How much liver and other organ meat belongs in a raw diet?

Short answer: There is no single answer; it has to be calculated nutrient by nutrient. Liver is very high in vitamin A and copper, and too much can push vitamin A past its upper limit. The common raw-feeding rule of about 5 percent liver and 5 percent other secreting organs is only a starting point, not a standard, so check each nutrient.

The site tool is an everyday nutrition-ratio reference, not a veterinary prescription, and is not for managing disease. For growing, pregnant, lactating or unwell animals, consult a licensed veterinarian. Raw feeding carries pathogen risk; handle food hygienically.

Why liver needs a limit

Using approximate values from common USDA entries, 100 g of raw beef liver contains about 16,900 IU of vitamin A, about 9.8 mg of copper and about 135 kcal. That works out to roughly 125,000 IU of vitamin A per 1,000 kcal of beef liver.

AAFCO's maximum for vitamin A in adult dogs is 62,500 IU per 1,000 kcal. In other words, beef liver eaten on its own supplies about twice the upper limit, so it has to be diluted by other ingredients, and the proportion needs calculating. For example, if beef liver supplies a tenth of the total energy in a mix, it alone contributes about 12,500 IU of vitamin A per 1,000 kcal, before counting any other ingredient.

Copper deserves attention too

Beef liver is also rich in copper. Copper is an essential nutrient, with an AAFCO adult minimum for dogs of 1.83 mg per 1,000 kcal. Some breeds are more prone to accumulating copper; in those cases please consult a licensed veterinarian.

Copper content varies a great deal between livers from different animals, so recalculate whenever you change the source. Chicken liver, for instance, usually contains far less copper than beef liver.

Other secreting organs

Kidney, spleen, pancreas and similar organs are often grouped as secreting organs, and their nutrient profiles differ. Beef kidney, for example, is comparatively high in selenium. Rotating several organs spreads out the quirks of any single ingredient, but the mix still needs to be calculated. Spleen is notably rich in iron, and pancreas can be hard to find, so adjust to what is available.

How to check your mix

Enter the shares of liver and other organs into the nutrient calculation, convert to a per-1,000-kcal basis, and check whether vitamin A, vitamin D, copper and selenium fall outside their ranges. The vitamin A limit for cats differs from the one for dogs, so check each species separately. Once the numbers are done, it is worth having a licensed veterinarian or veterinary nutritionist look them over.

Growing, pregnant or nursing animals should not be fed an adult recipe; please consult a licensed veterinarian.

Follow-up questions

Can I swap beef liver for chicken liver?

Yes, but the nutrient profile changes, including vitamin A and copper, so recalculate after any swap.

What if I leave liver out entirely?

Liver is a major source of vitamin A, copper and other nutrients. Without it these may fall short and need another source, which also has to be calculated.

Can I feed organs once a week instead of daily?

Some people do, but a large single serving of liver concentrates vitamin A intake. Spreading it across days is more common; ask a licensed veterinarian about specifics.

The fresh-food calculator we built takes your organ proportions and shows whether vitamin A, copper, selenium and other measures are out of range. It is an everyday nutrition-ratio reference, not a veterinary prescription, and is not for managing disease. For growing, pregnant, lactating or unwell animals, consult a licensed veterinarian. Raw feeding carries pathogen risk; handle food hygienically: thaw raw meat in the fridge and wash your hands after handling it.

About this tool

Sources

  1. USDA Agricultural Research Service, FoodData Central (beef liver and beef kidney, raw) · https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/
  2. AAFCO, Official Publication: AAFCO Dog and Cat Food Nutrient Profiles · https://www.aafco.org/
  3. National Research Council, 2006, Nutrient Requirements of Dogs and Cats, National Academies Press