaves (RM): "
      + ", ".join("{} {:,.0f}".format(k, v) for k, v in tot.items()))
print("pure share billed until month {} only: RM {:,.0f}; hybrid over the same months: RM {:,.0f}".format(
    cut, early, math.fsum(hybrid(1500 * 1.04 ** m) for m in range(cut))))

Single source and citation

Fan, Y. (2026). Hosted-Platform Retainers, Value-Anchored Revenue-Share Hybrids and Customer Lifetime Gross-Margin Lock-In (Version 0.1.0), Chapter 4: Revenue Sharing and Tiered Excess Shares: Floors, Caps, and the Arithmetic of Aligned and Misaligned Incentives. 5D Library. DOI pending

DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-135 · v0.1.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

BibTeX
@book{fan2026135,
  author    = {Fan, Yafu},
  title     = {Hosted-Platform Retainers, Value-Anchored Revenue-Share Hybrids and Customer Lifetime Gross-Margin Lock-In},
  year      = {2026},
  publisher = {5D Library},
  edition   = {0.1.0},
  note      = {DOI pending}
}

Other chapter answers in this book