5D Library › Singer Formant Clustering, Glottal Closure Quotients and Acoustic Authority Psychophysics · 中文

Chapter 2. Heard Without Shouting? The Cluster in 75 dB of Noise and the Price in Subglottal Pressure

Band gain is not broadband gain

The claim that a speaker’s formant cluster “raises the signal-to-noise ratio by 12 dB in 75 dB of noise without shouting” mixes two quantities: the level in one frequency band and the intelligibility of the whole signal. p03 puts the two vowels of Chapter 1 against speech-shaped noise and scores them with an index in the style of the Speech Intelligibility Index, in which each octave band contributes its importance times its audibility (American National Standards Institute 1997).

Calculation

# Chapter 2. p03: What the cluster buys in 75 dB of noise. Octave-band
# levels of the two vowels of p01 (same source, scaled so the "spread"
# vowel is 65 dB overall), against speech-shaped noise of 75 dB overall
# (octave levels -2, 0, -6, -12, -18, -24 dB from 250 to 8000 Hz, a
# fall of 6 dB per octave above 500 Hz). A speech-intelligibility-index
# style score: each band contributes its octave importance (ANSI S3.5
# octave weights) times its audibility, (SNR + 15) / 30 kept in 0..1.
# "Equivalent gain": how many dB the spread voice must be raised to
# score as well as the cluster voice.
from math import log10, log2, pi, sqrt

BW = (80, 90, 120, 150, 200, 250, 300)
SPREAD = (700, 1200, 2600, 3500, 4500, 5500, 6500)
CLUSTER = (700, 1200, 2600, 2900, 3200, 5500, 6500)
CENTRES = (250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 8000)
WEIGHT = (0.0617, 0.1671, 0.2373, 0.2648, 0.2142, 0.0549)
SHAPE = (-2, 0, -6, -12, -18, -24)

def gain_db(f, formants):
    s = 2j * pi * f
    g = 1.0
    for fn, bn in zip(formants, BW):
        p = complex(-pi * bn, 2 * pi * fn)
        g *= abs(p) ** 2 / (abs(s - p) * abs(s - p.conjugate()))
    return 20 * log10(g) + (-6 * log2(f / 100) if f > 100 else 0.0)

def power(formants, lo, hi):
    return sum(10 ** (gain_db(f, formants) / 10)
               for f in range(int(lo), int(hi), 10))

def bands(formants, offset):
    return [10 * log10(power(formants, c / sqrt(2), c * sqrt(2))) + offset
            for c in CENTRES]

def score(speech, noise):
    return sum(w * min(max((s - n + 15) / 30, 0.0), 1.0)
               for w, s, n in zip(WEIGHT, speech, noise))

if __name__ == "__main__":
    tot = 10 * log10(power(SPREAD, 50, 11314))
    sp = bands(SPREAD, 65 - tot)
    cl = bands(CLUSTER, 65 - tot)
    ns = 10 * log10(sum(10 ** (x / 10) for x in SHAPE))
    nz = [x + 75 - ns for x in SHAPE]
    print("   band (Hz)  noise  spread  cluster   SNR spread  SNR cluster")
    for c, n, a, b in zip(CENTRES, nz, sp, cl):
        print("   {:9d}  {:5.1f}  {:6.1f}  {:7.1f}   {:10.1f}  {:11.1f}"
              .format(c, n, a, b, a - n, b - n))
    s0, s1 = score(sp, nz), score(cl, nz)
    lo, hi = 0.0, 30.0
    for _ in range(60):
        mid = (lo + hi) / 2
        if score([x + mid for x in sp], nz) < s1:
            lo = mid
        else:
            hi = mid
    print("   score: spread {:.3f}, cluster {:.3f}".format(s0, s1))
    print("   equivalent broadband gain of the cluster: {:.1f} dB".format(lo))
    print("   spread voice raised 12 dB: score {:.3f}".format(
        score([x + 12 for x in sp], nz)))
#    band (Hz)  noise  spread  cluster   SNR spread  SNR cluster
#          250   70.1    51.9     52.0        -18.1        -18.1
#          500   72.1    61.0     61.4        -11.0        -10.7
#         1000   66.1    61.7     62.4         -4.4         -3.7
#         2000   60.1    40.6     50.8        -19.5         -9.3
#         4000   54.1    29.5     47.5        -24.6         -6.5
#         8000   48.1   -17.6    -33.0        -65.7        -81.1
#    score: spread 0.106, cluster 0.225
#    equivalent broadband gain of the cluster: 6.7 dB
#    spread voice raised 12 dB: score 0.370

With the spread vowel at 65 dB in 75 dB of noise the score is 0.106; with the cluster it is 0.225. In the 2 kHz octave the cluster’s signal-to-noise ratio is -9.3 dB instead of -19.5 dB, and in the 4 kHz octave -6.5 dB instead of -24.6 dB, but the bands below 1 kHz, which carry much of the importance, are unchanged. To score as well, the spread voice would have to be raised by 6.7 dB across the board. So the cluster is worth about 7 dB of broadband level in this model, not 12; raising the spread voice by a full 12 dB would give a score of 0.370, well above the cluster’s.

