5D Library › Implied Volatility Surfaces, Skew Premia and Quantitative Risk Control of Vertical Spreads · 中文
Chapter 3 The Bear Put Vertical Spread: Geometry, Costs and Early Exercise
A capped gain and a capped loss
A bear put vertical spread has two legs: buy a put with the higher strike and sell a put with the same expiry and a lower strike . Opening it costs a net premium (a “debit”), and at expiry it pays
So for European options held to expiry, with all trading costs included in :
- maximum gain , reached when ;
- maximum loss , incurred when ;
- break-even .
The framework’s three formulas are correct, but none of the three conditions can be dropped: when the spread is closed early its value is set by the market at that moment and the bid–ask spread is paid again; American options can be assigned early; and a computed at mid prices understates the cost. A note on units: prices in this book are per unit of underlying; standard exchange contracts usually multiply by 100.
Unlike a written put or a credit spread (such as a bull put spread), a debit spread pays its maximum loss in full at the outset, so as long as both legs remain open (the short leg has not been assigned) it faces no margin call; a credit spread must post margin of “strike width minus premium received” and carries assignment risk.
The arithmetic of skew and bid–ask spreads
Using the skew of Chapter 2, the put struck at 100 is quoted at 0.22 implied volatility and the put struck at 95 at 0.245, with 30 days left. The program below computes the cost of the spread, the effect of the skew, and the effect of bid–ask spreads (a half-spread per leg) on the maximum gain, maximum loss and break-even; finally, assuming the underlying really moves with volatility 0.18 (below the implied level), it computes the chance of finishing below break-even and the expected profit at expiry under several real-world drifts.
Calculation
# Bear put spread geometry: buy the 100 put, sell the 95 put, 30 days, with a skewed
# implied-volatility quote (higher vol at the lower strike). Capped gain and loss,
# break-even, the cost of crossing bid-ask spreads, and the chance of finishing in profit
# under assumed real-world drifts. Prices per unit of underlying; ILLUSTRATIVE numbers.
import math
def ncdf(x):
return 0.5 * (1.0 + math.erf(x / math.sqrt(2.0)))
def put(S, K, T, r, s):
d1 = (math.log(S / K) + (r + 0.5 * s * s) * T) / (s * math.sqrt(T))
return K * math.exp(-r * T) * ncdf(-d1 + s * math.sqrt(T)) - S * ncdf(-d1)
S, T, r, K1, K2, V1, V2 = 100.0, 30 / 365, 0.03, 100.0, 95.0, 0.22, 0.245
def e_put(K, mu, s=0.18):
# E[(K - S_T)+] for a lognormal with drift mu (not discounted)
d1 = (math.log(S / K) + (mu + 0.5 * s * s) * T) / (s * math.sqrt(T))
return K * ncdf(-d1 + s * math.sqrt(T)) - S * math.exp(mu * T) * ncdf(-d1)
def p_below(x, mu, s=0.18):
# P(S_T < x) for a lognormal with drift mu and volatility s
return ncdf((math.log(x / S) - (mu - 0.5 * s * s) * T) / (s * math.sqrt(T)))
if __name__ == "__main__":
p1, p2 = put(S, K1, T, r, V1), put(S, K2, T, r, V2)
flat = put(S, K2, T, r, V1)
print(f"long 100 put {p1:.3f} (vol {V1}), short 95 put {p2:.3f} (vol {V2});"
f" mid debit {p1 - p2:.3f}")
print(f" without skew the 95 put would be {flat:.3f}: the skew lowers the debit by"
f" {p2 - flat:.3f}")
print("half-spread debit max gain max loss gain/loss break-even round trip")
for h in (0.0, 0.02, 0.05, 0.10, 0.20):
d = p1 - p2 + 2 * h
g = K1 - K2 - d
print(f" {h:.2f} {d:6.3f} {g:6.3f} {d:6.3f} {g / d:5.2f}"
f" {K1 - d:6.2f} {4 * h / g:5.1%}")
d = p1 - p2 + 0.10
print(f"realised vol 0.18, debit {d:.3f}: P(<= break-even) P(<= 95) E[P&L], expiry")
for lab, mu in (("drift = r (no edge)", r), ("drift -20 %/yr", -0.20),
("drift -60 %/yr", -0.60)):
ev = math.exp(-r * T) * (e_put(K1, mu) - e_put(K2, mu)) - d
print(f" {lab:20s}{p_below(K1 - d, mu):15.3f}{p_below(K2, mu):9.3f}{ev:+11.3f}")
# long 100 put 2.391 (vol 0.22), short 95 put 0.873 (vol 0.245); mid debit 1.518
# without skew the 95 put would be 0.672: the skew lowers the debit by 0.201
# half-spread debit max gain max loss gain/loss break-even round trip
# 0.00 1.518 3.482 1.518 2.29 98.48 0.0%
# 0.02 1.558 3.442 1.558 2.21 98.44 2.3%
# 0.05 1.618 3.382 1.618 2.09 98.38 5.9%
# 0.10 1.718 3.282 1.718 1.91 98.28 12.2%
# 0.20 1.918 3.082 1.918 1.61 98.08 26.0%
# realised vol 0.18, debit 1.618: P(<= break-even) P(<= 95) E[P&L], expiry
# drift = r (no edge) 0.368 0.155 -0.070
# drift -20 %/yr 0.511 0.258 +0.593
# drift -60 %/yr 0.747 0.495 +1.776At mid prices the spread costs 1.518. Without skew, with both legs priced at 0.22, the 95 put sold would be worth only 0.672; the skew makes it worth 0.873 and so lowers the cost of entry by 0.201. This is what the hypothesis of Chapter 2 means by “the steeper the skew, the cheaper the debit put spread”.
