5D Library › 双过程睡眠架构、慢波胶质淋巴清除与体温节律相位控制 · English

第一章 睡眠压力、时钟,以及咖啡因到底做了什么

两个过程

双过程模型是关于「我们何时睡觉」最简单、却仍能作出定量预测的解释 (Borbély 1982; Daan et al. 1984)。稳态的过程 S 在清醒时上升、在睡眠时下降;它最著名的标志物是非快速眼动睡眠中脑电图的慢波活动——长时间清醒后它很高,整夜逐渐衰减。由视交叉上核产生的昼夜过程 C 设定两条在 24 小时内起伏的阈值。S 升到上阈值时睡眠开始,降到下阈值时睡眠结束。四十年的研究细化了这个模型,却没有推翻它的结构 (Borbély et al. 2016)。

推导

所用方程。 清醒时,SS 以时间常数 τr\tau_r 指数趋近 1:S(t+Δt)=1−(1−S)e−Δt/τrS(t+\Delta t) = 1 – (1-S)e^{-\Delta t/\tau_r}。睡眠时,它以 τd\tau_d 衰减趋近 0:S(t+Δt)=Se−Δt/τdS(t+\Delta t) = S\,e^{-\Delta t/\tau_d}。阈值为 H(t)=H0+Acos⁡(2π(t−ϕ)/24)H(t) = H_0 + A\cos(2\pi(t-\phi)/24) 与 L(t)=L0+Acos⁡(2π(t−ϕ)/24)L(t) = L_0 + A\cos(2\pi(t-\phi)/24)。程序使用经典的示意时间常数 18.2 小时与 4.2 小时;SS 无量纲。

推导

# Chapter 1. Borbely's two-process model. Process S (sleep pressure) rises
# toward 1 while awake with time constant TAU_R and decays toward 0 while
# asleep with TAU_D. Process C sets two thresholds that oscillate over 24 h:
# sleep starts when S reaches the upper one, waking happens when S falls to
# the lower one. Parameters are the classical illustrative values (time
# constants 18.2 h and 4.2 h); S is dimensionless. Time step 1 minute; t = 0
# is midnight.
import math

TAU_R, TAU_D = 18.2, 4.2
# thresholds and their peak hour
H0, L0, AMP, PHASE = 0.67, 0.17, 0.10, 16.0
DT = 1.0 / 60

def thr(t, base):
    return base + AMP * math.cos(2 * math.pi * (t - PHASE) / 24.0)

def run(days, no_sleep=None, s0=0.25, t0=7.0):
    """Simulate; returns list of (sleep_on, sleep_off, S_at_onset, area under
    S asleep)."""
    t, S, asleep = t0, s0, False
    bouts, cur = [], None
    while t < t0 + 24 * days:
        if asleep:
            S *= math.exp(-DT / TAU_D)
            cur[3] += S * DT
            if S <= thr(t, L0):
                asleep = False
                cur[1] = t
                bouts.append(tuple(cur))
        else:
            S = 1 - (1 - S) * math.exp(-DT / TAU_R)
            can_sleep = no_sleep is None or not (
                no_sleep[0] <= t < no_sleep[1]
            )
            if S >= thr(t, H0) and can_sleep:
                asleep = True
                cur = [t, None, S, 0.0]
        t += DT
    return bouts

def clock(h):
    h = h % 24
    return "{:02d}:{:02d}".format(int(h), int(round((h - int(h)) * 60)) % 60)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    b = run(10)
    on, off, s_on, area = b[-1]
    print("A. Entrained day (after 10 simulated days)")
    print(
        "   sleep {} -> {}   duration {:.2f} h\n   S at onset {:.3f}   S at"
        " waking {:.3f}".format(
            clock(on), clock(off), off - on, s_on, thr(off, L0)
        )
    )
    base_dur, base_area = off - on, area

