5D Library › 亚知觉色胺药代动力学、5-HT2A 受体脱敏与神经可塑性窗口的生物数学模型 · English

第一章 受体占据:没有拐点,所以没有阈值

5-HT2A 与致幻效应

证据

受体与主观效应(人体与动物)。 致幻类色胺与苯乙胺的主观效应与 5-HT2A 受体的激动有关。Glennon 等人 1984 年用一系列化合物的受体亲和力与行为效力的相关性提出 5-HT2 的参与 (Glennon, Titeler, and McKenney 1984)。Nichols 的长篇综述整理了这一类化合物的化学、受体药理与信号通路 (Nichols 2016),Vollenweider 与 Preller 综述了神经生物学与临床潜力 (Vollenweider and Preller 2020)。最直接的人体证据是药理阻断:Preller 等人发现,预先给予 5-HT2A 拮抗剂可消除 LSD 的主观效应与意义赋予的改变 (Preller et al. 2017)。

这足以说明 5-HT2A 的激动是这类化合物产生明显主观效应的必要环节。它不说明在远低于产生明显效应的暴露下还剩下什么——那正是本书要问的问题,而本章说明受体本身不能回答它。

占据的形状

受体占据遵循希尔关系。记 cc 为效应部位浓度,以半占据浓度为单位(所以 c=1c = 1 对应 50% 占据),hh 为希尔系数:

O(c)=chch+1.O(c) = \frac{c^h}{c^h + 1}.

希尔方程的来历与它在定量药理学中的位置,Gesztelyi 等人有专门的考察 (Gesztelyi et al. 2012)。本书全部的浓度都是这样的无量纲量。

推导

# Chapter 1. Receptor occupancy as a continuous function, and why
# "sub-perceptual" is not a property of a dose. Occupancy follows the Hill
# relation
#   O(c) = c^h / (c^h + 1)
# where c is the effect-site concentration in units of the half-occupancy
# concentration (so c = 1 is 50 % occupancy) and h is the Hill coefficient.
# EVERY concentration in this book is dimensionless: c = C / EC50. No mass, no
# dose and no product is named anywhere. The point of the program is that
# occupancy has no kink: there is no concentration at which an effect
# "switches on", so a boundary between perceptible and imperceptible has to
# come from somewhere other than the receptor. Exact arithmetic, no
# simulation.
import math

def occupancy(c, h=1.0):
    if c <= 0:
        return 0.0
    return c ** h / (c ** h + 1.0)

def conc_for_occupancy(o, h=1.0):
    return (o / (1.0 - o)) ** (1.0 / h)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print(
        "Occupancy against dimensionless effect-site concentration c = C /"
        " EC50.\n"
    )
    print("   c        h = 0.8   h = 1.0   h = 1.5   h = 2.0")
    for c in (0.01, 0.03, 0.1, 0.3, 1.0, 3.0, 10.0):
        print("   {:7.2f}".format(c) + "".join(
            "{:10.4f}".format(occupancy(c, h)) for h in (0.8, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0)))

    print(
        "\nThe local slope d log O / d log c, i.e. the fold change in"
        " occupancy per"
    )
    print("fold change in concentration (h = 1):")
    print("   c        occupancy   slope")
    for c in (0.03, 0.1, 0.3, 1.0, 3.0, 10.0):
        o = occupancy(c)
        # d log O / d log c = 1 - O for h = 1
        slope = 1.0 - o
        print("   {:7.2f} {:11.4f} {:7.3f}".format(c, o, slope))
    print(
        "\n   The slope falls smoothly from 1 toward 0 and is never zero or"
        " infinite:"
    )
    print(
        "   there is no concentration at which the curve turns a corner. So"
        " no dose"
    )
    print(
        "   is 'sub-perceptual' by virtue of the receptor; a threshold has"
        " to be"
    )
    print(
        "   imposed by perception, and programme p05 shows it is a"
        " distribution"
    )
    print("   across people rather than a number.")

