5D Library › HPA-Axis Coupled Oscillations, Cortisol Awakening Response Flattening and Burnout Recovery Kinetics · 中文
Chapter 2. What the Pulses Are For
A saturating function of a varying input
If the axis only needed to deliver a certain amount of hormone each day, a steady trickle would do. It does not use a steady trickle, and the reason is that the receptor’s response saturates. A saturating function of a fluctuating input is not the same as the function of the average input, and the direction of the difference is fixed: the average of the function is below the function of the average. So the same daily amount, delivered in pulses, engages the receptor less on average while engaging it more at the peak.
Lightman and Conway-Campbell set out the case that this is the point of the pulsatility rather than a side effect of it, and that a continuously equilibrating system needs the pulses to stay responsive (Lightman and Conway-Campbell 2010). The experimental counterpart is direct. Stavreva and colleagues gave cells the same total hormone as a pulsatile and as a constant exposure and found that the pulsatile exposure drove pulses of gene transcription, while the constant exposure did not reproduce them (Stavreva et al. 2009).
Evidence
Published. Lightman and Conway-Campbell argue that the pulsatile activity of the axis is necessary for continuous dynamic equilibration rather than incidental to it (Lightman and Conway-Campbell 2010). Stavreva and colleagues showed that ultradian hormone pulses produce pulses of receptor-mediated gene transcription that a constant exposure of the same total does not (Stavreva et al. 2009).
Calculation
# Chapter 2. p03: Why the hormone arrives in pulses rather than steadily.
# A receptor's occupancy is a saturating function of the hormone around
# it, and a saturating function of a fluctuating input is not the same as
# the function of its average. Delivering the same daily amount in tall
# brief pulses therefore produces a different mean occupancy from
# delivering it as a flat infusion, and the difference is not a detail:
# it is the whole reason a pulsatile axis can carry a large signal
# without keeping its own receptors permanently engaged.
KD, HILL = 1.0, 1.0 # occupancy half-point and Hill exponent
MEAN, DT, HOURS = 1.0, 0.002, 24.0
PATTERNS = (
# label, pulses a day, duty cycle (share of the day with hormone up)
("flat infusion", 1, 1.000),
("6 broad pulses", 6, 0.500),
("12 pulses", 12, 0.250),
("16 pulses", 16, 0.167),
("24 sharp pulses", 24, 0.100),
("36 sharper pulses", 36, 0.060),
)
def occupancy(c):
return c ** HILL / (KD ** HILL + c ** HILL)
def profile(n_pulses, duty):
# square pulses of height set so the daily mean is MEAN
height = MEAN / duty
period = HOURS / n_pulses
on = period * duty
steps = int(round(HOURS / DT))
out = []
for i in range(steps):
t = (i * DT) % period
out.append(height if t < on else 0.0)
return out
if __name__ == "__main__":
print(" same daily mean of {:.1f} in every pattern".format(MEAN))
print(" pattern peak mean occupancy peak occupancy")
rows = []
for label, n, duty in PATTERNS:
c = profile(n, duty)
occ = [occupancy(v) for v in c]
m = sum(occ) / len(occ)
rows.append((label, max(c), m, max(occ)))
print(" {:<20}{:<8.2f}{:<17.4f}{:.4f}"
.format(label, max(c), m, max(occ)))
flat = rows[0]
print(" occupancy of a flat infusion at the same mean: {:.4f}"
.format(flat[2]))
print(" pattern occupancy relative to flat")
for label, peak, m, pk in rows:
print(" {:<20}{:.4f}".format(label, m / flat[2]))
best = min(rows[1:], key=lambda r: r[2])
print(" the sharpest pattern holds occupancy down to {:.4f} of the"
.format(best[2] / flat[2]))
print(" flat value while delivering the same amount of hormone")
print(" and its peak occupancy is {:.4f} against {:.4f} flat,"
.format(best[3], flat[3]))
print(" so the signal is larger and the average load lower")
print(" peak to mean ratio of occupancy, by pattern:")
for label, peak, m, pk in rows:
print(" {:<20}{:.3f}".format(label, pk / m))
print(" that ratio is the contrast a downstream reader can see,")
print(" and it rises from {:.3f} to {:.3f} across the table"
.format(rows[0][3] / rows[0][2], rows[-1][3] / rows[-1][2]))
# same daily mean of 1.0 in every pattern
# pattern peak mean occupancy peak occupancy
# flat infusion 1.00 0.5000 0.5000
# 6 broad pulses 2.00 0.3333 0.6667
# 12 pulses 4.00 0.2000 0.8000
# 16 pulses 5.99 0.1440 0.8569
# 24 sharp pulses 10.00 0.0916 0.9091
# 36 sharper pulses 16.67 0.0566 0.9434
# occupancy of a flat infusion at the same mean: 0.5000
# pattern occupancy relative to flat
# flat infusion 1.0000
# 6 broad pulses 0.6667
# 12 pulses 0.4000
# 16 pulses 0.2879
# 24 sharp pulses 0.1832
# 36 sharper pulses 0.1132
# the sharpest pattern holds occupancy down to 0.1132 of the
# flat value while delivering the same amount of hormone
# and its peak occupancy is 0.9434 against 0.5000 flat,
# so the signal is larger and the average load lower
# peak to mean ratio of occupancy, by pattern:
# flat infusion 1.000
# 6 broad pulses 2.000
# 12 pulses 4.000
# 16 pulses 5.952
# 24 sharp pulses 9.926
# 36 sharper pulses 16.667
# that ratio is the contrast a downstream reader can see,
# and it rises from 1.000 to 16.667 across the tableEvery pattern in that table carries a daily mean of 1.0. The flat infusion produces a mean occupancy of 0.5000 and a peak occupancy of 0.5000, since nothing varies. The sharpest pattern produces a mean occupancy that is 0.1132 of the flat value while reaching a peak of 0.9434. The ratio of peak to mean rises from 1.000 for the flat infusion to 16.667 for the sharpest pattern.
