5D Library › 仪式神经学、空间边界切换与自我转移的计算生物医学 · English

第二章 应激轴、呼吸与炎症:哪些是方程,哪些是证据

从「异态负荷」到一个可以求解的模型

作者框架的第二章要做三件事:用四阶龙格—库塔法(RK4)求解 HPA 轴异态负荷与皮质醇日节律变平的方程;把每分钟约 6 次的「0.1 Hz 迈耶波共振呼吸」经压力反射与 RMSSD 接到 α7 烟碱受体介导的胆碱能抗炎通路(TNF-α、IL-6);再写出内源性 β-内啡肽与催产素的动力学。这三件事的证据基础很不一样,本章逐一分开。

先说概念。麦克尤恩 1998 年把异态负荷定义为身体在反复或长期应对应激时付出的累积代价:应激介质(皮质醇、儿茶酚胺、炎症因子)在短期内是保护性的,长期失调则带来损害 (McEwen 1998)。在研究中,它通常是一个由十几项生物标志物(血压、腰臀比、糖化血红蛋白、皮质醇等)超出风险分位数的个数相加而成的指数。它不是一个可以直接写进微分方程的状态变量。第 14 本已经讨论过 CRH–ACTH–皮质醇负反馈回路的双稳态与异态负荷指数的计算方法,这里只回顾,不重复。

一个示意的 HPA 模型

古普塔等人 2007 年把糖皮质激素受体加进 HPA 轴模型,得到了双稳态 (Gupta et al. 2007);斯里拉姆、罗德里格斯—费尔南德斯与多伊尔 2012 年在此基础上拟合了正常人、抑郁症与创伤后应激障碍患者的皮质醇与 ACTH 数据,说明不同的参数区域可以产生不同的日节律形状 (Sriram et al. 2012)。本书不复现他们的模型,而是写一个更简单的三变量示意模型(作者的模型):

dCdt=D(t)(1+S)1+(F/Ki)2−Cτc,dAdt=C1+(F/Ki)2−Aτa,dFdt=A−Fτf,\frac{dC}{dt} = \frac{D(t)(1+S)}{1 + (F/K_i)^2} – \frac{C}{\tau_c},\quad \frac{dA}{dt} = \frac{C}{1 + (F/K_i)^2} – \frac{A}{\tau_a},\quad \frac{dF}{dt} = A – \frac{F}{\tau_f},

其中 CC、AA、FF 分别是 CRH、ACTH 与皮质醇,D(t)=1+0.9cos⁡(2π(t−6.5)/24)D(t) = 1 + 0.9\cos\bigl(2\pi(t-6.5)/24\bigr) 是昼夜节律驱动,SS 是持续的额外驱动,KiK_i 是负反馈的半饱和常数(KiK_i 增大表示反馈抵抗),三个时间常数对应约 4、10 与 65 分钟的半衰期。日斜率按许多现场研究的做法,取 07:00 至 22:00 之间 ln⁡F\ln F 对钟点的最小二乘斜率。程序用步长 0.005 小时的 RK4 积分 8 天,取最后一天。

推导

# A three-variable HPA-axis model solved with fourth-order Runge-Kutta (Chapter 2).
# The author's simplified model in the spirit of Gupta et al. (2007) and Sriram et al.
# (2012); it is NOT their model and its parameters are illustrative, not fitted.
#   dC/dt = D(t) (1 + S) / (1 + (F/Ki)^2) - C/tc        CRH, circadian drive D(t)
#   dA/dt = C / (1 + (F/Ki)^2) - A/ta                   ACTH
#   dF/dt = A - F/tf                                     cortisol
# D(t) = 1 + 0.9 cos(2 pi (t - 6.5)/24). Time in hours; half-lives about 4 min (CRH),
# 10 min (ACTH) and 65 min (cortisol). Diurnal slope: least-squares slope of ln F
# against clock time from 07:00 to 22:00, as in many field studies (ln units per hour).
import math

