5D Library › Polypharmacy Supplement Interactions, Chronotherapy Dosing Windows and Cytochrome Enzyme Competition · 中文

Chapter 1. Competition at a Saturable Site

One equation, and the only thing it says

Everything in this book descends from a single relation written down in 1913. Michaelis and Menten described the rate of an enzyme-catalysed reaction as rising with the amount of substrate and levelling off, with one constant setting the substrate level at which half the maximum rate is reached (Michaelis and Menten 1913). The same form describes a carrier moving a mineral across a membrane, because a carrier, like an enzyme, has a finite number of binding sites.

A competitor that binds the same site does not lower the maximum rate, because at high enough substrate the competitor is displaced. What it does is make the site behave as though its affinity were worse, by a factor of one plus the ratio of the competitor’s concentration to its own inhibition constant. Segel’s treatment sets out that result and the several other patterns a competitor can produce (Segel 1975).

Evidence

Published. Michaelis and Menten’s 1913 paper gives the saturating rate equation and the constant that bears their names (Michaelis and Menten 1913). Segel’s text derives competitive, uncompetitive and non-competitive inhibition and the diagnostic differences between them (Segel 1975).

That one factor is the whole mechanism, and its consequence is not obvious until it is computed.

Calculation

# Chapter 1. p01: What competitive inhibition does to a rate. For a
# single site obeying the Michaelis equation the rate is Vmax times S
# over Km plus S. A competitor that binds the same site does not change
# Vmax; it multiplies the apparent Km by one plus the ratio of the
# competitor's concentration to its own inhibition constant. The table
# shows what that costs at several ratios and at several substrate
# levels relative to Km, which is the whole of the arithmetic that the
# rest of this book applies to transporters and liver enzymes.
RATIOS = (0.0, 0.5, 1.0, 2.0, 5.0, 10.0, 20.0)
SLEVELS = (0.1, 0.5, 1.0, 5.0)        # substrate as a multiple of Km

def velocity(s_over_km, ratio):
    # Vmax = 1, Km = 1, so s is already s_over_km
    return s_over_km / ((1.0 + ratio) + s_over_km)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   relative rate, competitor ratio by substrate level")
    print("   ratio " + "".join("{:>10.1f}".format(s) for s in SLEVELS))
    for r in RATIOS:
        print("   {:<6.1f}".format(r)
              + "".join("{:>10.4f}".format(velocity(s, r) / velocity(s, 0.0))
                        for s in SLEVELS))
    print("   a competitor at its own inhibition constant halves the")
    print("   apparent affinity, and at a substrate level of 0.1 times Km")
    print("   that costs {:.4f} of the rate"
          .format(1.0 - velocity(0.1, 1.0) / velocity(0.1, 0.0)))
    print("   at a substrate level of 5.0 times Km the same competitor")
    print("   costs only {:.4f}"
          .format(1.0 - velocity(5.0, 1.0) / velocity(5.0, 0.0)))
    print("   ratio of those two losses: {:.2f}"
          .format((1.0 - velocity(0.1, 1.0) / velocity(0.1, 0.0))
                  / (1.0 - velocity(5.0, 1.0) / velocity(5.0, 0.0))))
    print("   so a saturable site is vulnerable exactly where the dose is")
    print("   small, which is the case for every trace mineral")
    print("   competitor ratio needed to halve the rate:")
    print("   substrate level   ratio")
    for s in SLEVELS:
        lo, hi = 0.0, 1000.0
        for _ in range(60):
            mid = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
            if velocity(s, mid) / velocity(s, 0.0) > 0.5:
                lo = mid
            else:
                hi = mid
        print("   {:<18.1f}{:.4f}".format(s, 0.5 * (lo + hi)))
#    relative rate, competitor ratio by substrate level
#    ratio        0.1       0.5       1.0       5.0
#    0.0       1.0000    1.0000    1.0000    1.0000
#    0.5       0.6875    0.7500    0.8000    0.9231
#    1.0       0.5238    0.6000    0.6667    0.8571
#    2.0       0.3548    0.4286    0.5000    0.7500
#    5.0       0.1803    0.2308    0.2857    0.5455
#    10.0      0.0991    0.1304    0.1667    0.3750
#    20.0      0.0521    0.0698    0.0909    0.2308
#    a competitor at its own inhibition constant halves the
#    apparent affinity, and at a substrate level of 0.1 times Km
#    that costs 0.4762 of the rate
#    at a substrate level of 5.0 times Km the same competitor
#    costs only 0.1429
#    ratio of those two losses: 3.33
#    so a saturable site is vulnerable exactly where the dose is
#    small, which is the case for every trace mineral
#    competitor ratio needed to halve the rate:
#    substrate level   ratio
#    0.1               1.1000
#    0.5               1.5000
#    1.0               2.0000
#    5.0               6.0000

Read the table across a row rather than down a column. A competitor present at exactly its own inhibition constant leaves 0.5238 of the rate when the substrate sits at a tenth of the affinity constant, but 0.8571 when the substrate sits at five times it. The loss is 0.4762 in the first case and 0.1429 in the second, a ratio of 3.33. The competitor ratio needed to halve the rate rises from 1.1000 at the lowest substrate level to 6.0000 at the highest.

