5D Library › Dream Motif Bipartite Graphs, Deterministic Oracle Decks and Subconscious Prior Activation · 中文

Chapter 7. The Six Dreams of the Rites of Zhou, Wang Fu’s Ten Kinds of Dream, the Dunhuang Dream Book and Jung’s Synchronicity

Why read these sources here

The three problems of this book have old counterparts: how to classify dreams, how to read them, and how to judge a striking coincidence. This chapter reads four sources and asks which of their ideas survive the arithmetic of the previous chapters. Two points come out: the six dreams of the Rites of Zhou classify the state in which a dream arises, not its message; and Wang Fu, who listed both “direct” and “reverse” dreams, himself required the reader to weigh the dreamer’s circumstances and feelings, which is what turns a dream into evidence about the dreamer rather than about the future.

The dream diviner of the Rites of Zhou

Source text

Rites of Zhou, “Offices of Spring”, the dream diviner (zhan meng)

占梦:掌其岁时,观天地之会,辨阴阳之气,以日月星辰占六梦之吉凶:一曰正梦,二曰噩梦,三曰思梦,四曰寤梦,五曰喜梦,六曰惧梦。

(郑玄 and 贾公彦 1980)

“The dream diviner is in charge of its seasons and times; he observes the meetings of heaven and earth, distinguishes the breaths of yin and yang, and by the sun, moon, stars and markers divines the fortune of the six dreams: first, plain dreams; second, startled dreams; third, dreams of thought; fourth, dreams of waking; fifth, dreams of joy; sixth, dreams of fear.” The six names describe the condition of the dreamer: calm, alarmed, preoccupied, half-awake, glad, afraid. Read this way, the list is closer to a coding scheme for emotion in dreams (Hall and Van de Castle 1966) than to a dictionary of omens, and the divination proper is attached to calendar and sky, not to the images.

Wang Fu’s ten kinds of dream

Source text

Wang Fu, Qianfu lun, “Meng lie”

凡梦:有直,有象,有精,有想,有人,有感,有时,有反,有病,有性。

孔子生于乱世,日思周公之德,夜即梦之,此谓意精之梦也。

夫占梦,必谨其变故,审其征候,内考情意,外考王相,即吉凶之符,善恶之效,庶可见也。

(王符 et al. 1985)

“Dreams are of these kinds: direct, symbolic, of concentrated mind, of thought, personal, responsive, seasonal, reverse, of illness, of temperament … Confucius, born in a disordered age, thought by day of the virtue of the Duke of Zhou and dreamed of him by night: this is called a dream of concentrated intent … In divining a dream one must attend to changes and causes, examine signs, consider within the feelings and intentions, and consider without the waxing and waning of circumstance; then the tokens of fortune and the effects of good and bad may perhaps be seen.” The list contains both “direct” and “reverse” dreams, the pair that Chapter 2 showed cannot fail when chosen after the event. But Wang Fu’s last sentence asks the reader to consider the dreamer’s feelings and circumstances first. The computation below separates the two readings.

Calculation

# Chapter 7. p13: Wang Fu's ten kinds of dream, read before or after.
# (1) 10,000 dreams each carry good or bad news; outcomes are good or bad
# at random, independent of the dream. A reader who must label a dream
# "direct" or "reverse" BEFORE the outcome is right half the time; one
# who may choose the label AFTER it is always right. (2) A common cause:
# stress (probability 0.30) makes a fearful dream likelier (0.50 vs
# 0.15) and a bad outcome likelier (0.60 vs 0.35). Fearful dreams then
# "predict" bad outcomes, and the link vanishes once stress is known.
import random

if __name__ == "__main__":
    rng = random.Random(89)
    n, pre, post = 10000, 0, 0
    for _ in range(n):
        dream_good = rng.random() < 0.5
        outcome_good = rng.random() < 0.5
        label = "reverse" if rng.random() < 0.3 else "direct"
        pred = dream_good if label == "direct" else not dream_good
        pre += pred == outcome_good
        post += 1      # either "direct" or "reverse" fits afterwards
    print("   labelled before: {:.3f} right; after: {:.3f}".format(
        pre / n, post / n))
    cells = {}
    for _ in range(100000):
        s = rng.random() < 0.30
        fear = rng.random() < (0.50 if s else 0.15)
        bad = rng.random() < (0.60 if s else 0.35)
        c = cells.setdefault((s, fear), [0, 0])
        c[0] += bad
        c[1] += 1
    def rate(keys):
        return sum(cells[k][0] for k in keys) / sum(cells[k][1]
                                                    for k in keys)
    print("   P(bad | fearful dream) {:.3f}, P(bad | other) {:.3f}".format(
        rate([(True, True), (False, True)]),
        rate([(True, False), (False, False)])))
    for s in (True, False):
        print("   stress={}: fearful {:.3f}, other {:.3f}".format(
            "yes" if s else "no ", rate([(s, True)]), rate([(s, False)])))
#    labelled before: 0.501 right; after: 1.000
#    P(bad | fearful dream) 0.494, P(bad | other) 0.406
#    stress=yes: fearful 0.595, other 0.612
#    stress=no : fearful 0.354, other 0.354

A reader who labels a dream “direct” or “reverse” before the outcome is right 0.501 of the time, chance; one who chooses afterwards is right 1.000 of the time and has learned nothing. Wang Fu’s “consider within the feelings” points to a real mechanism: if stress makes both fearful dreams and bad outcomes likelier, fearful dreams do “predict” bad outcomes (0.494 against 0.406), and the link disappears once stress is known (0.595 against 0.612 under stress, 0.354 against 0.354 without). A dream can carry information about the dreamer’s state, as his “dream of concentrated intent” about Confucius does; it need not carry information about the world.

