5D Library › 诊学一体转化漏斗、掌握度门控课程与持牌人网络经济学 · English

第一章 自蚕食边界:课程何时多赚

问题:教会读者自己算,会不会砸了自己的饭碗

一位每年买三次测算的读者,一旦学会自己算,就不再买测算。课程收入是一次性的,测算收入是持续的;课程卖得越好,零售收入越少。这是一个典型的「自蚕食」问题。产品经济学中,卖家推出替代自己旧产品的新产品,只有当新产品的收入加上它带来的后续收入超过被替代的旧收入时才有利。

证据

相关的已发表结论。 (1)质量不可观察时,市场会被低质量供给侵蚀,这是 Akerlof 的「柠檬市场」(Akerlof 1970);执业牌照的一个经典理由正是设立最低质量标准,以阻止这种侵蚀 (Leland 1979)。(2)教育与资格证书即使不改变能力,也可以作为能力的信号起作用 (Spence 1973)。本章只用这两条做背景:课程的价值一部分来自它所通向的牌照,而牌照的价值取决于它是否真的过滤了质量(第五章)。

一位读者的账

设读者每年买 r=3r = 3 次测算,单价 39,毛利率 0.85;每年以 0.70 的概率继续做客户,现金按 10% 贴现,期限十年。课程价 480,毛利率 0.90,学完后不再买测算。牌照漏斗:比例 ee 的毕业生参加考试,其中比例 qq 通过,持牌人每年付 1,200 的牌照费(毛利率 0.70),续期概率 0.80。

推导

# Chapter 1. [p01] Self-cannibalization bound and the licence funnel.
# A reader buys r retail readings a year at price p with gross margin g,
# stays a customer each year with probability s, and cash is discounted
# at rate d over a 10-year horizon:
#     PV_retail = sum_{t<10} r p g (s / (1 + d))^t.
# A course at price P (margin gc) ends retail buying: the graduate now
# reads for himself. Without anything after the course, it pays only if
#     gc P > PV_retail          (the self-cannibalization bound).
# The licence funnel: a share e of graduates sit the exam, a share q of
# them pass, and a licensee pays L a year (margin gl), renewing with
# probability u. PV_after = e q PV_licence.

P_READ, R, G, S, D = 39.0, 3.0, 0.85, 0.70, 0.10
P_COURSE, GC = 480.0, 0.90
L, GL, U = 1200, 0.70, 0.80
YEARS = 10

def annuity(cash, keep):
    k = keep / (1 + D)
    return sum(cash * k ** t for t in range(YEARS))

if __name__ == "__main__":
    pv_retail = annuity(R * P_READ * G, S)
    pv_lic = annuity(L * GL, U)
    print("   PV of retail readings per reader : {:8.2f}".format(pv_retail))
    print("   course price that only breaks even: {:8.2f}".format(
        pv_retail / GC))
    print("   PV of one licence ({:,d} a year)  : {:8.2f}".format(L, pv_lic))
    print("   course LTV / retail LTV, P = {:.0f}:".format(P_COURSE))
    print("     exam take-up e   q=0.10   q=0.25   q=0.50")
    for e in (0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6):
        row = []
        for q in (0.10, 0.25, 0.50):
            ltv = GC * P_COURSE + e * q * pv_lic
            row.append(ltv / pv_retail)
        print("     {:14.1f} {:8.2f} {:8.2f} {:8.2f}".format(e, *row))
    for e, q in ((0.1, 0.10), (0.4, 0.25)):
        need = (pv_retail - e * q * pv_lic) / GC
        print("   e={:.1f}, q={:.2f}: break-even course price {:8.2f}".format(
            e, q, need))
    print("\nReading: a 480 course is already worth 1.60 times the")
    print("retail stream it ends; the licence funnel adds a long tail,")
    print("and a strong funnel alone covers the readings it replaces")
    print("(a negative break-even price means the course could be free).")
    print("'Several times' needs both exam take-up and pass rate to be")
    print("high: at e = 0.4 and q = 0.25 the ratio is 2.69, not 5.")
#    PV of retail readings per reader :   270.51
#    course price that only breaks even:   300.57
#    PV of one licence (1,200 a year)  :  2952.50
#    course LTV / retail LTV, P = 480:
#      exam take-up e   q=0.10   q=0.25   q=0.50
#                 0.0     1.60     1.60     1.60
#                 0.2     1.82     2.14     2.69
#                 0.4     2.03     2.69     3.78
#                 0.6     2.25     3.23     4.87
#    e=0.1, q=0.10: break-even course price   267.76
#    e=0.4, q=0.25: break-even course price   -27.49
#
# Reading: a 480 course is already worth 1.60 times the
# retail stream it ends; the licence funnel adds a long tail,
# and a strong funnel alone covers the readings it replaces
# (a negative break-even price means the course could be free).
# 'Several times' needs both exam take-up and pass rate to be
# high: at e = 0.4 and q = 0.25 the ratio is 2.69, not 5.
课程终身价值与零售终身价值之比,随通过率与参考率变化。

