5D Library › 胰岛素胰高血糖素双稳态、内脏脂解动力学与线性规划配餐 · English

第二章 脂肪酶:两个条件,以及一次过冲

脂肪离开细胞之前必须先发生什么

储存的脂肪是甘油三酯,而甘油三酯过不了细胞膜。它必须被切开,而负责切开它的那些酶被置于激素的控制之下。Lafontan 与 Langin 的综述在人体组织里列出这一串次序:胰岛素激活磷酸二酯酶 3B,把环腺苷单磷酸清掉;环腺苷单磷酸一低,蛋白激酶 A 就安静;激酶一安静,激素敏感性脂肪酶的激活位点就保持未磷酸化,脂滴也就保持关闭 (Lafontan and Langin 2009)。

流行的概括说胰岛素下降「去磷酸化并激活」这个酶,把主要那一步的方向说反了。激活位点是被磷酸化的,不是被去磷酸化的,而动手的是蛋白激酶 A。Anthonsen 等人鉴定了这些位点,并指出其中哪几个主导激活 (Anthonsen et al. 1998)。流行概括模糊记住的,是另外一个位点。Garton 等人证明腺苷单磷酸活化蛋白激酶磷酸化的是另一个丝氨酸,而这次磷酸化是约束这个酶,不是激活它 (Garton et al. 1989)。所以这个酶同时需要两个条件:激活位点开着,约束位点关着。

证据

已发表。 Lafontan 与 Langin 综述人体脂肪组织中脂解的调控,以及磷酸二酯酶 3B 在胰岛素抗脂解作用中的位置 (Lafontan and Langin 2009)。Anthonsen 等人绘出激素敏感性脂肪酶的激活磷酸化位点 (Anthonsen et al. 1998)。Garton 等人证明腺苷单磷酸活化蛋白激酶磷酸化的是一个作用相反的位点 (Garton et al. 1989)。

两个走在不同时间尺度上的条件,能做出单个条件做不到的事。p03 给约束位点一条自己的、依赖胰岛素的较慢曲线,然后把胰岛素从餐后水平阶跃下降到空腹水平。

推导

# Chapter 2. p03: What has to happen to hormone-sensitive lipase before
# stored fat can leave a fat cell. Insulin activates phosphodiesterase
# 3B, which clears cyclic AMP, so protein kinase A is quiet and the
# enzyme's activating sites stay unphosphorylated. Falling insulin lets
# cyclic AMP rise and the kinase phosphorylate those sites. A separate
# site that the energy sensor AMP-activated protein kinase phosphorylates
# holds the enzyme off until it is dephosphorylated, so the enzyme needs
# both: the activating sites on and the restraining site off. Insulin is
# in pmol/L; the rates are scaled to a maximum of one.
# The two conditions follow a fall in insulin on two timescales. The
# activating path (phosphodiesterase, cyclic AMP, kinase) relaxes toward
# its new level with a time constant TAU_ACT; the restraining site, set
# by the slower energy sensor, relaxes with TAU_RES. Both constants are
# illustrative, not fitted; only TAU_ACT < TAU_RES matters for the shape.
CAMP0, KI, HI = 1.0, 90.0, 1.8      # cyclic AMP fall as insulin rises
KPKA, HPKA = 0.45, 2.2              # kinase response to cyclic AMP
KS565, HS565 = 55.0, 1.4            # restraining site vs insulin
TAU_ACT = 11.0                      # minutes: activating path follows
TAU_RES = 40.0                      # minutes: restraining site follows
FED, FASTED = 350.0, 35.0           # insulin after a meal and when fasted

def camp(ins):
    return CAMP0 / (1.0 + (ins / KI) ** HI)

def pka(c):
    return c ** HPKA / (KPKA ** HPKA + c ** HPKA)

def free565(ins):
    # share of enzyme whose restraining site is dephosphorylated
    return 1.0 / (1.0 + (KS565 / max(ins, 1e-9)) ** HS565)

