关于「实践与预注册试验」,《心理物理学与多感官整合》给出的定量结论是什么?
结论:四步核查表依次检查:是否依赖一个可能失效的单一通道、微弱信号是否有第二通道的同步支持、视听时间差是否在不对称的窗口之内(声音提前不超过约 45 毫秒、延后不超过约 125 毫秒),以及学习者有多少时间在主动探索。预注册试验在相同的视听条件下,比较「把实时音高或共振峰误差编码为前臂振动」与「佩戴同款但不振动的设备」两种训练对 24 小时后无反馈音高模仿误差的影响:唯一的主要结局以音分计,先做 20 人的外部预试验,再按写成代码的规则(标准差取 80% 置信上限、最小关注差异固定为 20 音分、每组 150 至 350 人)确定样本量,计划值为每组 191 名可分析(招募 225 名),判定规则写成代码,并有嗓音负荷与振动的安全条款,无论结果如何都发表。
数据口径:物理强度与主观感觉之间是什么关系?大脑怎样把几种各有噪声的感觉合成一个判断?本书用心理物理学与贝叶斯模型回答这两个问题。 本书不是医疗建议,不能诊断任何感官或神经疾病。
对照数据表
下表数字由本章 Python 程序原样打印,可重新运行复现。 程序只用 Python 标准库与结论吻合的打印值: 150, 191, 20, 225, 350, 80
| check | 16% poor-pitch singers (229 c), rest 30 c -> mean 61 c; split alone gives SD 72 c |
| plan: SD 75, r 0.6, SESOI 20 (d | 0.27), 90 % power: 191 per arm, recruit 225 (450) |
| analysable per arm SESOI 15 | 20 30 |
| SD 60, r 0.4 | 284 160 72 |
| SD 60, r 0.6 | 217 123 55 |
| SD 75, r 0.4 | 443 250 112 |
| SD 75, r 0.6 | 338 191 86 |
| SD 90, r 0.4 | 637 359 160 |
| SD 90, r 0.6 | 486 274 123 |
| pilot of 10 per arm: SE of an arm difference about 27 c (SESOI 20) | |
| 80 % upper limit with df 18: SD x 1.183, so n x 1.40 | |
| pilot SD, r -> SD used, r used -> n per arm -> clamped -> recruit (all) | |
| 50, 0.65 | 59.2, 0.60 -> 119 -> 150 -> 177 (354) |
| 60, 0.70 | 71.0, 0.60 -> 171 -> 171 -> 202 (404) |
| 75, 0.60 | 88.7, 0.60 -> 266 -> 266 -> 313 (626) |
| 90, 0.45 | 106.5, 0.45 -> 477 -> 350 -> 412 (824) |
| true benefit | 0.0: P(some benefit verdict) 0.028, P(benefit >= SESOI shown) 0.000 |
| true benefit 20.0: P(some benefit verdict) 0.908, P(benefit >= SESOI shown) 0.026 | |
| true benefit 40.0: P(some benefit verdict) 1.000, P(benefit >= SESOI shown) 0.894 |
核心公式
\[e = 1200\,\log_2\frac{f_0}{f_t},\]