TC, TA, TF = 4 / 60 / math.log(2), 10 / 60 / math.log(2), 65 / 60 / math.log(2)

def rhs(t, y, S, Ki, evening):
    c, a, f = y
    d = 1 + 0.9 * math.cos(2 * math.pi * (t - 6.5) / 24)
    if evening and 17 <= t % 24 < 23:
        d += evening                                  # stress load late in the day
    fb = 1 / (1 + (f / Ki) ** 2)
    return (d * (1 + S) * fb - c / TC, c * fb - a / TA, a - f / TF)

def rk4(S=0.0, Ki=0.04, evening=0.0, days=8, dt=0.005):
    y, t, out = (0.1, 0.1, 0.1), 0.0, []
    for _ in range(round(days * 24 / dt)):
        f = lambda tt, yy: rhs(tt, yy, S, Ki, evening)
        k1 = f(t, y)
        k2 = f(t + dt / 2, tuple(v + dt / 2 * k for v, k in zip(y, k1)))
        k3 = f(t + dt / 2, tuple(v + dt / 2 * k for v, k in zip(y, k2)))
        k4 = f(t + dt, tuple(v + dt * k for v, k in zip(y, k3)))
        y = tuple(v + dt / 6 * (p + 2 * q + 2 * r + s)
                  for v, p, q, r, s in zip(y, k1, k2, k3, k4))
        t += dt
        if t > (days - 1) * 24 - 1e-9:
            out.append((t - (days - 1) * 24, y[2]))
    return out

def slope(day):
    pts = [(t, math.log(f)) for t, f in day if 7 <= t <= 22]
    mt = math.fsum(t for t, _ in pts) / len(pts)
    my = math.fsum(v for _, v in pts) / len(pts)
    return (math.fsum((t - mt) * (v - my) for t, v in pts)
            / math.fsum((t - mt) ** 2 for t, _ in pts))

def at(day, h):
    return min(day, key=lambda p: abs(p[0] - h))[1]

SCEN = (("baseline", {}), ("constant extra drive S = 0.5", {"S": 0.5}),
        ("evening load 17-23 h (+1.0)", {"evening": 1.0}),
        ("feedback resistance Ki x 2", {"Ki": 0.08}),
        ("S = 0.5 and Ki x 2", {"S": 0.5, "Ki": 0.08}))
print("cortisol in units of baseline F(08:00) = 100")
print("scenario                       F(08h)  F(22h)  ratio  slope (ln/h)  mean F")
res = {}
for name, kw in SCEN:
    day = rk4(**kw); res[name] = day
    u = 100 / at(res["baseline"], 8)
    print(f"{name:30s} {u * at(day, 8):6.1f} {u * at(day, 22):7.1f}"
          f" {at(day, 8) / at(day, 22):6.2f} {slope(day):11.3f}"
          f" {u * math.fsum(f for _, f in day) / len(day):8.1f}")
fine = rk4(dt=0.0025)
err = max(abs(a[1] - b[1]) for a, b in zip(res["baseline"], fine[0::2]))
print(f"RK4 check: largest change in F when the step is halved:"
      f" {err * 100 / at(res['baseline'], 8):.1e} units")
# cortisol in units of baseline F(08:00) = 100
# scenario                       F(08h)  F(22h)  ratio  slope (ln/h)  mean F
# baseline                        100.0    28.6   3.50      -0.137     66.7
# constant extra drive S = 0.5    117.3    40.6   2.89      -0.122     81.3
# evening load 17-23 h (+1.0)     100.0    85.0   1.18      -0.030     80.9
# feedback resistance Ki x 2      143.9    30.0   4.80      -0.160     89.2
# S = 0.5 and Ki x 2              176.2    44.0   4.01      -0.147    114.0
# RK4 check: largest change in F when the step is halved: 5.7e-10 units

