关于「现金门槛:印花税阶梯、交易费用与三问合成评分」,《资质三问、同天连看与独家委托》给出的定量结论是什么?

结论:示意房价 500,000、成数 0.90 时,第一问背后的现金门槛是 72,250,占房价 0.1445,比一成首付多出 22,250。印花税阶梯是累进的,跨档时平滑过渡,没有悬崖,任何压低合约价或价外安排的说法都没有算术依据,也不合规。三道题答案相关时,朴素贝叶斯会高估一致答案的后验,但「二二一」打分的排序能力不受影响;概率应当用台账回填校准。

数据口径:第一句被证伪:每多问一题,完成率下降,准确率的边际增益递减;示意参数下,现金、偿债比与时间表三问使每条线索的期望净价值达到峰值 129.21,但最优题数随每题留存比例在二到五题之间移动,三问是区间结论而不是定律。 第二句只对了一半:锚定在房价判断中真实存在,诺斯克拉夫特与尼尔的数字隐含锚定权重 0.4850;诱饵效应在真实可感的选择里通常不出现,示意账本中诱饵要胜过真比较房,效应须超过 0.1200。

English version

对照数据表

下表数字由本章 Python 程序原样打印,可重新运行复现。 程序只用 Python 标准库与结论吻合的打印值: 0.1445, 0.90, 22250, 500000, 72250

price 500,000LTV 0.90
down payment50,000
transfer duty9,000
loan duty2,250
legal, sale5,000
legal, loan4,500
disbursements1,500
total cash 72,250 = 0.1445 of price
price 500,000 LTV 0.90 (exemption scenario)
down payment50,000
transfer duty0
loan duty0
legal, sale5,000
legal, loan4,500
disbursements1,500
total cash 61,000 = 0.1220 of price
price 750,000LTV 0.90
down payment75,000
transfer duty16,500
loan duty3,375
legal, sale7,500
legal, loan6,750
disbursements1,500
total cash 110,625 = 0.1475 of price
price 750,000LTV 0.70
down payment225,000
transfer duty16,500
loan duty2,625
查看完整验算程序
# Chapter 3. p32: the cash threshold behind question one.
# Cash needed on signing and completion = down payment (1 - LTV) * price
# + transfer duty (bands of p31) + loan agreement duty (0.5 per cent of
# the loan) + legal fees on the sale agreement and on the loan (each an
# illustrative 0.010 of its base) + a flat disbursement allowance. A
# first-home exemption case sets both duties to zero, as a scenario
# only: eligibility and limits follow the relief in force at the time.
from fractions import Fraction

BANDS = [(100000, Fraction(1, 100)), (400000, Fraction(2, 100)),
         (500000, Fraction(3, 100)), (None, Fraction(4, 100))]
LEGAL = Fraction(1, 100)       # illustrative, per document base
DISBURSE = 1500                # illustrative flat allowance


def transfer_duty(price):
    left, duty = price, Fraction(0)
    for width, rate in BANDS:
        take = left if width is None else min(left, width)
        if take <= 0:
            break
        duty += take * rate
        left -= take
    return duty


def cash_needed(price, ltv, exempt=False):
    loan = price * ltv
    lines = [("down payment", price - loan),
             ("transfer duty", 0 if exempt else transfer_duty(price)),
             ("loan duty", 0 if exempt else loan * Fraction(5, 1000)),
             ("legal, sale", price * LEGAL),
             ("legal, loan", loan * LEGAL),
             ("disbursements", Fraction(DISBURSE))]
    total = Fraction(0)
    for _, v in lines:
        total += v
    return lines, total


if __name__ == "__main__":
    for price, ltv, ex in ((500000, Fraction(9, 10), False),
                           (500000, Fraction(9, 10), True),
                           (750000, Fraction(9, 10), False),
                           (750000, Fraction(7, 10), False)):
        lines, total = cash_needed(price, ltv, ex)
        print("price {:,}  LTV {:.2f}{}".format(
            price, float(ltv), "  (exemption scenario)" if ex else ""))
        for lab, v in lines:
            print("   {:<14} {:>9,}".format(lab, int(v)))
        print("   {:<14} {:>9,}   = {:.4f} of price".format(
            "total cash", int(total), float(total / price)))
    print("a buyer who budgets only 10 per cent for a 500,000 home is short"
          " by {:,}".format(int(cash_needed(500000, Fraction(9, 10))[1]
                                - 50000)))

唯一数据源与引用

范雅福(Fan, Y.). (2026). 《房产高意向客资质三问秒筛、多盘同天连看逼单与房东独家委托母典》第 3 章「现金门槛:印花税阶梯、交易费用与三问合成评分」(版本 1.0.0). 5D Library. DOI 待发布

DOI 待发布 · 专著页正式发布后上线(本站暂无专著页) · 5DL-B-355 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

BibTeX
@book{fan2026355,
  author    = {Fan, Yafu},
  title     = {Three-Question Property Lead Qualification, Same-Day Multi-Viewing Closing Kinetics and Exclusive Landlord Mandates},
  year      = {2026},
  publisher = {5D Library},
  edition   = {1.0.0},
  note      = {DOI pending}
}

本书其他章节结论