5D Library › HPA-Axis Coupled Oscillations, Cortisol Awakening Response Flattening and Burnout Recovery Kinetics · 中文
Chapter 4. Three Stages, and a Measure That Disagrees with Itself
Why the direction flips
The popular account of chronic stress has three stages: an alarm phase with high cortisol, a resistance phase, and an exhaustion phase with low cortisol. It is usually presented as established physiology and it is usually presented without a mechanism. There is, however, a solid empirical reason to take the shape seriously. Miller, Chen and Zhou’s meta-analysis of human studies found that the direction of the cortisol change depends on how long ago the stressor began: soon after onset cortisol is elevated, and long after onset the diurnal profile is flattened with a lower morning level (Miller et al. 2007). The direction really does flip, and the flip is a function of time.
Evidence
Published. Miller, Chen and Zhou’s meta-analysis found that time since onset of the stressor predicts the direction of the cortisol change: elevation soon after onset, and a flatter rhythm with a lower morning value long after (Miller et al. 2007). Adam and colleagues’ meta-analysis found flatter diurnal slopes associated with worse mental and physical health outcomes across many studies (Adam et al. 2017).
What the account lacks is a reason, and Chapter 3 supplies half of one. Receptor downregulation weakens the brake, which raises cortisol: that is the first stage and it is a positive feedback. But Chapter 3 also showed the receptor has a floor, so the receptor cannot explain a collapse. The second half has to come from the adrenal, and the mechanism the model uses is that a sustained high central output wears the adrenal’s ability to answer. Crucially, that output is itself raised by the weakened brake, so the two processes feed each other.
Calculation
# Chapter 4. p07: Why the same load first raises cortisol and later
# lowers it. Three slow variables are followed day by day. Receptor
# density falls as occupancy rises, which weakens the brake and raises
# cortisol further. Adrenal responsiveness falls while the central
# output of corticotropin stays above a threshold, and that output is
# itself raised by the weakened brake, so the two feed each other: as
# the adrenal answers less, cortisol falls, the brake weakens more, the
# central output rises more, and the damage accelerates. The daily mean
# cortisol is solved each day from the balance between drive, brake and
# adrenal. The fast loop of p01 is averaged out at this timescale. The
# end state of this model, a low cortisol with a high central output,
# is also what real adrenal failure looks like, which is why Chapter 8
# refuses to treat a flat profile as a self-diagnosis.
SYNTH, BASAL, EXTRA = 1.0, 1.0 / 28.0, 3.0 / 28.0
CMAX, FEED_N, FEED_K = 6.0, 2.0, 1.0
TAU_A, DMG, ACTH_THR = 240.0, 0.08, 0.20
LOAD_FACTOR, LOAD_END, TOTAL = 2.2, 240, 720
HI, MID, LO = 1.30, 1.00, 0.80
def occupancy(c):
return c / (1.0 + c)
def solve_c(drive, r, a):
lo, hi = 0.0, 50.0
for _ in range(80):
m = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
if CMAX * drive * a / (1.0 + r * (m / FEED_K) ** FEED_N) > m:
lo = m
else:
hi = m
return 0.5 * (lo + hi)
def acth(drive, r, c):
return drive / (1.0 + r * (c / FEED_K) ** FEED_N)
if __name__ == "__main__":
lo, hi = 0.0, 5.0
for _ in range(80):
m = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
if solve_c(m, 1.0, 1.0) < 1.0:
lo = m
else:
hi = m
base_drive = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
r_base = SYNTH / (BASAL + EXTRA * occupancy(1.0))
print(" drive that makes the normal mean one: {:.4f}"
.format(base_drive))
print(" corticotropin output at that mean: {:.4f}"
.format(acth(base_drive, 1.0, 1.0)))
r, a = 1.0, 1.0
traj = []
for day in range(TOTAL):
drive = base_drive * (LOAD_FACTOR if day < LOAD_END else 1.0)