把步长减半,皮质醇的最大变化只有 5.7×10−105.7\times10^{-10} 个单位,数值误差可以忽略。结果有一点出乎作者框架的预期。基线的早晚比为 3.50,斜率 −0.137。持续的额外驱动(S=0.5S = 0.5)使斜率略变平(−0.122)。晚间负荷(17–23 时驱动增加 1.0)使斜率变平得最多(−0.030),22 时的皮质醇从 28.6 升到 85.0,而 08 时不变。反馈抵抗(KiK_i 加倍)反而使斜率变陡(−0.160),早上的皮质醇升到 143.9。也就是说,在本模型中,「慢性应激使皮质醇日节律变平」不是自动成立的:它取决于负荷落在一天中的什么时候,以及受损的是驱动还是反馈。图 2 左画出了三种情形。

证据

皮质醇斜率与健康(人体观察研究的元分析)。 亚当等人 2017 年的元分析汇总了 80 项研究中的 179 个关联,发现较平的皮质醇日斜率与较差的身心健康结局相关,平均效应量 r=0.147r = 0.147 (Adam et al. 2017)。这些研究大多是横断面或纵向的观察研究,结局包括抑郁、疲劳、心血管指标与死亡率等。r=0.147r = 0.147 意味着斜率只能解释结局方差的约 2%;而且斜率变平可能是疾病的结果、睡眠时间的结果或测量时间不准的结果,不能读成「把斜率调陡就能改善健康」。

共振呼吸:压力反射环路的延迟

作者框架称每分钟约 6 次的呼吸为「0.1 Hz 迈耶波共振」。需要区分两个概念。迈耶波是动脉血压约 0.1 Hz 的自发振荡,一般认为与交感神经对血管的调节及压力反射环路有关 (Julien 2006)。共振呼吸是指以某个频率呼吸时,心率振荡的幅度达到最大。瓦斯奇洛、瓦斯奇洛与莱勒的解释是:呼吸引起血压波动,压力反射以一定的延迟改变心率,心率又改变血压;当呼吸周期与环路的延迟相配时,几种效应同相叠加,振幅最大 (Vaschillo et al. 2006; Lehrer and Gevirtz 2014)。所以共振来自压力反射环路的延迟,它与迈耶波的频率相近,但不是同一回事;而且每个人的共振频率不同,通常需要逐人测定。第 14 本已经提到每分钟约 6 次的共振,这里用一个线性环路模型说明它的来源与测量上的问题(作者的模型)。

设呼吸以角频率 ω\omega 驱动血压(增益 BB)与心率(迷走直接通路,低通,增益 RR,时间常数 TvT_v),心率经血管的低通(增益 KK,时间常数 TwT_w)影响血压,血压经压力反射以增益 −G-G 与延迟 τ\tau 影响心率。闭环的心率振幅为

H(ω)=R/(1+iωTv)−Ge−iωτB1+GKe−iωτ/(1+iωTw).H(\omega) = \frac{R/(1+i\omega T_v) – G e^{-i\omega\tau} B}{1 + G K e^{-i\omega\tau}/(1+i\omega T_w)}.

当环路相位接近 −π-\pi 时,分母变小,振幅被放大。程序再按每个频率生成 5 分钟的逐拍 RR 间期(平均心率 65 次/分,逐拍噪声 10 毫秒),计算 RMSSD 与 SDNN。

推导

# Resonance breathing in a linear baroreflex loop, and what RMSSD does (Chapter 2).
# The author's illustrative model (after the resonance idea of Vaschillo, Lehrer et al.):
# breathing at angular frequency w drives blood pressure (gain B) and heart rate directly
# (vagal low-pass, gain R, time constant Tv); heart rate feeds back on pressure through a
# Windkessel low-pass (gain K, time constant Tw); pressure acts on heart rate through the
# baroreflex with gain -G and delay tau. Closed-loop heart-rate amplitude per unit breath:
#   H(w) = (R/(1+iwTv) - G e^{-iw tau} B) / (1 + G K e^{-iw tau} / (1 + iwTw))
# Then 5-minute RR series (65 bpm mean, beat noise 10 ms) give RMSSD and SDNN.
import cmath, math, random