一位读者的零售现值是 270.51,所以不计牌照,课程价只要高于 300.57 就不亏。480 的课程本身已相当于零售现值的 1.60 倍。牌照的现值是 2952.50,远高于零售测算;只要有一部分毕业生走完漏斗,课程的终身价值就迅速上升:参考率 0.4、通过率 0.25 时是 2.69 倍,参考率 0.6、通过率 0.50 时是 4.87 倍。漏斗足够强时(e=0.4e = 0.4,q=0.25q = 0.25),盈亏平衡的课程价变成 -27.49:牌照收入本身就足以弥补被替代的零售收入,课程甚至可以免费。漏斗很弱时(e=0.1e = 0.1,q=0.10q = 0.10),平衡价是 267.76,与不计牌照时相差不大。

所以「LTV 提高数倍」并不是课程本身的性质,而是牌照漏斗的性质;它需要参考率与通过率同时足够高。

谁会买课程

上面的账把每位读者当成平均读者。现实中,最想学会自己算的,恰恰是买测算最多的人。程序用 20,000 位模拟读者检验这一点:每年的测算次数服从对数正态分布(中位数 1.5),读者对课程的估值随测算次数上升。

推导

# Chapter 1. [p02] Who buys the course? Self-selection by heavy readers.
# 20,000 simulated readers differ in how many readings a year they buy:
# r is lognormal with median 1.5 and log-sd 0.9. A reader values the
# course at v = 60 + 110 r times a lognormal taste (log-sd 0.4) and buys
# it when v > P. Heavy readers value self-reading most, so the course
# selects exactly the readers whose retail stream it ends. Net gain of
# offering the course at P (retail margins and horizon as in p01; the
# funnel at e = 0.4, q = 0.25):
#     sum over buyers of (gc P + e q PV_licence - PV_retail(r)).
import math
import random

G, S, D, P_READ, GC = 0.85, 0.70, 0.10, 39.0, 0.90
YEARS, PV_LIC, E, Q = 10, 2952.50, 0.4, 0.25

def pv_retail(r):
    k = S / (1 + D)
    return sum(r * P_READ * G * k ** t for t in range(YEARS))

