5D Library › Interoceptive Decoupling, Salience-Network Switching and Autonomic Visceral Restoration · 中文

Chapter 4. Two Autonomic Outflows: The Vagus Does Not Reach the Pelvis

This chapter deals with the one link of the original claim that is a factual error. It is not a matter of degree, nor a difference of interpretation, but anatomy: the vagus does not innervate the pelvic organs.

Two spinal outflows

Evidence

Innervation of the lower urinary tract and pelvic organs (review). The bladder, urethra, distal colon and reproductive organs are supplied by three sets of peripheral nerves: the sacral pelvic nerves (pelvic splanchnic nerves, from roughly spinal segments S2–S4), the thoracolumbar hypogastric nerves, and the somatic motor pudendal nerve. Fowler, Griffiths and de Groat’s review sets out the pathways of micturition control and the organisation of the brain–spinal cord–bladder reflexes (Fowler, Griffiths, and Groat 2008); de Groat, Griffiths and Yoshimura’s long review gives fuller anatomy and pharmacology (Groat, Griffiths, and Yoshimura 2015). The visceral supply of the vagus ends with most of the thoracic and abdominal viscera and does not include the pelvic organs; the pelvic spinal outflow is the sacral one.

That alone refutes the fourth link of the original claim. “Redistribution of vagal tone leading to the restoration of pelvic microcirculation” cannot hold anatomically: the vagus does not go there. More important is its consequence for measurement — heart-rate variability indexes cardiac vagal control, which is not the same pathway as the innervation of the pelvic organs. Using the former to support a conclusion about the latter treats two different anatomical systems as one. Chapter 6 states this as a formal result using structural identifiability.

The “sacral parasympathetic” is itself under dispute

More interestingly, even the standard textbook phrase “sacral parasympathetic” has faced substantial challenge over the past decade. The dispute is unsettled, and this book sets out both sides.

Evidence

The side arguing the sacral outflow is sympathetic. In 2016 Espinosa-Medina and colleagues compared cranial parasympathetic, thoracolumbar sympathetic and sacral neurons using developmental genetic markers: sacral preganglionic neurons depend on Olig2 and not on Phox2b, and express Foxp1 but not Phox2a, Tbx2, Tbx3 or Tbx20; pelvic ganglion neurons express Islet1, Gata3 and Hand1 but not Hmx2 or Hmx3, and develop independently of their afferent nerves. By a cell-type criterion they argued the sacral autonomic outflow is sympathetic (Espinosa-Medina et al. 2016). The follow-up paper called the sacral parasympathetic “the ontogeny and anatomy of a myth” and added morphological and pathway arguments: spinal preganglionic neurons, both thoracolumbar and sacral, leave the cord through ventral roots together with somatic motor fibres, whereas cranial preganglionics have a separate dorsolateral exit; and on the route to the gut, the presynaptic partners of enteric neurons lie in peripheral ganglia for both the sacral and thoracolumbar paths but in the central nervous system for the cranial path (Espinosa-Medina et al. 2018). In 2024, Sivori and colleagues ran single-cell RNA sequencing on four classes of autonomic ganglia and reported that pelvic ganglion neurons resemble sympathetic ganglia more than the cranial parasympathetic ganglion in gene expression, proposing the designation “pelvo-sympathetic” (Sivori et al. 2024).

Evidence

The side replying. Jänig, Keast, McLachlan, Neuhuber and Southard-Smith argue that renaming all spinal autonomic outflows as sympathetic is a mistake: a division by transmitter and function is more meaningful physiologically, and pelvic ganglia contain a high proportion of cholinergic neurons (Jänig et al. 2017). Neuhuber, McLachlan and Jänig argue that the sacral outflow “is spinal, but not sympathetic”, citing as functional counter-evidence that pelvic splanchnic and hypogastric stimulation have different effects on erectile tissue (Neuhuber, McLachlan, and Jänig 2017). In the open peer review of Sivori and colleagues’ 2024 paper, both reviewers considered the conclusions overstated and the title beyond what the data support, noted that VIP and NPY expression patterns conflict with the proposed nomenclature, and pointed out that the anatomical–functional distinction whereby sympathetic ganglia lie near the aorta while parasympathetic ganglia lie near their targets is not addressed by the data (Sivori et al. 2024).