def active(ins):
    return pka(camp(ins)) * free565(ins)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   insulin   cyclic AMP   kinase   site free   lipase active")
    for ins in (350.0, 200.0, 120.0, 90.0, 60.0, 45.0, 35.0, 25.0):
        print("   {:<10.0f}{:<13.3f}{:<9.3f}{:<12.3f}{:.3f}"
              .format(ins, camp(ins), pka(camp(ins)), free565(ins),
                      active(ins)))
    a_fed, a_fast = active(FED), active(FASTED)
    print("   active lipase fed {:.4f}, fasted {:.3f}, ratio {:.1f}"
          .format(a_fed, a_fast, a_fast / a_fed))
    print("   insulin at which the lipase reaches half its fasted value:")
    lo, hi = FASTED, FED
    for _ in range(60):
        mid = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
        if active(mid) > 0.5 * a_fast:
            lo = mid
        else:
            hi = mid
    half = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
    print("   {:.1f} pmol/L".format(half))
    print("   minutes after insulin steps from fed to fasted:")
    print("   minute   kinase   site free   lipase active   share of fasted")
    c0, c1 = camp(FED), camp(FASTED)
    s0, s1 = free565(FED), free565(FASTED)
    def course(t):
        e1 = 2.718281828459045 ** (-t / TAU_ACT)
        e2 = 2.718281828459045 ** (-t / TAU_RES)
        k = pka(c1 + (c0 - c1) * e1)
        s = s1 + (s0 - s1) * e2
        return k, s, k * s
    for t in (0, 10, 20, 30, 45, 60, 90, 120, 180):
        k, s, a = course(t)
        print("   {:<9d}{:<9.3f}{:<12.3f}{:<16.3f}{:.3f}"
              .format(t, k, s, a, a / a_fast))
    peak_t = max(range(0, 301), key=lambda t: course(t)[2])
    print("   peak at minute {:d}: {:.3f}, {:.3f} times the fasted value"
          .format(peak_t, course(peak_t)[2], course(peak_t)[2] / a_fast))
    print("   one time constant for both paths: largest share {:.3f}"
          .format(max(
              pka(c1 + (c0 - c1) * 2.718281828459045 ** (-t / TAU_ACT)) *
              (s1 + (s0 - s1) * 2.718281828459045 ** (-t / TAU_ACT))
              for t in range(0, 301)) / a_fast))
#    insulin   cyclic AMP   kinase   site free   lipase active
#    350       0.080        0.022    0.930       0.020
#    200       0.192        0.133    0.859       0.114
#    120       0.373        0.399    0.749       0.299
#    90        0.500        0.558    0.666       0.371
#    60        0.675        0.709    0.530       0.376
#    45        0.777        0.769    0.430       0.331
#    35        0.846        0.800    0.347       0.278
#    25        0.909        0.825    0.249       0.205
#    active lipase fed 0.0203, fasted 0.278, ratio 13.7
#    insulin at which the lipase reaches half its fasted value:
#    184.9 pmol/L
#    minutes after insulin steps from fed to fasted:
#    minute   kinase   site free   lipase active   share of fasted
#    0        0.022    0.930       0.020           0.073
#    10       0.596    0.801       0.478           1.720
#    20       0.738    0.701       0.517           1.864
#    30       0.778    0.622       0.484           1.744
#    45       0.795    0.536       0.426           1.536
#    60       0.799    0.477       0.381           1.373
#    90       0.800    0.408       0.327           1.177
#    120      0.800    0.376       0.301           1.084
#    180      0.800    0.353       0.283           1.019
#    peak at minute 17: 0.520, 1.874 times the fasted value
#    one time constant for both paths: largest share 1.258

沿着胰岛素那一列往下读第一张表。环腺苷单磷酸从胰岛素 350 时的 0.080 升到 25 时的 0.909,激酶随它从 0.022 走到 0.825,这正是教科书要求的。但约束位点在最低端并不空着:该位点清空的酶所占份额随胰岛素下降从 0.930 掉到 0.249,因为给它上磷酸的那个能量传感器本身就是被断食激活的。两者之积,也就是有活性的酶,于是不是单调的。它在胰岛素 60 附近见顶,达到 0.376,而在 25 时反而更低,只有 0.205。

时间曲线把这个后果显示出来,而这里两个时间尺度起作用。p03 中,胰岛素阶跃下降后,激活通路以 11 分钟的时间常数跟上,约束位点以 40 分钟的时间常数跟上;两个数值都是示意,要紧的只是它们的先后。阶跃后十分钟,蛋白激酶已到 0.596,而仍有 0.801 的酶约束位点未被占住,于是有活性的脂肪酶是其最终稳定空腹值的 1.720 倍。它在第 17 分钟达到峰值,为该值的 1.874 倍;三十分钟时仍是 1.744 倍,六十分钟 1.373 倍,到第 120 分钟 1.084 倍,随着约束位点追上来而回落。若两条通路用同一个时间常数,最大比值只有 1.258,即第一张表里的静态峰值;所以过冲的大部分来自两条通路之间的时间差。这个酶先过冲,再把一部分还回去。空腹态不是脂解能力最大的那个状态,走进空腹态的那段过渡才是。

