关于「断点上的跃迁:KataGo 量尺下的决策质量指数」,《围棋 AI 后的人类决策质量》给出的定量结论是什么?
结论:第一章把论文表 1 换算成效应量:AI 后普通着法的决策质量指数高出 0.59754 个百分点,新着高出 1.11258 个点,新着原有的代价缩小了 0.848;并说明匹配率超过一半时中位数汇总会碰到上限。
数据口径:书中除论文数字外的参数均为示意,全部计算由书中程序生成;本书是非个人化经营建议,不针对任何个人决定。 第四章用香农熵度量定式集中度,示意角部局面的策略熵从 1.608 升到 2.360 比特,从众学习模型显示外部评估者让群体提早约 12 年离开局部最优。
对照数据表
下表数字由本章 Python 程序原样打印,可重新运行复现。 程序只用 Python 标准库与结论吻合的打印值: 0.59754, 0.848, 1.11258
| term est se z | 95 % CI |
| after AI (b1) | 0.59754 0.01601 37.3 [0.5662, 0.6289] |
| novel (b2) | -0.60770 0.01219 -49.9 [-0.6316, -0.5838] |
| after x novel (b3) | 0.51504 0.02147 24.0 [0.4730, 0.5571] |
| model 2 b3 | 0.51498, se 0.02132: same to 4 decimals |
| cell means relative to pre-AI, non-novel moves (DQI points) | |
| pre-AI non-novel +0.00000 | |
| pre-AI novel | -0.60770 |
| post-AI non-novel +0.59754 | |
| post-AI novel +0.50488 | |
| AI gain, non-novel moves | 0.59754 |
| AI gain, novel moves | 1.11258 (1.862 x) |
| novelty penalty before | -0.60770 |
| novelty penalty after | -0.09266 |
| worst-case se of b1 + b3 | 0.03748, lower 95 % bound 1.0391 |
| share of b2 penalty removed by b3 | 0.848 |
查看完整验算程序
# Chapter 1. p11: what the published post-AI coefficients imply
# Source: Shin, Kim, van Opheusden and Griffiths (2023, PNAS), Table 1.
# Dependent variable: Decision Quality Index (DQI) of each move, in
# percentage points of win rate, DQI = 100 - (AI win rate - human win
# rate), estimated with KataGo (10000 simulated game patterns per
# decision); 5857513 moves, first 60 moves of each game, 1950 to 2021,
# player and move-number fixed effects, standard errors clustered by
# player. Only the coefficients and standard errors below are taken
# from the paper; every derived number is arithmetic on them.
import math
N_OBS = 5857513
PLAYOUTS = 10000
MAX_MOVE = 602
Z = 1.959964
# name: (model 1 estimate, se, model 2 estimate, se)
TABLE = [
("after AI (b1)", 0.59754, 0.01601, None, None),
("novel (b2)", -0.60770, 0.01219, -0.60777, 0.01218),
("after x novel (b3)", 0.51504, 0.02147, 0.51498, 0.02132),
]
def ci(b, se):
return b - Z * se, b + Z * se
if __name__ == "__main__":
print("term est se z 95 % CI")
for name, b, se, b2, se2 in TABLE:
lo, hi = ci(b, se)
print("{:<18} {:9.5f} {:8.5f} {:6.1f} [{:.4f}, {:.4f}]".format(
name, b, se, b / se, lo, hi))
b1, s1 = TABLE[0][1], TABLE[0][2]
b2, s2 = TABLE[1][1], TABLE[1][2]
b3, s3 = TABLE[2][1], TABLE[2][2]
print("model 2 b3 = {:.5f}, se {:.5f}: same to 4 decimals".format(
TABLE[2][3], TABLE[2][4]))
print("cell means relative to pre-AI, non-novel moves (DQI points)")
cells = [("pre-AI non-novel", 0.0), ("pre-AI novel", b2),
("post-AI non-novel", b1),
("post-AI novel", math.fsum([b1, b2, b3]))]
for name, v in cells:
print(" {:<18} {:+.5f}".format(name, v))
gain_novel = math.fsum([b1, b3])
print("AI gain, non-novel moves: {:.5f}".format(b1))
print("AI gain, novel moves: {:.5f} ({:.3f} x)".format(
gain_novel, gain_novel / b1))
print("novelty penalty before: {:.5f}".format(b2))
print("novelty penalty after: {:.5f}".format(math.fsum([b2, b3])))
worst = math.fsum([s1, s3])
print("worst-case se of b1 + b3: {:.5f}, lower 95 % bound {:.4f}".format(
worst, gain_novel - Z * worst))
print("share of b2 penalty removed by b3: {:.3f}".format(-b3 / b2))唯一数据源与引用
范雅福(Fan, Y.). (2026). 《围棋人工智能后人类决策质量跃迁、新颖着法率与棋经十三篇策略熵母典》第 1 章「断点上的跃迁:KataGo 量尺下的决策质量指数」(版本 1.0.0). 5D Library. DOI 待发布
DOI 待发布 · 专著页正式发布后上线(本站暂无专著页) · 5DL-B-230 · v1.0.0 · CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0
BibTeX
@book{fan2026230,
author = {Fan, Yafu},
title = {Post-AI Leaps in Human Go Decision Quality, Novel-Move Rates and Strategic Entropy in the Thirteen-Chapter Classic of Go},
year = {2026},
publisher = {5D Library},
edition = {1.0.0},
note = {DOI pending}
}