    print("\nB. One night of total sleep deprivation, then recovery")
    for extra in (0, 8, 16, 24):
        bb = run(12, no_sleep=(on - 1, on + extra) if extra else None)
        rec = [x for x in bb if x[0] >= on + extra - 0.5][0]
        print(
            "   kept awake {:>2} h past usual bedtime: recovery sleep {} ->"
            " {},\n      {:.2f} h (x {:.2f} usual), S at onset {:.3f},"
            " slow-wave proxy x {:.2f}".format(
                extra,
                clock(rec[0]),
                clock(rec[1]),
                rec[1] - rec[0],
                (rec[1] - rec[0]) / base_dur,
                rec[2],
                rec[3] / base_area,
            )
        )
    print(
        "\nReading: hours of sleep lost are not repaid hour for hour."
        " Recovery sleep"
    )
    print(
        "is longer only modestly; most of the repayment is in intensity"
        " (higher S at"
    )
    print(
        "onset, more slow-wave activity), and the clock (Process C) ends it"
        " on time."
    )
# A. Entrained day (after 10 simulated days)
#    sleep 23:27 -> 07:08   duration 7.68 h
#    S at onset 0.633   S at waking 0.102
#
# B. One night of total sleep deprivation, then recovery
#    kept awake  0 h past usual bedtime: recovery sleep 23:27 -> 07:08,
#       7.68 h (x 1.00 usual), S at onset 0.633, slow-wave proxy x 1.00
#    kept awake  8 h past usual bedtime: recovery sleep 07:27 -> 12:29,
#       5.03 h (x 0.66 usual), S at onset 0.764, slow-wave proxy x 1.00
#    kept awake 16 h past usual bedtime: recovery sleep 15:27 -> 22:37,
#       7.17 h (x 0.93 usual), S at onset 0.848, slow-wave proxy x 1.30
#    kept awake 24 h past usual bedtime: recovery sleep 23:27 -> 07:58,
#       8.52 h (x 1.11 usual), S at onset 0.902, slow-wave proxy x 1.47
#
# Reading: hours of sleep lost are not repaid hour for hour. Recovery sleep
# is longer only modestly; most of the repayment is in intensity (higher S at
# onset, more slow-wave activity), and the clock (Process C) ends it on time.

A 段是被昼夜节律锁定的一天:23:27 到 07:08 睡眠,共 7.68 小时,开始于压力达到 0.633 时。B 段是大多数人会弄错的结果。让人在平时就寝时间之后继续清醒,失去的小时不会按小时偿还。多醒 8 小时,补觉落在早上,而且比平常更短——5.03 小时,为平常的 0.66——因为昼夜阈值把它结束了。多醒整整一天,补觉也只是平常的 1.11 倍长,但入睡时的压力是 0.902 而不是 0.633,慢波代理量是平常的 1.47 倍。偿还主要体现在强度上,而不是时长上。

两个模拟日中,过程 S(实线)在清醒时上升、睡眠时下降,介于昼夜节律的上下阈值(虚线)之间。

证据

关于恢复已知的情况。 剥夺后的睡眠更深、而不是按比例更长,慢波活动随先前清醒时间而上升——这是该模型的实证核心 (Borbély 1982; Daan et al. 1984; Borbély et al. 2016)。程序中的数字是模型的数字,不是对任何人的测量。

腺苷与咖啡因

在脑中承载过程 S 的是什么尚无定论,但腺苷是首要候选:在猫身上,基底前脑的细胞外腺苷在长时间清醒中上升、在恢复睡眠中下降 (Porkka-Heiskanen et al. 1997)。咖啡因阻断腺苷受体。它是 A1 与 A2A 受体的非选择性拮抗剂 (Fredholm et al. 1999);在小鼠中,它的促醒作用依赖 A2A 而不是 A1 受体 (Huang et al. 2005)。

竞争性拮抗剂并不清除激动剂;它只是占据了激动剂本会使用的部分受体。所以模型把腺苷占据的受体份额写成 A/(A+KA(1+C/KC))A/(A + K_A(1 + C/K_C)),并假定感到的困意跟随这个份额。咖啡因以其自身解离常数为单位表示;本书任何地方都不涉及剂量。