    print(
        "\nConcentration needed for a given occupancy (h = 1), relative to"
        " 50 %:"
    )
    for o in (0.05, 0.10, 0.25, 0.50, 0.75, 0.90):
        print(
            "   {:3.0%} occupancy at c = {:7.4f}".format(
                o, conc_for_occupancy(o)
            )
        )

    print(
        "\nA consequence for the word 'microdose'. If one exposure gives c ="
        " c0 and"
    )
    print("another gives c = c0/5, occupancy does NOT fall fivefold:")
    for c0 in (0.2, 1.0, 5.0):
        o1, o2 = occupancy(c0), occupancy(c0 / 5.0)
        print(
            "   c0 = {:4.1f}: occupancy {:.4f} -> {:.4f}, a factor of {:.2f}"
            .format(c0, o1, o2, o1 / o2)
        )
    print(
        "\n   Far below half-occupancy the relation is nearly proportional"
        " (factor"
    )
    print(
        "   near 5); near and above it, occupancy saturates and the same"
        " fivefold"
    )
    print(
        "   reduction changes occupancy much less. So the relation between an"
    )
    print(
        "   exposure ratio and an occupancy ratio depends on where on the"
        " curve one"
    )
    print(
        "   already is - which is not known for the exposures discussed here."
    )
# Occupancy against dimensionless effect-site concentration c = C / EC50.
#
#    c        h = 0.8   h = 1.0   h = 1.5   h = 2.0
#       0.01    0.0245    0.0099    0.0010    0.0001
#       0.03    0.0570    0.0291    0.0052    0.0009
#       0.10    0.1368    0.0909    0.0307    0.0099
#       0.30    0.2762    0.2308    0.1411    0.0826
#       1.00    0.5000    0.5000    0.5000    0.5000
#       3.00    0.7066    0.7500    0.8386    0.9000
#      10.00    0.8632    0.9091    0.9693    0.9901
#
# The local slope d log O / d log c, i.e. the fold change in occupancy per
# fold change in concentration (h = 1):
#    c        occupancy   slope
#       0.03      0.0291   0.971
#       0.10      0.0909   0.909
#       0.30      0.2308   0.769
#       1.00      0.5000   0.500
#       3.00      0.7500   0.250
#      10.00      0.9091   0.091
#
#    The slope falls smoothly from 1 toward 0 and is never zero or infinite:
#    there is no concentration at which the curve turns a corner. So no dose
#    is 'sub-perceptual' by virtue of the receptor; a threshold has to be
#    imposed by perception, and programme p05 shows it is a distribution
#    across people rather than a number.
#
# Concentration needed for a given occupancy (h = 1), relative to 50 %:
#     5% occupancy at c =  0.0526
#    10% occupancy at c =  0.1111
#    25% occupancy at c =  0.3333
#    50% occupancy at c =  1.0000
#    75% occupancy at c =  3.0000
#    90% occupancy at c =  9.0000
#
# A consequence for the word 'microdose'. If one exposure gives c = c0 and
# another gives c = c0/5, occupancy does NOT fall fivefold:
#    c0 =  0.2: occupancy 0.1667 -> 0.0385, a factor of 4.33
#    c0 =  1.0: occupancy 0.5000 -> 0.1667, a factor of 3.00
#    c0 =  5.0: occupancy 0.8333 -> 0.5000, a factor of 1.67
#
#    Far below half-occupancy the relation is nearly proportional (factor
#    near 5); near and above it, occupancy saturates and the same fivefold
#    reduction changes occupancy much less. So the relation between an
#    exposure ratio and an occupancy ratio depends on where on the curve one
#    already is - which is not known for the exposures discussed here.