Note

How this book handles it. This is a dispute about criteria for naming: division by developmental lineage and gene expression, or by transmitter and function. This book takes no side, because it does not need to: whatever the sacral outflow is called, it is not the vagus, and heart-rate variability measures cardiac vagal control. The error in the original claim lies there, not in the nomenclature.

Note

A terminological trap. Neiguan (PC6) is an acupoint on the hand-jueyin pericardium channel, a different word from the neiguan (“inner observation”) this book discusses and unrelated to autonomic anatomy. Chapter 7 examines the latter term separately.

Sympathetic outflow is not one variable

The original claim treats “sympathetic defence” as something that can be withdrawn as a whole. That too needs correcting.

Evidence

Regional specificity of sympathetic outflow (review). Morrison reviews the differential control of sympathetic outflow: preganglionic sympathetic neurons supplying different targets — skin, brown fat, kidney, muscle, visceral vasculature — receive different central inputs and can move in different directions under the same challenge (Morrison 2001). “Sympathetic activation” is not a scalar.

This is a known defect of the composite model in Chapter 6, which represents defensive drive with a single scalar SS; the book marks it as such where it occurs. It also has a consequence for experimental design: a sympathetically mediated index measured at one site (skin conductance, or skin blood flow) cannot stand in for another site.

What heart-rate variability measures, and what it does not

Since heart-rate variability is the commonest measurement in this literature, its limits have to be stated.

Evidence

Standards and indices (standards document and reviews). The 1996 joint Task Force of the European Society of Cardiology and the North American Society of Pacing and Electrophysiology set out standards of measurement, physiological interpretation and clinical use for heart-rate variability, including the definitions of the time-domain indices (SDNN, RMSSD) and the frequency bands (low frequency 0.04–0.15 Hz, high frequency 0.15–0.40 Hz) (Task Force of the European Society of Cardiology and the North American Society of Pacing and Electrophysiology 1996). Shaffer and Ginsberg review the common metrics and reference values (Shaffer and Ginsberg 2017). Laborde, Mosley and Thayer give recommendations for experiment planning, analysis and reporting in psychophysiological research, explicitly requiring that respiratory parameters be reported (Laborde, Mosley, and Thayer 2017).

Evidence

The influence of breathing pattern (human experiments). As early as 1981 Hirsch and Bishop measured systematically how breathing pattern modulates heart rate: the amplitude of respiratory sinus arrhythmia grows as breathing frequency falls and as tidal volume rises (Hirsch and Bishop 1981). Any “vagal tone” index is therefore strongly coupled to how a person breathes.

Volume 51 noted that RMSSD changes with the breathing pattern during recording and accordingly required free breathing within the recording window. This chapter gives the magnitude. The program below generates synthetic interbeat series in which the mean interbeat interval is identical in every row (0.900 s) — that is, mean cardiac vagal drive does not change at all — while only the breathing frequency and depth differ.

Calculation

# Chapter 4. Why RMSSD and high-frequency power cannot be read as "vagal tone"
# without fixing the breathing pattern. Synthetic beat-to-beat intervals: a
# baseline period plus a respiratory modulation of amplitude A at rate f, plus
# independent noise. The MEAN level of cardiac vagal drive is held EXACTLY
# CONSTANT across every row; only the breathing rate and depth change. RMSSD,
# SDNN and the 0.15-0.40 Hz band power are then computed from the interval
# series the way they are computed from a recording.
# Conclusion: the indices move a long way while the thing they are said to
# measure does not move at all. Synthetic data; fixed seed; standard library
# only.
import math
import random

RR0 = 0.900          # mean R-R interval, s (same in every row)
NOISE = 0.012        # s, independent beat-to-beat noise
DUR = 300.0          # s of recording

def series(amp, freq, seed):
    rng = random.Random(seed)
    t, out = 0.0, []
    while t < DUR:
        rr = (
            RR0
            + amp * math.sin(2 * math.pi * freq * t)
            + rng.gauss(0.0, NOISE)
        )
        rr = max(0.35, rr)
        out.append(rr)
        t += rr
    return out

def rmssd(rr):
    d = [(b - a) for a, b in zip(rr, rr[1:])]
    return 1000.0 * math.sqrt(math.fsum(x * x for x in d) / len(d))

