关于「杠铃配置与随机占优」,《流动性体制、尾部相依与杠铃配置》给出的定量结论是什么?

结论:「90% 短债 + 10% 期权」的杠铃组合有名义下限与凸的上尾,但「随机占优」在一般意义上不成立。本书证明:有保底的杠铃组合不可能被股票一阶或二阶占优;当期权作废的概率高于股票跌破保底的概率时(本章模型中 56.4% 对 20.5%),它也不可能一阶占优股票;二阶占优要求期望收益不低,而这取决于期权的价格。在作者的跳跃扩散模型中,杠铃在四种期权定价下对股票、对 90/10 线性组合都不构成一阶或二阶占优;期权偏贵时,它反而被 90/10 线性组合二阶占优。期权长期偏贵(方差风险溢价)意味着杠铃的期权仓位多数年份是在交保险费。CPPI 是动态的保底方法,乘数越大,跳空击穿保底的风险越大。

数据口径:危机来临时,资产会一起下跌吗?储备与安全垫要留多少才够?本书是教学与研究用的数学模型,不是投资建议。 作者要求证明「90% 短债 + 10% 期权」的杠铃配置随机占优;书中证明它不可能被股票占优,且在期权作废的概率高于股票跌破保底的概率时(本书模型即如此)也不可能一阶占优于股票,并在跳跃扩散模型的四种期权定价下显示它对股票、对 90/10 线性组合都不构成一阶或二阶占优,期权偏贵时反而被 90/10 线性组合二阶占优;CPPI 在乘数 6 时有 6.4% 的年份跌破保底线。

English version

对照数据表

下表数字由本章 Python 程序原样打印,可重新运行复现。 程序只用 Python 标准库与结论吻合的打印值: 10, 56.4, 90

stock: total volatility 0.175; simulated mean return +0.080;
calls expire worthless in 56.4% of years
calls cheap, iv 0.13    : price 0.0263; mean return of the call sleeve +144.4%
calls equal, iv 0.175   : price 0.0431; mean return of the call sleeve  +49.1%
calls rich, iv 0.22     : price 0.0606; mean return of the call sleeve   +6.1%
calls very rich, iv 0.28: price 0.0843; mean return of the call sleeve  -23.7%
portfolio                       mean     sd   P(<-10%)  1% quantile  P(>+30%)
stock                          +0.080  0.187    16.3%     -0.323      11.8%
90 % bills + 10 % stock        +0.035  0.019     0.0%     -0.005       0.0%
barbell, cheap, iv 0.13        +0.171  0.414     0.0%     -0.073      24.8%
barbell, equal, iv 0.175       +0.076  0.253     0.0%     -0.073      16.0%
barbell, rich, iv 0.22         +0.033  0.180     0.0%     -0.073       9.5%
barbell, very rich, iv 0.28    +0.003  0.129     0.0%     -0.073       4.4%
dominance (row over column):   stock     90/10 linear  bills (+3 %)
barbell, cheap, iv 0.13        none      none          none
barbell, equal, iv 0.175       none      none          none
barbell, rich, iv 0.22         none      none          none
barbell, very rich, iv 0.28    none      none          none
over the four barbells (cheap, equal, rich, very rich):
stock                          none   none   none   none
90 % bills + 10 % stock        none   none   SSD    SSD
bills (+3 %)                   none   none   none   SSD
查看完整验算程序
# Does a barbell (90 % one-year bills + 10 % one-year calls) stochastically dominate?
# ILLUSTRATIVE 1-year model: bills 3 %; stock = Merton jump-diffusion (diffusion sd 0.15,
# 0.5 jumps a year with log size N(-0.08, 0.10)), expected return 8 %. Calls struck 10 %
# out of the money, bought at the Black-Scholes price with an implied volatility that is
# rich, equal or cheap relative to the stock's total volatility. 200,000 simulated years.
# First-order dominance: F_A <= F_B everywhere; second-order: integral of F_A <= of F_B.
import math, random, statistics