The Dunhuang dream book

Among the manuscripts found early in the twentieth century in the Mogao caves at Dunhuang is a “Newly Compiled Book of the Duke of Zhou’s Dream Interpretations” (Xinji Zhougong jiemeng shu), probably copied in the Tang. It has a preface of about 150 characters and 23 chapters arranged by subject, such as heaven, earth, mountains and plants, water, fire and thieves, and dreams by the day of the twelve branches; each entry has the form “whoever dreams of A, B follows”; it is the oldest complete dream book that survives (湯浅邦弘 1995). In the language of Chapter 1, it is a printed list of strong edges. Its arrangement by the day of the dream also shows that the same image could be read differently on different days, adding a further degree of freedom to the reading.

Jung’s synchronicity

In his 1952 essay on synchronicity, Jung described “meaningful coincidences” that he held to be acausal, the best known being a patient’s dream of a golden scarab told at the moment a rose-chafer beetle tapped at the consulting-room window (Jung 1952). Littlewood’s count (Chapter 5) asks how many chances such a career offers.

Calculation

# Chapter 7. p14: Jung's scarab as a counting problem. An analyst sees
# 1,000 sessions a year for 25 years; in each, a patient reports a dream
# with 4 animal or object motifs. The chance that one of those things
# turns up in the room or at the window during that hour is taken as
# 1 in 20,000, 1 in 100,000 or 1 in 1,000,000 per motif (illustrative).
# Expected count and P(at least one) for one career, and the expected
# number of such stories among 1,000 analysts.
import math

if __name__ == "__main__":
    chances = 25 * 1000 * 4
    print("   motif-hours in one career: {:,}".format(chances))
    for odds in (20000, 100000, 1000000):
        lam = chances / odds
        print("   1 in {:>9,}: expected {:.2f}, P(at least one) {:.3f}"
              .format(odds, lam, 1 - math.exp(-lam)))
        print("                   stories among 1,000 analysts: {:,.0f}"
              .format(1000 * lam))
#    motif-hours in one career: 100,000
#    1 in    20,000: expected 5.00, P(at least one) 0.993
#                    stories among 1,000 analysts: 5,000
#    1 in   100,000: expected 1.00, P(at least one) 0.632
#                    stories among 1,000 analysts: 1,000
#    1 in 1,000,000: expected 0.10, P(at least one) 0.095
#                    stories among 1,000 analysts: 100

An analyst with 1,000 sessions a year for 25 years hears about 100,000 motif-hours of dreams. If the chance that a given motif turns up in the room or at the window during the hour is 1 in 20,000, about 5.00 such events are expected in one career and the probability of at least one is 0.993; at 1 in 1,000,000 the probability is still 0.095, and among 1,000 analysts about 100 such stories arise. A single remarkable case does not distinguish an acausal principle from a large number of opportunities.

Hypothesis · not established

The author’s interpretation (not yet tested): the six dreams of the Rites of Zhou, coded from dream reports by blind raters, predict the dreamer’s self-reported stress the next day better than chance, but not next-day outcomes once stress is known. What would show it wrong: the six-dream codes predict next-day outcomes even after stress is accounted for, or do not predict stress at all.

Summary

The six dreams classify the dreamer’s state; Wang Fu’s ten kinds include the unfalsifiable pair of direct and reverse dreams, but his method of considering feelings and circumstances is what can make a dream informative, about the dreamer. The Dunhuang dream book is a printed list of strong edges, arranged by subject and by day. Jung’s scarab is an expected event for a long career.

References

Hall, Calvin S., and Robert L. Van de Castle. 1966. The Content Analysis of Dreams. Appleton-Century-Crofts.
Jung, Carl Gustav. 1952. “Synchronizität Als Ein Prinzip Akausaler Zusammenhänge.” In Naturerklärung Und Psyche, edited by Carl Gustav Jung and Wolfgang Pauli. Rascher.
湯浅邦弘. 1995. “夢の書の行方:敦煌本『新集周公解夢書』の研究.” 待兼山論叢 哲学篇 29: 1 to 15.
王符, 汪继培, and 彭铎. 1985. 潜夫论笺校正. 中华书局.
郑玄, and 贾公彦. 1980. 周礼注疏. 十三经注疏(阮元校刻本). 中华书局.

Fan, Y. (2026). Dream Motif Bipartite Graphs, Deterministic Oracle Decks and Subconscious Prior Activation: REM Semantic Spreading, SHA-256 Fisher-Yates Permutations and Retroactive Coincidence Rates [梦境意象二分图、确定性哈希牌卡与潜意识先验激活] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090233 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).