This is the asymmetry that organises the rest of the book. A substance taken in a large dose relative to its carrier’s affinity is nearly immune to competition, and a substance taken in a small dose is nearly defenceless. Minerals that come in hundreds of milligrams are the aggressors; minerals that come in tens are the victims. No intention or marketing claim enters into it.

The relative rate against the competitor ratio, at four substrate levels (p01).

The cupboard as a matrix

Applying that to a real cupboard requires only a list: what each item is, how much of it there is in moles rather than milligrams, and which route it uses.

Calculation

# Chapter 1. p02: The interaction matrix of a common stack. Eleven items
# are each given a dose, a molar mass, the site they pass through and a
# constant in millimoles for that site. Items that share a site compete
# for it: the uptake of one is its Michaelis fraction with the apparent
# affinity multiplied by one plus the summed ratios of every other item
# on the same site. Piperine is not a competitor at the conjugating site
# but an inhibitor of the enzyme that disposes of curcumin, so it is
# entered separately as an enhancement of its partner's surviving
# fraction, saturating at ENH_MAX. Doses and constants are illustrative.
ITEMS = (
    # name, dose mg, molar mass, site, Km mmol, Ki mmol
    ("magnesium",     400.00,  24.305, "divalent",  4.0000, 4.0000),
    ("zinc",           25.00,  65.380, "divalent",  0.1500, 0.1500),
    ("calcium",       500.00,  40.080, "divalent",  5.0000, 5.0000),
    ("iron",           18.00,  55.850, "divalent",  0.0800, 0.0800),
    ("vitamin D3",      0.10, 384.600, "micelle",   0.0004, 0.0004),
    ("vitamin K2",      0.18, 444.700, "micelle",   0.0005, 0.0005),
    ("NAD precursor", 300.00, 255.200, "nrk",       1.0000, 1.0000),
    ("curcumin",      500.00, 368.400, "conjugate", 1.0000, 1.0000),
    ("piperine",       10.00, 285.300, "conjugate", 0.0500, 0.0500),
    ("theanine",      200.00, 174.200, "amino",     1.0000, 1.0000),
    ("caffeine",      100.00, 194.200, "cyp1a2",    0.5000, 0.5000),
)
ENH_MAX, ENH_K = 1.60, 0.020      # piperine on curcumin, saturating
PAIR = ("piperine", "curcumin")

def mmol(dose_mg, molar_mass):
    return dose_mg / molar_mass

def enhancement(together):
    if not together:
        return 1.0
    for name, dose, mm, _, _, _ in ITEMS:
        if name == PAIR[0]:
            s = mmol(dose, mm)
            return 1.0 + ENH_MAX * s / (ENH_K + s)
    return 1.0

def uptake(i, together):
    name, dose, mm, site, km, ki = ITEMS[i]
    s = mmol(dose, mm)
    extra = 0.0
    if together:
        for j, other in enumerate(ITEMS):
            if j != i and other[3] == site:
                extra += mmol(other[1], other[2]) / other[5]
    base = s / (km * (1.0 + extra) + s)
    if name == PAIR[1]:
        base = min(1.0, base * enhancement(together))
    return base

