关于「漂移扩散、天花板效应与论文数据核查」,《井穴揿针与卒中后认知》给出的定量结论是什么?
结论:研究内容二是开放标签、加载设计、单中心、每组 34 例的试验。论文对 MoCA 给出两种组间结果:有效率 p = 0.287(「疗效相当」),治疗后评分 P = 0.005;后者未调整基线,对照组数值不自洽,又无假针对照,仍不足以下结论;摘要「疗效优于对照组」部分依据组内前后检验,而组内与基线比较不能代替组间比较。计时测验的提速可以来自漂移率、边界或非决策时间中的任何一个。MoCA 有 30 分的上限,有效率卡方检验浪费了大部分信息,协方差分析的把握度明显更高,托宾模型可以校正上限造成的低估。逐表核查发现:60 个整数计分格中 56 个不可能是中位数;四格即使作为均数也不成立或很难成立(两格超出分项满分);一行 MMSE 与色词数据重复;有效率表计数不一致,而 p = 0.287 对应有效 26/34 对 22/34;疗效公式方向相反;样本量计算与分析方法不匹配;p 值列未注明含义,两处基线 p 矛盾。这些问题需要论文作者用原始数据核对。
数据口径:卒中后在双手十二井穴贴上长 0.9 毫米的揿针并每天按揉,能否借指端密集的感觉传入改善认知?本书是教学与研究用的数学模型与方法学讨论,不是医疗建议。 书中以标注框区分已发表的证据、可运行的 Python 计算(16 段程序)、原典与作者的模型和假说;除注明的文献数据外,书中数据都是合成的。
对照数据表
下表数字由本章 Python 程序原样打印,可重新运行复现。 程序只用 Python 标准库与结论吻合的打印值: 0.287, 22, 26, 30, 34, 56
| C1 60 cells | 56 cannot be the median of 34 scores; the 4 that can: |
| 33.50, 2.00, 3.50, 25.50 | |
| as a mean of 34 scores (2 decimals, cut or rounded), incompatible: | |
| 0.247 (2-4), 0.247 (2-4), 1.83 (2-9) | |
| C2 M outside its own IQR (Q1, Q3), or above the item maximum: | |
| Table 2-8 MoCA, ctrl | 21.76 (24, 26.25) |
| Table 2-8 MMSE, ctrl | 20.91 (13, 16) |
| Table 2-9 visuospatial, treat | 3.32 (3, 3.25) |
| Table 2-9 abstraction, treat | 1.88 (2, 2) |
| Table 2-9 abstraction, ctrl | 1.79 (2, 2) |
| Table 2-10 naming, treat | 2.97 (3, 3) |
| Table 2-10 naming, ctrl | 3.06 (3, 3) ABOVE MAXIMUM 3 |
| Table 2-10 language, treat | 2.85 (3, 3) |
| Table 2-10 language, ctrl | 2.94 (3, 3) |
| Table 2-10 abstraction, ctrl | 2.09 (2, 2) ABOVE MAXIMUM 2 |
| Table 2-12 colour-word, ctrl | 20.91 (13, 16) |
| if 21.76 (24, 26.25) were a mean, the 8 lowest would average < | 12.2 |
| (all were 18-25 at entry); | |
| if 20.91 (13, 16) were a mean, the 8 highest colour-word scores would average | |