注

这一章的单位。 cc 是浓度与半占据浓度的比值,一个纯数。本书不给出任何质量、浓度或剂量的实际数值,也不提供换算。第 8 本第三章确立了这一写法,本书沿用。

程序的第二段是本章的要点。对 h=1h = 1,占据的对数—对数斜率恰为 1−O1 – O:它从 cc 很小时的 0.971 平滑地降到 c=10c = 10 时的 0.091,从不等于零,也从不是无穷。这条曲线没有拐角,也没有阈值。

这件事有一个直接的后果。「亚知觉剂量」这个说法暗示存在一个界线:界线以下受体「还没开始工作」,界线以上才开始。受体占据没有这样的界线。无论暴露多低,占据都是正的、都按比例随暴露变化。所以

没有哪个暴露量「因为受体的缘故」是亚知觉的。阈值只能由知觉给出。

而第三章会说明,知觉给出的不是一个数,而是一个人群分布。

程序的第四段给出另一个常被忽略的点。把暴露降到五分之一,占据不会降到五分之一:在远低于半占据处降为约 1/4.33,在半占据处降为 1/3.00,在半占据之上降为 1/1.67。也就是说,暴露比与占据比之间的关系取决于当前在曲线上的位置,而这个位置对所讨论的暴露并不知道。「十分之一的剂量」这类说法因此在受体层面没有确定的含义。

受体占据随无量纲效应部位浓度的变化,希尔系数 0.8、1.0、1.5、2.0。右图是同一曲线的对数—对数斜率(h = 1):它从 1 平滑降到 0,没有拐点,所以曲线上没有任何可以称为阈值的位置。

「亚知觉」还能是什么意思

既然受体不提供界线,「亚知觉」就必须指别的东西。合理的候选有三个,而它们互不等价。

  1. 主观觉察的阈值:在这个暴露下,人察觉不到任何变化。这是第三章处理的意义,而它是一个人群分布。
  2. 某个客观指标的检出限:在这个暴露下,某项测量(反应时、瞳孔、脑电)没有可检出的变化。这取决于测量的精度与样本量,不是药理学的性质。
  3. 某个阈值效应的下界:假定存在一个「必须达到才会有益」的占据水平。这是一个假设,而本书找不到支持它的证据;按第一节的曲线,占据是连续的,没有理由认为益处有阈值而觉察没有。

把三者混用会产生看起来有内容而其实没有的论证。例如「剂量低到不会有体验,但仍然足以激活受体」——按上面的曲线,这句话对任何非零暴露都成立,所以它没有排除任何东西。

假说 · 尚未验证

作者的假说(尚未确立): 在这一类化合物上,不存在一个「有益而不可察觉」的占据区间;任何足以产生可检出益处的占据水平,在同一人群中也会产生可检出的主观变化比例。什么样的结果能证明它是错的: 在事先登记的剂量—反应研究中,找到一个暴露水平,使预先指定的客观结局相对安慰剂的改善的 95% 置信区间排除零,而同一研究中主观察觉比例与安慰剂相比的差别的置信区间落在预先设定的等效界内,并在独立样本中重现。

信号偏向与一个本书不处理的复杂度

证据

不止一条通路(动物与体外)。 5-HT2A 是 Gq 偶联受体,但其配体可以偏向不同的下游通路(Gq/PLC、β-arrestin、以及受体复合物),Nichols 的综述整理了这一文献 (Nichols 2016)。更要紧的是 Hesselgrave 等人的结果:在小鼠中,赛洛西宾的抗抑郁样行为与突触效应不被 5-HT2 受体拮抗剂阻断 (Hesselgrave et al. 2021),而 Moliner 等人报告这类化合物可直接结合 TrkB (Moliner et al. 2023)。

注

这对本章的结论有什么影响。 如果存在不经 5-HT2A 的通路,那么「占据没有阈值」这个论证就只约束了经 5-HT2A 的那一部分。本书的处理是:第一章只讨论 5-HT2A 的占据,第六章单独处理 TrkB 与可塑性,并在那里写明两条通路在剂量—反应上可能不同。本书不声称已知哪条通路在低暴露下占主导——这正是未知的部分。注意这一点对原说法是不利的而不是有利的:如果效应可以不经受体占据,那么以受体占据为基础的全套剂量推理就失去了依据。

