5D Library › Biomathematical Models of Sub-Perceptual Tryptamine Pharmacokinetics, 5-HT2A Receptor Desensitisation and Neuroplastic Window Dynamics · 中文
Chapter 1. Receptor Occupancy: No Corner, Therefore No Threshold
5-HT2A and the psychedelic effect
Evidence
Receptor and subjective effect (human and animal). The subjective effects of psychedelic tryptamines and phenethylamines involve agonism at the 5-HT2A receptor. In 1984 Glennon and colleagues inferred 5-HT2 involvement from the correlation between receptor affinity and behavioural potency across a series of compounds (Glennon, Titeler, and McKenney 1984). Nichols’s long review collects the chemistry, receptor pharmacology and signalling of this class (Nichols 2016), and Vollenweider and Preller review the neurobiology and clinical potential (Vollenweider and Preller 2020). The most direct human evidence is pharmacological blockade: Preller and colleagues found that pre-treatment with a 5-HT2A antagonist abolishes the subjective effects of LSD and its alterations of meaning attribution (Preller et al. 2017).
That establishes 5-HT2A agonism as a necessary link in producing a marked subjective effect. It says nothing about what remains at exposures far below those that produce a marked effect — which is the question of this book, and this chapter shows that the receptor itself cannot answer it.
The shape of occupancy
Occupancy follows the Hill relation. Writing for the effect-site concentration in units of the half-occupancy concentration (so is 50 % occupancy) and for the Hill coefficient:
The origin of the Hill equation and its place in quantitative pharmacology have been examined by Gesztelyi and colleagues (Gesztelyi et al. 2012). Every concentration in this book is a dimensionless quantity of this kind.
Calculation
# Chapter 1. Receptor occupancy as a continuous function, and why
# "sub-perceptual" is not a property of a dose. Occupancy follows the Hill
# relation
# O(c) = c^h / (c^h + 1)
# where c is the effect-site concentration in units of the half-occupancy
# concentration (so c = 1 is 50 % occupancy) and h is the Hill coefficient.
# EVERY concentration in this book is dimensionless: c = C / EC50. No mass, no
# dose and no product is named anywhere. The point of the program is that
# occupancy has no kink: there is no concentration at which an effect
# "switches on", so a boundary between perceptible and imperceptible has to
# come from somewhere other than the receptor. Exact arithmetic, no
# simulation.
import math
def occupancy(c, h=1.0):
if c <= 0:
return 0.0
return c ** h / (c ** h + 1.0)
def conc_for_occupancy(o, h=1.0):
return (o / (1.0 - o)) ** (1.0 / h)
if __name__ == "__main__":
print(
"Occupancy against dimensionless effect-site concentration c = C /"
" EC50.\n"
)
print(" c h = 0.8 h = 1.0 h = 1.5 h = 2.0")
for c in (0.01, 0.03, 0.1, 0.3, 1.0, 3.0, 10.0):
print(" {:7.2f}".format(c) + "".join(
"{:10.4f}".format(occupancy(c, h)) for h in (0.8, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0)))
print(
"\nThe local slope d log O / d log c, i.e. the fold change in"
" occupancy per"
)
print("fold change in concentration (h = 1):")
print(" c occupancy slope")
for c in (0.03, 0.1, 0.3, 1.0, 3.0, 10.0):
o = occupancy(c)
# d log O / d log c = 1 - O for h = 1
slope = 1.0 - o
print(" {:7.2f} {:11.4f} {:7.3f}".format(c, o, slope))
print(
"\n The slope falls smoothly from 1 toward 0 and is never zero or"
" infinite:"
)
print(
" there is no concentration at which the curve turns a corner. So"
" no dose"
)
print(
" is 'sub-perceptual' by virtue of the receptor; a threshold has"
" to be"
)
print(
" imposed by perception, and programme p05 shows it is a"
" distribution"
)
print(" across people rather than a number.")