| > | 39.9 (treatment-arm P75 after treatment: 26) |
| C3 Table 2-8 'MMSE' = Table 2-12 'colour-word', both arms: True | |
| its control 20.91 = control baseline MMSE, Table 2-4: True | |
| its control (13, 16) = control figure-number IQR, Table 2-12: True | |
| C4 Table 2-5, treatment counts (0, 2, 26, 8): sum 36 (n | 34); |
| (2 + 26)/34 | 82.4% vs 'total effective 76.4 %' |
| 26 vs 22 effective: Pearson chi2 | 1.133, p = 0.287 |
| 28 vs 22 effective: Pearson chi2 | 2.720, p = 0.099 |
| 26 vs 22 with Yates correction: chi2 | 0.637, p = 0.425 |
核心公式
查看完整验算程序
# Chapter 6. Checks on summaries printed in Lu (2024) as "M (P25, P75)". DATA: all 60
# integer-scale cells of Tables 2-4, 2-8 to 2-12, 2-14, 2-22 (integer scoring of computer
# tests assumed): table, item, treatment M P25 P75, control M P25 P75. C1 granularity,
# C2 IQR and item maximum, C3 duplicates, C4 Table 2-5, C5 baseline tests, C6 response
# rule, C7 sample size, C8 Table 1-3, C9 p columns.
import math, statistics
DATA = """2-4 MoCA 20.24 19 21 19.94 18 21.25|2-4 MMSE 21.24 19 23 20.91 19.8 22|
2-4 CDR 0.247 0 0.5 0.247 0 0.5|2-4 SDS 32.03 28 35 33.50 30 36.25|
2-8 MoCA 27.67 25 28 21.76 24 26.25|2-8 MMSE 23.35 20 26 20.91 13 16|
2-9 visuospatial 3.32 3 3.25 3.32 3 4|2-9 naming 2.47 2 3 2.41 2 3|
2-9 attention 4.26 3 5 4.26 3.75 5|2-9 language 1.83 1 2.25 1.91 1 2.25|
2-9 abstraction 1.88 2 2 1.79 2 2|2-9 recall 1.64 1 2 1.61 1 2|
2-9 orientation 4.82 4 6 4.79 4 5|2-10 visuospatial 4.06 3 5 3.82 3 4|
2-10 naming 2.97 3 3 3.06 3 3|2-10 attention 5.23 5 6 5.09 5 6|
2-10 language 2.85 3 3 2.94 3 3|2-10 abstraction 2.00 2 2 2.09 2 2|
2-10 recall 3.55 3 4 3.05 3 4|2-10 orientation 5.03 4 6 5.09 5 5.25|
2-11 colour-word 17.61 13 23 16.85 14 19.25|
2-11 figure-number 11.74 8 15 10.09 7 14|
2-11 figure-calc 7.09 5 8.25 6.76 5 8.25|2-11 digit-span 3.50 3 4 3.44 3 4|
2-12 colour-word 23.35 20 26 20.91 13 16|
2-12 figure-number 17.08 16 19 14.67 13 16|
2-12 figure-calc 9.41 8 11 7.91 6 9|2-12 digit-span 5.35 5 6 5.24 4 6|
2-14 MoCA 25.50 23 27 24.24 22.5 25|2-22 MMSE 27.44 27 28 23.73 22 24.25"""
MAXI = {"visuospatial": 5, "naming": 3, "attention": 6, "language": 3, "abstraction": 2,
"recall": 5, "orientation": 6}
N = 34
CELLS = []
for rec in DATA.replace("\n", "").split("|"):
t, item, *v = rec.split()
for arm, k in (("treat", 0), ("ctrl", 3)):
CELLS.append((t, item, arm, *map(float, v[k:k + 3])))
def chi2_p(x, df):
if df == 1:
return math.erfc(math.sqrt(x / 2))
if df == 3:
return math.erfc(math.sqrt(x / 2)) + math.sqrt(2 * x / math.pi) * math.exp(-x / 2)
raise ValueError
def pearson(rows):
R = [sum(r) for r in rows]; C = [sum(c) for c in zip(*rows)]; T = sum(R)
return math.fsum((rows[i][j] - R[i] * C[j] / T) ** 2 / (R[i] * C[j] / T)
for i in range(len(R)) for j in range(len(C)))
def t_p(t, df): # two-sided p of Student t, exact series for even df
th = math.atan(abs(t) / math.sqrt(df)); c2 = math.cos(th) ** 2; term = acc = 1.0
for k in range(1, df // 2):
term *= c2 * (2 * k - 1) / (2 * k); acc += term
return 1 - math.sin(th) * acc
step = lambda item: 0.5 if item == "CDR" else 1.0
half = lambda c: c[3] / (step(c[1]) / 2)
med = [c for c in CELLS if abs(half(c) - round(half(c))) < 1e-9]