c = solve_c(drive, r, a)
ac = acth(drive, r, c)
traj.append((day, c, r, a, ac))
rt = (SYNTH / (BASAL + EXTRA * occupancy(c))) / r_base
r += (rt - r) * (BASAL + EXTRA * occupancy(c))
a += (1.0 - a) / TAU_A - DMG * max(0.0, ac - ACTH_THR) * a
a = max(0.02, min(1.0, a))
print(" day cortisol receptors adrenal corticotropin")
for day in (0, 15, 45, 90, 135, 180, 239, 300, 420, 540, 719):
d, c, rr, aa, ac = traj[day]
print(" {:<7d}{:<11.4f}{:<12.4f}{:<10.4f}{:.4f}"
.format(d, c, rr, aa, ac))
load = traj[:LOAD_END]
peak = max(load, key=lambda t: t[1])
print(" peak cortisol under load: {:.4f} on day {}"
.format(peak[1], peak[0]))
def first(pred):
return next((t[0] for t in load if pred(t[1])), None)
d_hi = first(lambda c: c < HI)
d_mid = first(lambda c: c < MID)
d_lo = first(lambda c: c < LO)
print(" stage one, cortisol above {:.2f}: days 0 to {}"
.format(HI, d_hi - 1))
print(" stage two, between {:.2f} and {:.2f}: days {} to {}"
.format(LO, HI, d_hi, d_lo - 1))
print(" it crosses the normal mean on day {}".format(d_mid))
print(" stage three, below {:.2f}: from day {} onward"
.format(LO, d_lo))
end = traj[LOAD_END - 1]
print(" at the end of the load: cortisol {:.4f}, receptors {:.4f},"
.format(end[1], end[2]))
print(" adrenal {:.4f}, corticotropin {:.4f}".format(end[3], end[4]))
print(" corticotropin has risen to {:.2f} times its normal value"
.format(end[4] / acth(base_drive, 1.0, 1.0)))
print(" while cortisol has fallen to {:.4f} of normal".format(end[1]))
print(" that pair, low cortisol with high corticotropin, is the")
print(" signature the model produces and the one a doctor reads")
print(" after the load is lifted, days until each passes 0.80:")
for name, idx in (("cortisol", 1), ("receptors", 2), ("adrenal", 3)):
d = next((t[0] - LOAD_END for t in traj[LOAD_END:]
if t[idx] > 0.80), None)
print(" {:<12}{}".format(name, d if d is not None
else "not within this run"))
last = traj[TOTAL - 1]
print(" {} days after the load: cortisol {:.4f}, adrenal {:.4f}"
.format(TOTAL - LOAD_END, last[1], last[3]))
print(" so the receptor recovers first, in weeks, and the adrenal")
print(" last, in many months: one axis, two very different clocks")
# drive that makes the normal mean one: 0.3333
# corticotropin output at that mean: 0.1667
# day cortisol receptors adrenal corticotropin
# 0 1.4364 1.0000 1.0000 0.2394
# 15 1.4362 0.9227 0.9476 0.2526
# 45 1.3580 0.9124 0.8280 0.2734
# 90 1.1964 0.9405 0.6379 0.3126
# 135 1.0031 0.9854 0.4540 0.3682
# 180 0.7948 1.0524 0.3007 0.4405
# 239 0.5680 1.1705 0.1778 0.5323
# 300 0.4476 1.3225 0.2831 0.2635
# 420 0.6142 1.1774 0.4435 0.2308
# 540 0.7396 1.1048 0.5933 0.2078
# 719 0.8850 1.0403 0.8031 0.1837
# peak cortisol under load: 1.4433 on day 7
# stage one, cortisol above 1.30: days 0 to 62
# stage two, between 0.80 and 1.30: days 63 to 178
# it crosses the normal mean on day 136
# stage three, below 0.80: from day 179 onward
# at the end of the load: cortisol 0.5680, receptors 1.1705,
# adrenal 0.1778, corticotropin 0.5323
# corticotropin has risen to 3.19 times its normal value
# while cortisol has fallen to 0.5680 of normal
# that pair, low cortisol with high corticotropin, is the
# signature the model produces and the one a doctor reads
# after the load is lifted, days until each passes 0.80:
# cortisol 360
# receptors 0
# adrenal 476
# 480 days after the load: cortisol 0.8850, adrenal 0.8031
# so the receptor recovers first, in weeks, and the adrenal
# last, in many months: one axis, two very different clocksThe trajectory has the shape the popular account describes, with dates. Cortisol is above 1.30 of normal on days 0 to 62, between the thresholds on days 63 to 178, crossing the normal mean on day 136, and below 0.80 from day 179. At the end of the load cortisol is 0.5680 of normal, receptors are at 1.1705 and the adrenal at 0.1778, while corticotropin has risen to 3.19 times its normal value.