Those two numbers together are the design. The average load on the receptor, which is what drives the downregulation of Chapter 3, falls by almost an order of magnitude; the height of the signal, which is what a downstream reader can detect, nearly doubles. Pulsatility buys both at once, and nothing else does.
Who can hear a pulse
A pulse is only informative to something fast enough to resolve it. Downstream of the receptor sit processes with very different speeds, and each is modelled here as a first-order integrator with its own time constant.
Calculation
# Chapter 2. p04: What a pulse pattern says, and to whom. Downstream of
# the receptor sit processes with their own speeds: a gene that responds
# within minutes and a remodelling process that takes days. Each is
# modelled as a first-order integrator of receptor occupancy with its
# own time constant. A fast reader follows the pulses and sees their
# height; a slow reader averages them and sees only the daily total. So
# the same daily amount of hormone, delivered in different patterns,
# says different things to different readers, and that is what it means
# for a pattern to carry information the total does not. Each reader is
# run for sixty days and measured over the final twenty-four hours of
# that, so even the slowest has settled and the swing reported is the
# swing within one day rather than a leftover of the approach to it.
KD, HILL = 1.0, 1.0
MEAN, DT, DAYS = 1.0, 0.002, 60.0
READERS = (("fast gene, 0.2 h", 0.2), ("slow gene, 2 h", 2.0),
("tissue, 24 h", 24.0), ("remodelling, 120 h", 120.0))
PATTERNS = (("flat infusion", 1, 1.000), ("12 pulses", 12, 0.250),
("24 sharp pulses", 24, 0.100),
("36 sharper pulses", 36, 0.060))
def occupancy(c):
return c ** HILL / (KD ** HILL + c ** HILL)
def drive(n_pulses, duty, t):
height = MEAN / duty
period = 24.0 / n_pulses
return height if (t % period) < period * duty else 0.0
def response(n_pulses, duty, tau):
y = 0.0
lo = hi = None
steps = int(round(DAYS * 24.0 / DT))
for i in range(steps):
t = i * DT
y += DT * (occupancy(drive(n_pulses, duty, t)) - y) / tau
if t > DAYS * 24.0 - 24.0:
lo = y if lo is None else min(lo, y)
hi = y if hi is None else max(hi, y)
return 0.5 * (lo + hi), hi - lo
if __name__ == "__main__":
print(" mean response of each reader, by pattern")
print(" reader " + "".join("{:>10}".format(p[0][:9])
for p in PATTERNS))
means = {}
for label, tau in READERS:
row = []
for pl, n, duty in PATTERNS:
m, swing = response(n, duty, tau)
means[(label, pl)] = (m, swing)
row.append(m)
print(" {:<20}".format(label)
+ "".join("{:>10.4f}".format(v) for v in row))
print(" swing of each reader, by pattern")
print(" reader " + "".join("{:>10}".format(p[0][:9])
for p in PATTERNS))
for label, tau in READERS:
print(" {:<20}".format(label)
+ "".join("{:>10.4f}".format(means[(label, p[0])][1])
for p in PATTERNS))
print(" ratio of the sharpest pattern to the flat infusion:")
print(" reader mean ratio swing ratio")
for label, tau in READERS:
a = means[(label, "flat infusion")]
b = means[(label, "36 sharper pulses")]
print(" {:<20}{:<13.4f}{}"
.format(label, b[0] / a[0],
"{:.1f}".format(b[1] / a[1]) if a[1] > 1e-5
else "flat has none"))
print(" a flat infusion leaves every reader with no swing at all,")
print(" so pattern is a channel the daily total cannot use")
print(" the fast reader's swing does not simply grow with the pulse")
print(" count; it peaks and then falls, because very brief pulses")
print(" do not give the integrator time to charge:")
print(" pulses a day fast reader swing")
best = None
for n in (2, 4, 6, 8, 12, 16, 24, 36, 48, 72):
duty = min(0.5, 6.0 / n)
m, swing = response(n, duty, 0.2)
if best is None or swing > best[1]:
