Should I praise my child for being smart or for working hard?
Short answer: Research favours specific praise for the process over general praise for being clever. In Mueller and Dweck's 1998 experiments, children praised for intelligence were more likely to avoid challenges after a setback. But praise for effort also needs to be specific and sincere, or it becomes just as empty. The best praise names the method your child used or the change they made.
The site tool is based on a traditional birth-data system. It is a reflection aid for parents, not a psychological or educational assessment, and it does not predict intelligence, grades or future outcomes. For developmental, emotional or learning concerns, please consult a paediatrician or a qualified assessor.
What the classic experiments found
In 1998 Claudia Mueller and Carol Dweck published a series of experiments in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. Fifth-graders completed a set of problems; some were then told they must be smart, others that they must have worked hard. When harder problems followed, children praised for intelligence more often chose easy tasks and showed less persistence and poorer performance after failure.
A 2013 longitudinal study by Elizabeth Gunderson and colleagues in Child Development observed real families and found that the share of process praise parents gave toddlers aged one to three was linked to children's belief, several years later, that ability can grow with effort.
Know the limits of the evidence
Growth mindset is not a magic key. A 2018 meta-analysis by Victoria Sisk and colleagues in Psychological Science found that the average effect of growth-mindset interventions on academic achievement was small, with possibly larger benefits for students who were struggling academically or came from lower-income households.
So changing how you praise is a worthwhile habit, but do not expect one phrase to transform grades. What matters is the climate over time: mistakes are allowed, hard problems get broken down and progress gets noticed.
Mindset research has also prompted lively debate among psychologists about effect sizes and replication. That debate is a good reason to treat praise advice as a sensible everyday habit rather than a promise of particular outcomes.
What good praise sounds like
Specific: ‘You drew a diagram, and that's how you spotted the pattern’ beats ‘Great job’.
Aimed at things your child controls: methods, strategies, persistence and asking for help, rather than innate talent.
Honest: when work is just average, you do not need to oversell it. Try ‘One fewer mistake than last time. Let's look at the rest together.’
Praise switching strategies too. Praising effort alone can keep a child grinding away with a method that does not work. Dweck herself has cautioned that what deserves recognition is effort combined with good strategies and seeking help.
Notice kindness, patience and curiosity too, not only marks on paper. Children learn a great deal from what the adults around them choose to pay attention to.
Follow-up questions
My child aced a test. Can I say they are smart?
Celebrate with them, then ask, ‘Which way of revising helped most?’ That points attention at a process they can repeat.
Can too much praise make children dependent on it?
It can. Swap some evaluation for description, such as ‘You packed your school bag by yourself’, so your child gets to feel the satisfaction directly.
How do I bring a growth mindset into criticism?
Use ‘not yet’ instead of ‘can't’: ‘You haven't mastered this unit yet’, followed by one concrete next step.
If you would like another lens on what kind of words your child responds to, our Child Strengths & Parenting Guide at destiny5d.com/kids offers one. It draws on a traditional birth-data system and is a reflection aid for parents, not a psychological or educational assessment; it does not measure IQ or say whether a child is clever.
About this toolSources
- Mueller, C. M. & Dweck, C. S., 1998, Praise for intelligence can undermine children's motivation and performance, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 75(1):33–52 · https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.75.1.33
- Gunderson, E. A. et al., 2013, Parent praise to 1- to 3-year-olds predicts children's motivational frameworks 5 years later, Child Development 84(5):1526–1541 · https://doi.org/10.1111/cdev.12064
- Sisk, V. F. et al., 2018, To what extent and under which circumstances are growth mind-sets important to academic achievement? Two meta-analyses, Psychological Science 29(4):549–571 · https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797617739704
- Dweck, C. S., 2006, Mindset: The New Psychology of Success, Random House