B, R, TV, K, TW, G = 2.0, 2.0, 1.5, 1.0, 2.0, 1.0

def hr_amp(f, tau=3.5):
    w = 2 * math.pi * f; d = cmath.exp(-1j * w * tau)
    return abs((R / (1 + 1j * w * TV) - G * d * B) / (1 + G * K * d / (1 + 1j * w * TW)))

def rr_series(rng, f, amp, minutes=5, hr0=65.0, noise=10.0):
    t, rr = 0.0, []
    while t < minutes * 60:
        hr = hr0 + amp * math.sin(2 * math.pi * f * t)
        x = 60000 / hr + rng.gauss(0, noise); rr.append(x); t += x / 1000
    return rr

def rmssd(rr):
    return math.sqrt(math.fsum((b - a) ** 2 for a, b in zip(rr, rr[1:])) / (len(rr) - 1))

def sdnn(rr):
    m = math.fsum(rr) / len(rr)
    return math.sqrt(math.fsum((x - m) ** 2 for x in rr) / (len(rr) - 1))

rng = random.Random(6)
print("breaths/min  HR amplitude (bpm)  RMSSD (ms)  ln RMSSD  SDNN (ms)")
rows = []
for bpm in (3, 4, 5, 5.5, 6, 6.5, 7, 8, 10, 12, 15):
    f = bpm / 60; a = hr_amp(f)
    rr = rr_series(rng, f, a); rows.append((bpm, a, rmssd(rr), sdnn(rr)))
    print(f"{bpm:9.1f} {a:15.2f} {rmssd(rr):15.1f} {math.log(rmssd(rr)):9.2f}"
          f" {sdnn(rr):9.1f}")
best = max(rows, key=lambda r: r[1]); top_r = max(rows, key=lambda r: r[2])
print(f"largest HR oscillation at {best[0]} breaths/min; largest RMSSD at"
      f" {top_r[0]} breaths/min")
print("resonance frequency against baroreflex delay tau (fine grid 2-15 breaths/min):")
for tau in (2.5, 3.0, 3.5, 4.0, 4.5):
    grid = [2 + 0.01 * i for i in range(1301)]
    fb = max(grid, key=lambda b: hr_amp(b / 60, tau))
    print(f"   tau = {tau:.1f} s: peak at {fb:.2f} breaths/min ({fb / 60:.3f} Hz)")
rr0 = rr_series(random.Random(1), 0.25, hr_amp(0.25))
rr6 = rr_series(random.Random(1), 0.1, hr_amp(0.1))
print(f"same model person recorded at 15/min vs paced 6/min: RMSSD {rmssd(rr0):.1f}"
      f" vs {rmssd(rr6):.1f} ms")
print("   (the whole difference comes from the breathing pattern during the recording)")
# breaths/min  HR amplitude (bpm)  RMSSD (ms)  ln RMSSD  SDNN (ms)
#       3.0            1.00            14.1      2.65      13.9
#       4.0            1.92            16.1      2.78      21.9
#       5.0            3.88            23.6      3.16      40.3
#       5.5            5.31            31.9      3.46      54.8
#       6.0            6.12            38.3      3.65      62.4
#       6.5            5.71            38.4      3.65      58.4
#       7.0            4.90            36.9      3.61      51.0
#       8.0            3.71            31.1      3.44      38.0
#      10.0            2.67            28.8      3.36      28.9
#      12.0            2.24            27.8      3.33      24.4
#      15.0            1.88            29.9      3.40      22.0
# largest HR oscillation at 6 breaths/min; largest RMSSD at 6.5 breaths/min
# resonance frequency against baroreflex delay tau (fine grid 2-15 breaths/min):
#    tau = 2.5 s: peak at 8.12 breaths/min (0.135 Hz)
#    tau = 3.0 s: peak at 6.90 breaths/min (0.115 Hz)
#    tau = 3.5 s: peak at 6.05 breaths/min (0.101 Hz)
#    tau = 4.0 s: peak at 5.42 breaths/min (0.090 Hz)
#    tau = 4.5 s: peak at 4.92 breaths/min (0.082 Hz)
# same model person recorded at 15/min vs paced 6/min: RMSSD 27.8 vs 38.3 ms
#    (the whole difference comes from the breathing pattern during the recording)

