5D Library › Rhythmic Acoustic Stimulation, Auditory Steady-State Responses and Modulation Signal Engineering · 中文

Chapter 2. Auditory Steady-State Responses and the Arnold Tongue

Two meanings of “entrainment”

To say that a rhythmic sound “entrains” brain waves can mean two very different things. The weak meaning is an evoked response: each cycle of the sound evokes a small neural response, and these add up to a spectral line at the stimulation rate in the EEG, the auditory steady-state response (ASSR). Responses near 40 Hz are especially clear (Galambos et al. 1981), and the ASSR is an established objective hearing test in audiology (Picton et al. 2003). The strong meaning is synchronisation: an intrinsic rhythm that already exists is pulled to the frequency of an external drive and stays there for a while after the drive stops. The latter needs an oscillator; the former does not.

The Arnold tongue

The simplest model of synchronisation is Adler’s equation (Adler 1946): with phase difference φ\varphi between the intrinsic rhythm and the drive, detuning ν\nu and coupling KK, φ̇=2πν−Ksin⁡φ\dot\varphi = 2\pi\nu – K\sin\varphi. Without noise the phase difference settles to a fixed value if and only if |2πν|≤K|2\pi\nu| \le K; this is locking, and in the plane of detuning and coupling the locked region is a “tongue” opening from zero detuning (Kuramoto 1984; Pikovsky et al. 2001). With noise, locking becomes a matter of degree, measured by the phase locking value (PLV) (Lachaux et al. 1999).

Calculation

# Chapter 2. p03: The Arnold tongue of a noisy phase oscillator.
# Adler's equation for the phase difference phi between an intrinsic
# rhythm and a periodic drive, with detuning nu (Hz) and coupling K
# (rad/s), plus white phase noise of strength D:
#     dphi = (2 pi nu - K sin phi) dt + sqrt(2 D dt) N(0, 1).
# Without noise the rhythm locks exactly when |2 pi nu| <= K (the
# tongue). With noise, locking is graded; we measure it by the phase
# locking value PLV = |mean exp(i phi)| over 60 s after a 5 s burn-in.
# Euler-Maruyama step 1 ms, fixed seed. D = 2 rad^2/s throughout.
import cmath
import math
import random

def plv(nu, K, D=2.0, T=60.0, dt=0.001, seed=7):
    rng = random.Random(seed)
    phi, acc, n = 0.0, 0j, 0
    burn = int(5.0 / dt)
    sd = math.sqrt(2 * D * dt)
    w = 2 * math.pi * nu
    for i in range(burn + int(T / dt)):
        phi += (w - K * math.sin(phi)) * dt + sd * rng.gauss(0, 1)
        if i >= burn and i % 10 == 0:
            acc += cmath.exp(1j * phi)
            n += 1
    return abs(acc) / n

if __name__ == "__main__":
    nus = (0.0, 0.5, 1.0, 2.0, 4.0)
    Ks = (2.0, 6.0, 12.0, 25.0)
    print("   PLV after 60 s; rows: coupling K (rad/s); cols: detuning nu")
    print("   K \\ nu  " + "".join("{:>9.1f}".format(v) for v in nus))
    for K in Ks:
        row = [plv(v, K) for v in nus]
        print("   {:6.1f}  ".format(K) + "".join(
            "{:9.3f}".format(r) for r in row))
    print("\n   noiseless tongue edge |nu| = K / (2 pi):")
    for K in Ks:
        print("     K = {:5.1f}  ->  |nu| <= {:.3f} Hz".format(
            K, K / (2 * math.pi)))
    print("\nReading: a weak drive locks a rhythm only if it is almost")
    print("at the same frequency already; the tongue widens in")
    print("proportion to the coupling. Outside the tongue the PLV")
    print("falls towards the chance floor for 6,000 samples.")
#    PLV after 60 s; rows: coupling K (rad/s); cols: detuning nu
#    K \ nu        0.0      0.5      1.0      2.0      4.0
#       2.0      0.544    0.287    0.146    0.077    0.043
#       6.0      0.838    0.736    0.496    0.251    0.115
#      12.0      0.921    0.917    0.880    0.588    0.244
#      25.0      0.962    0.962    0.960    0.954    0.690
#
#    noiseless tongue edge |nu| = K / (2 pi):
#      K =   2.0  ->  |nu| <= 0.318 Hz
#      K =   6.0  ->  |nu| <= 0.955 Hz
#      K =  12.0  ->  |nu| <= 1.910 Hz
#      K =  25.0  ->  |nu| <= 3.979 Hz
#
# Reading: a weak drive locks a rhythm only if it is almost
# at the same frequency already; the tongue widens in
# proportion to the coupling. Outside the tongue the PLV
# falls towards the chance floor for 6,000 samples.