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   item           mmol      site       alone   together  change")
    changes = []
    for i, (name, dose, mm, site, km, ki) in enumerate(ITEMS):
        a, t = uptake(i, False), uptake(i, True)
        changes.append((name, t / a - 1.0))
        print("   {:<15}{:<10.4f}{:<11}{:<8.4f}{:<10.4f}{:+.4f}"
              .format(name, mmol(dose, mm), site, a, t, t / a - 1.0))
    print("   ratio of competitor to its constant, for the four items")
    print("   that share the divalent site (row loses, column causes):")
    div = [i for i, it in enumerate(ITEMS) if it[3] == "divalent"]
    print("   item       " + "".join("{:<11}".format(ITEMS[j][0][:9])
                                     for j in div))
    for i in div:
        row = [0.0 if i == j
               else mmol(ITEMS[j][1], ITEMS[j][2]) / ITEMS[j][5] for j in div]
        print("   {:<11}".format(ITEMS[i][0][:9])
              + "".join("{:<11.3f}".format(v) for v in row))
    hurt = sorted(changes, key=lambda x: x[1])
    print("   worst hit: {} loses {:.4f}".format(hurt[0][0], -hurt[0][1]))
    print("   next: {} loses {:.4f}".format(hurt[1][0], -hurt[1][1]))
    print("   only gainer: {} gains {:.4f}".format(hurt[-1][0], hurt[-1][1]))
    print("   piperine's enhancement factor at this dose: {:.4f}"
          .format(enhancement(True)))
    n_hit = sum(1 for _, c in changes if c < -0.01)
    print("   items losing more than one part in a hundred: {} of {}"
          .format(n_hit, len(ITEMS)))
    print("   items untouched because nothing shares their site: {}"
          .format(sum(1 for _, c in changes if abs(c) < 1e-9)))
    hits = [-c for _, c in changes if c < -0.01]
    print("   mean loss among the items that lose anything: {:.4f}"
          .format(sum(hits) / len(hits)))
#    item           mmol      site       alone   together  change
#    magnesium      16.4575   divalent   0.8045  0.2900    -0.6395
#    zinc           0.3824    divalent   0.7182  0.1797    -0.7498
#    calcium        12.4750   divalent   0.7139  0.1759    -0.7537
#    iron           0.3223    divalent   0.8011  0.2840    -0.6456
#    vitamin D3     0.0003    micelle    0.3939  0.2643    -0.3291
#    vitamin K2     0.0004    micelle    0.4474  0.3291    -0.2643
#    NAD precursor  1.1755    nrk        0.5403  0.5403    +0.0000
#    curcumin       1.3572    conjugate  0.5758  0.8959    +0.5560
#    piperine       0.0351    conjugate  0.4121  0.2292    -0.4438
#    theanine       1.1481    amino      0.5345  0.5345    +0.0000
#    caffeine       0.5149    cyp1a2     0.5074  0.5074    +0.0000
#    ratio of competitor to its constant, for the four items
#    that share the divalent site (row loses, column causes):
#    item       magnesium  zinc       calcium    iron
#    magnesium  0.000      2.549      2.495      4.029
#    zinc       4.114      0.000      2.495      4.029
#    calcium    4.114      2.549      0.000      4.029
#    iron       4.114      2.549      2.495      0.000
#    worst hit: calcium loses 0.7537
#    next: zinc loses 0.7498
#    only gainer: curcumin gains 0.5560
#    piperine's enhancement factor at this dose: 2.0187
#    items losing more than one part in a hundred: 7 of 11
#    items untouched because nothing shares their site: 3
#    mean loss among the items that lose anything: 0.5465

Three things in that output are worth separating. First, most of the cupboard is not interacting with most of the rest. Three items are untouched, because nothing else uses their route; the nicotinamide precursor, theanine and caffeine are in the pile for reasons that have nothing to do with each other. Second, where interaction does happen it is severe: calcium loses 0.7537 and zinc 0.7498, and among the items that lose anything at all the mean loss is 0.5465.

Third, and most instructive, is the matrix of ratios. Magnesium at 400 milligrams is 16.4575 millimoles and calcium at 500 is 12.4750, while zinc at 25 milligrams is 0.3824 and iron at 18 is 0.3223. The bulk minerals outnumber the trace minerals at the shared site by more than thirty times in molar terms, and that is before any affinity constant is considered. The row for iron shows it facing a combined competitor ratio from magnesium, zinc and calcium that no adjustment of its own dose can overcome.

The one gainer is curcumin, which rises 0.5560 because piperine inhibits the enzyme that disposes of it. That is a different mechanism from everything else in the table, and Chapter 3 keeps it separate for that reason: it is the only pair in this cupboard where putting two things together is better than keeping them apart.

Hypothesis · not established

The author’s interpretation (not yet tested): because the molar ratios between bulk and trace minerals at a shared carrier are of order thirty to one, no realistic adjustment of a trace mineral’s dose can restore its absorption in the presence of the bulk ones, and separation in time is the only effective remedy. What would show it wrong: if, in a crossover study, raising the iron dose by a factor of three in the presence of a standard calcium and magnesium dose restored absorbed iron to what a separated schedule achieves, dose adjustment would be an adequate substitute for separation.

Summary

A competitor multiplies the apparent affinity of a shared site by one plus its own relative concentration, which costs 0.4762 of the rate where the substrate is a tenth of the affinity constant and only 0.1429 where it is five times that constant, a ratio of 3.33. Applied to a cupboard of eleven items, seven lose more than one part in a hundred, calcium worst at 0.7537, and three are untouched. Chapter 2 takes the most crowded site and looks at it closely.

References

Michaelis, Leonor, and Maud L. Menten. 1913. “Die Kinetik Der Invertinwirkung.” Biochemische Zeitschrift 49: 333 to 369.
Segel, Irwin H. 1975. Enzyme Kinetics: Behavior and Analysis of Rapid Equilibrium and Steady-State Enzyme Systems. Wiley.

Fan, Y. (2026). Polypharmacy Supplement Interactions, Chronotherapy Dosing Windows and Cytochrome Enzyme Competition: Michaelis-Menten Inhibition Matrices, Chelation Absorption Losses and Circadian Receptor Sensitivity [复合补剂相互作用、时间疗法给药窗口与代谢酶竞争] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090250 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).