print(
"\nConcentration needed for a given occupancy (h = 1), relative to"
" 50 %:"
)
for o in (0.05, 0.10, 0.25, 0.50, 0.75, 0.90):
print(
" {:3.0%} occupancy at c = {:7.4f}".format(
o, conc_for_occupancy(o)
)
)
print(
"\nA consequence for the word 'microdose'. If one exposure gives c ="
" c0 and"
)
print("another gives c = c0/5, occupancy does NOT fall fivefold:")
for c0 in (0.2, 1.0, 5.0):
o1, o2 = occupancy(c0), occupancy(c0 / 5.0)
print(
" c0 = {:4.1f}: occupancy {:.4f} -> {:.4f}, a factor of {:.2f}"
.format(c0, o1, o2, o1 / o2)
)
print(
"\n Far below half-occupancy the relation is nearly proportional"
" (factor"
)
print(
" near 5); near and above it, occupancy saturates and the same"
" fivefold"
)
print(
" reduction changes occupancy much less. So the relation between an"
)
print(
" exposure ratio and an occupancy ratio depends on where on the"
" curve one"
)
print(
" already is - which is not known for the exposures discussed here."
)
# Occupancy against dimensionless effect-site concentration c = C / EC50.
#
# c h = 0.8 h = 1.0 h = 1.5 h = 2.0
# 0.01 0.0245 0.0099 0.0010 0.0001
# 0.03 0.0570 0.0291 0.0052 0.0009
# 0.10 0.1368 0.0909 0.0307 0.0099
# 0.30 0.2762 0.2308 0.1411 0.0826
# 1.00 0.5000 0.5000 0.5000 0.5000
# 3.00 0.7066 0.7500 0.8386 0.9000
# 10.00 0.8632 0.9091 0.9693 0.9901
#
# The local slope d log O / d log c, i.e. the fold change in occupancy per
# fold change in concentration (h = 1):
# c occupancy slope
# 0.03 0.0291 0.971
# 0.10 0.0909 0.909
# 0.30 0.2308 0.769
# 1.00 0.5000 0.500
# 3.00 0.7500 0.250
# 10.00 0.9091 0.091
#
# The slope falls smoothly from 1 toward 0 and is never zero or infinite:
# there is no concentration at which the curve turns a corner. So no dose
# is 'sub-perceptual' by virtue of the receptor; a threshold has to be
# imposed by perception, and programme p05 shows it is a distribution
# across people rather than a number.
#
# Concentration needed for a given occupancy (h = 1), relative to 50 %:
# 5% occupancy at c = 0.0526
# 10% occupancy at c = 0.1111
# 25% occupancy at c = 0.3333
# 50% occupancy at c = 1.0000
# 75% occupancy at c = 3.0000
# 90% occupancy at c = 9.0000
#
# A consequence for the word 'microdose'. If one exposure gives c = c0 and
# another gives c = c0/5, occupancy does NOT fall fivefold:
# c0 = 0.2: occupancy 0.1667 -> 0.0385, a factor of 4.33
# c0 = 1.0: occupancy 0.5000 -> 0.1667, a factor of 3.00
# c0 = 5.0: occupancy 0.8333 -> 0.5000, a factor of 1.67
#
# Far below half-occupancy the relation is nearly proportional (factor
# near 5); near and above it, occupancy saturates and the same fivefold
# reduction changes occupancy much less. So the relation between an
# exposure ratio and an occupancy ratio depends on where on the curve one
# already is - which is not known for the exposures discussed here.Note
The units of this chapter. is the ratio of a concentration to the half-occupancy concentration, a pure number. This book gives no actual value for any mass, concentration or amount, and supplies no conversion. Volume 8, Chapter 3 established this convention and this book follows it.
The second section of the program is the point of the chapter. For the log-log slope of occupancy is exactly : it falls smoothly from 0.971 at small to 0.091 at , and is never zero and never infinite. The curve has no corner and no threshold.
That has a direct consequence. The phrase “sub-perceptual dose” implies a line below which the receptor is “not yet working” and above which it begins. Receptor occupancy has no such line. However low the exposure, occupancy is positive and varies in proportion to it. So
no exposure is sub-perceptual by virtue of the receptor. A threshold can only be imposed by perception.
And Chapter 3 will show that what perception imposes is not a number but a population distribution.
The fourth section gives another point that is often missed. Cutting the exposure to a fifth does not cut occupancy to a fifth: far below half occupancy it falls by a factor of about 4.33, at half occupancy by 3.00, and above it by 1.67. The relation between an exposure ratio and an occupancy ratio depends on where on the curve one already is, and that position is not known for the exposures at issue. Phrases like “a tenth of the dose” therefore have no definite meaning at the level of the receptor.