With coupling 6 rad/s the PLV is 0.838 at zero detuning and 0.251 at a detuning of 2 Hz; the noiseless edge of the tongue is at 0.955 Hz. With coupling 25 rad/s the edge is at 3.979 Hz and the PLV at a detuning of 4 Hz is still 0.690. The tongue widens in proportion to the coupling: a weak drive can lock only a rhythm that is already close in frequency. For rhythmic audio this means that pulling a 10 Hz intrinsic rhythm to 6 Hz would need a very strong drive, and Chapter 1 showed that a binaural beat is precisely a weak one.

PLV against detuning for four coupling strengths. Dotted lines mark the noiseless edges of the tongue.

How long must one record?

Even for an evoked response alone, one must ask whether it can be seen. Let the response amplitude peak near 40 Hz and the power density of the background EEG fall as 1/f1/f. A Fourier transform of length TT places the response in one bin of width 1/T1/T, while the noise power in that bin falls with TT; so the power signal-to-noise ratio grows in proportion to TT and the amplitude ratio as T\sqrt{T}. The program asks for 10 dB and at least ten full cycles.

Calculation

# Chapter 2. p04: How long must a rhythm play before EEG can see it?
# Illustrative model of an auditory steady-state response (ASSR):
#   response amplitude a(fm) = 0.15 + 0.35 exp(-((fm - 40) / 10)^2) uV
#     for a fully modulated (isochronic) drive, scaled by the drive;
#   background EEG power density P(f) = 4 / f uV^2/Hz (a 1/f law).
# A DFT of T seconds puts the response in one bin of width 1/T, so the
# power SNR is (a^2 / 2) T / P(fm): it grows in proportion to T and the
# amplitude SNR as sqrt(T). We ask for 10 dB and also for at least ten
# full cycles. Binaural drive = 0.13116 (carrier 400 Hz, from p02).
# Then: the drive of a static tone, wavelengths of 432 and 528 Hz,
# and the chance level of the phase locking value over M epochs.
import math

def amp(fm):
    return 0.15 + 0.35 * math.exp(-((fm - 40.0) / 10.0) ** 2)

def t_needed(fm, drive, target_db=10.0):
    a = amp(fm) * drive
    snr_per_s = (a * a / 2.0) / (4.0 / fm)
    t_snr = 10 ** (target_db / 10.0) / snr_per_s
    return max(t_snr, 10.0 / fm)

def fmt(t):
    if t < 60:
        return "{:8.1f} s".format(t)
    if t < 3600:
        return "{:8.1f} m".format(t / 60)
    return "{:8.1f} h".format(t / 3600)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   rate Hz   a (uV)   isochronic T   binaural T   ratio")
    for fm in (0.1, 2.0, 6.0, 10.0, 40.0):
        ti, tb = t_needed(fm, 1.0), t_needed(fm, 0.13116)
        print("   {:7.1f} {:8.3f}   {}   {}  {:6.1f}".format(
            fm, amp(fm), fmt(ti), fmt(tb), tb / ti))
    print("\n   amplitude SNR at 40 Hz, isochronic, as T grows:")
    for T in (1, 4, 16, 64):
        s = (amp(40) ** 2 / 2) * T / (4.0 / 40)
        print("     T = {:3d} s   power {:7.2f}   amplitude {:6.2f}".format(
            T, s, math.sqrt(s)))
    print("\n   static tones: modulation depth 0, so drive 0 and a")
    print("   response of 0 uV at every rate and every duration.")
    for f in (432, 528):
        print("   {} Hz: wavelength {:.3f} m in air, {:.3f} m in water,"
              .format(f, 343.0 / f, 1480.0 / f))
        print("           {:.2f} billion times the 2 nm width of DNA"
              .format(1480.0 / f / 2e-9 / 1e9))
    print("\n   chance PLV for M random-phase epochs, sqrt(pi / (4 M)):")
    for M in (10, 40, 160, 640):
        print("     M = {:4d}   {:.4f}".format(M, math.sqrt(math.pi / 4 / M)))
#    rate Hz   a (uV)   isochronic T   binaural T   ratio
#        0.1    0.150        9.9 h      574.1 h    58.1
#        2.0    0.150       29.6 m       28.7 h    58.1
#        6.0    0.150        9.9 m        9.6 h    58.1
#       10.0    0.150        5.9 m        5.7 h    58.1
#       40.0    0.500        8.0 s        7.8 m    58.1
#
#    amplitude SNR at 40 Hz, isochronic, as T grows:
#      T =   1 s   power    1.25   amplitude   1.12
#      T =   4 s   power    5.00   amplitude   2.24
#      T =  16 s   power   20.00   amplitude   4.47
#      T =  64 s   power   80.00   amplitude   8.94
#
#    static tones: modulation depth 0, so drive 0 and a
#    response of 0 uV at every rate and every duration.
#    432 Hz: wavelength 0.794 m in air, 3.426 m in water,
#            1.71 billion times the 2 nm width of DNA
#    528 Hz: wavelength 0.650 m in air, 2.803 m in water,
#            1.40 billion times the 2 nm width of DNA
#
#    chance PLV for M random-phase epochs, sqrt(pi / (4 M)):
#      M =   10   0.2802
#      M =   40   0.1401
#      M =  160   0.0701
#      M =  640   0.0350