That last pair is the correction this chapter exists to make. In the model’s third stage cortisol is low and corticotropin is high. That is not the signature of an exhausted gland being asked for less; it is the signature of a gland that cannot answer what it is being asked for, and it is exactly the laboratory picture of primary adrenal insufficiency. The model therefore produces a state that a doctor must distinguish from a disease, which is why Chapter 8 refuses to let a reader interpret a flat profile alone.
Recovery after the load is lifted shows the two clocks plainly. Receptors pass 0.80 immediately, because they overshoot during the collapse, cortisol takes 360 days and the adrenal 476. Four hundred and eighty days after the load, cortisol is 0.8850 and the adrenal 0.8031.
One measure, two definitions
The commonest field measure of the axis is the rise in cortisol over the half hour after waking. Fries, Dettenborn and Kirschbaum review what it does and does not reflect (Fries et al. 2009), and the expert consensus guidelines of Stalder and colleagues set out how much the result depends on the details of measurement, including whether the rise is expressed in absolute terms or relative to the waking value (Stalder et al. 2016).
Evidence
Published. Fries, Dettenborn and Kirschbaum review the awakening response and its determinants (Fries et al. 2009). Stalder and colleagues’ expert consensus guidelines specify sampling, timing and the choice of index, and discuss how the choice between absolute and relative measures affects conclusions (Stalder et al. 2016).
Calculation
# Chapter 4. p08: The awakening rise, and two ways of measuring it that
# disagree. On waking, cortisol climbs for about half an hour and then
# falls. The size of that climb is the most used field measure of the
# axis. The three states below are the ones p07 reached on days 0, 90
# and 239 of its load: a baseline, the middle of the slide and the
# collapse. The burst's height is taken as proportional to adrenal
# responsiveness and the baseline as the day's mean. Two measures are
# computed for each: the absolute rise above waking, and the rise as a
# percentage of the waking value. They do not agree, and which one a
# study used decides what it reported.
STATES = (
# label, daily mean cortisol, adrenal responsiveness
("baseline, day 0", 1.4364, 1.0000),
("mid slide, day 90", 1.1964, 0.6379),
("collapse, day 239", 0.5680, 0.1778),
("recovered, day 719", 0.8850, 0.8031),
)
BURST, TPEAK, MINUTES = 1.10, 30.0, 90
E = 2.718281828459045
def burst(t, a):
# a gamma-like rise peaking at TPEAK minutes, scaled by responsiveness
return BURST * a * (t / TPEAK) * E ** (1.0 - t / TPEAK)
def profile(mean, a):
base = 0.62 * mean # the waking value, below the daily mean
return [base + burst(float(t), a) for t in range(MINUTES + 1)], base
if __name__ == "__main__":
print(" state waking peak rise rise pct")
rows = []
for label, mean, a in STATES:
p, base = profile(mean, a)
rise = max(p) - base
rows.append((label, base, max(p), rise, rise / base,
sum(x - base for x in p) / 60.0))
print(" {:<22}{:<9.4f}{:<9.4f}{:<8.4f}{:.4f}"
.format(label, base, max(p), rise, rise / base))
print(" state area above waking relative area")
first = rows[0]
for label, base, peak, rise, pct, area in rows:
print(" {:<22}{:<20.4f}{:.4f}"
.format(label, area, area / first[5]))
print(" the absolute rise falls to {:.4f} of its baseline value at"
.format(rows[2][3] / first[3]))
print(" the collapse, and to {:.4f} at the middle of the slide"
.format(rows[1][3] / first[3]))
print(" but the percentage rise falls only to {:.4f} and {:.4f}"
.format(rows[2][4] / first[4], rows[1][4] / first[4]))
print(" of their baseline values, because the waking value fell too")
print(" ratio between what the two measures report at the collapse:")
print(" {:.2f}".format((rows[2][4] / first[4])
/ (rows[2][3] / first[3])))