What else “sub-perceptual” might mean
Since the receptor supplies no line, “sub-perceptual” must refer to something else. There are three plausible candidates, and they are not equivalent.
- A threshold of subjective awareness: at this exposure a person notices no change. This is the sense Chapter 3 treats, and it is a population distribution.
- The detection limit of some objective measure: at this exposure some measurement — reaction time, pupil diameter, EEG — shows no detectable change. That depends on the precision of the measurement and the sample size, and is not a property of the pharmacology.
- A lower bound on some threshold effect: the assumption that there is an occupancy level that must be reached before any benefit appears. This is a hypothesis, and the book finds no evidence for it; by the curve above, occupancy is continuous, and there is no reason to suppose benefit has a threshold while awareness does not.
Using the three interchangeably produces arguments that look substantive and are not. “The dose is low enough that there is no experience, but still enough to activate the receptor” is true of any non-zero exposure by the curve above, so it excludes nothing.
Hypothesis · not established
The author’s hypothesis (not established): for this class of compounds there is no interval of occupancy that is beneficial and imperceptible; any occupancy sufficient to produce a detectable benefit also produces a detectable proportion of subjective change in the same population. What would show it to be wrong: in a pre-registered dose-response study, finding an exposure level at which the 95 % confidence interval for improvement in a pre-specified objective outcome relative to placebo excludes zero while the interval for the difference in the proportion reporting subjective change falls inside a pre-set equivalence bound, and replicating that in an independent sample.
Signalling bias, and one complication this book does not handle
Evidence
More than one route (animal and in vitro). 5-HT2A is Gq-coupled, but its ligands can bias different downstream pathways — Gq/PLC, β-arrestin, and receptor complexes — a literature Nichols’s review collects (Nichols 2016). More importantly, Hesselgrave and colleagues found that in mice the antidepressant-like behavioural and synaptic effects of psilocybin are not blocked by a 5-HT2 antagonist (Hesselgrave et al. 2021), and Moliner and colleagues reported that these compounds bind TrkB directly (Moliner et al. 2023).
Note
What this does to the chapter’s conclusion. If there is a route that does not pass through 5-HT2A, then the argument that occupancy has no threshold constrains only the part that does. There is no reason for the two routes to share a dose-response relation. This makes the situation more uncertain, not less. The book’s handling is to confine Chapter 1 to 5-HT2A occupancy, treat TrkB and plasticity separately in Chapter 6, and state there that the two routes may differ in dose-response. The book does not claim to know which route predominates at low exposure — that is precisely the unknown. Note that this counts against the original claim rather than for it: if effects can occur without receptor occupancy, then the whole dose argument built on occupancy loses its basis.
Summary
5-HT2A agonism is a necessary link in producing a marked subjective effect, with human evidence from pharmacological blockade. But receptor occupancy follows the Hill relation, whose log-log slope falls smoothly from 1 to 0 and never shows a corner or a threshold, so no exposure is sub-perceptual by virtue of the receptor; a threshold can only be imposed by perception. The relation between an exposure ratio and an occupancy ratio depends on position along the curve (a fifth of the exposure cuts occupancy by factors between 4.33 and 1.67), so “a tenth of the dose” has no definite meaning at receptor level. The three possible senses of “sub-perceptual” — a subjective threshold, a measurement detection limit, and an assumed effect threshold — are not equivalent, and conflating them produces empty arguments. Finally, if there is a route that bypasses 5-HT2A, as Hesselgrave and colleagues’ and Moliner and colleagues’ results suggest, then dose reasoning built on receptor occupancy has less support, not more.
References
Fan, Y. (2026). Biomathematical Models of Sub-Perceptual Tryptamine Pharmacokinetics, 5-HT2A Receptor Desensitisation and Neuroplastic Window Dynamics: From Michaelis–Menten Kinetics of Prodrug Deacetylation and Whole-Brain Connectivity Entropy to the Microdose Tolerance Ratchet, with a Textual Examination of the Dose Boundary in the Classical Materia Medica [亚知觉色胺药代动力学、5-HT2A 受体脱敏与神经可塑性窗口的生物数学模型] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24019347 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).