5D Library › Insulin-Glucagon Bistability, Visceral Lipolysis Kinetics and Linear-Programming Diet Optimization · 中文
Chapter 1. The Switch: Where the Fourteen to Twenty Hours Come From
How long the liver’s glycogen actually lasts
Between meals the liver is the only organ that puts glucose into the blood. It does so from two sources: it breaks down its own glycogen, and it builds new glucose out of lactate, glycerol and amino acids. Only the first draws on a store, and the store is small. Magnetic resonance measurements in fasting adults put hepatic glycogen near a hundred grams after a meal and show it falling steadily, with gluconeogenesis taking over a growing share of total output as the hours pass (Rothman et al. 1991). Cahill’s long review of fuel use in starvation gives the same picture from the other side: the brain’s demand is nearly constant, so the only question is which source is paying for it (Cahill 2006).
Evidence
Published. Rothman and colleagues followed liver glycogen by carbon-13 magnetic resonance through a fast and separated glycogenolysis from gluconeogenesis directly, rather than inferring the split (Rothman et al. 1991). Cahill’s review sets out the sequence of fuels across days of starvation and the point at which ketone bodies take over much of the brain’s supply (Cahill 2006).
That makes the popular claim testable. If the store is some number of grams and glycogenolysis draws it down at some number of grams an hour, the time to empty it is the quotient. Both numbers vary between people and within a person, so the honest answer is a grid, not a point.
Calculation
# Chapter 1. p01: How long the liver's glycogen lasts. The liver is the
# only organ that releases glucose into the blood between meals. The
# time to run the store down is the store divided by the part of
# hepatic glucose output that glycogenolysis supplies; gluconeogenesis
# supplies the rest and does not draw on the store. The grid below
# spans the stores and drain rates reported for healthy adults.
STORE = (80, 90, 100, 110, 120) # g of liver glycogen after a meal
DRAIN = (4.5, 5.0, 5.5, 6.0, 6.5) # g per hour from glycogenolysis
LOW, HIGH = 14.0, 20.0 # the window the popular claim uses
def quantile(values, a):
s = sorted(values)
return s[int(a * (len(s) - 1))]
if __name__ == "__main__":
print(" time to empty the store, hours: store (g) by drain (g/h)")
print(" store" + "".join("{:>8.1f}".format(d) for d in DRAIN))
cells = []
for s in STORE:
row = [s / d for d in DRAIN]
cells.extend(row)
print(" {:<5d}".format(s)
+ "".join("{:>8.1f}".format(h) for h in row))
inside = [h for h in cells if LOW <= h <= HIGH]
print(" cells inside the {:.0f} to {:.0f} hour window: {} of {}"
.format(LOW, HIGH, len(inside), len(cells)))
print(" share of the grid inside that window: {:.3f}"
.format(len(inside) / len(cells)))
print(" median of the grid: {:.1f} hours".format(quantile(cells, 0.5)))
print(" full spread: {:.1f} to {:.1f} hours"
.format(min(cells), max(cells)))
print(" a 100 g store at 5.5 g/h: {:.1f} hours"
.format(100 / 5.5))
# time to empty the store, hours: store (g) by drain (g/h)
# store 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5
# 80 17.8 16.0 14.5 13.3 12.3
# 90 20.0 18.0 16.4 15.0 13.8
# 100 22.2 20.0 18.2 16.7 15.4
# 110 24.4 22.0 20.0 18.3 16.9
# 120 26.7 24.0 21.8 20.0 18.5
# cells inside the 14 to 20 hour window: 16 of 25
# share of the grid inside that window: 0.640
# median of the grid: 18.2 hours
# full spread: 12.3 to 26.7 hours
# a 100 g store at 5.5 g/h: 18.2 hoursOf the twenty-five cells in that grid, sixteen fall inside the fourteen to twenty hour window, a share of 0.640. The median of the grid is 18.2 hours, and the full spread runs from 12.3 hours at the smallest store and fastest drain to 26.7 hours at the largest store and slowest drain. A hundred-gram store drawn at 5.5 grams an hour empties in 18.2 hours. So the window quoted on the internet is the middle of a plausible range, and the range is nearly a factor of two wide. Anyone whose plan depends on the exact hour has built on a quantity that is not known to that precision in any one person.
Two hormones that shut each other off
The second claim is about the shape of the change, not its timing. Falling insulin lets fat out of storage; the fuels released, with glucagon rising alongside, feed back and suppress insulin secretion further. Unger set out this reciprocal arrangement in its modern form (Unger 1971). Mutual inhibition of this kind does not give a threshold. It gives a switch with two stable settings, and the settings are separated by a barrier, so the system remembers which side it came from.
