5D Library › Singer Formant Clustering, Glottal Closure Quotients and Acoustic Authority Psychophysics · 中文

Chapter 6. Semi-Occluded Vocal Tract Exercises: Straw Physics and a Fourteen-Day Closed-Quotient Curve

How much back pressure a straw makes

Semi-occluded vocal tract exercises (phonating into a straw, through pursed lips or a tube in water) raise the pressure above the glottis. Titze’s account is that the added inertive and resistive load helps the folds vibrate efficiently with less collision force (Titze 2006). p11 computes the back pressure of straws of different diameters at a moderate flow.

Calculation

# Chapter 6. p11: Back pressure of a straw in semi-occluded phonation.
# Air flow 0.15 L/s through a straw 0.15 m long. Laminar (Poiseuille)
# loss 8 mu L U / (pi r^4) plus the exit loss of the jet, rho v^2 / 2;
# air viscosity mu = 1.8e-5 Pa s, density rho = 1.2 kg/m^3. Reynolds
# number Re = rho v d / mu: above about 2,300 the flow is not laminar
# and the Poiseuille term is only a lower bound. Pressure is compared
# with 0.6 kPa, a typical subglottal pressure of conversational speech
# (1 cm H2O = 98.07 Pa).
from math import pi

MU, RHO, L, U = 1.8e-5, 1.2, 0.15, 0.15e-3

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   diameter (mm)  speed (m/s)     Re   back pressure (Pa)"
          "  cm H2O  / 0.6 kPa")
    for d_mm in (2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8):
        r = d_mm / 2000
        v = U / (pi * r * r)
        lam = 8 * MU * L * U / (pi * r ** 4)
        jet = 0.5 * RHO * v * v
        p = lam + jet
        print("   {:13d}  {:11.1f}  {:5,.0f}  {:18,.0f}  {:6.1f}  {:9.2f}"
              .format(d_mm, v, RHO * v * d_mm / 1000 / MU, p, p / 98.07,
                      p / 600))
#    diameter (mm)  speed (m/s)     Re   back pressure (Pa)  cm H2O  / 0.6 kPa
#                2         47.7  6,366               2,399    24.5       4.00
#                3         21.2  4,244                 474     4.8       0.79
#                4         11.9  3,183                 150     1.5       0.25
#                5          7.6  2,546                  61     0.6       0.10
#                6          5.3  2,122                  30     0.3       0.05
#                8          3.0  1,592                   9     0.1       0.02

At 0.15 L/s a straw of 3 mm makes 474 Pa (4.8 cm H2O), about 0.79 of a conversational subglottal pressure of 0.6 kPa; one of 4 mm makes 150 Pa (0.25 of it); 6 mm only 30 Pa. A 2 mm straw would need 2,399 Pa at this flow, four times the subglottal pressure, so in practice the flow drops instead. The Reynolds numbers are above 2,300 for every straw of 5 mm or less, so the laminar term is a lower bound and real back pressures are somewhat higher. The diameter, not the exercise label, sets the load: halving the diameter multiplies the laminar loss by sixteen.

A fourteen-day curve

Training claims are often stated as curves: “closed quotient rises over fourteen days”. p12 assumes such a curve, a rise of 0.06 in closed quotient approached exponentially with a time constant of four days, and asks what one person and a group can measure.

Calculation

# Chapter 6. p12: A 14-day straw-phonation programme and the closed
# quotient (CQ, the share of each cycle the folds are closed, from
# electroglottography). Illustrative model: CQ(day) = 0.40 + g (1 -
# exp(-day / 4)), measured once a day with noise sd 0.03. Persons
# differ in g (sd 0.03 around the mean gain). (a) One person, mean gain
# 0.06: the change estimated from day 0 to day 14, from single sessions
# or from three-day averages. (b) Persons needed for a paired test
# (two-sided 5%, power 80%, normal approximation, rounded up) with
# three-day averages, by mean gain.
# 4,000 persons simulated, seed 99.
import random
from math import ceil, exp, sqrt