假说 · 尚未验证

作者的诠释(尚未验证): 因为能力在过渡期过冲、随后落到更低处,在平均胰岛素相同的前提下,由若干个中等深度的胰岛素低谷构成的一天,动员量可能超过由单个又深又长的低谷构成的一天。什么会证明它错: 在二十四小时平均胰岛素与能量摄入都匹配的条件下,如果用示踪剂测得的甘油出现速率在多谷与单谷两种日程之间没有差别,或在单谷那一天更高,那么这次过冲就没有全身层面的后果。

为什么腹腔先让步

腹腔里的脂肪与皮下的脂肪不是同一种组织。Bjorntorp 的论证先是解剖学的,然后才是生物化学的:内脏脂库汇入门静脉,所以它释放的东西最先到达肝脏,而且是以别处都见不到的浓度到达 (Bjorntorp 1990)。它的受体也不同。它带着更多把脂解打开的机件,而对把脂解关掉的胰岛素反应更弱,这意味着它正是胰岛素压不住的那个脂库。Arner 等人用放射性碳为人体脂肪细胞里的脂质定年,还进一步证明储存脂质的周转在人与人之间、脂库与脂库之间都不同,并不是这种组织的一个常数 (Arner et al. 2011)。

推导

# Chapter 2. p04: Why the visceral depot gives way first. Two depots are
# modelled: the fat inside the abdomen, drained by the portal vein, and
# the fat under the skin. The visceral depot carries more of the
# catecholamine receptors that switch lipolysis on and fewer of the
# insulin receptors that switch it off, so at the same insulin level it
# releases more fatty acids per kilogram. Masses are illustrative for an
# adult with a large waist; the release rates are scaled so that the
# subcutaneous depot releases one unit per kilogram at fasted insulin.
MASS = {"visceral": 2.2, "subcutaneous": 12.0}       # kg of fat
VMAX = {"visceral": 2.30, "subcutaneous": 1.00}      # per kg, insulin free
IC50 = {"visceral": 110.0, "subcutaneous": 55.0}     # pmol/L, half block
HILL = 1.6
PER_UNIT = 0.84         # g of fatty acid an hour per unit of release

def rate(depot, ins):
    return VMAX[depot] / (1.0 + (ins / IC50[depot]) ** HILL)

def release(depot, ins):
    return MASS[depot] * rate(depot, ins)

if __name__ == "__main__":
    print("   insulin   visceral   subcutaneous   visceral share")
    for ins in (350.0, 200.0, 120.0, 90.0, 60.0, 45.0, 35.0, 25.0):
        v, s = release("visceral", ins), release("subcutaneous", ins)
        print("   {:<10.0f}{:<11.3f}{:<15.3f}{:.3f}"
              .format(ins, v, s, v / (v + s)))
    v35 = release("visceral", 35.0)
    s35 = release("subcutaneous", 35.0)
    v350 = release("visceral", 350.0)
    s350 = release("subcutaneous", 350.0)
    print("   visceral share at fasted insulin {:.3f}, after a meal {:.3f}"
          .format(v35 / (v35 + s35), v350 / (v350 + s350)))
    share_mass = (MASS["visceral"]
                  / (MASS["visceral"] + MASS["subcutaneous"]))
    print("   visceral mass is {:.3f} of the two depots together"
          .format(share_mass))
    print("   times its share of mass: fasted {:.2f}, after a meal {:.2f}"
          .format((v35 / (v35 + s35)) / share_mass,
                  (v350 / (v350 + s350)) / share_mass))
    print("   grams of fat released a day at a steady insulin level:")
    print("   insulin   visceral   subcutaneous   together")
    for ins in (90.0, 60.0, 45.0, 35.0):
        v = release("visceral", ins) * PER_UNIT * 24.0
        s = release("subcutaneous", ins) * PER_UNIT * 24.0
        print("   {:<10.0f}{:<11.1f}{:<15.1f}{:.1f}"
              .format(ins, v, s, v + s))
    print("   release is not loss: most of it returns to the depot unless")
    print("   the day ends in an energy deficit, which p05 and p06 set out")
#    insulin   visceral   subcutaneous   visceral share
#    350       0.686      0.591          0.537
#    200       1.405      1.350          0.510
#    120       2.354      2.676          0.468
#    90        2.933      3.751          0.439
#    60        3.669      5.583          0.397
#    45        4.083      6.955          0.370
#    35        4.362      8.080          0.351
#    25        4.628      9.351          0.331
#    visceral share at fasted insulin 0.351, after a meal 0.537
#    visceral mass is 0.155 of the two depots together
#    times its share of mass: fasted 2.26, after a meal 3.47
#    grams of fat released a day at a steady insulin level:
#    insulin   visceral   subcutaneous   together
#    90        59.1       75.6           134.7
#    60        74.0       112.6          186.5
#    45        82.3       140.2          222.5
#    35        87.9       162.9          250.8
#    release is not loss: most of it returns to the depot unless
#    the day ends in an energy deficit, which p05 and p06 set out

