5D Library › HPA-Axis Coupled Oscillations, Cortisol Awakening Response Flattening and Burnout Recovery Kinetics · 中文
Chapter 5. Five On, Two Off
A cycle, not a recovery
The working week is a periodic forcing, and a first-order system under periodic forcing does not make progress; it settles into a cycle. Where that cycle sits is a question with an answer, and the answer is not encouraging. Geurts and Sonnentag set out recovery as the mechanism that connects acute stress responses to chronic impairment: what matters is not the size of the daily response but whether it is undone before the next one (Geurts and Sonnentag 2006). Sonnenschein and colleagues found that impaired recovery, measured through sleep, complicates improvement in burnout independently of depressed mood, which is the clinical form of the same point (Sonnenschein et al. 2007).
Evidence
Published. Geurts and Sonnentag argue that insufficient recovery is the mechanism linking acute stress reactions to chronic health impairment (Geurts and Sonnentag 2006). Sonnenschein and colleagues found that impaired sleep recovery complicates burnout improvement independently of depressive mood (Sonnenschein et al. 2007).
Calculation
# Chapter 5. p09: Why two days off does not undo five days on. Receptor
# density is driven by the cortisol it sees, and cortisol follows the
# load. A working week puts the load on for five days and takes it off
# for two, over and over. Because the rise and the fall are both
# first-order with their own rates, the week settles into a cycle rather
# than making progress, and where that cycle sits is what this program
# computes. The comparison is a full rest of the same total length.
SYNTH, BASAL, EXTRA = 1.0, 1.0 / 28.0, 3.0 / 28.0
C_ON, C_OFF = 2.5, 1.0 # cortisol multiples with the load on, off
WEEKS = 40
def occupancy(c):
return c / (1.0 + c)
def steady(c):
return SYNTH / (BASAL + EXTRA * occupancy(c))
def rate(c):
return BASAL + EXTRA * occupancy(c)
def step(r, c):
return r + (steady(c) - r) * rate(c)
def run(pattern, days):
r = steady(C_OFF)
out = []
for d in range(days):
c = C_ON if pattern[d % len(pattern)] else C_OFF
r = step(r, c)
out.append(r)
return out
if __name__ == "__main__":
full = steady(C_OFF)
worn = steady(C_ON)
print(" receptor density rested {:.4f}, fully loaded {:.4f}"
.format(full, worn))
print(" the whole range a load can move is {:.4f}"
.format(full - worn))
five_two = (1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0)
seven = (1,) * 7
rest = (0,) * 7
print(" week five on two off seven on relative to rested")
a = run(five_two, WEEKS * 7)
b = run(seven, WEEKS * 7)
for w in (1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 24, 40):
print(" {:<7d}{:<18.4f}{:<11.4f}{:.4f}"
.format(w, a[w * 7 - 1], b[w * 7 - 1],
a[w * 7 - 1] / full))
print(" after {} weeks the five-on-two-off cycle sits at {:.4f},"
.format(WEEKS, a[-1]))
print(" which is {:.4f} of rested and {:.4f} of the way from the"
.format(a[-1] / full, (a[-1] - worn) / (full - worn)))
print(" fully loaded value back towards rested")
print(" seven days on sits at {:.4f}, which is {:.4f} of rested"
.format(b[-1], b[-1] / full))
print(" so the two days off are worth {:.4f} of the gap"
.format((a[-1] - b[-1]) / (full - b[-1])))
swing = max(a[-7:]) - min(a[-7:])
print(" the weekly swing in the settled cycle is only {:.4f},"
.format(swing))
print(" which is {:.4f} of the whole range"
.format(swing / (full - worn)))
print(" from the settled cycle, days of full rest to pass 0.95"
" of rested:")
r = a[-1]
d = 0
while r / full < 0.95 and d < 2000:
r = step(r, C_OFF)
d += 1
print(" {}".format(d))
print(" and to pass 0.99: ", end="")
while r / full < 0.99 and d < 2000:
r = step(r, C_OFF)
d += 1
print("{}".format(d))