Bid–ask spreads matter more than one might think. Opening pays two half-spreads, raising the debit from 1.518 to ; at a half-spread of 0.05 the maximum gain falls from 3.482 to 3.382 and the gain-to-loss ratio from 2.29 to 2.09; closing early pays two more half-spreads, a round trip equal to 5.9 % of the maximum gain; for an illiquid contract with a half-spread of 0.20 the round trip reaches 26 % of the maximum gain. Muravyev and Pearson (2020) found that option traders who time their trades pay effective spreads of less than 40 % of conventional estimates, and that the overall average is about a quarter below them (Muravyev and Pearson 2020); so “filling at half the quoted spread” can overstate or understate costs, and a backtest must fix its fill assumptions in advance (Chapter 8).
The last three lines show that the spread’s “win rate” and expected profit depend on the underlying’s true drift, about which the pricing formula knows nothing. With no directional edge (drift equal to the risk-free rate) the chance of finishing below break-even is 0.368 and the expected profit is −0.070: implied volatility above realised volatility hurts the buyer, the skew makes the leg sold dearer, the two roughly cancel, and what remains is mostly the bid–ask cost. Only if the trader really has downside information (say an annual drift of −20 %) is the expected profit clearly positive (+0.593). These drifts are assumptions, not estimates for any market.
Note
A spread cannot remove the error in a directional view; it can only cap it. The capped loss makes the worst outcome known at entry, the most important risk property of a debit spread; but it does not improve the accuracy of the view. A trader without a real directional edge has a negative expected return after costs.
American options: early exercise and early assignment
Options on stocks and most exchange-traded funds are American: the holder may exercise at any time before expiry. Merton (1973) proved that early exercise of an American call on a non-dividend-paying underlying is never optimal (Merton 1973); puts are different: deep in the money, exercising now to collect and earning interest on it can beat holding on. The program below uses a 600-step binomial tree to compare American and European puts, finds the critical price below which immediate exercise is optimal, and looks at what early exercise does to the spread.