查看完整验算程序
# Sample size for the Chapter 8 trial, with a pre-registered re-estimation rule.
# Primary outcome: mean absolute pitch error (cents) when imitating 5 target notes,
# 24 h after training, without feedback. Planning values, all ASSUMED:
# SD between people 75 cents (published means only; see the check below),
# correlation with baseline r 0.6, smallest effect of interest (SESOI) 20 cents,
# two-sided alpha 0.05, 90 % power, 15 % loss. ANCOVA on the baseline shrinks the
# variance by (1 - r^2) (Borm, Fransen & Lemmens 2007).
# Pilot rule: external pilot, n = 20 (10 per arm), never in the main analysis. An
# independent statistician reports only the pooled within-arm SD (df 18) and r.
# SD used = one-sided 80 % upper confidence limit (Browne 1995); r used = pilot r, but
# never above the planned 0.6 nor below 0. SESOI stays 20: the pilot never estimates
# the effect. Final n is clamped to [150, 350] analysable per arm.
import math, random
from statistics import NormalDist
N = NormalDist()
SESOI, LOSS, N_MIN, N_MAX = 20.0, 0.15, 150, 350
def per_arm(sd, delta, r, alpha=0.05, power=0.90):
z = N.inv_cdf(1 - alpha / 2) + N.inv_cdf(power) # +1 below ~ t correction z_a^2/4
return math.ceil(2 * z ** 2 * sd ** 2 * (1 - r ** 2) / delta ** 2) + 1
def chi2_cdf(x, k): # regularised lower gamma P(k/2, x/2), series
a, y = k / 2, x / 2
term = total = 1 / a
for i in range(1, 500):
term *= y / (a + i); total += term
return total * math.exp(-y + a * math.log(y) - math.lgamma(a))
def chi2_ppf(p, k):
lo, hi = 1e-9, 10 * k + 100
for _ in range(100):
mid = (lo + hi) / 2
lo, hi = (mid, hi) if chi2_cdf(mid, k) < p else (lo, mid)
return (lo + hi) / 2
def reestimate(s, r, df=18, conf=0.80):
s_up = s * math.sqrt(df / chi2_ppf(1 - conf, df))
r_use = min(max(r, 0.0), 0.6)
n = per_arm(s_up, SESOI, r_use)
return s_up, r_use, n, min(max(n, N_MIN), N_MAX)
def simulate(rng, n, true_diff, sd=75.0, r=0.6, sims=3000):
benefit = strongest = 0
for _ in range(sims):
arms = []
for shift in (0.0, -true_diff): # arm A lowers the error
xs = [rng.gauss(0, sd) for _ in range(n)]
ys = [r * x + rng.gauss(shift, sd * math.sqrt(1 - r * r)) for x in xs]
arms.append((xs, ys))
cx = [[x - sum(xs) / n for x in xs] for xs, _ in arms] # centre within arms
cy = [[y - sum(ys) / n for y in ys] for _, ys in arms]
b = sum(x * y for a, c in zip(cx, cy) for x, y in zip(a, c)) \
/ sum(x * x for a in cx for x in a)
adj = [sum(y - b * x for x, y in zip(xs, ys)) / n for xs, ys in arms]
d = adj[0] - adj[1] # B minus A: positive = A better
rss = sum((y - b * x) ** 2 for a, c in zip(cx, cy) for x, y in zip(a, c))
lo = d - 1.96 * math.sqrt(rss / (2 * n - 3) * 2 / n)
benefit += lo > 0; strongest += lo >= SESOI
return benefit / sims, strongest / sims
if __name__ == "__main__":
p, good, poor = 7 / 45, 30.0, 229.0 # Pfordresher & Brown 2007, Exp. 2
print(f"check: {p:.0%} poor-pitch singers (229 c), rest 30 c -> mean"
f" {p * poor + (1 - p) * good:.0f} c; split alone gives SD"
f" {math.sqrt(p * (1 - p)) * (poor - good):.0f} c")
n = per_arm(75, SESOI, 0.6); rec = math.ceil(n / (1 - LOSS))
print(f"plan: SD 75, r 0.6, SESOI 20 (d = {20 / 75:.2f}), 90 % power: {n} per arm,"
f" recruit {rec} ({2 * rec})")
print("analysable per arm SESOI 15 20 30")
for sd in (60, 75, 90):
for r in (0.4, 0.6):
print(f" SD {sd}, r {r:.1f} {'':8s}"
+ "".join(f"{per_arm(sd, dl, r):7d}" for dl in (15, 20, 30)))
se = 75 * math.sqrt(2 / 10) * math.sqrt(1 - 0.36)
print(f"pilot of 10 per arm: SE of an arm difference about {se:.0f} c (SESOI 20)")
k = math.sqrt(18 / chi2_ppf(0.20, 18))
print(f"80 % upper limit with df 18: SD x {k:.3f}, so n x {k * k:.2f}")
print("pilot SD, r -> SD used, r used -> n per arm -> clamped -> recruit (all)")
for s, r in ((50, 0.65), (60, 0.70), (75, 0.60), (90, 0.45)):
s_up, r_lo, raw, n2 = reestimate(s, r)
rec2 = math.ceil(n2 / (1 - LOSS))
print(f" {s:4d}, {r:.2f} -> {s_up:5.1f}, {r_lo:.2f} -> {raw:4d} -> {n2:3d}"
f" -> {rec2} ({2 * rec2})")
rng = random.Random(2026)
for true in (0.0, 20.0, 40.0):
p_any, p_top = simulate(rng, n, true)
print(f"true benefit {true:4.1f}: P(some benefit verdict) {p_any:.3f},"
f" P(benefit >= SESOI shown) {p_top:.3f}")唯一数据源与引用
范雅福(Fan, Y.). (2026). 《心理物理学、韦伯-费希纳定律与多感官贝叶斯整合的数学模型》第 8 章「实践与预注册试验」(版本 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23788548
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23788548 · 阅读本章所在专著 · 5DL-B-034 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026034,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Psychophysics, the Weber-Fechner Law and Optimal Bayesian Multisensory Integration},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {1.0.0},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.23788548},
url = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23788548}
}