# receptor density rested 11.2000, fully loaded 8.9091
# the whole range a load can move is 2.2909
# week five on two off seven on relative to rested
# 1 10.3476 9.9046 0.9239
# 2 9.9578 9.3417 0.8891
# 4 9.6980 8.9908 0.8659
# 8 9.6323 8.9120 0.8600
# 16 9.6293 8.9091 0.8598
# 24 9.6293 8.9091 0.8598
# 40 9.6293 8.9091 0.8598
# after 40 weeks the five-on-two-off cycle sits at 9.6293,
# which is 0.8598 of rested and 0.3144 of the way from the
# fully loaded value back towards rested
# seven days on sits at 8.9091, which is 0.7955 of rested
# so the two days off are worth 0.3144 of the gap
# the weekly swing in the settled cycle is only 0.3231,
# which is 0.1410 of the whole range
# from the settled cycle, days of full rest to pass 0.95 of rested:
# 12
# and to pass 0.99: 29The whole range a load can move receptor density, in these units, is 2.2909: from 11.2000 rested to 8.9091 fully loaded. Five days on and two off settles, by about week eight, at 9.6293, which is 0.8598 of rested and 0.3144 of the way back from the fully loaded value. Seven days on settles at 8.9091, which is 0.7955 of rested. So the two days off are worth 0.3144 of the gap and no more, however many weeks they are repeated.
The swing inside the settled cycle is the part that explains the subjective experience. It is only 0.3231, which is 0.1410 of the whole range. A person in this cycle feels a little better on Sunday evening and no better at all across months, because the weekly variation is a seventh of the range and the position of the cycle does not move.
From the settled cycle, twelve days of complete rest bring the density past 0.95 of rested and twenty-nine days past 0.99. Those two figures are what the weekend is competing against.
What the alternatives are worth
The plans people actually choose are a short list, and they can be priced against each other.
Calculation
# Chapter 5. p10: Which way of unloading actually works. Starting from
# the settled working-week cycle of p09, five candidate plans are run
# and the days each takes to bring receptor density back to a given
# share of its rested value are reported. The plans are the ones people
# actually choose: keep going and hope, take the weekends, cut the load
# by a third every day, take a fortnight off, take a month off. The
# model has no opinion about which is affordable; it only prices them.
SYNTH, BASAL, EXTRA = 1.0, 1.0 / 28.0, 3.0 / 28.0
C_ON, C_OFF = 2.5, 1.0
CUT = 0.65 # the load left after cutting it by a third
TARGETS = (0.90, 0.95, 0.99)
HORIZON = 400
def occupancy(c):
return c / (1.0 + c)
def steady(c):
return SYNTH / (BASAL + EXTRA * occupancy(c))
def step(r, c):
return r + (steady(c) - r) * (BASAL + EXTRA * occupancy(c))
def settled():
r = steady(C_OFF)
pattern = (1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0)
for d in range(399): # ends on a Sunday, as in p09
r = step(r, C_ON if pattern[d % 7] else C_OFF)
return r
def load_of(plan, day):
if plan == "carry on, seven days":
return C_ON
if plan == "weekends off":
return C_OFF if (day % 7) >= 5 else C_ON
if plan == "a third less, every day":
return C_OFF + CUT * (C_ON - C_OFF)
if plan == "a fortnight off":
return C_OFF if day < 14 else (C_OFF if (day % 7) >= 5 else C_ON)
return C_OFF if day < 30 else (C_OFF if (day % 7) >= 5 else C_ON)
PLANS = ("carry on, seven days", "weekends off", "a third less, every day",
"a fortnight off", "a month off then weekends")
if __name__ == "__main__":
full = steady(C_OFF)
start = settled()
print(" starting density {:.4f}, which is {:.4f} of rested"
.format(start, start / full))
print(" plan " + "".join(
"{:>9.2f}".format(t) for t in TARGETS))
for plan in PLANS:
r = start
hits = {t: None for t in TARGETS}
for day in range(HORIZON):
r = step(r, load_of(plan, day))
for t in TARGETS:
if hits[t] is None and r / full >= t:
hits[t] = day + 1
print(" {:<30}".format(plan) + "".join(
"{:>9}".format(hits[t] if hits[t] is not None else "never")
for t in TARGETS))
print(" where a plan says never, it means not within {} days"
.format(HORIZON))
print(" density reached after {} days under each plan:"
.format(HORIZON))
for plan in PLANS:
r = start
for day in range(HORIZON):
r = step(r, load_of(plan, day))
print(" {:<30}{:.4f} ({:.4f} of rested)"
.format(plan, r, r / full))
r = start
for day in range(30):
