5D Library › Persuasive Copywriting Algebra, Loss-Framing Asymmetry and Checkout Micro-Architecture · 中文

Chapter 2. Signalling Models of Price Endings and Numerical Precision

The left-digit effect

Thomas and Morwitz showed that buyers’ judgements of price weigh the leftmost digit heavily: a one-cent cut that changes the leftmost digit is felt as much larger than the same cut changing a later digit (Thomas and Morwitz 2005). Lacetera, Pope and Sydnor estimated in the used-car market that buyers pay only partial attention to the digits of an odometer after the first, with an inattention parameter of about 0.3 (Lacetera et al. 2012). The program writes the mechanism as: perceived price = the round number the first digit stands for + (1−θ)(1-\theta) × the rest.

Calculation

# Chapter 2. p03: The left-digit effect as partial inattention.
# A buyer reads the leading digits fully and the rest with weight
# (1 - theta): for a price with d digits, perceived price
#   P~ = L + (1 - theta) (P - L),  L = P rounded down to its first digit.
# Lacetera, Pope and Sydnor (2012) estimated theta about 0.3 for car
# odometers. We compare just-below and round prices, then ask how much
# conversion a just-below price buys with the WTP model of p02.
from math import log, erf, sqrt

def lead(p):
    s = str(int(p))
    return int(s[0]) * 10 ** (len(s) - 1)

def perceived(p, theta):
    L = lead(p)
    return L + (1 - theta) * (p - L)

def buy_share(price, med=30.0, sd=1.0):
    return 0.5 * (1 - erf((log(price) - log(med)) / sd / sqrt(2)))

if __name__ == "__main__":
    pairs = ((49, 50), (298, 300), (9800, 10000), (29800, 30000))
    for theta in (0.0, 0.3):
        print("   theta = {:.1f}".format(theta))
        for a, b in pairs:
            pa, pb = perceived(a, theta), perceived(b, theta)
            print("     RM {:>6,} feels like {:9.1f}; RM {:>6,} like {:9.1f};"
                  .format(a, pa, b, pb))
            print("       gap {:.1%} of the round price (nominal {:.1%})"
                  .format((pb - pa) / b, (b - a) / b))
    s49 = buy_share(perceived(49, 0.3))
    s50 = buy_share(perceived(50, 0.3))
    print("\n   share buying, theta 0.3: RM 49 {:.4f} vs RM 50 {:.4f}"
          " ({:+.1%})".format(s49, s50, s49 / s50 - 1))
    print("   revenue per visitor: RM 49 {:.2f} vs RM 50 {:.2f}".format(
        49 * s49, 50 * s50))
#    theta = 0.0
#      RM     49 feels like      49.0; RM     50 like      50.0;
#        gap 2.0% of the round price (nominal 2.0%)
#      RM    298 feels like     298.0; RM    300 like     300.0;
#        gap 0.7% of the round price (nominal 0.7%)
#      RM  9,800 feels like    9800.0; RM 10,000 like   10000.0;
#        gap 2.0% of the round price (nominal 2.0%)
#      RM 29,800 feels like   29800.0; RM 30,000 like   30000.0;
#        gap 0.7% of the round price (nominal 0.7%)
#    theta = 0.3
#      RM     49 feels like      46.3; RM     50 like      50.0;
#        gap 7.4% of the round price (nominal 2.0%)
#      RM    298 feels like     268.6; RM    300 like     300.0;
#        gap 10.5% of the round price (nominal 0.7%)
#      RM  9,800 feels like    9560.0; RM 10,000 like   10000.0;
#        gap 4.4% of the round price (nominal 2.0%)
#      RM 29,800 feels like   26860.0; RM 30,000 like   30000.0;
#        gap 10.5% of the round price (nominal 0.7%)
#
#    share buying, theta 0.3: RM 49 0.3322 vs RM 50 0.3047 (+9.0%)
#    revenue per visitor: RM 49 16.28 vs RM 50 15.24

With θ=0\theta = 0 the perceived gap between RM 49 and RM 50 is the nominal 2.0%. With θ=0.3\theta = 0.3, RM 49 is perceived as 46.3 and the perceived gap grows to 7.4%; RM 298 is perceived as 268.6, a gap of 10.5% (nominally 0.7%); RM 9,800 is perceived as 9560.0. In the valuation model of Chapter 1, the share buying at RM 49 is 0.3322 and at RM 50 0.3047 (+9.0%), revenue per visitor RM 16.28 and RM 15.24.

Round prices and authority

The left-digit effect explains why impulse purchases at the front end so often end in 49 or 298. Conversely, round prices feel “right”: Wadhwa and Zhang found that for purchases evaluated by feeling, round prices raise product evaluations, while for purchases evaluated by calculation, non-round prices do better (Wadhwa and Zhang 2015). So writing a round RM 10,000 for a high-ticket licence or advisory service and a just-below RM 49 for an impulse purchase can both be right: they address different modes of evaluation. Note that RM 9,800 is not a round price; it is still a price “discounted below the first digit”.