if __name__ == "__main__":
    rng = random.Random(74002)
    pop = []
    for _ in range(20000):
        r = 1.5 * math.exp(rng.gauss(0, 0.9))
        v = (60 + 110 * r) * math.exp(rng.gauss(0, 0.4))
        pop.append((r, v))
    mean_all = sum(pv_retail(r) for r, _ in pop) / len(pop)
    print("   mean retail PV, all readers: {:8.2f}".format(mean_all))
    print("      P buyers mean r buyers' PV  net/buyer  net/buyer  per 1000")
    print("                                 no funnel  w/ funnel   readers")
    for P in (180, 300, 480, 720, 960):
        b = [r for r, v in pop if v > P]
        pv_b = sum(pv_retail(r) for r in b) / len(b)
        n0 = GC * P - pv_b
        n1 = n0 + E * Q * PV_LIC
        sh = len(b) / len(pop)
        print("   {:4d} {:6.3f} {:6.2f} {:10.2f} {:10.2f} {:10.2f} {:9.0f}"
              .format(P, sh, sum(b) / len(b), pv_b, n0, n1, 1000 * sh * n1))
    print("\nReading: the readers who buy the course are the heaviest")
    print("retail buyers, so the retail stream it ends is well above")
    print("the average reader's. Priced on the average, the bound")
    print("of p01 is too lax; without the funnel the course loses money")
    print("on its buyers at every price up to 720. With the funnel, the")
    print("total per 1,000 readers is highest at the lowest price.")
#    mean retail PV, all readers:   203.38
#       P buyers mean r buyers' PV  net/buyer  net/buyer  per 1000
#                                  no funnel  w/ funnel   readers
#     180  0.636   3.06     275.82    -113.82     181.43    115370
#     300  0.370   4.08     368.32     -98.32     196.93     72807
#     480  0.184   5.54     499.25     -67.25     228.00     42010
#     720  0.085   7.45     671.83     -23.83     271.42     23017
#     960  0.045   9.25     833.88      30.12     325.37     14755
#
# Reading: the readers who buy the course are the heaviest
# retail buyers, so the retail stream it ends is well above
# the average reader's. Priced on the average, the bound
# of p01 is too lax; without the funnel the course loses money
# on its buyers at every price up to 720. With the funnel, the
# total per 1,000 readers is highest at the lowest price.

全体读者的平均零售现值是 203.38,但课程的买家远高于平均:课程价 480 时,买家每年平均买 5.54 次测算,零售现值 499.25;课程价 180 时,买家的零售现值是 275.82。若没有牌照漏斗,课程在 180、300、480、720 每个价位都在买家身上亏钱(480 时每位买家亏 67.25);只有在 960,买家只剩 0.045,课程才在买家身上略有盈余 30.12。

这就是「逆向自选择」:课程吸引的正是它会替代掉最多零售收入的人。用平均读者来算第一节的边界会过于宽松。加上牌照漏斗后,每位买家的净收益都转为正值,而每千位读者的总净收益在最低价位 180 时最高(115370),因为在本模型中每位毕业生进入漏斗的机会相同。这一点是模型假设,不是结论:如果重度读者也更可能参加考试并持牌,最低价位未必最优。

假说 · 尚未验证

作者的诠释(尚未验证): 在作者的业务中,课程的买家主要是已经购买多次测算的老读者,因此课程不应当按「新增收入」评估,而应当按「替代的零售收入 + 牌照漏斗」评估;没有牌照漏斗的课程是在自蚕食。什么会证明这一判断错:若真实数据(而非本书的参数)显示课程买家在购课前一年的测算次数与未购课读者没有显著差别,或者购课后他们的测算购买并未下降,那么逆向自选择不存在,第一节的平均边界就足够。

小结

课程本身只抵得上它所终止的零售收入的 1.60 倍;终身价值能否提高数倍,取决于牌照漏斗的参考率与通过率。买课程的是重度读者,他们放弃的零售现值是平均读者的两倍以上,因此没有牌照漏斗的课程在多数价位上是亏的。牌照漏斗的价值又取决于牌照是否可信,这留给第五章。

参考文献

Akerlof, George A. 1970. “The Market for ‘Lemons’: Quality Uncertainty and the Market Mechanism.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 84 (3): 488–500.
Leland, Hayne E. 1979. “Quacks, Lemons, and Licensing: A Theory of Minimum Quality Standards.” Journal of Political Economy 87 (6): 1328–46.
Spence, Michael. 1973. “Job Market Signaling.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 87 (3): 355–74.

Fan, Y. (2026). Diagnostic-to-Pedagogy Conversion Funnels, Mastery-Gated Curriculum Architecture and Certification Network Economics: Self-Cannibalization Bounds, Spaced-Retrieval Curves and Two-Sided Practitioner Licensing [诊学一体转化漏斗、掌握度门控课程与持牌人网络经济学] (Version 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24090197 · Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).