在 τ=3.5\tau = 3.5 秒时,心率振幅在每分钟 6 次时最大(6.12 次/分),比每分钟 15 次(1.88)大三倍多;SDNN 也在 6 次时最大(62.4 毫秒)。但 RMSSD 的峰值较平:6 次时 38.3、6.5 次时 38.4、15 次时 29.9 毫秒。从每分钟 15 次到 6 次,心率振幅增大到 3.3 倍,SDNN 增大到 2.8 倍,RMSSD 只增大约 1.3 倍。原因是 RMSSD 计算的是相邻心搏之差,一个 10 秒周期的慢振荡在相邻两拍之间变化很小,所以 RMSSD 对它相对不敏感;但相对不敏感不等于不变,下面会看到,它仍会随记录时的呼吸方式明显改变。共振频率随延迟移动:延迟从 2.5 秒增到 4.5 秒,峰值从每分钟 8.12 次移到 4.92 次。图 2 右画出了三种延迟下的曲线。

最后两行对第八章的设计很重要:同一个模型中的人,按每分钟 15 次呼吸记录,RMSSD 为 27.8 毫秒;按每分钟 6 次记录,为 38.3 毫秒。这个差别完全来自记录时的呼吸方式。心率变异性的测量指南早就提醒,呼吸频率与潮气量会影响短时程指标,研究者应当控制或至少报告呼吸 (Task Force of the European Society of Cardiology and the North American Society of Pacing and Electrophysiology 1996; Laborde et al. 2017)。如果试验的一组在记录时仍在慢呼吸,另一组自然呼吸,RMSSD 的差别就不能解释为「恢复得更好」。

左:示意 HPA 模型中一天的皮质醇曲线(基线、晚间负荷、额外驱动加反馈抵抗;08:00 基线 = 100)。右:压力反射环路模型中心率振幅随呼吸频率的变化,三种延迟(作者的模型,示意参数)。

证据

慢呼吸与心率变异性(人体研究)。 拉博德等人 2022 年的系统综述与元分析纳入 223 项研究(172 项测量呼吸过程中、16 项测量单次练习之后、49 项测量多次练习之后的效应),发现慢呼吸在练习中、单次练习之后与多次练习之后都提高了迷走介导的心率变异性 (Laborde et al. 2022)。扎卡罗等人 2018 年的系统综述也报告慢呼吸与心率变异性升高、自主神经与情绪指标的改善有关,但纳入研究的质量参差不齐 (Zaccaro et al. 2018)。这些结果支持「慢呼吸在练习中与练习后短时间内提高迷走指标」;它们本身不说明这种提高会持续多久,也不说明它会改变炎症或疾病结局。

胆碱能抗炎通路:动物、器械与呼吸

作者框架把呼吸、RMSSD 与「α7nAChR 胆碱能抗炎通路」连成一条链。这条链的每一环证据强度不同。

证据

动物与机制证据。 博罗维科娃等人 2000 年在大鼠中发现,电刺激迷走神经可以减弱内毒素引起的全身炎症反应与 TNF 升高 (Borovikova et al. 2000);王等人 2003 年在小鼠中发现,巨噬细胞上的 α7 烟碱型乙酰胆碱受体是这一抑制作用所必需的 (Wang et al. 2003);特雷西 2002 年把这些结果概括为「炎症反射」(Tracey 2002)。这些是动物与机制研究:它们说明迷走传出活动能够抑制细胞因子的产生,但所用的刺激强度、时程与内毒素剂量都与人的日常呼吸练习相去甚远。