def series(rng, g):
    return [0.40 + g * (1 - exp(-d / 4)) + rng.gauss(0, 0.03)
            for d in range(15)]

if __name__ == "__main__":
    rng = random.Random(99)
    one, avg = [], []
    for _ in range(4000):
        s = series(rng, 0.06)
        one.append(s[14] - s[0])
        avg.append(sum(s[12:15]) / 3 - sum(s[0:3]) / 3)
    for name, v in (("single sessions", one), ("three-day means", avg)):
        m = sum(v) / len(v)
        sd = sqrt(sum((x - m) ** 2 for x in v) / (len(v) - 1))
        print("   (a) {:<16} mean change {:.4f}, sd {:.4f}, share < 0: {:.3f}"
              .format(name, m, sd, sum(x < 0 for x in v) / len(v)))
    true0 = 0.40 + 0.06 * (sum(1 - exp(-d / 4) for d in range(3)) / 3)
    true14 = 0.40 + 0.06 * (sum(1 - exp(-d / 4) for d in (12, 13, 14)) / 3)
    frac = (true14 - true0) / 0.06
    sd_change = sqrt((0.03 * frac) ** 2 + 2 * 0.03 ** 2 / 3)
    print("   (b) mean gain   expected change   persons needed")
    for g in (0.06, 0.03, 0.015):
        n = ((1.959964 + 0.841621) * sd_change / (g * frac)) ** 2
        print("   {:15.3f}   {:15.4f}   {:14d}".format(g, g * frac, ceil(n)))
#    (a) single sessions  mean change 0.0583, sd 0.0422, share < 0: 0.083
#    (a) three-day means  mean change 0.0453, sd 0.0242, share < 0: 0.028
#    (b) mean gain   expected change   persons needed
#              0.060            0.0453                5
#              0.030            0.0227               18
#              0.015            0.0113               69

For one person, the change from day 0 to day 14 measured from single sessions has a standard deviation of 0.0422 around a mean of 0.0583, and comes out negative in 0.083 of cases even though the true change is positive; three-day means reduce the spread to 0.0242 (negative in 0.028) but also the measured change to 0.0453, because the first three days already include some improvement. For a group, five persons suffice if the mean gain is 0.06, but 18 are needed for 0.03 and 69 for 0.015. Since practice and familiarity with the electroglottograph also change closed quotient, a control group without straw phonation is needed before any curve is attributed to the exercise.

Back pressure of a 0.15 m straw at 0.15 L/s by diameter; the dashed line is 0.6 kPa (p11).

Hypothesis · not established

The author’s interpretation (not yet tested): fourteen days of daily straw phonation with a straw of 3 to 4 mm raise the electroglottographic closed quotient of untrained adult speakers by at least 0.03 more than fourteen days of equally long reading aloud. What would show it wrong: in a pre-registered randomized trial with at least 18 persons per arm, the difference in change of closed quotient between arms is below 0.03 or its confidence interval includes zero.

Summary

The back pressure of straw phonation is set by the straw’s diameter: hundreds of pascals at 3 mm, tens at 6 mm. A fourteen-day closed-quotient curve can be seen in one person only with averaged sessions, and attributed to training only with a control group of about twenty persons or more if the true gain is modest.

References

Titze, Ingo R. 2006. “Voice Training and Therapy with a Semi-Occluded Vocal Tract: Rationale and Scientific Underpinnings.” Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research 49 (2): 448 to 459.

Fan, Y. (2026). Singer Formant Clustering, Glottal Closure Quotients and Acoustic Authority Psychophysics: Subglottal Pressure Dynamics, Pitch-Floor Stability and Pause-to-Phoneme Persuasion Ratios [歌手共振峰簇、声门闭合商与声学权威度心理物理学] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090258 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).