推导

# Chapter 1. Caffeine as a competitive antagonist at adenosine receptors.
# Adenosine (proportional to Process S) and caffeine compete for the same
# receptor; the share of receptors occupied by adenosine is
#     occ = A / (A + KA x (1 + C / KC))          (competitive binding)
# Felt sleepiness is taken to follow occ, not A. Caffeine follows
# one-compartment elimination with half-life 3 h ("fast") or 8 h ("slow");
# concentrations are expressed in units of KC, with a peak of 2.0 KC one hour
# after intake. No doses are implied. The two-process model of p01 supplies A;
# slow-wave activity in the first three hours of sleep is taken, as a working
# hypothesis, to scale with adenosine occupancy.
import math

TAU_R, TAU_D = 18.2, 4.2
KA = 0.5
PEAK = 2.0

def caffeine(t, intake, half):
    if t < intake:
        return 0.0
    k = math.log(2) / half
    ka = 3.0                               # absorption rate per hour (fast)
    # Bateman function scaled so the peak is about PEAK
    raw = (math.exp(-k * (t - intake)) - math.exp(-ka * (t - intake)))
    tmax = math.log(ka / k) / (ka - k)
    rmax = math.exp(-k * tmax) - math.exp(-ka * tmax)
    return PEAK * raw / rmax

def occ(A, C):
    return A / (A + KA * (1 + C))

def S_awake(hours_awake, s_wake=0.10):
    return 1 - (1 - s_wake) * math.exp(-hours_awake / TAU_R)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    wake, bed = 7.0, 23.0
    A_bed = S_awake(bed - wake)
    print(
        "A. Adenosine pressure at 23:00 is the same with or without caffeine:"
    )
    print("   S = {:.3f}".format(A_bed))
    print(
        "   felt pressure (occupancy) at 23:00, by intake time and half-life"
    )
    print(
        "   intake    half-life   caffeine left at 23:00 (x KC)   occupancy  "
        " vs none"
    )
    base = occ(A_bed, 0.0)
    for intake in (8.0, 14.0, 17.0):
        for half in (3.0, 8.0):
            c = caffeine(bed, intake, half)
            o = occ(A_bed, c)
            print(
                "   {:02d}:00      {:3.0f} h          {:6.3f}                "
                "      {:.3f}       {:5.1%}".format(
                    int(intake), half, c, o, o / base - 1
                )
            )
    print(
        "   no caffeine                                            {:.3f}"
        .format(base)
    )

    print(
        "\nB. Working hypothesis: slow-wave activity over the first 3 h of"
        " sleep"
    )
    print(
        "   scales with adenosine occupancy. Predicted change vs no caffeine:"
    )
    for intake in (8.0, 14.0, 17.0):
        row = []
        for half in (3.0, 8.0):
            tot = tot0 = 0.0
            for i in range(180):
                t = bed + i / 60
                A = A_bed * math.exp(-(i / 60) / TAU_D)
                tot += occ(A, caffeine(t, intake, half))
                tot0 += occ(A, 0.0)
            row.append(tot / tot0 - 1)
        print(
            "   intake {:02d}:00   fast (3 h) {:+6.1%}   slow (8 h) {:+6.1%}"
            .format(int(intake), *row)
        )