best = (n, swing)
print(" {:<15d}{:.4f}".format(n, swing))
print(" the swing is largest at {} pulses a day, at {:.4f}"
.format(best[0], best[1]))
print(" and the observed human axis runs near 16, which is inside")
print(" that range rather than at either extreme")
# mean response of each reader, by pattern
# reader flat infu 12 pulses 24 sharp 36 sharpe
# fast gene, 0.2 h 0.5000 0.3678 0.1827 0.0928
# slow gene, 2 h 0.5000 0.2061 0.0923 0.0570
# tissue, 24 h 0.5000 0.2000 0.0909 0.0566
# remodelling, 120 h 0.5000 0.2000 0.0910 0.0566
# swing of each reader, by pattern
# reader flat infu 12 pulses 24 sharp 36 sharpe
# fast gene, 0.2 h 0.0000 0.7348 0.3575 0.1705
# slow gene, 2 h 0.0000 0.1478 0.0409 0.0178
# tissue, 24 h 0.0000 0.0125 0.0034 0.0015
# remodelling, 120 h 0.0000 0.0025 0.0007 0.0003
# ratio of the sharpest pattern to the flat infusion:
# reader mean ratio swing ratio
# fast gene, 0.2 h 0.1856 flat has none
# slow gene, 2 h 0.1141 flat has none
# tissue, 24 h 0.1132 flat has none
# remodelling, 120 h 0.1132 flat has none
# a flat infusion leaves every reader with no swing at all,
# so pattern is a channel the daily total cannot use
# the fast reader's swing does not simply grow with the pulse
# count; it peaks and then falls, because very brief pulses
# do not give the integrator time to charge:
# pulses a day fast reader swing
# 2 0.6667
# 4 0.6667
# 6 0.6666
# 8 0.6660
# 12 0.6580
# 16 0.6787
# 24 0.5627
# 36 0.3593
# 48 0.2363
# 72 0.1172
# the swing is largest at 16 pulses a day, at 0.6787
# and the observed human axis runs near 16, which is inside
# that range rather than at either extremeThe slow readers see almost nothing but the mean. For the twenty-four hour and hundred-and-twenty hour readers the mean falls to 0.1132 for both, which is just the occupancy result of p03 passed through, and their swing within a day is negligible. The fast reader is different: it tracks the pulses, and its swing within a day is large.
But the fast reader’s swing does not simply increase with the pulse rate. It is 0.6667 at two pulses a day, peaks at 0.6787 at 16, and then falls away to 0.1172 at 72, because pulses that are too brief do not give the integrator time to charge. The human axis runs near sixteen pulses a day, which is inside that range rather than at either extreme.
Hypothesis · not established
The author’s interpretation (not yet tested): the pulse rate of the axis is set by the time constants of the fastest transcriptional readers it needs to drive, so species or tissues whose glucocorticoid-responsive genes have slower kinetics should show correspondingly slower pulse rates. What would show it wrong: if measured pulse rates across species were unrelated to the measured response times of their glucocorticoid-responsive transcription, or were better predicted by body mass or metabolic rate, the reading would be wrong.
Summary
At the same daily total, the sharpest pulse pattern holds mean receptor occupancy to 0.1132 of what a flat infusion produces while raising peak occupancy from 0.5000 to 0.9434, and the ratio of peak to mean rises from 1.000 to 16.667. Slow readers see only the mean; a fast reader’s swing peaks at 16 pulses a day, at 0.6787, which is where the human axis sits. Chapter 3 turns to the receptor itself and what the average load does to it.
References
Fan, Y. (2026). HPA-Axis Coupled Oscillations, Cortisol Awakening Response Flattening and Burnout Recovery Kinetics: Glucocorticoid Receptor Downregulation, Ultradian Pulsatility and Allostatic Load Reset [下丘脑垂体肾上腺轴耦合振荡、皮质醇觉醒反应扁平化与倦怠恢复动力学] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090252 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).