R, SIG, LAM, JM, JS, MU = 0.03, 0.15, 0.5, -0.08, 0.10, 0.08
K = 1.10
TOT = math.sqrt(SIG ** 2 + LAM * (JM ** 2 + JS ** 2))
KAP = math.exp(JM + JS ** 2 / 2) - 1

def stock_draw(rng):
    n, t = 0, rng.expovariate(LAM)
    while t < 1:
        n += 1; t += rng.expovariate(LAM)
    lr = (math.log(1 + MU) - LAM * KAP - SIG ** 2 / 2 + SIG * rng.gauss(0, 1)
          + sum(rng.gauss(JM, JS) for _ in range(n)))
    return math.exp(lr)

def bs_call(s, k, vol, r=math.log(1 + R), t=1.0):
    d1 = (math.log(s / k) + (r + vol * vol / 2) * t) / (vol * math.sqrt(t))
    N = statistics.NormalDist().cdf
    return s * N(d1) - k * math.exp(-r * t) * N(d1 - vol * math.sqrt(t))

def cdfs(sample, grid):
    s = sorted(sample); n = len(s); out, j = [], 0
    for x in grid:
        while j < n and s[j] <= x:
            j += 1
        out.append(j / n)
    return out

def dominance(a, b, grid, dx):
    Fa, Fb = cdfs(a, grid), cdfs(b, grid)
    fsd = all(x <= y + 0.002 for x, y in zip(Fa, Fb))
    Ia = Ib = 0.0; ssd = True
    for x, y in zip(Fa, Fb):
        Ia += x * dx; Ib += y * dx
        ssd = ssd and Ia <= Ib + 0.0005
    return "FSD" if fsd else ("SSD" if ssd else "none")

if __name__ == "__main__":
    rng = random.Random(1992)
    S = [stock_draw(rng) for _ in range(200_000)]
    grid = [-0.9 + 0.002 * i for i in range(1451)]; dx = 0.002
    stock = [s - 1 for s in S]; linear = [0.9 * (1 + R) + 0.1 * s - 1 for s in S]
    print(f"stock: total volatility {TOT:.3f}; simulated mean return"
          f" {statistics.fmean(stock):+.3f};")
    print(f"calls expire worthless in {sum(s <= K for s in S) / len(S):.1%} of years")
    rows = [("stock", stock), ("90 % bills + 10 % stock", linear)]
    for lab, vol in (("cheap, iv 0.13", 0.13), ("equal, iv 0.175", 0.175),
                     ("rich, iv 0.22", 0.22), ("very rich, iv 0.28", 0.28)):
        c = bs_call(1.0, K, vol)
        calls = [max(s - K, 0) / c - 1 for s in S]
        bar = [0.9 * (1 + R) + 0.1 * (1 + x) - 1 for x in calls]
        print(f"calls {lab:18s}: price {c:.4f}; mean return of the call sleeve"
              f" {statistics.fmean(calls):+7.1%}")
        rows.append((f"barbell, {lab}", bar))
    print("portfolio                       mean     sd   P(<-10%)  1% quantile  P(>+30%)")
    for lab, x in rows:
        s = sorted(x)
        print(f"{lab:30s} {statistics.fmean(x):+.3f}  {statistics.pstdev(x):.3f}"
              f"   {sum(v < -0.10 for v in x) / len(x):6.1%}     {s[len(s) // 100]:+.3f}"
              f"     {sum(v > 0.30 for v in x) / len(x):6.1%}")
    print("dominance (row over column):   stock     90/10 linear  bills (+3 %)")
    bills = [R] * len(stock)
    for lab, x in rows[2:]:
        dm = [dominance(x, y, grid, dx) for y in (stock, linear, bills)]
        print(f"{lab:30s} {dm[0]:8s}  {dm[1]:8s}      {dm[2]}")
    print("over the four barbells (cheap, equal, rich, very rich):")
    for lab, x in rows[:2] + [("bills (+3 %)", bills)]:
        dm = [dominance(x, y, grid, dx) for _, y in rows[2:]]
        print((f"{lab:30s} " + "  ".join(f"{v:5s}" for v in dm)).rstrip())

唯一数据源与引用

范雅福(Fan, Y.). (2026). 《宏观流动性体制转换、极值尾部相依与杠铃资产配置》第 5 章「杠铃配置与随机占优」(版本 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23828049

DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23828049 · 阅读本章所在专著 · 5DL-B-040 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

BibTeX
@book{fan2026040,
  author    = {Fan, Yafu},
  title     = {Macro-Liquidity Regime Switching, Extreme Tail Dependence and Barbell Asset Allocation},
  year      = {2026},
  publisher = {5D Library},
  edition   = {1.0.0},
  doi       = {10.5281/zenodo.23828049},
  url       = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23828049}
}

本书其他章节结论