What does Hosted Retainers and Value-Anchored Shares conclude, in numbers, about “Method: Three Ways to Misprice Hosting, the Value Anchor and the Two-Part Contract”?

Answer: Chapter 1 sets the book's sample, an invented middle-office supplier, Bridgecalc, and a purchasing-agent house, Lanyu, with about fifteen hundred orders a month. The system gives Lanyu RM 5,568.75 of measurable value a month, of which the list prices of three feature modules cover only 0.116; a pure retainer stops covering the cost to serve above 5,681.8 orders, an 8% pure share passes the client's cost of building its own system at 4,062.5 orders, while a hybrid capped at RM 4,800 still leaves the client RM 17,475 a month at 6,000 orders; client lifetime is only 15.00 months under constant churn against 32.08 months under sBG; and a grown pure-share client need only churn 0.0338 more a month for the pure share to lose to the hybrid.

Scope of the numbers: Marked boxes separate published evidence, runnable calculations, sources and the author's hypotheses, each stating what would refute it.

中文版

Data table

The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 17475, 4062.5, 4800, 5568.75, 5681.8, 6000

orders value_V cost plan bill_RM supplier_GM share_of_V client_net > in-house?
1,0003,712.50 870 retainer 1,900 0.542 0.512 1,812.50 no
1,0003,712.50 870 share 8% 1,280 0.320 0.345 2,432.50 no
1,0003,712.50 870 hybrid B 1,900 0.542 0.512 1,812.50 no
1,5005,568.75 980 retainer 1,900 0.484 0.341 3,668.75 no
1,5005,568.75 980 share 8% 1,920 0.490 0.345 3,648.75 no
1,5005,568.75 980 hybrid B 1,900 0.484 0.341 3,668.75 no
3,000 11,137.501,310 retainer 1,900 0.311 0.171 9,237.50 no
3,000 11,137.501,310 share 8% 3,840 0.659 0.345 7,297.50 no
3,000 11,137.501,310 hybrid B 3,340 0.608 0.300 7,797.50 no
4,500 16,706.251,640 retainer 1,900 0.137 0.114 14,806.25 no
4,500 16,706.251,640 share 8% 5,760 0.715 0.345 10,946.25 yes
4,500 16,706.251,640 hybrid B 4,300 0.619 0.257 12,406.25 no
6,00022,275 1,970 retainer 1,900 -0.037 0.085 20,375 no
6,00022,275 1,970 share 8% 7,680 0.743 0.345 14,595 yes
6,00022,275 1,970 hybrid B 4,800 0.590 0.215 17,475 no
per extra order: client value RM 3.7125; supplier marginal cost RM 0.22
supplier marginal revenue: retainer 0; share RM 1.28; hybrid RM 0.96 (tier 1), RM 0.64 (tier 2), 0 at cap
pure share passes the in-house cost RM 5,200 at 4,062.5 orders/month
pure retainer stops covering cost to serve at 5,681.8 orders/month
hybrid reaches its cap at 5,282 orders/month
Show the full program
# Chapter 1. p12: Pure retainer, pure revenue share and the book's hybrid as Lanyu grows from 1,000 to 6,000.
# Hybrid "B": retainer RM 1,900 covering 1,500 orders; 6% of Lanyu's service revenue on orders 1,501-3,000,
# 4% above 3,000; monthly bill capped at RM 4,800. Fictional figures; value per order from p10.
from fractions import Fraction as F


def rm(x):
    x = F(x)
    if x.denominator == 1:
        return "{:,}".format(int(x))
    return "{:,.2f}".format(float(x))


V_PER = F("3.7125")          # measured value per order (p10)
FEE = F(16)                  # Lanyu service revenue per order
FIX, VAR = F(650), F("0.22")  # Bridgecalc cost to serve
INHOUSE = F(5200)            # Lanyu's monthly cost to run its own system (assumption)
RET = F(1900)
SHARE = F("0.08")
HYB = dict(base=F(1900), incl=1500, t1=(3000, F("0.06")), t2=F("0.04"), cap=F(4800))


def hybrid(n):
    b = HYB["base"]
    hi, r1 = HYB["t1"]
    b += max(0, min(n, hi) - HYB["incl"]) * FEE * r1
    b += max(0, n - hi) * FEE * HYB["t2"]
    return min(b, HYB["cap"])


plans = [("retainer", lambda n: RET), ("share 8%", lambda n: SHARE * FEE * n), ("hybrid B", hybrid)]
print("orders   value_V   cost   plan        bill_RM  supplier_GM  share_of_V  client_net  > in-house?")
for n in (1000, 1500, 3000, 4500, 6000):
    v, c = V_PER * n, FIX + VAR * n
    for name, f in plans:
        b = f(n)
        print("{:>6,} {:>9} {:>6} {:<10} {:>9} {:>12.3f} {:>11.3f} {:>11} {:>12}".format(
            n, rm(v), rm(c), name, rm(b), float((b - c) / b), float(b / v), rm(v - b),
            "yes" if b > INHOUSE else "no"))
print()
print("per extra order: client value RM {}; supplier marginal cost RM {}".format(float(V_PER), float(VAR)))
print("  supplier marginal revenue: retainer 0; share RM {}; hybrid RM {} (tier 1), RM {} (tier 2), 0 at cap"
      .format(float(SHARE * FEE), float(FEE * HYB["t1"][1]), float(FEE * HYB["t2"])))
print("pure share passes the in-house cost RM {} at {:,.1f} orders/month".format(
    rm(INHOUSE), float(INHOUSE / (SHARE * FEE))))
print("pure retainer stops covering cost to serve at {:,.1f} orders/month".format(float((RET - FIX) / VAR)))
lo = next(n for n in range(1500, 20000) if hybrid(n) >= HYB["cap"])
print("hybrid reaches its cap at {:,} orders/month".format(lo))

Single source and citation

Fan, Y. (2026). Hosted-Platform Retainers, Value-Anchored Revenue-Share Hybrids and Customer Lifetime Gross-Margin Lock-In (Version 0.1.0), Chapter 1: Method: Three Ways to Misprice Hosting, the Value Anchor and the Two-Part Contract. 5D Library. DOI pending

DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-135 · v0.1.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

BibTeX
@book{fan2026135,
  author    = {Fan, Yafu},
  title     = {Hosted-Platform Retainers, Value-Anchored Revenue-Share Hybrids and Customer Lifetime Gross-Margin Lock-In},
  year      = {2026},
  publisher = {5D Library},
  edition   = {0.1.0},
  note      = {DOI pending}
}

Other chapter answers in this book