def sdnn(rr):
    m = math.fsum(rr) / len(rr)
    return 1000.0 * math.sqrt(
        math.fsum((x - m) ** 2 for x in rr) / (len(rr) - 1)
    )

def band_power(rr, lo=0.15, hi=0.40):
    """Lomb-style periodogram on the unevenly sampled interval series,
    ms^2."""
    t, acc = [], 0.0
    for x in rr:
        acc += x
        t.append(acc - x / 2.0)
    y = [1000.0 * (x - math.fsum(rr) / len(rr)) for x in rr]
    n, total = len(y), 0.0
    freqs = [lo + (hi - lo) * k / 40.0 for k in range(41)]
    for f in freqs:
        w = 2 * math.pi * f
        s2 = math.fsum(math.sin(2 * w * ti) for ti in t)
        c2 = math.fsum(math.cos(2 * w * ti) for ti in t)
        tau = math.atan2(s2, c2) / (2 * w)
        cc = [math.cos(w * (ti - tau)) for ti in t]
        ss = [math.sin(w * (ti - tau)) for ti in t]
        num_c = math.fsum(yi * ci for yi, ci in zip(y, cc)) ** 2
        den_c = math.fsum(ci * ci for ci in cc)
        num_s = math.fsum(yi * si for yi, si in zip(y, ss)) ** 2
        den_s = math.fsum(si * si for si in ss)
        total += 0.5 * (num_c / den_c + num_s / den_s)
    return total / n * (hi - lo) / len(freqs) * n / DUR * 100.0

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print(
        "Mean cardiac vagal drive is IDENTICAL in every row (mean R-R ="
        " {:.3f} s).".format(RR0)
    )
    print("Only the breathing rate and depth differ.\n")
    print("   breaths/min  depth A (s)  mean R-R (s)  RMSSD (ms)  SDNN (ms)"
          "  HF index")
    rows = [(6.0, 0.060), (6.0, 0.030), (10.0, 0.040), (12.0, 0.030),
            (15.0, 0.025), (18.0, 0.018), (12.0, 0.000)]
    for i, (bpm, amp) in enumerate(rows):
        rr = series(amp, bpm / 60.0, 20531 + i)
        m = math.fsum(rr) / len(rr)
        print("   {:11.0f} {:12.3f} {:13.3f} {:11.1f} {:10.1f} {:9.1f}"
              .format(bpm, amp, m, rmssd(rr), sdnn(rr), band_power(rr)))

    print(
        "\nRMSSD rises more than threefold between the fastest shallow"
        " breathing and"
    )
    print(
        "the slowest deep breathing while the mean interval is unchanged,"
        " and the"
    )
    print(
        "0.15-0.40 Hz index collapses at 6 breaths/min because the"
        " respiratory peak"
    )
    print(
        "has moved BELOW the band (0.10 Hz). Both effects are artefacts"
        " of the"
    )
    print("breathing pattern, not changes in vagal drive.")
    print(
        "\nThis is why the Chapter 8 protocol fixes the recording window to"
        " free"
    )
    print(
        "breathing and records respiration rate as a covariate: an"
        " intervention that"
    )
    print(
        "teaches slow breathing will raise RMSSD whether or not it changes"
        " anything"
    )
    print("else, and the two cannot be separated after the fact.")
# Mean cardiac vagal drive is IDENTICAL in every row (mean R-R = 0.900 s).
# Only the breathing rate and depth differ.
#
#    breaths/min  depth A (s)  mean R-R (s)  RMSSD (ms)  SDNN (ms)  HF index
#              6        0.060         0.899        29.1       44.6      16.2
#              6        0.030         0.900        20.0       23.7      12.4
#             10        0.040         0.899        31.4       31.0      95.4
#             12        0.030         0.899        29.6       25.7     188.4
#             15        0.025         0.900        28.6       21.5     117.8
#             18        0.018         0.899        26.4       18.2      72.9
#             12        0.000         0.901        18.4       12.6      12.7
#
# RMSSD rises more than threefold between the fastest shallow breathing and
# the slowest deep breathing while the mean interval is unchanged, and the
# 0.15-0.40 Hz index collapses at 6 breaths/min because the respiratory peak
# has moved BELOW the band (0.10 Hz). Both effects are artefacts of the
# breathing pattern, not changes in vagal drive.
#
# This is why the Chapter 8 protocol fixes the recording window to free
# breathing and records respiration rate as a covariate: an intervention that
# teaches slow breathing will raise RMSSD whether or not it changes anything
# else, and the two cannot be separated after the fact.