print(f"C1 {len(CELLS)} cells: {len(CELLS) - len(med)} cannot be the median of 34 scores;"
f" the {len(med)} that can:\n " + ", ".join(f"{c[3]:.2f}" for c in med))
def mean_ok(v, st):
return any(abs(math.floor(100 * k * st / N) / 100 - v) < 1e-9 or
abs(round(k * st / N, 2) - v) < 1e-9 for k in range(int(40 * N / st)))
odd = [c for c in CELLS if not mean_ok(c[3], step(c[1]))]
print(" as a mean of 34 scores (2 decimals, cut or rounded), incompatible:\n " +
", ".join(f"{c[3]:g} ({c[0]})" for c in odd))
print("C2 M outside its own IQR (Q1, Q3), or above the item maximum:")
for t, item, arm, m, q1, q3 in CELLS:
over = item in MAXI and t in ("2-9", "2-10") and m > MAXI[item]
if m < q1 - 1e-9 or m > q3 + 1e-9 or over:
flag = f" ABOVE MAXIMUM {MAXI[item]}" if over else ""
print(f" Table {t:5s} {item + ', ' + arm:20s} {m:6.2f} ({q1:g}, {q3:g}){flag}")
lo, mid, hi = 8, 18, 8 # observations below P25 / inside / above P75
need_low = (N * 21.76 - mid * 24 - hi * 26.25) / lo
need_high = (N * 20.91 - lo * 13 - mid * 16) / hi
print(f" if 21.76 (24, 26.25) were a mean, the {lo} lowest would average"
f" <= {need_low:.1f}"
"\n (all were 18-25 at entry);")
print(f" if 20.91 (13, 16) were a mean, the {hi} highest colour-word scores would"
" average"
f"\n >= {need_high:.1f} (treatment-arm P75 after treatment: 26)")
row = lambda t, it: [c[3:] for c in CELLS if c[0] == t and c[1] == it]
print("C3 Table 2-8 'MMSE' = Table 2-12 'colour-word', both arms:",
row("2-8", "MMSE") == row("2-12", "colour-word"))
cw = row("2-12", "colour-word")[1]
print(" its control 20.91 = control baseline MMSE, Table 2-4:",
cw[0] == row("2-4", "MMSE")[1][0])
print(" its control (13, 16) = control figure-number IQR, Table 2-12:",
cw[1:] == row("2-12", "figure-number")[1][1:])
tx = (0, 2, 26, 8); ct = (0, 0, 22, 12)
print(f"C4 Table 2-5, treatment counts {tx}: sum {sum(tx)} (n = 34);"
f"\n (2 + 26)/34 = {28 / 34:.1%} vs 'total effective 76.4 %'")
for lab, a in (("26 vs 22 effective", 26), ("28 vs 22 effective", 28)):
x = pearson([[a, 34 - a], [22, 12]])
print(f" {lab}: Pearson chi2 = {x:.3f}, p = {chi2_p(x, 1):.3f}")
rows = [[26, 8], [22, 12]]; R = [34, 34]; C = [48, 20]
yates = math.fsum((abs(rows[i][j] - R[i] * C[j] / 68) - 0.5) ** 2 / (R[i] * C[j] / 68)
for i in range(2) for j in range(2))
print(f" 26 vs 22 with Yates correction: chi2 = {yates:.3f},"
f" p = {chi2_p(yates, 1):.3f}")
print(" -> p = 0.287 fits 26/34 effective (uncorrected); counts summing to 34 with 26"
"\n effective: (0, 2, 24, 8) or (0, 0, 26, 8)")
print("C5 baseline tests re-computed from the printed summaries")
for lab, m1, s1, m2, s2, rep in (
("age (Table 2-3)", 61.70, 9.98, 65.52, 7.94, "-1.747, 0.085"),
("days since stroke", 52.67, 51.04, 37.88, 36.60, "1.373, 0.174")):
t = (m1 - m2) / math.sqrt((s1 ** 2 + s2 ** 2) / N)
print(f" {lab:17s} t = {t:+.3f}, p = {t_p(t, 2 * N - 2):.3f} (reported {rep})")
x = pearson([[24, 10], [23, 11]]); x2 = pearson([[7, 20, 5, 2], [10, 13, 7, 4]])
print(f" sex: chi2 = {x:.3f}, p = {chi2_p(x, 1):.3f} (Table 2-6: 0.069, 0.793;"
" text calls 0.069 the p)")
print(f" education: chi2 = {x2:.3f}, p = {chi2_p(x2, 3):.3f} (Table 2-7: 3.014, 0.389)")
print("C6 response rule: the printed (pre - post)/pre is negative for any improvement.")