Write the fuel signal as a falling function of insulin tone and insulin secretion as a rising function of glucose and a falling function of the fuel signal, with one part of secretion that no fuel signal can switch off. At a steady state the pair reduces to a single equation in insulin tone whose roots are the steady settings:
Calculation
# Chapter 1. p02: A two-hormone switch with two stable settings. Write
# x for insulin tone and y for the fatty-acid and glucagon tone that
# rises when fat is mobilised. Insulin suppresses lipolysis, and the
# fuels lipolysis releases suppress insulin secretion, so the pair is a
# mutual-inhibition toggle: y = B / (1 + x**N) at a steady state, and
# x = a * (E + (1 - E) / (1 + y**N)), where E is the part of insulin
# secretion that no fuel signal can switch off and a = AMAX * g /
# (g + KG) is the drive from blood glucose g. The steady settings of x
# are the roots of f below. Three roots mean two stable settings with an
# unstable one between them, and the switch is then hysteretic: glucose
# must fall well below the level at which the fed state took hold.
N, B, E = 3.0, 4.0, 0.15
AMAX, KG = 8.0, 1.0
GRID, XMAX = 120001, 9.0
def drive(g):
return AMAX * g / (g + KG)
def fuel(x):
return B / (1.0 + x ** N)
def f(x, a):
return a * (E + (1.0 - E) / (1.0 + fuel(x) ** N)) - x
def roots(a):
out, px, pf = [], 0.0, f(0.0, a)
for i in range(1, GRID):
x = XMAX * i / (GRID - 1)
fx = f(x, a)
if (pf < 0.0) != (fx < 0.0):
lo, hi = px, x
for _ in range(60):
mid = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
if (f(lo, a) < 0.0) != (f(mid, a) < 0.0):
hi = mid
else:
lo = mid
out.append(0.5 * (lo + hi))
px, pf = x, fx
return out
def threshold(lo, hi):
# lo and hi must have different numbers of steady settings
base = len(roots(drive(lo))) == 3
for _ in range(44):
mid = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
if (len(roots(drive(mid))) == 3) == base:
lo = mid
else:
hi = mid
return 0.5 * (lo + hi)
if __name__ == "__main__":
print(" Hill exponent N = {:.1f}, unswitchable secretion E = {:.2f}"
.format(N, E))
print(" glucose g steady settings of insulin tone x")
for i in range(11):
g = 0.20 + 0.10 * i
r = roots(drive(g))
print(" {:<12.2f}".format(g)
+ " ".join("{:.3f}".format(v) for v in r))
g_on = threshold(0.20, 0.80)
g_off = threshold(0.80, 1.60)
print(" fed state first becomes possible at g = {:.4f}".format(g_on))
print(" fasted state is lost above g = {:.4f}".format(g_off))
print(" width of the hysteresis in g: {:.4f}".format(g_off - g_on))
print(" ratio of the two glucose thresholds: {:.2f}"
.format(g_off / g_on))
r = roots(drive(0.80))
print(" at g = 0.80 the stable insulin tones are {:.3f} and {:.3f}"
.format(r[0], r[2]))
print(" fatty-acid tone there: {:.3f} fasted, {:.3f} fed"
.format(fuel(r[0]), fuel(r[2])))
print(" ratio of the two fatty-acid tones: {:.1f}"
.format(fuel(r[0]) / fuel(r[2])))
# Hill exponent N = 3.0, unswitchable secretion E = 0.15
# glucose g steady settings of insulin tone x
# 0.20 0.218
# 0.30 0.303
# 0.40 0.378 1.548 2.214
# 0.50 0.445 1.387 2.647
# 0.60 0.506 1.293 2.992
# 0.70 0.564 1.221 3.290
# 0.80 0.621 1.159 3.554
# 0.90 0.678 1.099 3.788
# 1.00 0.742 1.036 3.999
# 1.10 0.840 0.940 4.190
# 1.20 4.363
# fed state first becomes possible at g = 0.3554
# fasted state is lost above g = 1.1142
# width of the hysteresis in g: 0.7589
# ratio of the two glucose thresholds: 3.14
# at g = 0.80 the stable insulin tones are 0.621 and 3.554
# fatty-acid tone there: 3.229 fasted, 0.087 fed
# ratio of the two fatty-acid tones: 37.0With a Hill exponent of 3.0 and an unswitchable fraction of 0.15, the fed setting first becomes possible at a glucose drive of 0.3554, while the fasted setting survives until 1.1142. The two thresholds differ by a factor of 3.14, and the width of the hysteresis in the drive is 0.7589. In the overlap, at a drive of 0.80, the two stable insulin tones are 0.621 and 3.554, and the fatty-acid tone that goes with them is 3.229 against 0.087, a ratio of 37.0. The same glucose level, in other words, is compatible with a body that is mobilising fat hard and with one that is not mobilising it at all. Which of the two obtains depends on the recent history of eating, not on the current measurement.
Hypothesis · not established
The author’s interpretation (not yet tested): because the arrangement is hysteretic, the clinically useful quantity is not the hour at which a fast is held but the depth of the glucose trough reached before refeeding, since only a trough below the lower threshold moves the system onto the fasted branch, after which it stays there at drives that could not have put it there. What would show it wrong: if, in people fasted for matched total hours, the mobilisation measured after refeeding is explained by total fasted hours and not by the minimum glucose reached, or if the two predict equally well, the hysteretic reading adds nothing.
Summary
The fourteen to twenty hour window is the middle of a range that runs from 12.3 to 26.7 hours on plausible parameters, and only 0.640 of that grid falls inside it. The change at the end of the window is not a threshold but a switch with two stable settings whose thresholds differ by 3.14 in the glucose drive, so the same glucose reading is compatible with two quite different rates of fat mobilisation. Chapter 2 asks what has to happen inside the fat cell once the switch has moved.
References
Fan, Y. (2026). Insulin-Glucagon Bistability, Visceral Lipolysis Kinetics and Linear-Programming Diet Optimization: Hepatic Glycogen Depletion Times, Triglyceride-Glucose Indices and Micronutrient-Constrained Menus [胰岛素胰高血糖素双稳态、内脏脂解动力学与线性规划配餐] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090248 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).