    print(
        "\nC. After an 08:00 intake (3 h half-life): felt pressure climbs"
        " faster as"
    )
    print(
        "   caffeine clears, because the masked pressure is unmasked on"
        " top of"
    )
    print("   the rise")
    print(
        "   time    adenosine S   felt   felt without   rise of felt over 2 h"
    )
    print("                                caffeine       (with / without)")
    prev = None
    for h in (9, 11, 13, 15, 17, 19):
        A = S_awake(h - wake)
        f, f0 = occ(A, caffeine(h, 8.0, 3.0)), occ(A, 0.0)
        rise = (
            ""
            if prev is None
            else "{:+.3f} / {:+.3f}".format(f - prev[0], f0 - prev[1])
        )
        print(
            "   {:02d}:00     {:.3f}      {:.3f}        {:.3f}       {}"
            .format(
                h, A, f, f0, rise
            ).rstrip()
        )
        prev = (f, f0)
    print(
        "\nReading: caffeine lowers how much of the pressure is felt, not the"
        " pressure."
    )
    print(
        "As it clears, the full accumulated pressure is felt again; the"
        " slower the"
    )
    print(
        "clearance, the more of it is still masking adenosine when sleep"
        " begins."
    )
# A. Adenosine pressure at 23:00 is the same with or without caffeine:
#    S = 0.626
#    felt pressure (occupancy) at 23:00, by intake time and half-life
#    intake    half-life   caffeine left at 23:00 (x KC)   occupancy   vs none
#    08:00        3 h           0.084                      0.536       -3.6%
#    08:00        8 h           0.624                      0.435       -21.7%
#    14:00        3 h           0.335                      0.484       -13.0%
#    14:00        8 h           1.049                      0.379       -31.8%
#    17:00        3 h           0.671                      0.428       -22.9%
#    17:00        8 h           1.361                      0.347       -37.7%
#    no caffeine                                            0.556
#
# B. Working hypothesis: slow-wave activity over the first 3 h of sleep
#    scales with adenosine occupancy. Predicted change vs no caffeine:
#    intake 08:00   fast (3 h)  -3.1%   slow (8 h) -22.5%
#    intake 14:00   fast (3 h) -11.3%   slow (8 h) -32.8%
#    intake 17:00   fast (3 h) -20.3%   slow (8 h) -38.7%
#
# C. After an 08:00 intake (3 h half-life): felt pressure climbs faster as
#    caffeine clears, because the masked pressure is unmasked on top of
#    the rise
#    time    adenosine S   felt   felt without   rise of felt over 2 h
#                                 caffeine       (with / without)
#    09:00     0.194      0.114        0.279
#    11:00     0.278      0.192        0.357       +0.077 / +0.078
#    13:00     0.353      0.277        0.414       +0.085 / +0.057
#    15:00     0.420      0.354        0.457       +0.078 / +0.043
#    17:00     0.480      0.418        0.490       +0.064 / +0.033
#    19:00     0.535      0.469        0.517       +0.050 / +0.027
#
# Reading: caffeine lowers how much of the pressure is felt, not the pressure.
# As it clears, the full accumulated pressure is felt again; the slower the
# clearance, the more of it is still masking adenosine when sleep begins.

A 段把要点说得很直白:无论白天喝了什么,23:00 的腺苷压力都是 0.626。改变的只是其中被感到的部分。半衰期 3 小时时,早上摄入到就寝时几乎不剩(感到的压力 −3.6%)。半衰期 8 小时时,同样的早上摄入仍掩盖了 −21.7%,17:00 的摄入则掩盖 −37.7%。

B 段在一个明确声明的工作假设——慢波活动与腺苷占据率成正比——之下,把这一点变成对睡眠头三个小时的预测:快代谢者早上摄入为 −3.1%,慢代谢者为 −22.5%;17:00 摄入则为 −20.3% 与 −38.7%。半衰期比摄入时间本身更要紧:慢代谢者 08:00 的一杯,作用大约相当于快代谢者 17:00 的一杯。

C 段就是所谓的「崩溃」。咖啡因降低了感到的压力,但压力在下面照样累积。随着咖啡因清除,被掩盖的压力在持续上升之上被揭开,所以感到的压力比不喝咖啡时上升得更快:13:00 到 15:00 之间为 +0.078,对 +0.043。