Calculation
# American versus European puts on a non-dividend-paying underlying (CRR tree, 600
# steps): the early-exercise premium, the critical price below which exercise is optimal,
# and what early assignment of the short leg does to a 100/95 bear put spread.
import math
def ncdf(x):
return 0.5 * (1.0 + math.erf(x / math.sqrt(2.0)))
def euro_put(S, K, T, r, s):
d1 = (math.log(S / K) + (r + 0.5 * s * s) * T) / (s * math.sqrt(T))
return K * math.exp(-r * T) * ncdf(-d1 + s * math.sqrt(T)) - S * ncdf(-d1)
def amer_put(S, K, T, r, s, n=600):
dt = T / n; u = math.exp(s * math.sqrt(dt)); d = 1 / u
p = (math.exp(r * dt) - d) / (u - d); disc = math.exp(-r * dt)
v = [max(K - S * u ** j * d ** (n - j), 0.0) for j in range(n + 1)]
for i in range(n - 1, -1, -1):
v = [max(disc * (p * v[j + 1] + (1 - p) * v[j]), K - S * u ** j * d ** (i - j))
for j in range(i + 1)]
return v[0]
def critical(K, T, r, s):
lo, hi = 1.0, K # largest S at which exercising now is optimal
for _ in range(40):
mid = 0.5 * (lo + hi)
ex = amer_put(mid, K, T, r, s, 300) <= K - mid + 1e-9
lo, hi = (mid, hi) if ex else (lo, mid)
return lo
if __name__ == "__main__":
s = 0.22
for r in (0.03, 0.08):
print(f"r = {100 * r:.0f} %, put K = 100, vol {s}, 30 days: S European American"
" premium")
for S in (80, 90, 95, 100):
e, a = euro_put(S, 100, 30 / 365, r, s), amer_put(S, 100, 30 / 365, r, s)
print(f"{'':39s}{S:3d} {e:7.3f} {max(e, a):7.3f} {a - e:6.3f}")
cr = ", ".join(f"{critical(100, d / 365, r, s):.1f} ({d} d)" for d in (30, 7))
print(f" exercise now is optimal below S = {cr}")
r = 0.03; T = 30 / 365
print("100/95 spread, r = 3 %, 30 days: S European American legs difference")
for S in (80, 90, 95, 100):
e = euro_put(S, 100, T, r, 0.22) - euro_put(S, 95, T, r, 0.245)
a = amer_put(S, 100, T, r, 0.22) - amer_put(S, 95, T, r, 0.245)
print(f"{'':34s}{S:3d} {e:7.3f} {a:7.3f} {a - e:+.3f}")
print("payoff if the short 95 put is assigned at S = 85 and the long 100 put is"
" exercised")
print(f" at once: (100 - 85) - (95 - 85) = {(100 - 85) - (95 - 85)} = spread width;"
" max loss stays the debit")
# r = 3 %, put K = 100, vol 0.22, 30 days: S European American premium
# 80 19.754 20.000 0.246
# 90 9.883 10.023 0.140
# 95 5.526 5.578 0.052
# 100 2.391 2.407 0.015
# exercise now is optimal below S = 88.6 (30 d), 93.4 (7 d)
# r = 8 %, put K = 100, vol 0.22, 30 days: S European American premium
# 80 19.345 20.000 0.655
# 90 9.495 10.000 0.505
# 95 5.207 5.392 0.186
# 100 2.193 2.246 0.052
# exercise now is optimal below S = 91.1 (30 d), 94.6 (7 d)
# 100/95 spread, r = 3 %, 30 days: S European American legs difference
# 80 4.972 5.000 +0.028
# 90 4.243 4.336 +0.093
# 95 2.983 3.021 +0.039
# 100 1.518 1.530 +0.012
# payoff if the short 95 put is assigned at S = 85 and the long 100 put is exercised
# at once: (100 - 85) - (95 - 85) = 5 = spread width; max loss stays the debitWith a 3 % interest rate and 30 days left, the early-exercise premium of the 100-strike American put is 0.246 when the underlying is at 80 (where the American price is just the intrinsic value of 20) and only 0.015 at the money; immediate exercise is optimal below 88.6, and with seven days left the critical price rises to 93.4. At 8 % interest both the premium and the critical price are higher (0.052 at the money; critical prices 91.1 and 94.6), because receiving the strike early earns more interest.
For the spread, when both legs are American its value is slightly higher than the European one (by 0.093 with the underlying at 90): the right to exercise the long leg early belongs to the holder and that of the short leg to the counterparty, and the former, being higher-struck and deeper in the money, is worth more, so the net effect is positive. The key issue is early assignment of the short leg. If the underlying falls to 85 and the 95 put is assigned, the trader buys the underlying at 95; as long as he exercises (or sells) the 100 put at the same time, he sells at 100, collects the strike width of 5 in all, and the maximum loss is still the debit . The danger lies in the two things not happening together:
- Pin risk. If the closing price on expiry day sits near the short strike, the trader does not know whether he will be assigned; if he is assigned after the long leg has expired, he opens the next trading day holding an unprotected position in the underlying.
- After-hours moves and gaps. Assignment is notified after the close; if the market gaps the next day, a loss that was capped can be breached.
Both lie outside the pricing model. The practical response is to close or roll before expiry, which is where the cost of closing at expiry in the model of Chapter 5 comes from.
Chapter summary
The maximum gain, maximum loss and break-even of a bear put vertical spread hold for European options held to expiry with all costs included; a debit spread’s maximum loss is paid in full at entry, so while both legs remain open it needs no further margin. Skew lowers the cost of entry, while bid–ask spreads compress the room for gain substantially; the expected profit depends on whether the trader has a real directional edge, which the pricing formula itself cannot supply. The short leg of an American spread can be assigned early; with the long leg kept the loss stays capped, but pin risk and gaps lie outside the model.
References
Fan, Y. (2026). Implied Volatility Surfaces, Skew Premia and Quantitative Risk Control of Vertical Spreads: Microstructure Pricing and Time-Stop Dynamics under Non-Gaussian Tails [期权隐含波动率曲面、偏度溢价与垂直价差结构的定量风控] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23796765 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).