证据

人体证据。 库普曼等人 2016 年在类风湿关节炎患者中植入迷走神经刺激器,报告 TNF 的产生受到抑制、疾病活动度下降;这是一项开放标签的小型研究,用的是植入式器械,不是呼吸 (Koopman et al. 2016)。科克斯等人 2014 年让 12 名男性接受包括呼吸技巧、冷暴露与冥想的训练,再与 12 名未训练者一起注射内毒素:训练组的肾上腺素升高,抗炎因子 IL-10 较高,TNF-α、IL-6 与 IL-8 较低,流感样症状较少 (Kox et al. 2014)。作者认为这一效应与交感神经—肾上腺素的激活有关,而不是迷走。这项研究常被引用为「呼吸可以抗炎」,但它的呼吸方式是过度通气与屏气,而不是慢呼吸,机制也不是作者框架所说的迷走—α7 通路。本书核对时没有找到「慢呼吸练习可靠地降低健康人或患者血中 TNF-α、IL-6」的一致证据。

下面的程序用两个示意模型说明,为什么不能从动物结果直接推出人体中的效应大小。A 部分是一个玩具模型:内毒素样刺激随时间衰减,TNF 的产生率被迷走活动 vv 按 1/(1+v/Kv)1/(1+v/K_v) 抑制,IL-6 随 TNF 而动。B 部分是一个单室激素模型:练习的 12 分钟内以恒定速率分泌,之后按一级动力学消除。

推导

# Two schematic kinetic models (Chapter 2). Parameters are illustrative, NOT estimates.
# A. Cholinergic anti-inflammatory pathway as a toy: an endotoxin-like stimulus E(t)
#    decays with a 1-hour time constant; TNF is produced at rate E/(1 + v/Kv) and cleared
#    with a 20-minute half-life; IL-6 follows TNF with a 1-hour half-life. v is efferent
#    vagal activity (arbitrary units). How much does TNF fall when v rises from 0 to 1?
#    The answer is set by Kv, which is unknown in humans, and by timing.
# B. A one-compartment hormone pulse: secretion at a constant rate for 12 minutes, then
#    first-order elimination with half-life h. What share of the peak is still there when
#    blood is drawn at various times after the practice ends?
import math

def toxin(v, kv, hours=8.0, dt=0.001, window=None):
    e, tnf, il6, t, peak, auc = 1.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, []
    kt, ki = math.log(2) / (20 / 60), math.log(2) / 1.0
    while t < hours:
        vv = v if window is None or window[0] <= t < window[1] else 0.0
        de = -e; dtnf = e / (1 + vv / kv) - kt * tnf; dil = tnf - ki * il6
        e += dt * de; tnf += dt * dtnf; il6 += dt * dil; t += dt
        peak = max(peak, tnf); auc.append(il6 * dt)
    return peak, math.fsum(auc)

print("A  TNF peak and IL-6 area, relative to v = 0 (same Kv)")
for kv in (0.5, 2.0, 10.0):
    p0, a0 = toxin(0.0, kv)
    row = []
    for v in (0.5, 1.0, 2.0):
        p, a = toxin(v, kv); row.append(f"v={v:.1f}: {p / p0:5.2f}/{a / a0:5.2f}")
    print(f"   Kv = {kv:4.1f}  " + "   ".join(row))

p0, a0 = toxin(0.0, 2.0)
print("   a 12-minute rise to v = 1 (Kv = 2), starting at various times after"
      " the stimulus")
for st in (0.0, 0.5, 1.0, 2.0):
    p, a = toxin(1.0, 2.0, window=(st, st + 0.2))
    print(f"   start +{st:3.1f} h: TNF peak {p / p0:5.2f}, IL-6 area {a / a0:5.2f}")

def pulse(h, t_after, dur=12.0, rate=1.0):
    k = math.log(2) / h
    peak = rate / k * (1 - math.exp(-k * dur))            # at the end of secretion
    return peak, peak * math.exp(-k * t_after)