print(" so a study reporting the percentage rise sees a shallower")
print(" flattening than one reporting the absolute rise, on exactly")
print(" the same people, which is a measurement artefact and not a")
print(" disagreement about biology")
print(" minute by minute at the collapse against baseline:")
print(" minute baseline collapse ratio")
pb, bb = profile(STATES[0][1], STATES[0][2])
pc, bc = profile(STATES[2][1], STATES[2][2])
for t in (0, 10, 20, 30, 45, 60, 90):
print(" {:<9d}{:<11.4f}{:<11.4f}{:.4f}"
.format(t, pb[t], pc[t], pc[t] / pb[t]))
# state waking peak rise rise pct
# baseline, day 0 0.8906 1.9906 1.1000 1.2352
# mid slide, day 90 0.7418 1.4435 0.7017 0.9460
# collapse, day 239 0.3522 0.5477 0.1956 0.5554
# recovered, day 719 0.5487 1.4321 0.8834 1.6100
# state area above waking relative area
# baseline, day 0 1.2009 1.0000
# mid slide, day 90 0.7660 0.6379
# collapse, day 239 0.2135 0.1778
# recovered, day 719 0.9644 0.8031
# the absolute rise falls to 0.1778 of its baseline value at
# the collapse, and to 0.6379 at the middle of the slide
# but the percentage rise falls only to 0.4496 and 0.7659
# of their baseline values, because the waking value fell too
# ratio between what the two measures report at the collapse:
# 2.53
# so a study reporting the percentage rise sees a shallower
# flattening than one reporting the absolute rise, on exactly
# the same people, which is a measurement artefact and not a
# disagreement about biology
# minute by minute at the collapse against baseline:
# minute baseline collapse ratio
# 0 0.8906 0.3522 0.3954
# 10 1.6047 0.4791 0.2986
# 20 1.9140 0.5341 0.2791
# 30 1.9906 0.5477 0.2752
# 45 1.8913 0.5301 0.2803
# 60 1.6999 0.4961 0.2918
# 90 1.3372 0.4316 0.3227Taking the three states from p07 and giving each an awakening burst proportional to adrenal responsiveness, the absolute rise falls from 1.1000 at baseline to 0.1956 at the collapse, which is 0.1778 of its baseline value. But the rise expressed as a percentage of the waking value falls only from 1.2352 to 0.5554, which is 0.4496 of its baseline value, because the waking value fell from 0.8906 to 0.3522 as well. The two measures disagree by a factor of 2.53.
That is a measurement artefact and not a disagreement about biology, and it has a practical consequence for reading the literature. Two studies of the same people, one reporting the absolute rise and one the percentage rise, will report flattening that differs by more than twice, and neither will be wrong.
Hypothesis · not established
The author’s interpretation (not yet tested): a substantial part of the heterogeneity in the published awakening-response literature is attributable to the choice between absolute and relative indices rather than to differences between populations, and reanalysing studies with both indices would reduce the spread of reported effect sizes. What would show it wrong: if a meta-analysis that coded index choice as a moderator found it explained little of the between-study heterogeneity, the artefact would not be driving the spread.
Summary
Coupling receptor downregulation to adrenal wear reproduces the three stages with dates: above 1.30 on days 0 to 62, in between to day 178, below 0.80 from day 179, ending at a cortisol of 0.5680 with corticotropin at 3.19 times normal. That pair is the picture of adrenal failure and must be distinguished from it by a doctor. The awakening rise falls to 0.1778 of baseline measured absolutely and only to 0.4496 measured as a percentage, a disagreement of 2.53. Chapter 5 prices the plans people actually choose.
References
Fan, Y. (2026). HPA-Axis Coupled Oscillations, Cortisol Awakening Response Flattening and Burnout Recovery Kinetics: Glucocorticoid Receptor Downregulation, Ultradian Pulsatility and Allostatic Load Reset [下丘脑垂体肾上腺轴耦合振荡、皮质醇觉醒反应扁平化与倦怠恢复动力学] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090252 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).