What does Extra Entries, Extra Layers conclude, in numbers, about “Classical Sources East and West: "The Great Road Is Very Smooth, yet People Love the Byways" and Pigou's Two Roads”?

Answer: Program p71 writes "the great road is very smooth, yet the people love byways" as Pigou's two roads: as long as anyone uses the main road, the byway is squeezed until it is exactly as slow, and those who take it gain nothing; the optimal split could lower the average from 10.000 to 9.000. The ancient description of behaviour is right; its moral attribution of the cause can be refuted by the model. Program p72 tests Knight's criticism of Pigou: when the main road is uncongested, the owner's toll of 4.000 is exactly the optimal toll; when the main road congests too, the owner raises his toll to 6.500 and the average, 11.440, stays above the optimal 11.143. The last chapter turns these models into a loop an owner can execute: how can one run, without harming customers, an experiment that could actually overturn this book?

Scope of the numbers: Marked boxes separate published evidence, runnable Python calculations (21 programs), classical sources and the author's hypotheses.

中文版

Data table

The numbers below are printed verbatim by the chapter's Python program and can be reproduced by running it. standard-library Python onlyprinted values that match the answer: 11.143, 11.440, 4.000, 6.500, 9.000

broad-road slope cshare: freebestowner| owner tollbest toll
00.5000.2500.250|4.0004.000
20.5560.3330.278|5.0004.000
50.6190.4290.310|6.5004.000
100.6920.5380.346|9.0004.000
c = 5: average time free 11.905, owner 11.440, best 11.143
c = 0: owner toll 4 equals the best toll 4: True
Show the full program
# Chapter 7. p72: Knight (1924) answered Pigou (1920): if the narrow,
# good road had an owner, the owner's own toll would produce the ideal
# split with no tax. Check it in exact fractions, then add congestion to
# the broad road too and see where the claim stops holding.
# Narrow road a + b x, broad road R + c (1 - x), demand 1, x = share on
# the narrow road; the owner maximises toll * x. Values illustrative.
from fractions import Fraction as F


def cases(a, b, R, c):
    x_ue = min(F(1), (R + c - a) / (b + c))
    x_so = min(F(1), (R + 2 * c - a) / (2 * (b + c)))
    tau_own = (R + c - a) / 2                 # argmax of tau * x(tau)
    x_own = (R + c - a - tau_own) / (b + c)
    # the one toll on the narrow road that yields the best split:
    # its marginal damage minus the broad road's
    tau_pig = b * x_so - c * (1 - x_so)

    def avg(x):
        return x * (a + b * x) + (1 - x) * (R + c * (1 - x))
    return x_ue, x_so, x_own, tau_own, tau_pig, avg


print("broad-road slope c   share: free  best   owner  |"
      " owner toll  best toll")
for c in (F(0), F(2), F(5), F(10)):
    x_ue, x_so, x_own, t_own, t_pig, avg = cases(F(2), F(16), F(10), c)
    print("       %3s               %5.3f  %5.3f  %5.3f  |"
          "    %6.3f      %6.3f"
          % (c, float(x_ue), float(x_so), float(x_own), float(t_own),
             float(t_pig)))
print()
x_ue, x_so, x_own, t_own, t_pig, avg = cases(F(2), F(16), F(10), F(5))
print("c = 5: average time free %.3f, owner %.3f, best %.3f"
      % (float(avg(x_ue)), float(avg(x_own)), float(avg(x_so))))
x_ue, x_so, x_own, t_own, t_pig, avg = cases(F(2), F(16), F(10), F(0))
print("c = 0: owner toll %s equals the best toll %s: %s"
      % (t_own, t_pig, t_own == t_pig))

Single source and citation

Fan, Y. (2026). Braess's Paradox and Wardrop Equilibrium: When One More Purchase Entry or One More Coordination Layer Slows Everyone Down (Version 1.0.0), Chapter 7: Classical Sources East and West: "The Great Road Is Very Smooth, yet People Love the Byways" and Pigou's Two Roads. 5D Library. DOI pending

DOI pending · monograph page goes live after publication · 5DL-B-246 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

BibTeX
@book{fan2026246,
  author    = {Fan, Yafu},
  title     = {Braess's Paradox and Wardrop Equilibrium: When One More Purchase Entry or One More Coordination Layer Slows Everyone Down},
  year      = {2026},
  publisher = {5D Library},
  edition   = {1.0.0},
  note      = {DOI pending}
}

Other chapter answers in this book