5D Library › Retrodictive Belief Locking, Sequential Pain-Point Agitation and Markovian Upsell Automata · 中文
Chapter 1. Retrodictive Statements and the “Trust Avalanche”
What a hit is worth
The most persuasive moment in a reading is often not a prediction about the future but a statement about the past: “around 2020 you went through a deep low”, “as a child you had a tense relationship with your father”. For a sceptical user such “retrodictions” are easier to check than any prophecy, and so they build trust more easily.
Bayes’ theorem says how much that trust should grow (Good 1950). Let the user start with a probability of 0.01 that the reader has real insight (odds 1 to 99). A statement hits with probability if the reader has insight, and with its base rate in the population if not. A hit multiplies the odds by the likelihood ratio Whether trust “avalanches” depends entirely on : a hit on a statement with a high base rate is almost no evidence.
Evidence
The Barnum effect. Forer gave his students a personality test and then handed each the same generic description taken from an astrology book; on average they rated it as very accurate for themselves (Forer 1949). People take statements with a high base rate as aimed at them personally, that is, they judge too low.
Calculation
# Chapter 1. [p01] What a retrodictive "hit" is worth: likelihood ratios.
# A sceptic gives the reader a prior probability of real insight of
# 0.01 (odds 1:99). A retrodictive statement about her past hits with
# probability h if the reader has insight and with the base rate b if
# not; a hit multiplies the odds by LR = h / b. Four kinds of
# statement. A generic statement feels personal (the Forer effect):
# the user takes its base rate to be 0.20, not 0.80. For the
# "trough year" the user believes b = 1/15 (one of
# 15 years) while the true base rate is 0.25, because in the population
# one year (a shared shock) is the worst year for a quarter of people.
# Hits needed to reach a posterior of 0.5 and of 0.95, with true and
# with perceived base rates.
import math
PRIOR = 0.01
KINDS = (("generic (Barnum)", 0.95, 0.80, 0.20),
("semi-specific", 0.90, 0.30, 0.30),
("trough year of 15", 0.90, 0.25, 1 / 15),
("checkable detail", 0.90, 0.02, 0.02))
def hits_needed(lr, target):
need = math.log(target / (1 - target)) - math.log(PRIOR / (1 - PRIOR))
return math.ceil(need / math.log(lr)) if lr > 1 else None
if __name__ == "__main__":
print(" statement h b true b seen LR true LR seen")
for name, h, b, seen in KINDS:
print(" {:19s} {:5.2f} {:8.3f} {:7.3f} {:8.2f} {:8.2f}".format(
name, h, b, seen, h / b, h / seen))
print("\n hits needed for posterior 0.5 (true/seen)"
" 0.95 (true/seen)")
for name, h, b, seen in KINDS:
print(" {:19s} {:>12s} {:>17s}".format(
name,
"{}/{}".format(hits_needed(h / b, 0.5),
hits_needed(h / seen, 0.5)),
"{}/{}".format(hits_needed(h / b, 0.95),
hits_needed(h / seen, 0.95))))
print("\nReading: a generic statement is almost no evidence (LR 1.19);")
print("a sceptic would need 27 such hits, but if it feels personal she")
print("is half convinced after 3 and sure after 5. The trough year")
print("looks strong for the same reason. Only checkable details carry")
print("the weight they seem to.")
# statement h b true b seen LR true LR seen
# generic (Barnum) 0.95 0.800 0.200 1.19 4.75
# semi-specific 0.90 0.300 0.300 3.00 3.00
# trough year of 15 0.90 0.250 0.067 3.60 13.50
# checkable detail 0.90 0.020 0.020 45.00 45.00
#
# hits needed for posterior 0.5 (true/seen) 0.95 (true/seen)
# generic (Barnum) 27/3 44/5
# semi-specific 5/5 7/7
# trough year of 15 4/2 6/3
# checkable detail 2/2 2/2
#
# Reading: a generic statement is almost no evidence (LR 1.19);
# a sceptic would need 27 such hits, but if it feels personal she
# is half convinced after 3 and sure after 5. The trough year
# looks strong for the same reason. Only checkable details carry
# the weight they seem to.A generic statement (base rate 0.80) has a true likelihood ratio of only 1.19: a sceptic with prior 0.01 needs 27 hits to be half convinced and 44 to be sure. But if it “feels accurate” and she takes its base rate for 0.20, the ratio becomes 4.75, and 3 hits make her half convinced, 5 make her sure. “The trough year of the past 15” looks like one chance in fifteen, a ratio of 13.50; but if one year (a shared shock, say) is the worst for a quarter of the population, the true base rate is 0.25 and the ratio only 3.60. Only checkable details carry real weight: base rate 0.02, ratio 45.00, and two hits convince a sceptic.