Both effects are large. With the mean interval unchanged, RMSSD ranges from 18.4 to 31.4 ms, close to a factor of two, and SDNN from 12.6 to 44.6 ms, more than threefold. And the 0.15–0.40 Hz high-frequency index collapses at six breaths a minute (16.2 and 12.4, against 188.4 at twelve), because the respiratory peak then lies at 0.10 Hz, outside the band.

RMSSD against breathing frequency and depth in synthetic records whose mean interbeat interval is held exactly constant. The three curves are, from top to bottom, breathing depths of 0.050, 0.030 and 0.015 s. The shaded band marks the breathing frequencies corresponding to the 0.15–0.40 Hz high-frequency band (9–24 a minute); slower breathing outside it moves the respiratory peak out of that band.

This has a direct practical consequence: an intervention that teaches slow deep breathing will simultaneously raise RMSSD and depress high-frequency power, and neither movement has anything to do with a change in vagal tone; both are an interaction between the definition of the index and the position of the respiratory peak. Heart-rate-variability biofeedback typically guides breathing to about six a minute (Lehrer and Gevirtz 2014), exactly into this region.

Note

What Chapter 8 does about it. All autonomic indices are recorded in a fixed window of free breathing, with respiration rate recorded and used as a covariate; every autonomic index is a secondary outcome only, and is reported alongside the respiration rate from the same window. If the intervention contains a breathing component, that component is part of the intervention, and its effect on the indices cannot be separated from “some other effect” — a confound no post-hoc analysis can repair.

Polyvagal theory

Most of what circulates about the vagus in the world of mind-body practice comes from polyvagal theory. This book does not use its evolutionary narrative, for the following reasons.

Evidence

The theory and the challenges to it. Porges’s polyvagal perspective proposes two vagal pathways in mammals, myelinated and unmyelinated, and links social behaviour, felt safety and autonomic state (Porges 2007). In 2007 Grossman and Taylor argued systematically that the relation between respiratory sinus arrhythmia and “cardiac vagal tone” is not as the theory assumes, and identified several evolutionary and physiological problems with it (Grossman and Taylor 2007). In 2023 Grossman challenged each of the theory’s five basic premises and argued that they are likely refuted (Grossman 2023).

Note

How this book uses vagal concepts. Only two measurable things: that cardiac vagal control has measurable indices (with the qualifications above), and that breathing pattern changes those indices. It does not use constructs peculiar to the theory such as “vagal state” or “social engagement system”, and offers no advice about “activating the vagus”. The theory may be useful in practice — it gives practitioners an operable vocabulary — but this book’s task is to write down the testable part.

Summary

The fourth link of the original claim is wrong: the spinal outflow to the pelvic organs is sacral, the vagus does not innervate them, so “redistribution of vagal tone leading to the restoration of pelvic microcirculation” cannot hold anatomically, and heart-rate variability, which measures cardiac vagal control, cannot support a conclusion about the pelvis. Even the “sacral parasympathetic” is under dispute: Espinosa-Medina and colleagues and Sivori and colleagues argue from developmental lineage and single-cell transcriptomics that the sacral outflow is sympathetic, while Jänig and colleagues and Neuhuber and colleagues reply from transmitter and function, and the open peer review judged the relevant title to exceed the data. This book takes no side, because whatever it is called it is not the vagus. Sympathetic outflow is regionally specific and not a scalar. Finally, RMSSD and high-frequency power move a long way with breathing pattern: in synthetic records with the mean interbeat interval held exactly constant, RMSSD ranges from 18.4 to 31.4 ms, and at six breaths a minute the high-frequency index collapses because the respiratory peak has left the band.