print("B  share of the end-of-practice level left at the blood draw")
print("   half-life      +5 min   +20 min   +40 min   +60 min")
for h in (4.0, 10.0, 25.0, 60.0):
    cells = [pulse(h, t)[1] / pulse(h, 0)[1] for t in (5, 20, 40, 60)]
    print(f"   {h:5.0f} min " + "".join(f"{c:10.3f}" for c in cells))
# A  TNF peak and IL-6 area, relative to v = 0 (same Kv)
#    Kv =  0.5  v=0.5:  0.50/ 0.50   v=1.0:  0.33/ 0.33   v=2.0:  0.20/ 0.20
#    Kv =  2.0  v=0.5:  0.80/ 0.80   v=1.0:  0.67/ 0.67   v=2.0:  0.50/ 0.50
#    Kv = 10.0  v=0.5:  0.95/ 0.95   v=1.0:  0.91/ 0.91   v=2.0:  0.83/ 0.83
#    a 12-minute rise to v = 1 (Kv = 2), starting at various times after the stimulus
#    start +0.0 h: TNF peak  0.93, IL-6 area  0.94
#    start +0.5 h: TNF peak  0.96, IL-6 area  0.96
#    start +1.0 h: TNF peak  1.00, IL-6 area  0.98
#    start +2.0 h: TNF peak  1.00, IL-6 area  0.99
# B  share of the end-of-practice level left at the blood draw
#    half-life      +5 min   +20 min   +40 min   +60 min
#        4 min      0.420     0.031     0.001     0.000
#       10 min      0.707     0.250     0.062     0.016
#       25 min      0.871     0.574     0.330     0.189
#       60 min      0.944     0.794     0.630     0.500

A 部分的结论几乎完全由一个在人体中未知的参数 KvK_v 决定:vv 从 0 升到 1 时,TNF 峰值在 Kv=0.5K_v = 0.5 时降到 0.33,在 Kv=10K_v = 10 时只降到 0.91。时机也很重要:在 Kv=2K_v = 2 时,一段 12 分钟的迷走活动升高若与刺激同时开始,TNF 峰值只降到 0.93;若在刺激后 1 小时才开始,峰值不变(1.00)。所以任何「呼吸练习使 TNF 下降 X%」的说法,如果没有人体测量,都只是参数的选择。

B 部分说明测量上的问题。若一种激素的血浆半衰期只有 4 分钟,练习结束 20 分钟后抽血,只剩练习结束时水平的 3.1%;若半衰期为 25 分钟,剩 57.4%。β-内啡肽与催产素的半衰期、中枢与外周的分泌是否同步,都是需要另行核对的经验问题;本书只把它们写成示意参数,不写成测量值。外周血浆中测不到变化,不能证明中枢没有变化;测到变化,也不能证明它来自中枢或与情绪改变有关。

假说 · 尚未验证 · 慢呼吸与炎症指标

作者的假说(尚未确立): 在健康成年人中,连续 8 周每天两次、每次 15 分钟、以个人共振频率进行的慢呼吸练习,与时间匹配的自然呼吸放松相比,会降低全血经内毒素刺激后体外产生的 TNF-α。什么样的结果能证明它是错的: 在预先登记的随机对照试验中,两组 TNF-α 产生量之差的置信区间落在事先规定的最小关注效应之内;或者差别只出现在练习当天、在洗脱一周后消失。

本章小结

异态负荷是一个多指标指数,不是方程变量;本书的 HPA 方程是示意模型,RK4 数值误差可忽略。在本模型中,皮质醇日斜率变平主要来自晚间负荷(−0.137 变为 −0.030),而反馈抵抗使斜率变陡;人体元分析中斜率变平与较差健康的关联为 r=0.147r = 0.147,是相关。共振呼吸来自压力反射环路的延迟,与迈耶波相近但不相同,共振频率因人而异;RMSSD 对慢振荡相对不敏感(变化远小于 SDNN),但记录时的呼吸方式仍能明显改变它。胆碱能抗炎通路的证据主要来自动物与植入式刺激,呼吸练习降低人体炎症因子的证据薄弱;内源性肽的动力学在本书只是示意。