本章小结

5-HT2A 的激动是这类化合物产生明显主观效应的必要环节,这有药理阻断的人体证据。但受体占据遵循希尔关系,其对数—对数斜率从 1 平滑地降到 0,从不出现拐点或阈值,所以没有哪个暴露量「因为受体的缘故」是亚知觉的;阈值只能由知觉给出。暴露比与占据比的关系取决于曲线上的位置(五分之一的暴露使占据降为 1/4.33 到 1/1.67 不等),所以「十分之一的剂量」在受体层面没有确定含义。「亚知觉」的三种可能意义——主观阈值、测量检出限、假定的效应阈值——互不等价,混用会产生空洞的论证。最后,若存在不经 5-HT2A 的通路(Hesselgrave 等人与 Moliner 等人的结果提示这一点),那么以受体占据为基础的剂量推理就更缺依据,而不是更有依据。

参考文献

Gesztelyi, Rudolf, Judit Zsuga, Adam Kemeny-Beke, Balazs Varga, Bela Juhasz, and Arpad Tosaki. 2012. “The Hill Equation and the Origin of Quantitative Pharmacology.” Archive for History of Exact Sciences 66: 427–38. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00407-012-0098-5.
Glennon, Richard A., Milt Titeler, and J. D. McKenney. 1984. “Evidence for 5-HT2_2 Involvement in the Mechanism of Action of Hallucinogenic Agents.” Life Sciences 35 (25): 2505–11. https://doi.org/10.1016/0024-3205(84)90436-3.
Hesselgrave, Natalie, Timothy A. Troppoli, Andreas B. Wulff, Anthony B. Cole, and Scott M. Thompson. 2021. “Harnessing Psilocybin: Antidepressant-Like Behavioral and Synaptic Actions of Psilocybin Are Independent of 5-HT2R Activation in Mice.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 118 (17): e2022489118. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2022489118.
Moliner, Rafael, Mykhailo Girych, Cecilia A. Brunello, Vera Kovaleva, Caroline Biojone, Giray Enkavi, Lina Antenucci, et al. 2023. “Psychedelics Promote Plasticity by Directly Binding to BDNF Receptor TrkB.” Nature Neuroscience 26: 1032–41. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41593-023-01316-5.
Nichols, David E. 2016. “Psychedelics.” Pharmacological Reviews 68 (2): 264–355. https://doi.org/10.1124/pr.115.011478.
Preller, Katrin H., Marcus Herdener, Thomas Pokorny, Andrea Planzer, Rainer Kraehenmann, Philipp Stampfli, Matthias E. Liechti, Erich Seifritz, and Franz X. Vollenweider. 2017. “The Fabric of Meaning and Subjective Effects in LSD-Induced States Depend on Serotonin 2A Receptor Activation.” Current Biology 27 (3): 451–57. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2016.12.030.
Vollenweider, Franz X., and Katrin H. Preller. 2020. “Psychedelic Drugs: Neurobiology and Potential for Treatment of Psychiatric Disorders.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 21: 611–24. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41583-020-0367-2.

Fan, Y. (2026). Biomathematical Models of Sub-Perceptual Tryptamine Pharmacokinetics, 5-HT2A Receptor Desensitisation and Neuroplastic Window Dynamics: From Michaelis–Menten Kinetics of Prodrug Deacetylation and Whole-Brain Connectivity Entropy to the Microdose Tolerance Ratchet, with a Textual Examination of the Dose Boundary in the Classical Materia Medica [亚知觉色胺药代动力学、5-HT2A 受体脱敏与神经可塑性窗口的生物数学模型] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24019347 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).