References

Espinosa-Medina, Isabel, Orthis Saha, Franck Boismoreau, and Jean-François Brunet. 2018. “The ‘Sacral Parasympathetic’: Ontogeny and Anatomy of a Myth.” Clinical Autonomic Research 28 (1): 13–21. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10286-017-0478-7.
Espinosa-Medina, Isabel, Orthis Saha, Franck Boismoreau, Zoubida Chettouh, Francesca Rossi, William D. Richardson, and Jean-François Brunet. 2016. “The Sacral Autonomic Outflow Is Sympathetic.” Science 354 (6314): 893–97. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aah5454.
Fowler, Clare J., Derek Griffiths, and William C. de Groat. 2008. “The Neural Control of Micturition.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 9: 453–66. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrn2401.
Groat, William C. de, Derek Griffiths, and Naoki Yoshimura. 2015. “Neural Control of the Lower Urinary Tract.” Comprehensive Physiology 5 (1): 327–96. https://doi.org/10.1002/cphy.c130056.
Grossman, Paul. 2023. “Fundamental Challenges and Likely Refutations of the Five Basic Premises of the Polyvagal Theory. PMID 37230290.” Biological Psychology 180: 108589. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2023.108589.
Grossman, Paul, and Edwin W. Taylor. 2007. “Toward Understanding Respiratory Sinus Arrhythmia: Relations to Cardiac Vagal Tone, Evolution and Biobehavioral Functions.” Biological Psychology 74 (2): 263–85. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2005.11.014.
Hirsch, J. A., and B. Bishop. 1981. “Respiratory Sinus Arrhythmia in Humans: How Breathing Pattern Modulates Heart Rate.” American Journal of Physiology: Heart and Circulatory Physiology 241 (4): H620–29. https://doi.org/10.1152/ajpheart.1981.241.4.H620.
Jänig, Wilfrid, Janet R. Keast, Elspeth M. McLachlan, Winfried L. Neuhuber, and Michelle Southard-Smith. 2017. “Renaming All Spinal Autonomic Outflows as Sympathetic Is a Mistake.” Autonomic Neuroscience 206: 60–62. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.autneu.2017.04.003.
Laborde, Sylvain, Emma Mosley, and Julian F. Thayer. 2017. “Heart Rate Variability and Cardiac Vagal Tone in Psychophysiological Research — Recommendations for Experiment Planning, Data Analysis, and Data Reporting.” Frontiers in Psychology 8: 213. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2017.00213.
Lehrer, Paul M., and Richard Gevirtz. 2014. “Heart Rate Variability Biofeedback: How and Why Does It Work?” Frontiers in Psychology 5: 756. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2014.00756.
Morrison, Shaun F. 2001. “Differential Control of Sympathetic Outflow.” American Journal of Physiology: Regulatory, Integrative and Comparative Physiology 281 (3): R683–98. https://doi.org/10.1152/ajpregu.2001.281.3.R683.
Neuhuber, Winfried, Elspeth McLachlan, and Wilfrid Jänig. 2017. “The Sacral Autonomic Outflow Is Spinal, but Not ‘Sympathetic.’ Volume and Pages Verified from the Publisher Record; See Editorial Note.” The Anatomical Record 300. https://doi.org/10.1002/ar.23600.
Porges, Stephen W. 2007. “The Polyvagal Perspective.” Biological Psychology 74 (2): 116–43. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2006.06.009.
Shaffer, Fred, and J. P. Ginsberg. 2017. “An Overview of Heart Rate Variability Metrics and Norms.” Frontiers in Public Health 5: 258. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2017.00258.
Sivori, Mattia, Bowen Dempsey, Zoubida Chettouh, Franck Boismoreau, Maira Ayerdi, Sylvain Baulande, Sonia Lameiras, et al. 2024. “The Pelvic Organs Receive No Parasympathetic Innervation.” eLife 12: RP91576. https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.91576.3.
Task Force of the European Society of Cardiology and the North American Society of Pacing and Electrophysiology. 1996. “Heart Rate Variability: Standards of Measurement, Physiological Interpretation, and Clinical Use.” Circulation 93 (5): 1043–65. https://doi.org/10.1161/01.CIR.93.5.1043.

Fan, Y. (2026). Interoceptive Decoupling, Salience-Network Switching and Autonomic Visceral Restoration: From Precision-Weighting in the Default Mode Network and the Redistribution of Vagal Tone to the Neurophenomenology of a Non-Judgmental Imagery Stream, with a Textual Examination of neiguan in the Huangdi Neijing [内感受解离、突显网络切换与内脏自主神经修复] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24020418 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).