参考文献

Adam, Emma K., Meghan E. Quinn, Royette Tavernier, Mollie T. McQuillan, Katie A. Dahlke, and Kirsten E. Gilbert. 2017. “Diurnal Cortisol Slopes and Mental and Physical Health Outcomes: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.” Psychoneuroendocrinology 83: 25–41. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psyneuen.2017.05.018.
Borovikova, Lyudmila V., Svetlana Ivanova, Minghuang Zhang, et al. 2000. “Vagus Nerve Stimulation Attenuates the Systemic Inflammatory Response to Endotoxin.” Nature 405 (6785): 458–62. https://doi.org/10.1038/35013070.
Gupta, Suresh, Eric Aslakson, Brian M. Gurbaxani, and Suzanne D. Vernon. 2007. “Inclusion of the Glucocorticoid Receptor in a Hypothalamic Pituitary Adrenal Axis Model Reveals Bistability.” Theoretical Biology and Medical Modelling 4: 8. https://doi.org/10.1186/1742-4682-4-8.
Julien, Claude. 2006. “The Enigma of Mayer Waves: Facts and Models.” Cardiovascular Research 70 (1): 12–21.
Koopman, Frieda A., Sangeeta S. Chavan, Sanda Miljko, et al. 2016. “Vagus Nerve Stimulation Inhibits Cytokine Production and Attenuates Disease Severity in Rheumatoid Arthritis.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 113 (29): 8284–89. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1605635113.
Kox, Matthijs, Lucas T. van Eijk, Jelle Zwaag, et al. 2014. “Voluntary Activation of the Sympathetic Nervous System and Attenuation of the Innate Immune Response in Humans.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 111 (20): 7379–84. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1322174111.
Laborde, Sylvain, Mark S. Allen, Uirassu Borges, et al. 2022. “Effects of Voluntary Slow Breathing on Heart Rate and Heart Rate Variability: A Systematic Review and a Meta-Analysis.” Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 138: 104711. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2022.104711.
Laborde, Sylvain, Emma Mosley, and Julian F. Thayer. 2017. “Heart Rate Variability and Cardiac Vagal Tone in Psychophysiological Research: Recommendations for Experiment Planning, Data Analysis, and Data Reporting.” Frontiers in Psychology 8: 213. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2017.00213.
Lehrer, Paul M., and Richard Gevirtz. 2014. “Heart Rate Variability Biofeedback: How and Why Does It Work?” Frontiers in Psychology 5: 756. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2014.00756.
McEwen, Bruce S. 1998. “Protective and Damaging Effects of Stress Mediators.” New England Journal of Medicine 338 (3): 171–79. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199801153380307.
Sriram, Krishna, Maria Rodriguez-Fernandez, and III Doyle Francis J. 2012. “Modeling Cortisol Dynamics in the Neuro-Endocrine Axis Distinguishes Normal, Depression, and Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) in Humans.” PLoS Computational Biology 8 (2): e1002379. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1002379.
Task Force of the European Society of Cardiology and the North American Society of Pacing and Electrophysiology. 1996. “Heart Rate Variability: Standards of Measurement, Physiological Interpretation and Clinical Use.” Circulation 93 (5): 1043–65. https://doi.org/10.1161/01.CIR.93.5.1043.
Tracey, Kevin J. 2002. “The Inflammatory Reflex.” Nature 420 (6917): 853–59. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature01321.
Vaschillo, Evgeny G., Bronya Vaschillo, and Paul M. Lehrer. 2006. “Characteristics of Resonance in Heart Rate Variability Stimulated by Biofeedback.” Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback 31 (2): 129–42.
Wang, Hong, Man Yu, Mahendar Ochani, et al. 2003. “Nicotinic Acetylcholine Receptor α\alpha7 Subunit Is an Essential Regulator of Inflammation.” Nature 421 (6921): 384–88. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature01339.
Zaccaro, Andrea, Andrea Piarulli, Marco Laurino, et al. 2018. “How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing.” Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 12: 353. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnhum.2018.00353.

Fan, Y. (2026). Neurobiology of Ritual, Spatial Boundary Transitions and Computational Biomedicine of Self-Transcendence: From Predictive-Coding Free-Energy Minimisation, Default-Mode Network Decoupling and Vagal–Endocrine Restoration to Classical Chinese Medicine on Shifting the Spirit (Yijing Bianqi) [仪式神经学、空间边界切换与自我转移的计算生物医学] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23839910 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).