r = step(r, C_OFF)
print(" a month of complete rest alone reaches {:.4f} of rested"
.format(r / full))
print(" the two plans that get there are the ones that remove the")
print(" load rather than reduce it, which is the finding a reader")
print(" is least likely to want")
# starting density 9.6293, which is 0.8598 of rested
# plan 0.90 0.95 0.99
# carry on, seven days never never never
# weekends off never never never
# a third less, every day never never never
# a fortnight off 4 12 never
# a month off then weekends 4 12 29
# where a plan says never, it means not within 400 days
# density reached after 400 days under each plan:
# carry on, seven days 8.9091 (0.7955 of rested)
# weekends off 9.5484 (0.8525 of rested)
# a third less, every day 9.3596 (0.8357 of rested)
# a fortnight off 9.5484 (0.8525 of rested)
# a month off then weekends 9.5484 (0.8525 of rested)
# a month of complete rest alone reaches 0.9915 of rested
# the two plans that get there are the ones that remove the
# load rather than reduce it, which is the finding a reader
# is least likely to wantStarting from the settled cycle at the end of a Sunday, 0.8598 of rested (the same point as p09), neither carrying on, nor taking the weekends, nor cutting the load by a third every day reaches even 0.90 within four hundred days. A fortnight off reaches 0.90 in 4 days and 0.95 in 12, and a month off reaches 0.99 in 29. The two plans that work are the two that remove the load entirely.
One row deserves a second look. Cutting the load by a third every day reaches 0.8357 of rested, which is below the 0.8525 that weekends off reach (both read at the end of day 400, a Monday, when the weekly swing is at its low point). Reducing the load continuously is worse than removing it two days in seven, because the disposal rate is a saturating function of cortisol, so the time spent at a low level is worth more than an equal reduction spread evenly. That is the opposite of the advice usually given to someone who cannot take leave, and it is the one result in this chapter with an immediate practical use: if the load cannot be removed, it should be removed in blocks rather than thinned.
Note
What the model cannot see. These plans are priced only in receptor density. A fortnight of leave also changes sleep, alcohol, exercise, daylight exposure and the thing that caused the load, and a third less work every day may be the only option a person has. The arithmetic says which plan moves one variable faster; it does not say which plan a person should choose, and it knows nothing about whether the leave is available or affordable.
Hypothesis · not established
The author’s interpretation (not yet tested): because the disposal rate saturates, blocks of complete rest beat an equivalent amount of load reduction spread evenly, so a four-day break every six weeks should outperform a permanent ten per cent reduction in hours delivering the same total relief. What would show it wrong: in a trial of equivalent-total-relief schedules with a receptor or sensitivity endpoint, if the evenly spread reduction matched or beat the blocks, the saturation argument would not transfer.
Summary
Five days on and two off settles at 0.8598 of rested, recovering 0.3144 of the gap and then stopping, with a weekly swing of only 0.1410 of the range. From there, twelve days of complete rest pass 0.95 and twenty-nine pass 0.99. Cutting the load by a third every day reaches only 0.8357, below what weekends off reach, because the disposal rate saturates and blocks of rest are worth more than an even thinning. Chapter 6 turns to the one variable that can be moved in days.
References
Fan, Y. (2026). HPA-Axis Coupled Oscillations, Cortisol Awakening Response Flattening and Burnout Recovery Kinetics: Glucocorticoid Receptor Downregulation, Ultradian Pulsatility and Allostatic Load Reset [下丘脑垂体肾上腺轴耦合振荡、皮质醇觉醒反应扁平化与倦怠恢复动力学] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090252 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).