print(" Sign reversed, (post - pre)/pre, the largest rate reachable with MoCA <= 30:")
print(" baseline: " + " ".join(f"{b}:{(30 - b) / b:.0%}" for b in range(18, 26)))
print(" 'cured' (>= 75 %) is unreachable for every eligible patient; 'effective'"
" (>= 25 %)\n needs a perfect 30 at baseline 24 and is impossible at 25")
z = statistics.NormalDist().inv_cdf
d = (25.88 - 22.96) / math.sqrt((4.83 ** 2 + 2.88 ** 2) / 2)
for lab, za in (("two-sided 0.05", z(0.975)), ("one-sided 0.05", z(0.95))):
nn = 2 * (za + z(0.80)) ** 2 / d ** 2 + za ** 2 / 4
print(f"C7 sample size, d = {d:.3f}, 80 % power, {lab}: {math.ceil(nn)} per arm"
if lab.startswith("two") else f" {lab}: {math.ceil(nn)} per arm"
" (thesis: 25)")
print(f" 20 % dropout: 25 / 0.8 = {25 / 0.8:.2f} -> 32 per arm (thesis: 25 x 1.2 = 30)")
T13 = (("Baihui", 127, 73.83), ("Sishencong", 68, 39.53), ("Shenting", 63, 36.72),
("Zusanli", 51, 29.65), ("Fengchi", 47, 27.33), ("Neiguan", 43, 40.03),
("Sanyinjiao", 40, 23.26), ("Shenmen", 38, 22.09), ("Yintang", 23, 13.37))
off = [(p, f, r, 100 * f / 172) for p, f, r in T13 if abs(100 * f / 172 - r) > 0.06]
print(f"C8 Table 1-3, f/172 against the printed %:"
f" {len(T13) - len(off)} of {len(T13)} agree;")
for p, f, r, c in off:
print(f" {p}: {f}/172 = {c:.2f} %, printed {r} %")
print("C9 p columns of Tables 2-8, 2-10, 2-12 are unlabelled; they match the treatment")
print(" arm's within-group p (2-10 orientation 0.407 = Table 2-21; 2-12 all < 0.001 =")
print(" Tables 2-23 to 2-27). Conflicting baseline p: MMSE 0.511 (Table 2-4) vs 0.661")
print(" (2.3.4(1)); digit span 0.648 (Table 2-11) vs 0.759 (2.3.4(6))")唯一数据源与引用
范雅福(Fan, Y.). (2026). 《指—脑皮层放大、远端微针传入与卒中后认知网络重建的计算神经学》第 6 章「漂移扩散、天花板效应与论文数据核查」(版本 1.0.0). 5D Library. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23839915
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23839915 · 阅读本章所在专著 · 5DL-B-052 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026052,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Finger–Brain Cortical Magnification, Distal Microneedle Afference and Computational Neurology of Post-Stroke Cognitive Network Reconstruction},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {1.0.0},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.23839915},
url = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23839915}
}