A full-depth 40 Hz isochronic tone needs only 8.0 s; a binaural beat at the same rate needs 7.8 min, 58.1 times longer. At 10 Hz the isochronic tone needs 5.9 min and the binaural beat 5.7 h; at 0.1 Hz even the isochronic tone needs 9.9 h, ten cycles alone take 100 s, and the low-frequency background of the EEG is very large. The amplitude ratio grows as the square root of time: 1.12 at 1 s, 4.47 at 16 s.

A static 432 Hz or 528 Hz tone has modulation depth 0 and drive 0 and produces no rhythmic response for any duration. Its wavelength is 0.794 m or 0.650 m in air and 3.426 m or 2.803 m in water, which is 1.71 billion and 1.40 billion times the width of the DNA double helix (about 2 nm). At that scale a sound wave is just a uniform change of pressure on a molecule; “resonant repair” has nothing to act through.

Finally, the PLV has a chance level of its own: the mean length of MM unit vectors with random phases is about π/(4M)\sqrt{\pi/(4M)}, which is 0.2802 for 10 epochs and 0.0350 for 640. A PLV reported without the number of epochs reports nothing.

Hypothesis · not established

Testable consequence. If 432 Hz and 528 Hz tones have a frequency-specific effect on the EEG, then under double-blind conditions they should differ from a 440 Hz tone in power or phase locking in pre-specified bands and electrodes. What would show this wrong: if, with an adequate sample and a pre-registered analysis, the EEG measures do not differ between the three tones, the claim of “special frequencies” has no physiological basis.

Summary

The measurable kind of entrainment is the steady-state response, strongest near 40 Hz, which takes seconds to minutes of recording to see; binaural beats take far longer. True synchronisation is bounded by the Arnold tongue: a weak drive can lock only a rhythm already close in frequency. A static pure tone offers no rhythm to evoke or synchronise.

References

Adler, Robert. 1946. “A Study of Locking Phenomena in Oscillators.” Proceedings of the IRE 34 (6): 351–57.
Galambos, Robert, Scott Makeig, and Peter J. Talmachoff. 1981. “A 40-Hz Auditory Potential Recorded from the Human Scalp.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 78 (4): 2643–47.
Kuramoto, Yoshiki. 1984. Chemical Oscillations, Waves, and Turbulence. Springer.
Lachaux, Jean-Philippe, Eugenio Rodriguez, Jacques Martinerie, and Francisco J. Varela. 1999. “Measuring Phase Synchrony in Brain Signals.” Human Brain Mapping 8 (4): 194–208.
Picton, Terence W., M. Sasha John, Andrew Dimitrijevic, and David Purcell. 2003. “Human Auditory Steady-State Responses.” International Journal of Audiology 42 (4): 177–219.
Pikovsky, Arkady, Michael Rosenblum, and Jürgen Kurths. 2001. Synchronization: A Universal Concept in Nonlinear Sciences. Cambridge University Press.

Fan, Y. (2026). Rhythmic Acoustic Stimulation, Auditory Steady-State Responses and Modulation Signal Engineering: Binaural versus Isochronic Envelope Depth, 40-Hz Phase-Locking Bounds and Pink-Noise Spectral Masking [节律声刺激、听觉稳态反应与双耳等时调制工程] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090211 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).