证据

关于咖啡因与睡眠已知的情况。 健康成年人之间咖啡因的消除半衰期相差数倍;吸烟使它缩短,怀孕和包括口服避孕药在内的一些药物使它延长,肝酶 CYP1A2 的遗传差异也有作用 (Nehlig 2018)。研究表明早上摄入的咖啡因会影响当晚的睡眠及其脑电频谱 (Landolt et al. 1995);在一项对照研究中,即使在就寝前六小时摄入,咖啡因也可测地减少了睡眠 (Drake et al. 2013)。

假说 · 尚未验证

作者的假说(尚未验证): 在习惯摄入时间相同的成年人中,下午摄入咖啡因后第一个睡眠周期慢波活动的下降,在慢代谢者中更大;下降的幅度由熄灯时估计的残余咖啡因预测,好于由摄入的钟点预测。什么结果会证明它错:估计残余咖啡因与慢波活动的变化无关,或者这种关系完全可以用摄入时间解释。

小结

在双过程模型中,睡眠压力清醒时上升、睡眠时下降,昼夜时钟设定睡眠开始与结束的水平。失去的睡眠主要以强度偿还:多醒整整一天,补觉只延长约十分之一,入睡压力与慢波代理量却提高约一半;错过一夜后在早上补觉,睡得很短,因为时钟把它结束了。咖啡因作为竞争性拮抗剂并不清除腺苷;它降低被感到的份额,而随着咖啡因清除,这份额会回来——而且比不喝时回来得更快。就寝时还有多少被掩盖,至少同样取决于半衰期,而不只是最后一杯的时间。

参考文献

Borbély, Alexander A. 1982. “A Two Process Model of Sleep Regulation.” Human Neurobiology 1 (3): 195–204.
Borbély, Alexander A., Serge Daan, Anna Wirz-Justice, and Tom Deboer. 2016. “The Two-Process Model of Sleep Regulation: A Reappraisal.” Journal of Sleep Research 25 (2): 131–43.
Daan, Serge, Domien G. M. Beersma, and Alexander A. Borbély. 1984. “Timing of Human Sleep: Recovery Process Gated by a Circadian Pacemaker.” American Journal of Physiology 246 (2): R161–83.
Drake, Christopher, Timothy Roehrs, John Shambroom, and Thomas Roth. 2013. “Caffeine Effects on Sleep Taken 0, 3, or 6 Hours before Going to Bed.” Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine 9 (11): 1195–200.
Fredholm, Bertil B., Karl Bättig, Janet Holmén, Astrid Nehlig, and Edwin E. Zvartau. 1999. “Actions of Caffeine in the Brain with Special Reference to Factors That Contribute to Its Widespread Use.” Pharmacological Reviews 51 (1): 83–133.
Huang, Zhi-Li, Wei-Min Qu, et al. 2005. “Adenosine A2A, but Not A1, Receptors Mediate the Arousal Effect of Caffeine.” Nature Neuroscience 8 (7): 858–59.
Landolt, Hans-Peter, Esther Werth, Alexander A. Borbély, and Derk-Jan Dijk. 1995. “Caffeine Intake (200 Mg) in the Morning Affects Human Sleep and EEG Power Spectra at Night.” Brain Research 675 (1–2): 67–74.
Nehlig, Astrid. 2018. “Interindividual Differences in Caffeine Metabolism and Factors Driving Caffeine Consumption.” Pharmacological Reviews 70 (2): 384–411.
Porkka-Heiskanen, Tarja, Robert E. Strecker, Mahesh Thakkar, Alvhild A. Bjørkum, Robert W. Greene, and Robert W. McCarley. 1997. “Adenosine: A Mediator of the Sleep-Inducing Effects of Prolonged Wakefulness.” Science 276 (5316): 1265–68. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.276.5316.1265.

Fan, Y. (2026). Two-Process Sleep Architecture, Slow-Wave Glymphatic Clearance and Thermoregulatory Phase Control: Adenosine Homeostasis, Flip-Flop Switch Bistability, Core-Distal Heat Flux and Sleep-Stage Markov Chains [双过程睡眠架构、慢波胶质淋巴清除与体温节律相位控制] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090162 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).