5D Library › 说服文案代数、损失框架不对称性与结账微界面工程 · English
第三章 结账微界面的摩擦方程
希克-海曼定律:对数,不是指数
希克与海曼发现,在多个等可能选项中作出选择的反应时间随选项数的对数线性增长: (Hick 1952; Hyman 1953)。程序取示意参数 秒、 秒:1 个选项 0.350 秒,15 个选项 0.800 秒。选项翻倍只增加一个常数时间。所以「每多一个选项,流失呈指数级上升」的说法不来自希克-海曼定律;结账的损失来自另一个机制:每一个环节都有人离开。
独立风险率模型
设每个必填字段使到达它的人中有 的比例离开,每一次换页使 的比例离开,则完成率为
推导
# Chapter 3. p05: Fields, steps and the arithmetic of checkout loss.
# Hick-Hyman law: choice time T = a + b log2(n + 1) grows with the log of
# the number of options n, not exponentially. Checkout loss is modelled
# as independent hazards: each required field loses a share h of those
# who reach it; each page transition loses a share d. Completion is the
# product of survivals: (1 - h)^fields x (1 - d)^(pages - 1).
from math import log2
def hick(n, a=0.2, b=0.15):
return a + b * log2(n + 1)
def completion(fields, pages, h=0.02, d=0.08):
return (1 - h) ** fields * (1 - d) ** (pages - 1)
if __name__ == "__main__":
print(" options n choice time (s)")
for n in (1, 3, 7, 15):
print(" {:9d} {:.3f}".format(n, hick(n)))
print("\n fields pages completion (h = 0.02 per field,"
" d = 0.08 per page)")
base = completion(12, 3)
for f, p in ((12, 3), (12, 1), (8, 3), (8, 1), (5, 1), (3, 1)):
c = completion(f, p)
print(" {:6d} {:5d} {:10.4f} {:+.1%}".format(
f, p, c, c / base - 1))
print("\n each field removed multiplies completion by {:.4f};".format(
1 / 0.98))
print(" each page removed by {:.4f}.".format(1 / 0.92))
# options n choice time (s)
# 1 0.350
# 3 0.500
# 7 0.650
# 15 0.800
#
# fields pages completion (h = 0.02 per field, d = 0.08 per page)
# 12 3 0.6642 +0.0%
# 12 1 0.7847 +18.1%
# 8 3 0.7201 +8.4%
# 8 1 0.8508 +28.1%
# 5 1 0.9039 +36.1%
# 3 1 0.9412 +41.7%
#
# each field removed multiplies completion by 1.0204;
# each page removed by 1.0870.取示意参数 、:12 个字段、3 页的完成率为 0.6642;同样 12 个字段压到 1 页,为 0.7847(+18.1%);压到 1 页 3 个字段,为 0.9412(+41.7%)。每去掉一个字段,完成率乘以 1.0204;每去掉一页,乘以 1.0870。这是几何级数的乘法,效果可观,但不是「指数级暴增」。
与分心赛跑
另一种写法把结账看成与分心的赛跑:访客每秒离开的风险率因人而异(服从伽马分布,平均每 150 秒一次),结账需要的时间由字段、页面与支付方式的数量决定。
推导
# Chapter 3. p06: Checkout as a race against distraction.
# Visitors differ in patience: the hazard of leaving per second is
# lam ~ Gamma(shape 2, mean 1/150 s). Checkout time T = 6 s per field
# + 7 s per page (load and re-orientation) + 4 s per payment choice
# considered. Completion for one visitor is exp(-lam T); averaged over
# the gamma it is (1 + T / (2 x 150))^-2 (closed form). We check by
# simulation and compare layouts.
import random
from math import exp
def avg_completion(T, shape=2.0, mean=150.0):
return (1 + T * (1 / mean) / shape) ** (-shape)
def layout_time(fields, pages, pay_options):
return 6 * fields + 7 * pages + 4 * pay_options
if __name__ == "__main__":
rng = random.Random(77006)
layouts = (("3 pages, 12 fields, 6 ways to pay", 12, 3, 6),
("1 page, 12 fields, 6 ways to pay", 12, 1, 6),
("1 page, 5 fields, 3 ways to pay", 5, 1, 3),
("1 modal, 3 fields, 2 ways to pay", 3, 1, 2))
base = None
for name, f, p, k in layouts:
T = layout_time(f, p, k)
exact = avg_completion(T)
sim = sum(exp(-rng.gammavariate(2.0, 1 / 300) * T)
for _ in range(100000)) / 100000
base = base or exact
print(" {:35s} T {:3d} s {:.4f} (sim {:.4f}) {:+.1%}".format(
name, T, exact, sim, exact / base - 1))
print("\n marginal value of one field at T = 40 s: {:.4f}".format(
avg_completion(34) - avg_completion(40)))
print(" marginal value of one field at T = 120 s: {:.4f}".format(
avg_completion(114) - avg_completion(120)))
# 3 pages, 12 fields, 6 ways to pay T 117 s 0.5176 (sim 0.5195) +0.0%
# 1 page, 12 fields, 6 ways to pay T 103 s 0.5542 (sim 0.5536) +7.1%
# 1 page, 5 fields, 3 ways to pay T 49 s 0.7389 (sim 0.7383) +42.8%
# 1 modal, 3 fields, 2 ways to pay T 33 s 0.8116 (sim 0.8114) +56.8%
#
# marginal value of one field at T = 40 s: 0.0282
# marginal value of one field at T = 120 s: 0.0149三页、12 个字段、6 种支付方式需要 117 秒,平均完成率 0.5176;同样内容放在一页,103 秒,0.5542(+7.1%);一页 5 个字段、3 种支付方式,49 秒,0.7389(+42.8%);一个弹窗、3 个字段、2 种支付方式,33 秒,0.8116(+56.8%)。模拟值与闭式解在小数点后两位一致。收益是递减的:在 40 秒附近每减少一个字段提高 0.0282,在 120 秒附近只提高 0.0149。
注
哪些字段不能删。 支付所需的信息、法律要求的同意与退款条款的告知不能为了转化而省略或隐藏;预先勾选的附加费用与难以找到的取消入口属于有记录的「暗模式」(Mathur et al. 2019)。本章的模型只处理真正非必要的摩擦。
小结
希克-海曼定律是对数关系。结账损失是各环节存活率的乘积:示意参数下,从三页 12 个字段压到一个弹窗 3 个字段,完成率提高四到六成;越靠近短流程,每个字段的边际价值越大。
参考文献
Fan, Y. (2026). Persuasive Copywriting Algebra, Loss-Framing Asymmetry and Checkout Micro-Architecture: Prospect-Theory Valuation Ratios, Numerical Specificity Credibility and Cognitive-Fluency Conversion Bounds [说服文案代数、损失框架不对称性与结账微界面工程] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090205 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).