How the “avalanche” happens
The program simulates 20,000 sceptical users whose prior log-odds scatter around 0.01. The reader has no insight at all and makes only generic statements, each hitting with its base rate 0.80. One group updates with the true likelihood ratios; the other with the felt ones, and nearly forgets the misses (giving them a fifth of their weight).
Calculation
# Chapter 1. [p02] A "trust avalanche" without any insight.
# 20,000 sceptical users (seed 69); prior log-odds of insight normal
# with mean log(1/99) and sd 1.5. A reader WITHOUT insight makes m
# generic retrodictive statements; each hits with its base rate 0.80.
# Proper updating uses the true likelihood ratios (hit 0.95/0.80, miss
# 0.05/0.20). Biased updating uses the perceived base rate 0.20 (hit
# 0.95/0.20) and gives each miss only weight 0.2 (misses are
# forgotten). Reported: share of users whose posterior exceeds 0.9.
import math
import random
N = 20000
def run(m, biased, rng):
lh = math.log(0.95 / (0.20 if biased else 0.80))
lm = math.log(0.05 / (0.80 if biased else 0.20))
wm = 0.2 if biased else 1.0
sure = 0
for _ in range(N):
lo = rng.gauss(math.log(1 / 99), 1.5)
for _ in range(m):
lo += lh if rng.random() < 0.80 else wm * lm
sure += lo > math.log(9)
return sure / N
if __name__ == "__main__":
print(" m share sure (proper) share sure (biased)")
for m in (0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 10, 15):
a = run(m, False, random.Random(69))
b = run(m, True, random.Random(69))
print(" {:2d} {:20.4f} {:21.4f}".format(m, a, b))
print("\nReading: with the true likelihood ratios almost nobody is")
print("convinced by any number of generic hits. With the felt ratios")
print("the share jumps from a few per cent to most users within a")
print("handful of statements: an avalanche made of misjudged base")
print("rates, not of evidence.")
# m share sure (proper) share sure (biased)
# 0 0.0000 0.0000
# 1 0.0000 0.0003
# 2 0.0000 0.0043
# 3 0.0000 0.0408
# 4 0.0000 0.1603
# 5 0.0001 0.3452
# 6 0.0000 0.5263
# 8 0.0000 0.7928
# 10 0.0001 0.9261
# 15 0.0001 0.9960
#
# Reading: with the true likelihood ratios almost nobody is
# convinced by any number of generic hits. With the felt ratios
# the share jumps from a few per cent to most users within a
# handful of statements: an avalanche made of misjudged base
# rates, not of evidence.Users who update with the true ratios are almost never convinced, however many generic statements they hear. Users who update by feel show the classic S-shape: 0.0408 after 3 statements, 0.5263 after 6, 0.9261 after 10. This is the “phase-transition collapse” of the outline, but it is built from misjudged base rates and forgotten misses, not from evidence.
Hypothesis · not established
The author’s interpretation (not yet tested): most of the experience of “being read correctly” in reading services can be explained by generic statements, misjudged base rates and selective recall, whatever the validity of the reading method. What would show this wrong: if, in a blinded matching test like that of Chapter 8, users pick out the retrodictive statements written for them at a rate significantly above one in three, the statements carry information beyond the generic.
Summary
What a retrodictive statement is worth depends on its base rate. Generic statements are almost no evidence but are felt as evidence; a “trough year” that is a shared low is far less specific than it looks. In this chapter’s model the so-called trust avalanche comes entirely from misjudged base rates and forgotten misses.
References
Fan, Y. (2026). Retrodictive Belief Locking, Sequential Pain-Point Agitation and Markovian Upsell Automata: Bayesian Trust Avalanches, Sunk-Cost Commitment Ratchets and Cross-Domain Transition Matrices [回溯信念锁定、序贯痛点唤醒与马尔可夫升单自动机] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090186 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).