The credibility of precise numbers

Is “error under 12 seconds” more credible than “extremely accurate”? Experiments find that precise numbers are more readily taken as fact and shift readers’ anchors (Janiszewski and Uy 2008). The program uses a simple Bayesian model to show where the credibility comes from: a speaker may be honest or may exaggerate; an honest speaker gives a precise figure with probability qhq_h, an exaggerating one with probability qpq_p.

Calculation

# Chapter 2. p04: When does a precise number earn trust?
# A claim comes from an honest source (prior pi) or a puffing one.
# Honest sources state precise figures with probability qh, puffers with
# qp (precision is costlier to fake: a precise figure can be checked).
# Seeing a precise figure, P(honest | precise) = pi qh / (pi qh +
# (1 - pi) qp). If a checked false figure is caught with probability c,
# puffers who fear checking lower qp; the trust gain then grows.
def posterior(pi, qh, qp):
    return pi * qh / (pi * qh + (1 - pi) * qp)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    pi = 0.5
    print("   prior 0.50   qh    qp    P(honest|precise)  P(honest|vague)")
    for qh, qp in ((0.6, 0.6), (0.6, 0.4), (0.7, 0.3), (0.8, 0.1)):
        print("              {:.1f}   {:.1f}   {:17.3f}  {:15.3f}".format(
            qh, qp, posterior(pi, qh, qp), posterior(pi, 1 - qh, 1 - qp)))
    print("\n   puffers' precision falls as checking risk c rises:"
          " qp = 0.6 (1 - c)")
    for c in (0.0, 0.25, 0.5, 0.75):
        qp = 0.6 * (1 - c)
        print("     c = {:.2f}: qp {:.2f}, P(honest|precise) {:.3f}".format(
            c, qp, posterior(pi, 0.6, qp)))
    print("\n   with no checking (c = 0) precision carries no information;")
    print("   its value comes entirely from the chance of being checked.")
#    prior 0.50   qh    qp    P(honest|precise)  P(honest|vague)
#               0.6   0.6               0.500            0.500
#               0.6   0.4               0.600            0.400
#               0.7   0.3               0.700            0.300
#               0.8   0.1               0.889            0.182
#
#    puffers' precision falls as checking risk c rises: qp = 0.6 (1 - c)
#      c = 0.00: qp 0.60, P(honest|precise) 0.500
#      c = 0.25: qp 0.45, P(honest|precise) 0.571
#      c = 0.50: qp 0.30, P(honest|precise) 0.667
#      c = 0.75: qp 0.15, P(honest|precise) 0.800
#
#    with no checking (c = 0) precision carries no information;
#    its value comes entirely from the chance of being checked.

If both kinds give precise figures with the same probability (0.6 each), the posterior after seeing a precise figure equals the prior, 0.500: precision in itself carries no information. Precision becomes informative only when exaggerators give precise figures less often for fear of being checked: with a checking probability of 0.50 the posterior rises to 0.667; with 0.8 for the honest and 0.1 for exaggerators it is 0.889. The persuasiveness of a precise number comes entirely from its being checkable, which also means that a precise figure on the page must be a true figure that survives checking; otherwise it is exactly the sentence most easily exposed.

Hypothesis · not established

The author’s hypothesis (not yet tested): on the sales page of a reading report, replacing “extremely accurate” with a checkable precise statement (the calculation error of the program, say) raises paid conversion mainly among visitors who have already read the free part. What would show it wrong: if, stratifying by whether visitors finished the free part, the lift does not differ significantly between the two strata, the hypothesis fails.

Summary

The effect of just-below prices can be computed from an inattention parameter: with θ=0.3\theta = 0.3 the perceived gap between RM 49 and RM 50 is more than three times the nominal one. Round prices suit high-ticket purchases evaluated by feeling. The credibility of precise numbers comes from their being checkable; without checking there is no information.

References

Janiszewski, Chris, and Dan Uy. 2008. “Precision of the Anchor Influences the Amount of Adjustment.” Psychological Science 19 (2): 121–27.
Lacetera, Nicola, Devin G. Pope, and Justin R. Sydnor. 2012. “Heuristic Thinking and Limited Attention in the Car Market.” American Economic Review 102 (5): 2206–36.
Thomas, Manoj, and Vicki Morwitz. 2005. “Penny Wise and Pound Foolish: The Left-Digit Effect in Price Cognition.” Journal of Consumer Research 32 (1): 54–64.
Wadhwa, Monica, and Kuangjie Zhang. 2015. “This Number Just Feels Right: The Impact of Roundedness of Price Numbers on Product Evaluations.” Journal of Consumer Research 41 (5): 1172–85.

Fan, Y. (2026). Persuasive Copywriting Algebra, Loss-Framing Asymmetry and Checkout Micro-Architecture: Prospect-Theory Valuation Ratios, Numerical Specificity Credibility and Cognitive-Fluency Conversion Bounds [说服文案代数、损失框架不对称性与结账微界面工程] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090205 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).