在这次拟合里,内脏脂库占两个脂库质量合计的 0.155,但它贡献的从来没有这么少。在空腹胰岛素下,它在释放中的份额是 0.351,是其质量份额的 2.26 倍;而在餐后、胰岛素为 350 时,这个份额升到 0.537,是其质量份额的 3.47 倍。这个方向值得停下来看,因为它与这个说法通常被讲述的方式相反。内脏脂库的相对优势在胰岛素高时最大,不是在胰岛素低时最大。胰岛素一低,每个脂库都在接近自己的上限释放,而皮下更大的那团质量就主导了总量:胰岛素为 35 时,两者每天释放 87.9 与 162.9 克,合计 250.8。

内脏脂库在总释放中的份额对胰岛素,图中标出其质量份额以便对照(p04)。

p04 的最后两行才是要带去下一章的。释放不等于减少。没有被氧化的脂肪酸会被重新摄取并重新酯化,在能量平衡的一天结束时,脂库还在它出发的地方。热量缺口定下的是减掉的总量;进食模式所能改变的,是这些量从哪个脂库里出来,以及差多少。第三章把这个算出来。

小结

这个脂肪酶需要激活位点被蛋白激酶 A 磷酸化、约束位点被去磷酸化,所以那句流行的一行概括是以一种要紧的方式只对了一半:两个条件走在不同的时间尺度上,于是胰岛素下降后第 17 分钟,这个酶过冲到其稳定空腹值的 1.874 倍。内脏脂库在空腹时交出其质量份额的 2.26 倍,在餐后则是 3.47 倍,所以它的优势在高胰岛素时最大,这与通常的讲法正好相反。

参考文献

Anthonsen, Marit W., Lars Ronnstrand, Christer Wernstedt, Eva Degerman, and Cecilia Holm. 1998. “Identification of Novel Phosphorylation Sites in Hormone-Sensitive Lipase That Are Phosphorylated in Response to Isoproterenol and Govern Activation Properties in Vitro.” The Journal of Biological Chemistry 273 (1): 215 to 221.
Arner, Peter, Samuel Bernard, Mehran Salehpour, et al. 2011. “Dynamics of Human Adipose Lipid Turnover in Health and Metabolic Disease.” Nature 478 (7367): 110 to 113.
Bjorntorp, Per. 1990. “Portal Adipose Tissue as a Generator of Risk Factors for Cardiovascular Disease and Diabetes.” Arteriosclerosis 10 (4): 493 to 496.
Garton, Andrew J., David G. Campbell, David Carling, D. Grahame Hardie, Roger J. Colbran, and Stephen J. Yeaman. 1989. “Phosphorylation of Bovine Hormone-Sensitive Lipase by the AMP-Activated Protein Kinase.” European Journal of Biochemistry 179 (1): 249 to 254.
Lafontan, Max, and Dominique Langin. 2009. “Lipolysis and Lipid Mobilization in Human Adipose Tissue.” Progress in Lipid Research 48 (5): 275 to 297.

Fan, Y. (2026). Insulin-Glucagon Bistability, Visceral Lipolysis Kinetics and Linear-Programming Diet Optimization: Hepatic Glycogen Depletion Times, Triglyceride-Glucose Indices and Micronutrient-Constrained Menus [胰岛素胰高血糖素双稳态、内脏脂解动力学与线性规划配餐] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090248 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).