5D Library › 关系断裂生存分析、断联期记忆衰减与复联博弈窗口 · English
第六章 两个静止状态:戈特曼的差分方程
把伴侣看作动力系统
戈特曼的观察研究发现,一对伴侣怎样处理冲突,尤其是冲突中有多少负面情绪,可以预测日后的离婚 (Gottman 1994; Gottman and Levenson 2000)。他与默里等人把这些互动写成一对差分方程 (Gottman et al. 2002)。在一次冲突对话中,每一方下一轮的得分取决于自己不受影响时的心情 、惯性 ,以及对方上一轮得分的影响函数 :
p11 使用带阈值的影响函数:小的得分把自身的五分之一传给对方;得分高于 0.8 时把对方提高 0.6;得分低于负面阈值 时把对方压低 1.2,力度是两倍。
推导
# Chapter 6. p11: Gottman-Murray difference equations. Each partner's
# score in a conflict talk is W(t+1) = a + r W(t) + I(H(t)) and
# H(t+1) = a + r H(t) + I(W(t+1)), with a threshold influence function:
# I(x) = 0.2 x between the thresholds, +0.6 above 0.8, and -1.2 below
# the negativity threshold T (negativity counts double). Uninfluenced
# start a = 0.3, inertia r = 0.5. Steady states solve x = a + r x + I(x):
# above 0.8 at (a + 0.6) / (1 - r), below T at (a - 1.2) / (1 - r);
# between the thresholds a / (1 - r - 0.2) = 1.0 lies above 0.8, so
# there is no third resting point.
# Two couples share every parameter and differ only in the first
# exchange; then the negativity threshold T is lowered (made harder to
# cross) from -1 to -2.5.
def make(t_neg):
def infl(x):
if x > 0.8:
return 0.6
if x < t_neg:
return -1.2
return 0.2 * x
return infl
def path(w, h, t_neg=-1.0, a=0.3, r=0.5, n=40):
infl = make(t_neg)
out = [(w, h)]
for _ in range(n):
w = a + r * w + infl(h)
h = a + r * h + infl(w)
out.append((w, h))
return out
if __name__ == "__main__":
print(" upper steady state {:+.2f}; lower {:+.2f}".format(
(0.3 + 0.6) / 0.5, (0.3 - 1.2) / 0.5))
for t_neg in (-1.0, -2.5):
for w0, h0 in ((1.0, 1.0), (-1.5, -2.0)):
p = path(w0, h0, t_neg)
print(" T {:+.1f} start ({:+.1f}, {:+.1f}):".format(
t_neg, w0, h0), end="")
for t in (1, 3, 10, 40):
print(" t{} {:+.2f}".format(t, p[t][0]), end="")
print()
# upper steady state +1.80; lower -1.80
# T -1.0 start (+1.0, +1.0): t1 +1.40 t3 +1.70 t10 +1.80 t40 +1.80
# T -1.0 start (-1.5, -2.0): t1 -1.65 t3 -1.76 t10 -1.80 t40 -1.80
# T -2.5 start (+1.0, +1.0): t1 +1.40 t3 +1.70 t10 +1.80 t40 +1.80
# T -2.5 start (-1.5, -2.0): t1 -0.85 t3 +0.11 t10 +1.68 t40 +1.80存在两个静止状态:温暖的 +1.80 与敌对的 -1.80。阈值为 时,一对开头顺利的伴侣停在温暖状态;同一对伴侣开头不顺,就停在敌对状态并留在那里。两人没有任何不同,只有第一轮的交流不同。如果把负面阈值降到 ,也就是需要更多才会引发强烈的负面反应,敌对状态就不再存在:开头不顺的对话在第三轮经过 +0.11,到第十轮达到 +1.68。在这个模型里,提高一对伴侣对对方负面情绪的承受度,比让任何一方更开心更重要。
修复与那个著名的比例
戈特曼研究常被概括为:稳定的伴侣在冲突中每一次负面互动大约对应五次正面互动。p12 加入随机冲击与修复尝试(以机会 抵消强烈的负面推力),并记录正面与负面交流之比。
推导
# Chapter 6. p12: Repair attempts and the 5 to 1 ratio. The p11 couple
# (T = -1) talks for 60 exchanges with random shocks (sd 1.0) added to
# each score. When a score falls below T, a repair attempt cancels the
# -1.2 influence with chance rho. Start (+0.5, +0.5). Report the share
# of talks that end in the negative basin, and the ratio of positive to
# negative exchanges (score > 0 versus score < 0) in talks that end
# well and in talks that end badly. 4,000 talks per row, seed 92.
import random
def talk(rng, rho, a=0.3, r=0.5, n=60):
def infl(x):
if x > 0.8:
return 0.6
if x < -1:
return 0.0 if rng.random() < rho else -1.2
return 0.2 * x
w = h = 0.5
pos = neg = 0
for _ in range(n):
w = a + r * w + infl(h) + rng.gauss(0, 1.0)
h = a + r * h + infl(w) + rng.gauss(0, 1.0)
for x in (w, h):
pos += x > 0
neg += x < 0
return (w + h) / 2 < 0, pos, neg
if __name__ == "__main__":
rng = random.Random(92)
print(" repair rho ends negative pos:neg (good) pos:neg (bad)")
for rho in (0.0, 0.3, 0.6, 0.9):
res = [talk(rng, rho) for _ in range(4000)]
bad = [x for x in res if x[0]]
good = [x for x in res if not x[0]]
rg = sum(x[1] for x in good) / max(1, sum(x[2] for x in good))
rb = sum(x[1] for x in bad) / max(1, sum(x[2] for x in bad))
print(" {:10.1f} {:13.3f} {:14.2f} {:13.2f}".format(
rho, len(bad) / len(res), rg, rb))
# repair rho ends negative pos:neg (good) pos:neg (bad)
# 0.0 0.184 4.02 2.75
# 0.3 0.128 5.19 3.91
# 0.6 0.100 6.05 4.57
# 0.9 0.096 6.82 5.10没有修复时,0.184 的对话以敌对状态结束;修复三成成功时 0.128;六成时 0.100;九成时 0.096。比例的表现没有那么简单。结局良好的对话,没有修复时比例是 4.02,修复频繁时 6.82;结局不好的对话分别是 2.75 与 5.10。于是,修复频繁的坏对话可以显示出比没有修复的好对话更高的比例。这个比例是一对伴侣动态的结果,并且取决于怎样计数;它不是一个本身就决定伴侣命运的门槛。
假说 · 尚未验证
作者的诠释(尚未验证): 在观察到的冲突讨论中,一对伴侣从一次负面交流中恢复的速度,比正负交流的总比例更能预测日后的稳定。什么会证明它错: 在一项对冲突讨论编码的预先登记纵向研究中,总比例预测分手至少与恢复速度一样好,而在已知总比例之后恢复速度没有增加任何预测力。
小结
在戈特曼与默里的模型里,同一对伴侣可以停在温暖或敌对的状态,而负面情绪在什么阈值引发强烈反应,决定了敌对状态是否存在。修复有帮助,但好坏时刻的单一比例只是概括,不是定律。
参考文献
Fan, Y. (2026). Relationship Rupture Survival Analysis, No-Contact Memory Decay and Reconciliation Game Windows: Negative-Affect Dissipation Rates, Dual-Process Nostalgia Peaks and Signaling Equilibria [关系断裂生存分析、断联期记忆衰减与复联博弈窗口] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090241 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).