5D Library › 慢崩盘流动性储备、实物资产期权估值与跨代财富保全动力学 · English

第六章 家族基金:默顿规则与动态提取上限

默顿规则给出的提取率

默顿在连续时间中求出了常相对风险厌恶者的最优资产配置与消费率 (Merton 1969)。p11 用示意的市场参数计算不同风险厌恶程度下的结果。

推导

# Chapter 6. p11: Merton's rule for a family fund. With constant relative
# risk aversion g, market excess return mu - r = 0.04, sd 0.18, cash
# r = 0.02 and impatience rho = 0.03, the best share in the market is
# pi = (mu - r) / (g sd^2) and the best spending rate (of current
# wealth, infinite horizon) is
# c = (rho - (1 - g) (r + (mu - r)^2 / (2 g sd^2))) / g.
# Wealth then grows at the time-average rate
# r + pi (mu - r) - pi^2 sd^2 / 2 - c.
MU_R, SD, R, RHO = 0.04, 0.18, 0.02, 0.03

def merton(g):
    pi = MU_R / (g * SD ** 2)
    c = (RHO - (1 - g) * (R + MU_R ** 2 / (2 * g * SD ** 2))) / g
    growth = R + pi * MU_R - pi ** 2 * SD ** 2 / 2 - c
    return pi, c, growth

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   risk aversion   market share   spending rate   wealth growth")
    for g in (1, 2, 3, 5, 8):
        print("   {:13d}   {:12.3f}   {:13.4f}   {:13.4f}".format(
            g, *merton(g)))
#    risk aversion   market share   spending rate   wealth growth
#                1          1.235          0.0300          0.0147
#                2          0.617          0.0312          0.0073
#                3          0.412          0.0288          0.0049
#                5          0.247          0.0260          0.0029
#                8          0.154          0.0240          0.0018

风险厌恶为 2 时,最优的市场仓位是 0.617,最优的提取率约为每年 0.0312,财富本身的时间平均增长率只剩 0.0073。风险厌恶越高,仓位越低,提取率也越低,但财富增长率同样越低:在这些参数下,没有一种组合可以让家族每年提取 4% 而财富仍然增长。默顿规则提取的是当前财富的一个比例,而不是一个固定的金额。

一百年的家族基金

流行的「4% 法则」来自对美国退休者三十年提款的历史回测 (Bengen 1994),并不是为一个要延续一百年、受益人还会增加的家族基金设计的。p12 让基金以六成市场、四成现金持有,市场年实际回报带有第五章的崩盘年,受益人每年增加 1.5%,比较五种提取规则。

推导

# Chapter 6. p12: A family fund over 100 years. The fund starts at 100
# (real terms) and holds 60% in the market and 40% in cash at a real
# rate of 0. The market's real yearly return has mean 4% and sd 18%,
# with crashes as in p10 (chance 0.03 a year of a crash year, mean -42%,
# sd 10%; otherwise mean 5.42%, sd 16.23%). The number of heirs grows
# 1.5% a year. Five payout rules: a fixed 4 a year; a fixed 5 a year;
# 4% of the fund's current value; 3.5% or 1.5% of its average value
# over the last three years. A fund below 10 counts as spent. Per-heir
# payouts are shown relative to year 1. 5,000 paths, seed 88.
import random

def market(rng):
    if rng.random() < 0.03:
        return rng.gauss(-0.42, 0.10)
    return rng.gauss(0.0542, 0.1623)

def run(rng, rule, years=100):
    v, hist, heirs = 100.0, [100.0] * 3, 1.0
    first, at50, spent = None, None, False
    for t in range(1, years + 1):
        v *= 1 + 0.6 * market(rng)
        if rule == "fixed 4":
            pay = 4.0
        elif rule == "fixed 5":
            pay = 5.0
        elif rule == "4% of value":
            pay = 0.04 * v
        elif rule == "3.5% of 3-yr mean":
            pay = 0.035 * sum(hist) / 3
        else:
            pay = 0.015 * sum(hist) / 3
        pay = min(pay, max(v, 0.0))
        v -= pay
        hist = hist[1:] + [v]
        heirs *= 1.015
        if first is None:
            first = pay
        if t == 50:
            at50 = pay / heirs / first
        if v < 10:
            spent = True
    return spent, v, pay / heirs / first, at50

if __name__ == "__main__":
    rng = random.Random(88)
    q = lambda v, a: sorted(v)[int(a * (len(v) - 1))]
    print("   rule               spent    median fund   per heir,"
          "   per heir,")
    print("                      by 100   at year 100   year 100    year 50,")
    print("                                             (median)    10th pct")
    for rule in ("fixed 4", "fixed 5", "4% of value", "3.5% of 3-yr mean",
                 "1.5% of 3-yr mean"):
        res = [run(rng, rule) for _ in range(5000)]
        spent = sum(1 for r in res if r[0]) / 5000
        print("   {:<17}  {:6.3f}   {:11.0f}   {:9.3f}   {:9.3f}".format(
            rule, spent, q([r[1] for r in res], 0.5),
            q([r[2] for r in res], 0.5), q([r[3] for r in res], 0.1)))
#    rule               spent    median fund   per heir,   per heir,
#                       by 100   at year 100   year 100    year 50,
#                                              (median)    10th pct
#    fixed 4             0.926             0       0.000       0.000
#    fixed 5             0.978             0       0.000       0.000
#    4% of value         0.554            10       0.024       0.058
#    3.5% of 3-yr mean   0.405            16       0.039       0.069
#    1.5% of 3-yr mean   0.024           135       0.308       0.203

每年固定提取 4,一百年内耗尽的机会是 0.926;固定提取 5 是 0.978。按当前价值的 4% 提取,耗尽的机会降到 0.554;按过去三年平均值的 3.5% 提取是 0.405。只有把提取率降到过去三年平均值的 1.5%,也就是接近组合的时间平均增长率时,耗尽的机会才降到 0.024,第 100 年基金中位数是 135。即使如此,因为受益人增加,每位受益人在第 100 年领到的只有第一年的 0.308。

四种规则下基金的中位数路径(p12 的设定,四百条路径)。

注

动态提取上限: 家族基金每年的提取不超过过去三年平均值乘以组合时间平均增长率的估计;每十年依实际增长重估一次;受益人的分配按户而非按人计算,或明确规定人均分配会随受益人增加而下降。

小结

默顿规则与遍历性给出同一个结论:要延续一百年的基金,提取率必须接近组合的时间平均增长率,在示意参数下远低于 4%。固定金额的提取几乎必然耗尽基金;按平滑后的价值、以低比例提取,基金才能延续,而受益人的增加仍会稀释每个人的份额。

参考文献

Bengen, William P. 1994. “Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data.” Journal of Financial Planning 7 (4): 171 to 180.
Merton, Robert C. 1969. “Lifetime Portfolio Selection under Uncertainty: The Continuous-Time Case.” The Review of Economics and Statistics 51 (3): 247 to 257.

Fan, Y. (2026). Slow-Crash Liquidity Reserves, Real-Asset Option Valuation and Intergenerational Wealth Preservation: Thirty-Month Drawdown Kinetics, Distressed Resource Acquisition and Ergodic Dynasty Trusts [慢崩盘流动性储备、实物资产期权估值与跨代财富保全动力学] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090231 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).