Octave-band signal-to-noise ratios of the two vowels against 75 dB of speech-shaped noise (p03).

The price of being heard

In noise, speakers raise their voices without deciding to: the Lombard effect (Lane and Tranel 1971). The rise costs subglottal pressure; sound level grows by about 8 to 9 dB for each doubling of pressure (Titze and Sundberg 1992). p04 combines a Lombard slope of 0.5 dB per dB with the 6.7 dB of p03.

Calculation

# Chapter 2. p04: The price of being heard, in subglottal pressure. A
# speaker who raises the voice by 0.5 dB per dB of noise above 50 dB (a
# Lombard slope; reported slopes range from about 0.3 to 0.6) starts
# from 0.6 kPa of subglottal pressure in quiet. Sound level rises by
# 8 to 9 dB per doubling of pressure, so a rise of R dB needs pressure
# 0.6 * 2^(R / slope). With a cluster worth G = 6.7 dB (p03), the rise
# needed for the same intelligibility is R - G (not below 0).
G, P0, LOMBARD = 6.7, 0.6, 0.5

def pressure(rise, slope):
    return P0 * 2 ** (max(rise, 0.0) / slope)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   noise  rise   Ps (kPa) 8 dB  9 dB   with cluster: rise"
          "  8 dB  9 dB")
    for n in (55, 65, 75, 85):
        r = LOMBARD * max(n - 50, 0)
        fmt = ("   {:5d}  {:4.1f}  {:13.2f}  {:4.2f}  {:19.1f}  {:4.2f}"
               "  {:4.2f}")
        print(fmt.format(n, r, pressure(r, 8), pressure(r, 9),
                      max(r - G, 0.0), pressure(r - G, 8),
                      pressure(r - G, 9)))
    print("   pressure saved at 75 dB of noise: {:.0%} (8 dB) to {:.0%}"
          " (9 dB)".format(1 - 2 ** (-G / 8), 1 - 2 ** (-G / 9)))
#    noise  rise   Ps (kPa) 8 dB  9 dB   with cluster: rise  8 dB  9 dB
#       55   2.5           0.75  0.73                  0.0  0.60  0.60
#       65   7.5           1.15  1.07                  0.8  0.64  0.64
#       75  12.5           1.77  1.57                  5.8  0.99  0.94
#       85  17.5           2.73  2.31                 10.8  1.53  1.38
#    pressure saved at 75 dB of noise: 44% (8 dB) to 40% (9 dB)

In 75 dB of noise the Lombard rise is 12.5 dB, which needs 1.77 kPa of subglottal pressure at 8 dB per doubling, or 1.57 kPa at 9 dB, against 0.6 kPa in quiet. With the cluster the rise needed falls to 5.8 dB and the pressure to 0.99 or 0.94 kPa: a saving of about 40% to 44%. This is the sense in which the cluster lets a speaker be heard “without shouting”: not by adding 12 dB, but by making each dB of effort count for more in the bands that matter.

Hypothesis · not established

The author’s interpretation (not yet tested): after training that narrows the F3 to F5 spacing, speakers addressing a room in 75 dB of noise use less subglottal pressure (estimated from intraoral pressure during voiceless stops) for the same intelligibility than before. What would show it wrong: in a pre-registered training study with intraoral pressure measurement, intelligibility-matched pressure in noise does not fall after training, or falls equally in a control group trained only in loudness.

Summary

In the model, the cluster’s 14 dB in the 2 to 4 kHz band is worth about 7 dB of broadband level for intelligibility in 75 dB of speech-shaped noise. Its real benefit is economy: the subglottal pressure needed to be understood in that noise falls by about two fifths.

References

American National Standards Institute. 1997. Methods for Calculation of the Speech Intelligibility Index (ANSI S3.5-1997). Acoustical Society of America.
Lane, Harlan, and Bernard Tranel. 1971. “The Lombard Sign and the Role of Hearing in Speech.” Journal of Speech and Hearing Research 14 (4): 677 to 709.
Titze, Ingo R., and Johan Sundberg. 1992. “Vocal Intensity in Speakers and Singers.” The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 91 (5): 2936 to 2946.

Fan, Y. (2026). Singer Formant Clustering, Glottal Closure Quotients and Acoustic Authority Psychophysics: Subglottal Pressure Dynamics, Pitch-Floor Stability and Pause-to-Phoneme Persuasion Ratios [歌手共振峰簇、声门闭合商与声学权威度心理物理学] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090258 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).